2011 Award Winners 
Wine of the Year
&
Best of Show Sparkling
G.H. Mumm Brut Rose Champagne, Reims, France $70 Best of Show White Hagafen 2010 White Riesling, Devoto Vineyards, Lake County $18 Best of Show Rose Robert Oatley Vineyards 2010 Rose of Sangiovese, Mudgee, Australia $15 Best of Show Red Cakebread Cellars 2007 Merlot, Napa Valley $54 Best of Show Dessert Inniskillin 2007 Vidal Ice Wine VQA, Niagara Peninsula, Canada $60 DIRECTOR'S AWARD
Winery of the Year Champagne G.H. Mumm, Reims, France
Acorn Winery
Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Franc, Alegria Vineyards Russian River Valley $30.00 Dark color almost to rim. Black cherries, graphite and clove on nose. There is a baked-bean aspect to the palate. There is a pleasant quinine aspect that adds interest. Extremely tannic but interesting nonetheless. - Katherine Cole; - Lean and lithe, satisfied with a lighter, more restrained profile. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Gold 2008 Dolcetto, Alegria Vineyards Russian River Valley $30.00 A good blend of ripeness and food-friendliness. It's pleasantly fruity and would go well with barbecued meat. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Silver 2008 Syrah, Axiom, Alegria Vineyards Russian River Valley $29.00 Deep ruby black color; ripe fruit aroma, ok; full bodied, firm on the palate; black fruit and sweet oak flavors, pretty good; medium finish. - Wilfred Wong Alice White
Critics Silver 2009 Cabernet Sauvignon South Eastern Australia $6.99 Crowd-pleasingly ripe black cherry and cassis flavors on a firm yet not at all astringent tannic frame. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver 2010 Lexia Moscato South Eastern Australia $6.99 Good acidity balances the sweetness - Ed McCarthy Almaden Vineyards
Critics Silver NV Cabernet Sauvignon, Heritage California $18.00 Bright & fresh - Nick Passmore Amalaya
Critics Silver 2009 Vino Tinto de Altura, Valle Calchaqui Argentina $17.00 Juicy and plush, with lots of licorice and spice to jazz up the plummy fruit. - Linda Murphy Ambas
Critics Silver 2009 Malbec, Mendoza Argentina $4.99 Fine balance and packed with bright cherries and plums. - Nick Passmore Ancient Peaks Winery
Critics Gold 2009 Cabernet Sauvignon Paso Robles $17.00 Classic ripe fruit style, big but balanced, - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Silver 2010 Sauvignon Blanc Paso Robles $14.00 Good body and zip. - Michael Apstein Angoves
Critics Silver 2007 Shiraz, Vineyard Select McLaren Vale $19.75 Depth, concentration and brightness - Mary Ewing-Mulligan Antler Hill
Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, The Biltmore Collection Napa Valley $48.00 Has an energetic edge of acidity that will make it very friendly on the table - Mary Ewing-Mulligan
Critics Silver 2006 Syrah, The Biltmore Collection Napa Valley $35.00 Sweet fruit, a hint of chocolate - Marguerite Thomas Baileyana Winery
Critics Platinum 2008 Pinot Noir, Grand Firepeak Cuvee Edna Valley $33.00 Ripe fruit, not overdone. Great balance of ripe fruit and savory elements. Good spice. Balanced and long. - Michael Apstein
Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay, Grand Firepeak Cuvee Edna Valley $28.00 Lemon fruit with an interesting earthy undertone. - W. Blake Gray Bandit
Critics Silver NV Cabernet Sauvignon California $8.99 Supple and mouth-filling, with rounded tannins, plump red and black cherry flavors, and succulence. What it may lack in complexity, it makes up for in drink-now pleasure. - Linda Murphy. Banfi
Critics Silver 2008 Chianti Classico DOCG Italy $13.00 Garnet to edges. Nose at first lacking in fruit. More tannin than fruit. Nice spices at finish second time around. This one is growing on me. - Katherine Cole; - Soft and supple. Easy to drink. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Platinum 2007 Chianti Classico DOCG Riserva Italy $18.00 A beautiful modern-styled Chianti, with real depth and intensity, but at the same time distinct Tuscan earthy flavors. Long, deep, and very satisfying. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2009 Centine Bianco, Toscana IGT Italy $11.00 Crisp and clean, touched by hints of aromatic spice. - Nick Passmore
Critics Gold 2009 Centine Rosè, Toscana IGT Italy $11.00 So delicate, it's almost ethereal. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Gold 2010 Rosa Regale, Brachetto d'Acqui DOCG Italy $23.00 Austere minty edges to the giving strawberry fruit makes for a lot of fun with just a touch of seriousness. - Jon Bonne Barefoot Bubbly
Critics Silver NV Moscato Spumante California $10.99 A pleasant bite here gives a honeysuckle and chalk edge to the muscat flourish. - Jon Bonne
Critics Silver NV Brut Cuvee California $9.99 Great acidity, balances the fruit - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver NV Pinot Grigio California $10.99 A pleasant apple and thyme melange gives this great pep. - Jon Bonne Barefoot Cellars
Critics Silver NV White Zinfandel California $6.99 Ripe watermelon and pear flood the palate - try this instead of fresh lemonade! - Rich Cook
Critics Gold NV Merlot California $6.99 Surprising depth of flavor, restrained oak presence well integrated fruit - Marguerite Thomas; - Deep ruby color; ripe fruit, lots going on here; medium bodied, layered and textured on the palate; attractive, ripe red fruit flavors, excellent concentration; medium finish. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Silver NV Pinot Noir California $6.99 The velvety, elegant texture and nicely ripened red cherry and cranberry fruit makes this wine a great buy. Residual sweetness adds to the plump mouthfeel. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver NV Moscato California $6.99 Has some freshness and delicacy thanks to a slight spritz - Mary Ewing-Mulligan
Critics Silver NV Pinot Grigio American $6.99 Minerality on nose. White-peach freshness. Good spritzy palate. Could use more acidity, but would be a nice aperitif or lunch wine. - Katherine Cole
Critics Silver NV Riesling California $6.99 Bright floral fruity (peaches) character balanced by fresh acidity. Good length. - Michael Apstein
Critics Silver NV Sauvignon Blanc California $6.99 Palate is dry with floral perfume at the finish. It's tasty but it's not typical of sauv blanc. Floral. But it does have some hints of asparagus and meyer lemon. Interesting and certainly quaffable. - Katherine Cole Bargetto Winery
Critics Silver 2008 Merlot, Reserve Santa Cruz Mountains $40.00 Aromatics are ripe blackberry. Lots of black pepper on palate, with blackberry bramble. The fresh fruit is alluring. Subtly spiced finish tempered by some good acidity. - Katherine Cole; - Fleshy and ripe but at the same time soft on the palate. Enticing. - Paul Lukacs Barrel Ranch
Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Noir California $11.99 Tightly wound, tart and pleasingly edgy in its tangerine and rhubarb vivaciousness. - Jon Bonne Bella Sera
Critics Gold 2009 Chianti DOCG Italy $6.99 Alluring floral nose. Soft color. blue fruit, violets. Elegant. Some whole-cluster? Bright freshness to fruit. Nice acidity on finish. Well integrated. And that balsamic note of Chianti. I like the restraint on this. - Katherine Cole
Critics Silver 2010 Moscato, Puglia IGT Italy $6.99 Delicate and edged by freesia and orange blossom, with peach jam and honey at its core. - Jon Bonne Benedetto
Critics Silver 2009 Chianti DOCG Italy $10.99 Garnet with soft edges. Pretty nose with spice and balsamic. Light palate, good acidity. Alluring floral finish. - Katherine Cole; - Beautiful earthy aromatics, with a dry, dusty finish. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Platinum 2010 Pinot Grigio, Delle Venezie IGP Italy $10.99 A beautiful example of pinot grigio because it is layered and complex in the mid-palate and finish. The wine starts with well-defined citrus, but gains interest as it becomes nutty, with an almost chalky, mineral-like undertone. Very long and lingering. Impressive! - Paul Lukacs Beringer
Critics Gold 2009 Merlot, Founders Estate California $10.00 Vibrant, with lots of verve. Focused black cherry fruit, black licorice, hint of hazelnut, polished tannins yet with firm structure. Beautiful balance. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay, Founders Estate California $10.00 Vibrant and structured, in a lean, clean style. Subtle hints of oak spice, caramel and fennel, with a bracing finish. - Linda Murphy Beronia
Critics Silver 2008 Rioja DDOC, Crianza Spain $14.99 Tons of appeal, notes of leather and sage, hint of chocolate - Marguerite Thomas; - Light to medium ruby color; woody and kind of old world in the aroma, a bit fruit shy; medium bodied, rustic on the palate, soft tannins; dry, soft acidity, balanced; red fruit flavors, with some rustic earthiness; soft finish, astringent aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Silver 2004 Rioja DDOC, Gran Reserva Spain $27.99 Big flavors nicely balanced between fruit, oak, acidity - Marguerite Thomas; - Medium brick red color; ripe fruit aroma, slight note of mocha, appealing, fine depth; medium bodied, just a bit tired, yet complex on the palate; dry, nice acidity, well balanced; a note of oxidation in the flavors, trace of red fruit; medium finish, nice smooth aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong Big Kahuna
Critics Gold NV Cabernet / Shiraz / Petite Verdot South Eastern Australia $1.99 A delightful, relatively light-bodied style, very flavorful and refreshing - Mary Ewing-Mulligan Biltmore
Critics Gold NV Chardonnay Sur Lies American $10.99 Piquant apple and clove nose. Fairly light but has freshness and limpidity. Goes easy on the oak and is all the better for it. Quite long. - Stephen Brook Critics Silver NV Brut American $24.99 Lean and focused, with lots of stone and grated lemon for vibrancy, and a pleasing bite that's a neon arrow to the dinner table. - Jon Bonne
Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon Alexander Valley $24.99 A pronounced smoky character adds interest and intrigue. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Gold 2009 Pinot Noir Russian River Valley $24.99 Spice and fruit. Good length. Balanced. Alluring spice and fruit mixture. - Michael Apstein Bin 36
Critics Gold 2007 Pinot Noir Monterey $26.00 A very graceful pinot noir, thoroughly silky, with nuance of flavor. - Mary Ewing-Mulligan Black Box
Critics Gold 2009 Merlot California $24.99 Slight brick tinge to this one. nose is well-integrated wood. Subtle. lingering bitter spices. Cloves and juniper. Tastes more expensive than this price category. - Katherine Cole; - A beautiful merlot, with excellent depth of flavor and genuine complexity in the finish. Astounding value! - Paul Lukacs Black Opal
Critics Silver 2009 Shiraz South Eastern Australia $7.00 Big, huge, sweet, oaky crowd pleaser - Marguerite Thomas; - Deep ruby color; too much artificial vanilla in the aromas, but very consumer-friendly; medium bodied a bit too heavy on the palate; ripe fruit with a plank note to it; medium finish. - Wilfred Wong Blackstone Winery
Critics Gold 2007 Rubric, Sonoma Reserve Sonoma County $22.99 Well-defined with present but not excessively persistent tannins, and impressive depth of fruit flavor. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon, Sonoma Reserve Sonoma County $19.99 Plump black fruit. Fine tannins. lovely savory notes complement the prominent black fruit flavors. - Michael Apstein
Critics Silver 2008 Merlot, Sonoma Reserve Sonoma County $19.99 Has a core of juicy cherry/plum fruit with mouth-caressing tannins and a gentle herbal note on the crisp finish. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver 2009 Merlot, Winemaker's Select California $19.99 Quite rich and broad, with ample fruit if not much personality. Has some balancing acidity that gives the wine freshness. - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay, Sonoma Reserve Sonoma County $16.99 Inviting mineral, pear and hazelnut aromas are followed by a firmly structured palate, with brisk acidity supporting the plump pear and apple fruit. Nicely balanced. - Linda Murphy Bluenose Wines
Critics Silver 2007 Zinfandel Sonoma County $19.99 A juicy lip-smacker, berries and cherries and essence of zin - Marguerite Thomas Boro Hills
Critics Gold 2010 Sauvignon Blanc Marlborough $9.99 Nose is grass and gooseberry. A bit of bright tropical fruit (guava, passionfruit) to the finish. A crowd-pleaser. varietally correct. - Katherine Cole Bota Box
Critics Silver 2010 Zinfandel California $18.99 There seems to be some residual sweetness here, yet the weight and complexity carries it. Tangy wild blackberry, dark chocolate and a briary note. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver 2009 Riesling California $18.99 Reminescent of ripe white peaches. - Michael Apstein Bouchaine Vineyards
Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Meunier, Estate Carneros $40.00 Tart, bright and refreshing - it's a homegrown answer to what you put in a pitcher. - Jon Bonne
Critics Gold 2008 Pinot Noir Carneros $30.00 Cherry-like fruit complemented by herbal savory notes. Juicy and lip-smacking acidity - Michael Apstein
Critics Gold 2010 Bouche D'Or, Late Harvest Chardonnay Carneros $30.00 Ripe peaches on the nose. fresh ripe apricot, sweet peaches, guava and passionfruit on the palate. Nice acidity on the finish, with some lemonade. There is a lot going on here--a fun way to finish a meal. - Katherine Cole
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay, Estate Carneros $25.00 Lemon fruit with slight floral hints. - W. Blake Gray Bouchon
Critics Gold 2009 Cabernet Sauvignon, Superior California $8.99 Lots going on here: savory aromas, hints of forest floor, black cherry and cassis, ripe red fruit and well managed tannins. A fine drink. - Linda Murphy Bracey Vineyards
Critics Platinum 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon Howell Mountain $70.00 Rich nose, sweet and supple, with very ripe fruit and well judged oak. Medium-bodied, a graceful style but it doesn't lack concentration and grip. Sleek and stylish, with a long lifted finish. - Stephen Brook
Critics Platinum 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, TKL Oakville $75.00 Charred toasty nose, with new oak dominating the fruit aromas. Plump, rounded, quite chocolatey and dense, very ripe and concentrated, and enough acidity to give drive and energy to the finish. - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Noir, La Encantada Vineyard Sta. Rita Hills $49.00 Tangy and almost fiery in its cinnamon and cranberry profile. - Jon Bonne
Critics Gold 2009 Pinot Noir, Doctor's Vineyard Santa Lucia Highlands $49.00 Lovely and delicious - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay, Split Rock Vineyard Sonoma Coast $38.00 Balanced and refreshing, with a note of baked apple and pear. - Robert Whitley Brancott
Critics Silver 2010 Sauvignon Blanc Marlborough $26.00 Very grassy and zingy, lively - Elin McCoy; - All grassy rhubarb intensity. - Nick Passmore
Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Grigio South Island $14.00 Richer and more obvious fruit than many pinot grigios, pear and quince, deeper gold color - Marguerite Thomas Brassfield Estate
Critics Silver 2009 Serenity High Valley $10.00 Pretty floral nose, nicely made, with herbal, greeny finish - Elin McCoy; - As easy and as pleasing as pudding. - Nick Passmore
Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Noir, High Serenity Ranch Vineyard High Valley $15.00 Full, tannic - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Grigio, High Serenity Ranch Vineyard High Valley $10.00 Crisp and refreshing with a pronounced citrus character. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2009 Sauvignon Blanc, High Serenity Ranch Vineyard High Valley $10.00 Dried straw and citrus aromas with green apple, citrus fruit and savory acidity - Rebecca Murphy Brokenwood
Critics Silver 2010 Semillon Hunter Valley $20.00 Pure, clean and bracingly precise. - Nick Passmore
Critics Gold 2006 Semillon, Oakey Creek Vineyard Hunter Valley $32.00 Very intense, pungent nose, oily texture, needs time - Elin McCoy Cadet D'Oc
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay, Pays d'Oc France $9.99 Palate is crisp and dry. Some pear-apple. Texture is soft and smooth. - Katherine Cole Cadre
Critics Gold 2007 Pinot Noir, The Architects Central Coast $45.00 Subtle and delicious - Ed McCarthy Cakebread Cellars
Critics Platinum 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $61.00 Powerful oaky blackcurrant nose, forceful. Rich, plump, full-bodied, concentrated, very ripe but not jammy. Has svelte tannins and a good texture. Spicy and long, powerful but not overbearing. - Stephen Brook
Best of Show Red 2007 Merlot Napa Valley $54.00 Most impressive for its structure, with everything in beautiful balance. Delicious now but surely capable of extended aging, this is a very serious and very delicious wine. - Paul Lukacs Callaway Vineyard And Winery
Critics Silver 2010 Rosè of Sangiovese, Special Selection Temecula Valley $18.00 Medium to deep pink color; pleasant, herbal, red fruit aroma; zippy palate; some sweetness; rounded in the aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon, Special Selection Temecula Valley $28.00 Solid; well-balanced - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2008 Merlot, Winemaker's Reserve Temecula Valley $38.00 Lots of character - Ed McCarthy Cameron Hughes
Critics Gold 2008 Meritage, Lot 213 Napa Valley $13.00 Ripe, plump, but lovely savory counterpoint. Lovely acidity amplifies the finish. Polished tannins. Subtle chocolate notes add intrigue. Great value! - Michael Apstein
Critics Silver 2008 Meritage, Lot 254 Santa Ynez Valley $15.00 Lovely herbal notes intertwined with spice and ripe fruit flavors. - Michael Apstein
Critics Silver 2009 Meritage California $15.00 Toasty nuances, plummy fruit. Slight chocolate nuances. Suave tannins. - Michael Apstein; - A melange of herbs and vanilla in the nose, silky smooth in the mouth finishing with velvety tannins - Rebecca Murphy
Critics Silver 2009 Syrah / Grenache / Mourvedre, Lot 251 Arroyo Seco $15.00 Garnet with slight paling at rim. Strawberries on nose. Velvety palate of ripe black cherries, strawberries, white pepper. Rather simple; could use more acidity, but an enjoyable wine. - Katherine Cole; - Impressive depth. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2010 Riesling / Chenin Blanc, Lot 259 Columbia Valley $11.00 Ripe summer melons and peaches chased with a bracing citrus acidity. - Nick Passmore
Critics Gold 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon, Lot 211 Napa Valley $22.00 Quite good; well-balanced - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2008 Merlot, Lot 210 Napa Valley $12.00 Easy drinking wine with savory, vanilla, aromas, round, supple black cherry fruit, good balance of fruit, acidity, alcohol, smooth tannins - Rebecca Murphy
Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Noir, Lot 227, Casablanca Valley Chile $15.00 A bit ripe, but pleasant - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2009 Pinot Noir, Lot 255 Yorkville Highlands $15.00 A wound-up, bright bolt of cherry fruit edged by fenugreek and pepper. It's got mellow low tones, but not at the expense of some tense, mineral-edged complexity. - Jon Bonne
Critics Silver 2009 Zinfandel, Lot 191 Lodi $12.00 Dark ruby color; ripe berry aroma, pleasing; medium to full bodied, rounded on the palate; dryish (threshold residual sugar), good balance; ripe berry flavors; flavorful aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Silver 2009 Zinfandel, Lot 219, Monte Rosso Vineyard Sonoma Valley $12.00 Nice fresh fruit, well balanced wine - Marguerite Thomas; - Deep ruby color; heady, oaky aroma, dense; medium bodied, firm on the palate, tannic; bodied berry and wood flavors; sturdy aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Silver 2009 Zinfandel, Lot 221 Lodi $12.00 Rich zippy zin driven by ripe fruit - Marguerite Thomas; - Deep ruby color; pruney aroma, pretty good; medium bodied, rounded on the palate; ripe berry flavors; lingering finish. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay, Lot 212 Carneros $13.00 Lovely toasty nose. Round. - Michael Apstein
Critics Gold 2009 Sauvignon Blanc, Lot 225, Leyda Valley Chile $10.00 Lovely graceful hint of grapefruit rind. Refreshing acidity without aggression - Michael Apstein Campo Viejo
Critics Gold 2007 Rioja DDOC, Crianza Spain $9.99 Finely textured tannins add a good note, nice structure - Marguerite Thomas; - Medium red, brick color; ripe red and black fruit aroma, nice depth; medium bodied, lively on the palate, sweet tannins, quite fine structure; dry, nice acidity, well balanced; bright red fruit flavors, bright aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Silver 2006 Rioja DDOC, Reserva Spain $13.99 Nice balance of fruit, acid, texture and tannin - Marguerite Thomas; - Light to medium ruby color; red fruit, with a note of menthol in the aroma, a hint volatile, medium depth; medium to full bodied, firm and rounded on the palate; dry, medium acidity, almost a note of sweetness, good balance; rustic, red fruit flavors, some oak and earth; medium finish, fresh aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong Campus Oaks
Critics Silver 2008 Zinfandel, Old Vine Lodi $10.99 Medium red color; fine berry aroma; medium bodied, candied orange rind and marmalade aroma, medium to full bodied, rewarding; red berry flavors; tasty aftertaste; a bit sweet and tannic in the aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong Candor
Critics Silver NV Zinfandel, Lot 3 California $16.00 Blackberries covered in dark chocolate make for a heady wine, yet the acidity kicks in to make for a refreshing finish. - Linda Murphy Caposaldo
Critics Gold 2009 Chianti DOCG Italy $10.00 Classic Chianti character, with dark cherry fruit, an earthy bouquet, and layered secondary notes in the finish. Delightful, and very satisfying. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver NV Brut Prosecco DOC Italy $15.00 A briny edge runs through the vanilla-bean and apple flavors, giving it a crispness that's matched by well-defined bubbles. Prosecco with gravitas. - Jon Bonne Casillero Del Diablo
Critics Gold 2009 Carmenere, Reserve, Rapel Valley Chile $12.00 Excellent structure - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2009 Cabernet Sauvignon, Reserve, Central Valley Chile $12.00 Deep ruby, almost black color; ripe, black currant aroma, pretty good, medium depth; medium bodied, layered and rich on the palate, pretty rewarding; dry, nice acidity, good balanced; ripe, red fruit flavors, persistent; medium finish, easy yet firm aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Silver 2010 Sauvignon Blanc, Reserve, Casablanca Valley Chile $12.00 Bright, clean, zesty. Lemony finish. Good length - Michael Apstein Casteller
Critics Silver NV Cava Brut Spain $10.00 Fresh, frothy and showing tremendous mineral power amid its buoyant citrus fruit. a refreshing cava with classic lines. - Jon Bonne Castello Banfi
Critics Gold 2009 Rosso di Montalcino DOC Italy $19.00 Pale around edges. Wow, fabulous aromatics! Ripe fruit and floral component here. Nice acidity. This is a fun, approachable wine. Well integrated. Pleasurable. - Katherine Cole
Critics Silver 2006 Brunello di Montalcino DOCG Italy $55.00 Well-defined structure, with firm tannins providing a frame for full flavor -- but right now, that flavor is muted and somewhat hidden. Here's hoping it will emerge with time. - Paul Lukacs Cedar Creek Winery
Critics Silver NV Vidal American $8.50 Grapey apricot nose. Medium-bodied, fresh, quite a pretty wine and there's enough acidity to balance the sweetness. - Stephen Brook Cellar No. 8
Critics Silver 2008 Merlot California $10.00 Mild cherry nose. Quite rich, supple, moderately concentrated so has some weight of fruit. Long, spicy finish. - Stephen Brook
Critics Gold 2009 Pinot Noir California $10.00 Rich red berries balanced by a zesty finish - Nick Passmore
Critics Silver 2008 Zinfandel California $10.00 Smoky cherry nose, some creosote. Quite rich, broad, juicy, easygoing, but doesn't lack concentration and persistence. A touch sweet but acceptable and not out of balance. - Stephen Brook Chandelle
Critics Gold 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon Sonoma County $20.00 Sweet red and black berry fruit countered by fine structure with zesty acidity. Excellent balance and length! - Paul Lukacs Chateau Frank
Critics Silver 2006 Blanc De Blancs Finger Lakes $29.99 Well done. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2005 Brut Finger Lakes $24.99 Creamy texture, bright apple, pear and a mild toasty note. Crisp and quite full and long. Cheers! - Rich Cook Chateau Meroux
Critics Silver 2007 Merlot, Reserve Bennett Valley $24.99 Juicy, focused and with some real guts to bring to the table. - Jon Bonne Chateau Ste. Michelle
Critics Gold 2007 Meritage, Artist Series Columbia Valley $50.00 Delightfully, a medium-bodied wine; very good length - Mary Ewing-Mulligan; - Elegant, delicate and balanced. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon, Cold Creek Vineyard Columbia Valley $30.00 Dark color. Nose is black currant, dark chocolate. Juicy palate with some blackberry cordial. Acidity. Gravel and pencil shavings. There is heat, but it is appealing here. - Katherine Cole
Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon, Ethos Reserve Columbia Valley $38.00 Sweet but well-balanced, with good depth of flavor. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Gold 2008 Chardonnay, Canoe Ridge Estate Horse Heaven Hills $24.00 Ripe, mouth-filling and spicy, with notes of pear and lemon oil. - Robert Whitley
Critics Gold 2009 Dry Riesling Columbia Valley $9.00 Vivid mineral nose suggests a tight, restrained wine, yet the palate is far more generous, with Meyer lemon and pink grapefruit flavors, background notes of lime zest and fennel, and with a crisp close. - Linda Murphy; - Spicy mineral nose, apricot and quince. Good attack, lean and lively, has drive and persistence, and a strong dry finish. - Stephen Brook Chateau Tanunda
Critics Silver 2008 Shiraz, Grand Barossa Barossa $18.99 Very juicy, fresh, reliable - Mary Ewing-Mulligan Clos Du Bois
Critics Silver 2006 Marlstone Alexander Valley $50.00 Chewy, powerful, oaky and intense. - Mary Ewing-Mulligan
Critics Gold 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon North Coast $14.99 Ripe sweet black fruit offset by herbal savory elements. Polished tannins. Good length. - Michael Apstein
Critics Gold 2008 Chardonnay, Calcaire Russian River Valley $25.00 Ripe and lemony, with toast in the background and good balance. Nice. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Grigio California $11.99 Nervosity, crisp, a thirst quencher - Marguerite Thomas; - Medium straw color; perky, fresh apple aroma; medium bodied, racy on the palate; dry, nice acidity, well balanced; lemony, apple flavors; medium finish. - Wilfred Wong Clos LaChance
Critics Gold 2008 Lila's Cuvee Red Wine, Estate Vineyard Central Coast $50.00 Lots of character. Flavorful. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon, Whitestone Vineyard Central Coast $40.00 A dry cab, with concentration, firmness, yet all in balance - Mary Ewing-Mulligan
Critics Silver 2008 Malbec, Estate Central Coast $35.00 Round, plummy nose with firm tannins and pleasant citric acidity propping up the long finish. Food friendly! - Rich Cook
Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Noir Santa Cruz Mountains $32.00 Very lovely aroma, nuanced; very good concentration of fruit character. Silky texture; slightly sweet impression - Mary Ewing-Mulligan Cloud Valley
Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Noir California $7.99 A lean, tart style, with a subtle earthy nose, dried cherry and pomegranate flavors, and a tight, crisp finish. - Linda Murphy; - Ripe cherry nose with some wood influence. Quite rich, with some tannins and structure, and a spicy finish. - Stephen Brook Columbia Crest
Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon, Grand Estates Columbia Valley $12.00 Deep ruby color; ripe and fine, oaky, with attractive ripe berry flavors; medium bodied, firm palate; ripe fruit, sweet oak flavors; medium finish, firm aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong Concannon Vineyard
Critics Gold 2008 Petite Sirah, Conservancy Livermore Valley $14.00 Big, round, mellow and voluptuous. - Nick Passmore
Critics Gold 2008 Shiraz, Selected Vineyards Central Coast $10.00 Red plum flavor that integrates interesting savory notes in a seamless way. - W. Blake Gray Cook's
Critics Silver NV Spumante California $6.99 Very good. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver NV Extra Dry California $6.99 Delicious. - Ed McCarthy Crooked Vine
Critics Silver 2008 Jim's Cabernet Sauvignon Rutherford $42.00 Soft and likeable, well-balanced - Mary Ewing-Mulligan Crossing Vineyards And Winery
Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Noir Pennsylvania $22.00 Lean, taut with lots of nerve - Mary Ewing-Mulligan Cupcake
Critics Silver 2010 Malbec, Mendoza Argentina $14.00 Explosively, volcanically powerful. - Nick Passmore
Critics Silver 2009 Merlot Central Coast $14.00 This is what most merlot drinkers expect in a wine: ripe, plump, mouthfilling flavors, supple tannins and a hint of sweet oak and barrel spice. Very drinkable. - Linda Murphy
Critics Gold 2009 Pinot Noir Central Coast $14.00 Charm and balance, pretty fruit, hints of spice - Nick Passmore
Critics Silver NV Prosecco DOC, Extra Dry Italy $14.00 Finds a frothy way to show off its orange blossom and peach flavors without letting the sweetness take over. Nicely balanced. - Jon Bonne
Critics Gold 2009 Chardonnay Central Coast $14.00 Firm oaky nose, with plenty of pineappley fruit. Rich, full-bodied, opulent, but has spice and vigour. Exotic fruit but shows some precision and length. - Stephen Brook
Critics Gold 2010 Riesling Mosel $14.00 Light dusty, floral aromas, light, bright floral, stone fruit flavors, lively acidity - Rebecca Murphy
Critics Silver 2010 Sauvignon Blanc Marlborough $14.00 Medium straw color; intense herbal, dried citrus aroma; medium bodied, textured on the palate; citrus flavor; fine aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong Curtis Winery
Critics Silver 2007 Heritage Cuvee Santa Barbara County $20.00 Garnet to rim. Nose understated and fresh. Dark fruit, earth, licorice, spice, gravel, coffee. Palate is understated, tannic, but nice bitter licorice/Campari note to finish. Oak brings a vanilla undernote. tannins are too aggressive for my taste but this could be a good food wine. - Katherine Cole
Critics Silver 2007 Grenache Santa Ynez Valley $25.00 Light ruby color; fresh and frisky raspberry aroma; medium bodied, zippy and fresh on the palate; medium bodied, fine and lively on the palate; dry, nice acidity, balance; pleasing raspberry flavors; medium finish, easy aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Gold 2007 Syrah, Ambassador's Vineyard Santa Ynez Valley $22.00 Big and fleshy, raspberry jam, spread it on toast or enjoy a glass of it with big red meat or lamb - Marguerite Thomas; - Deep ruby, black color; dusty, asphalt aroma; full bodied, rounded and fat on the palate; black fruit and tar flavors; peppy aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong Cycles Gladiator
Critics Silver 2009 Merlot California $10.99 Blackberry, black cherry and bacon on the nose, bright fruit and spice on the palate. A solid cocktail style merlot. - Rich Cook
Critics Silver 2009 Syrah California $10.99 Lots of tannin on rear palate balances sweetness on the fore. A good guzzle - Mary Ewing-Mulligan
Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Grigio California $10.99 Fresh and lively, but also soft, so inviting. A good aperitif choice. - Paul Lukacs D & S
Critics Silver 2007 Red Blend California $22.00 Rich oaky nose, plums and chocolate. Broad, lush, very ripe but not jammy, quite chocolatey, spicy and lively, if not very coherent or harmonious. - Stephen Brook Darcie Kent
Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon, Madden Ranch Livermore Valley $24.00 Dark to rim. Wow, juicy fruit on nose, and pine tree. Gravel. Minty, eucalyptus aromatics and palate. - Katherine Cole; - Varietally true, with taut tannins to keep the sweet fruit appropriately in check. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2008 Merlot, Picazo Livermore Valley $30.00
Critics Gold 2008 Pinot Noir, West Pinnacles Vineyard Monterey County $24.00 Bright and vivacious in the mouth with herbal, savory notes complementing the red cherry fruit. - Rebecca Murphy
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay, DeMayo Vineyard Livermore Valley $30.00 Well balanced and elegant, with notes of pear, apple and spice. - Robert Whitley David Bruce Winery
Critics Gold 2008 Pinot Noir, Winemakers Reserve Anderson Valley $55.00 Chewy and beautifully spiced -- think kaffir lime and shoyu. A slightly musky tone won't take all comers, but those who go there will dig the robust, stony cherry fruit that it exudes. - Jon Bonne
Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Noir Santa Cruz Mountains $55.00 Solid and robust in its big, swaggery fruit. - Jon Bonne
Critics Gold 2008 Chardonnay Santa Cruz Mountains $55.00 Rich without being overdone, this creamy chardonnay exhibits pretty aromas of pear and apple, with a hint of oak vanillin. - Robert Whitley David Girard Vineyard
Critics Platinum 2007 Coda Rouge, Estate Vineyard El Dorado $30.00 Paling to rim. Nose is crushed wild herbs. Palate is peppery, forthright. exciting. Dried cherries, licorice, red chiles. crushed dried herbs. Well-integrated oak adds notes of smoke and caramel. lingering spice on the finish. - Katherine Cole
Critics Gold 2009 Mourvedre, Estate Vineyard El Dorado $34.00 Pretty aromatics, bright red fruit. Mid garnet color. Palate is light, gently spiced. dried and fresh red cherries. intriguing red apple note. softness to approach. Supple leather. Vanilla. Floral notes. There's a touch of cola tinged with Campari as well. I love the fresh acidity to the finish. - Katherine Cole; - Real Rhone character, with a peppery, gamey character beneath the more obvious juicy fresh fruit. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Gold 2008 Okei-San El Dorado $70.00 Redwood forest, incense, delicate pleasures lie in wait with this wine - Marguerite Thomas; - Medium dark ruby color; red fruit aroma; medium bodied, zippy and fine; red fruit; well balanced; long, lively aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong Davis Bynum Winery
Critics Gold 2008 Chardonnay Russian River Valley $25.00 Rich and full-bodied, with an underpinning of fresh acidity and a lovely dollop of lemon cräme and pear aroma. - Robert Whitley Diseno
Critics Silver 2010 Malbec, Old Vine, Mendoza Argentina $10.99 A rare bird - a polished and elegant malbec - Nick Passmore Dolce Vita
Critics Silver NV Lambrusco, Del Emiliaght IGT Italy $3.99 Lovely example of semi-sweet Lambrusco - Ed McCarthy; - Peppy and proper, with enough wound-up sweet bayberry to charm. - Jon Bonne Domaine Carneros
Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Noir, Estate Carneros $35.00 Dry, lean, some earthiness - Mary Ewing-Mulligan
Critics Platinum 2008 Pinot Noir, Famous Gate Carneros $68.00 Elegance, true pinot character, lean and lovely - Marguerite Thomas; - Medium red, crimson; outstanding aroma; dried strawberries, leaves, elegant, medium to full depth, pure; medium bodied, textured and rounded on the palate; bright, red strawberry flavors, excellent concentration; medium to long finish. - Wilfred Wong Domaine Carneros by Tattinger
Critics Gold 2007 Brut Carneros $26.00 Very good - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2005 La Reve Blanc de Blancs Carneros $95.00 Stony and herb-driven, with a lean and mean disposition and great frothy energy. - Jon Bonne Domaine Laurier
Critics Platinum 2009 Cabernet Sauvignon, Reserve Sonoma County $12.99 Energetic with a swirl of good ripe fruit balanced by soft tannins - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Silver 2007 Merlot, Reserve Sonoma County $12.99 Lifted black currant, cherry aromas, cherry, vanilla flavors, light bodied, moderate tannins. For drinking, not for thinking - Rebecca Murphy
Critics Silver NV Brut California $9.99 Well balanced - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay, Reserve Sonoma County $12.99 Fresh fruity pineapple notes. Lovely balance. - Michael Apstein Domaine Ste. Michelle
Critics Silver NV Blanc De Noirs Columbia Valley $13.00 Tasty. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver NV Brut Columbia Valley $13.00 Delicious now - Ed McCarthy Domenico Wines
Critics Silver 2006 Dolcetto California $28.00 Nice dried plum fruit with good structure. Riper than an italian dolcetto would be. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Silver 2006 Nebbiolo Amador County $28.00 Impressive length on the palate and a lovely somewhat floral bouquet. The only problem is that the wine is a bit hot. - Paul Lukacs Donati Family Vineyard
Critics Gold 2007 Ezio Paicines $34.99 Satisfyingly deep and rich, with a lingering sweetness in the finish. Very drinkable now but should reward mid-term aging by becoming more complex. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Gold 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon Paicines $18.99 Harmonious wine, fruit and tannins relate well to each other, generous finish - Marguerite Thomas; - Deep ruby color; attractive aroma, black currant and ripe berries, fine depth; medium to full bodied, rounded and layered on the palate; dry, medium acidity, good balance; ripe fruit flavors, with a streak of oak; medium finish, fine, tasty aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Gold 2007 Merlot Paicines $17.99 Plummy. Some herbal notes. Good structure. Fine tannins. Lovely aromatics. Hint of chocolate-like notes - Michael Apstein Dr. Konstantin Frank Wine Cellars
Critics Gold 2009 Gewurztraminer, Reserve Finger Lakes $24.99 Bright, on point and showing its floral stripes, with a deep and gratifying peach flavor. - Jon Bonne
Critics Platinum 2009 Rkatsiteli Finger Lakes $17.99 Mineraly nuances combine with citrus notes in this beautifully balanced wine. Long and graceful. Pure and precise. It has class and complexity. Exciting wine. - Michael Apstein
Critics Silver 2010 Riesling, Dry Finger Lakes $14.99 Rather sweet apple compote nose. Lush, juicy, creamy but rather heavy for riesling, though quite concentrated and lively on the finish. - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver 2010 Riesling, Semi-Dry Finger Lakes $14.99 Floral and wintergreen nose, quite juicy and appealing - Elin McCoy; - Rich lemon pudding in a glass. - Nick Passmore Dry Creek Vineyard
Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon Dry Creek Valley $25.00 Ripe, but delicious - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2009 Zinfandel, Heritage Sonoma County $19.00 Attractive briary fruit. fine tannins and acidity lend structure and prevent it from being sweet. - Michael Apstein
Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay, Foggy Oaks Russian River Valley $20.00 Elegant, with delicate aromas of pear, baked apple and spice. - Robert Whitley Dutcher Crossing Winery
Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon, Taylor Reserve Dry Creek Valley $43.00 Good balance, depth and richness - Mary Ewing-Mulligan
Critics Silver 2009 Zinfandel, Proprietors Reserve Dry Creek Valley $29.00 Juicy raspberry nose. Fresh, clean, brisk, simple but has a light touch with attractive acidity on the finish. - Stephen Brook
Critics Gold 2010 Sauvignon Blanc Dry Creek Valley $22.00 Delicious and complex, with flavors of lemon-lime, stones, and chalk. . - Elin McCoy Eberle Winery
Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon / Syrah Paso Robles $29.00 Has good consistency of velvety texture, is dry, and not too big - Mary Ewing-Mulligan; - Tangy red plum flavor with meaty tannins. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Silver NV Full Boar Red Paso Robles $15.00 Easy drinking. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2008 Cotes-du-Robles Paso Robles $21.00 Real depth of flavor with peppery spice in the finish that contributes exciting complexity. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2009 Cotes-du-Robles Blanc Paso Robles $24.00 Good balance, long and satisfying. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Gold 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon, Vineyard Selection Paso Robles $19.00 Elegant cab, medium body, - Marguerite Thomas; - Medium ruby color; ripe red fruit, pencil lead aroma, medium depth; medium bodied, soft, yet firm and juicy on the palate; dryish, soft acidity, balanced; tart, red fruit flavors, medium finish, soft aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon Paso Robles $34.00 Very fine; well-balanced - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2010 Viognier, Mill Road Vineyard Paso Robles $21.00 Apple fruit with a pretty floral note. - W. Blake Gray Emiliana
Critics Platinum 2008 Coyam, Los Robles Estate, Colchagua Valley Chile $34.00 Opulent plummy nose. Rich, voluptuous, creamy, full-bodied, yet there's good acidity to balance the wine and keep it from being too heavy. Spicy, vigorous, and very long. - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver 2010 Natura Sauvignon Blanc, Valle de Casablanca Chile $11.00 Citrus, melon fruit, crisp acidity. - Rebecca Murphy Eponymous
Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $58.99 Solid, firm, conentrated - Mary Ewing-Mulligan Erath Winery
Critics Gold 2009 Pinot Noir Oregon $18.00 Some real savory and sweet ripe fruit for an inexpensive pinot, and surprising length - Nick Passmore.
Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Noir, Estate Selection Willamette Valley $36.00 Hint of earth. Nice counterpoint to bright fruit. Clove allspice notes. - Michael Apstein Estraie
Critics Silver 2006 Sortie Red Sonoma County $14.00 Pleasant - Ed McCarthy Falkner Winery
Critics Silver 2007 Merlot Temecula Valley $24.95
Critics Platinum 2009 Riesling Temecula Valley $16.95 Great aromatics. Floral. Peachy. Balanced. Lovely length! A great choice for Asian fare. - Michael Apstein Fat Cat Cellars
Critics Silver 2009 Merlot California $8.99 Lots of life in this inexpensive charmer. Medium weight, restrained fresh fruit, whiff of oak. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Noir California $8.99 A crowd-pleasing wine that's supple, plump and loaded with juicy red fruit. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Grigio California $8.99 Palate is creamy and pleasant, with some nice spritz. Finish has an almond-paste note to it. - Katherine Cole Fat Monk
Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Noir Central Coast $15.00 Buoyant berries, a mushroomy accent and lots of chewy orange peel to round it out. This is fun stuff, with truly earth-bound pinot bones. - Jon Bonne Fattoria Cardella
Critics Silver 2009 Merlot, Cardella Ranch, Vineyard 22 Fresno County $14.99 Fresh. Lovely aromatics. Plummy. Fresh. Opens nicely with air. - Michael Apstein Fernz
Critics Gold 2010 Sauvignon Blanc Marlborough $13.99 Pure and precise, bright piercing style. Racy. Good length and depth. Good value. - Michael Apstein; - Bright lime zest aromas, crisp, fresh grapefruit, lime zest flavors, snappy acidity. A happy, charming wine - Rebecca Murphy Feudi Di San Gregorio
Critics Gold 2008 Rubrato Aglianico, Irpinia IGT Italy $15.99 Has a hint of jammy ripeness but is solid, firm, ripe - Mary Ewing-Mulligan; - A wine that keeps on unfolding, with dried plums and cherries and some cherry tobacco. The mouthfeel is appealing: good acidity and tannins, giving it some textural grip. - W. Blake Gray Finca Constancia
Critics Silver 2009 Tempranillo, Parcela 23, Tierra de Castilla Spain $20.99 Lush and plump, with a spicy kick, it relies on black fruit, black licorice and black pepper. - Linda Murphy Fish Eye
Critics Silver 2010 Merlot South Eastern Australia $8.00 Bright cherry fruit in a soft, easy to drink package. - Paul Lukacs Flipflop
Critics Gold 2009 Merlot California $7.00 Impressive depth of flavor, especially given the low price tag. A serious wine at a value price. - Paul Lukacs Flying Winemaker
Critics Silver 2009 Zinfandel, Ancient Vine Lodi $13.00 Medium deep ruby color; fine, ripe raspberry and blackberry aroma, fine depth; rich on the palate; bold berry flavors; delicious aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong Fog Head
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay, Highland Series Reserve Monterey $13.99 Lush peachy nose. Rich, full-bodied, juicy, plenty of ripe fruit here, and some spice on the finish. Quite long, but drink soon. - Stephen Brook Folie A Deux
Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $28.00 Good structure; have with beef - Ed McCarthy Fontana D'Italia
Critics Silver 2009 Chianti DOCG Italy $10.99 Simple and direct, but satisfying, with an impressively long finish. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2010 Pinot Grigio, Delle Venezie IGT Italy $10.99 Light straw color; pleasant, dried citrus aroma, medium depth; medium bodied, crisp on the palate; dry, nice acidity, good balance; ripe fruit, dried sorrel flavors; medium finish, delicate aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong Foodies
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay California $7.99 Paler straw color. Nose is soft and delicate. Apple blossom. Palate is soft and pleasing. For this price range, a subtle and pleasing wine. - Katherine Cole ForeFront by Pine Ridge Vineyards
Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa, San Luis Obispo, Lake Counties $24.00 Very good; drink now - Ed McCarthy Forest Glen
Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Noir California $9.99 Full-bodied and ever-so lightly sweet, with rich, juicy strawberry and red cherry flavors and a healthy does of toasty oak for complexity. - Linda Murphy; - Ripe juicy red fruits nose. Sleek, juicy, plenty of upfront fruit, and moderate length of flavour - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay California $9.99 Buttered popcorn and sweet vanilla distinguish this lush, lavish chard. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2010 Pinot Grigio, Tehachapi Clone California $8.99 Light straw color; fresh, ripe fruit aroma, on the light side, clean; medium bodied, rounded on the palate; mostly dry, medium acidity, balanced; pleasant, tart citrus flavors; medium finish. - Wilfred Wong Four Vines
Critics Gold 2008 Zinfandel, The Sophisticate Sonoma County $25.00 Lush smoky cherry and red fruits nose. Rich, broad, opulent, moderately concentrated and has some tannic grip. Spicy and long. - Stephen Brook Foxhorn
Critics Gold NV Pinot Grigio / Chardonnay South Eastern Australia $8.00 Honeysucle touched by golden sunshine. - Nick Passmore
Critics Silver NV White Zinfandel American $8.00 Bright strawberry spice nose with a leafy note. Good acid balance, light crisp and ready for poolside. - Rich Cook
Critics Silver NV Cabernet Sauvignon South Eastern Australia $8.00 Nicely made, with some olivey cabernet character; creamy, mellow & succulent - Nick Passmore Francis Ford Coppola
Critics Platinum 2008 Cinema, Director's Cut Sonoma County $50.00 Lifted minty. black cherry aromas lead to a firm, acid-freshened palate of dark berries, licorice, black pepper and a hint of vanilla. very complex and integrated, with a crisp close. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver 2010 Sofia Rosè Monterey County $17.00 Light cherry fruit in a cheerful, refreshing wine. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Gold 2009 Pinot Noir, Director's Sonoma Coast $21.00 Lovely balance of fruit and earth. Suave. Ripe, but not overdone. Lovely length - Michael Apstein; - The focus is on pretty black cherry fruit, smooth and elegant on the palate with velvet tannins - Rebecca Murphy
Critics Gold 2009 Chardonnay, Director's Cut Russian River Valley $21.00 Well balanced, showing lovely notes of pear and apple and judiciously restrained oak. - Robert Whitley
Critics Gold 2010 Sauvignon Blanc, Diamond Collection, Yellow Label California $17.00 Juicy, zingy - Marguerite Thomas; - Light straw, green color; tart citrus aroma; light zippiness on the palate; dry, nice acidity, well balanced; tart citrus flavors, pretty good; medium finish, crisp aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong Frank Family Vineyards
Critics Gold 2009 Pinot Noir Carneros $35.00 Terriffic concentration of red fruit and black berries; silky texture; lots of heft and character. - Mary Ewing-Mulligan
Critics Gold 2009 Chardonnay Carneros $32.50 Well balanced, exhibiting a note of ripe pear and lemon cräme, with firm acidity and a crisp, clean finish. - Robert Whitley; - An intense wine with vibrant lemon fruit. - W. Blake Gray Frogtown Cellars
Critics Gold 2006 Cabernet Franc Lumpkin County $29.99 A delicate, elegant style, with moderate wood influence and a long, so satisfying finish. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Gold 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon Lumpkin County $29.99 Distinct East Coast character with full but beautifully integrated fruit. Bravo! - Paul Lukacs
Critics Gold 2006 Merlot, Kritzer Family Reserve Lumpkin County $48.99 Extremely impressive, with an attractive green (but nor under-ripe) quality in the nose, followed by long, well-defined flavors, with real complexity in the finish. Can compete with merlots made anywhere in the world. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Gold 2006 Tannat Lumpkin County $29.99 Brightly floral and loamy, with tart cherry and a beetroot depth, and tannins that stretch their legs just far enough. Bring on the barbecue. - Jon Bonne G.H. Mumm
Critics Gold NV Champagne, Cordon Rouge, Brut Reims $35.00 Very good; excellent balance - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold NV Champagne, Mumm de Cramant, Grand Cru Reims $75.00 Excellent ; very fine - Ed McCarthy
Wine of the Year NV Champagne, Brut Rose Reims $70.00 Roasted orange and clove, with dried strawberry and blossom and a stony grip that gives it terrific depth. A serious wine for the table. - Jon Bonne Gabbiano
Critics Silver 2006 Chianti DOCG Riserva Italy $23.00 Dark color. Dried cherries, leather and balsamic. Hazelnuts. Quite grippy, but with good acidity. Brightness at finish brings it back into balance. Texture is soft. This could age well, I think. - Katherine Cole; - Rustic and earthy. Will satisfy if you like that style. - Paul Lukacs Gallo Family Vineyards
Critics Silver NV Sweet Chardonnay California $5.99 With its crisp acidity, tastes dryer than it is. Nice! - Mary Ewing-Mulligan
Critics Gold NV Moscato, Valencia DDO Spain $5.99 Delicate and pretty, this has nice apricot fruit and a balanced level of sweetness. - W. Blake Gray Glen Carlou
Critics Silver 2008 Grand Classique, Paarl South Africa $17.00 Juicy. bright. mostly fruit, but not over ripe. Fine tannins. - Michael Apstein
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay, Paarl South Africa $17.00 Lightly toasty nose, apple and apricot. Rich, rounded, full-bodied, has concentration, is solid and fruity. - Stephen Brook Gloria Ferrer
Critics Platinum 2007 Pinot Noir, Estate Grown Carneros $22.00 Rich red fruit, spice, not overdone. Some earthy nuances. Suave and classy. Good length. Lovely layers. Classy wine! shows the flavor without weight - Michael Apstein
Critics Platinum 2006 Pinot Noir, Rust Rock Terrace Vineyard Carneros $40.00 Wow! I'm impressed. Great balance - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2006 Pinot Noir, Gravel Knob Vineyard Carneros $40.00 Lovely fruit - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2006 Blanc De Blancs Carneros $24.00 Excellent; fine balance - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold NV Blanc De Noirs Carneros $20.00 Thrilling orange-peel, strawberry and agave nectar notes that lift the slightly sweet bass line underneath. - Jon Bonne
Critics Silver NV Brut Sonoma County $20.00 Has a proper berryish depth that portends its complexity. Roasted carrot and bread dough accents give it a savory-sweet interplay. - Jon Bonne
Critics Silver 2002 Royal Cuvee Carneros $32.00 Quite good.- Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver NV Va de Vi, Ultra Cuvee Sonoma County $22.00 Tasty. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2006 Brut Rosè Carneros $42.00 Classy and polished - peach fuzz, soapstone, thyme and red berry, with a beautiful yeasty edge that gives it distinction. - Jon Bonne Gnarly Head
Critics Gold 2009 Zinfandel Lodi $10.99 Textbook briary nose, very clean, fresh raspberry and dark cherry fruit, creamy vanillin in the background. Balanced and very drinkable. - Linda Murphy
Critics Platinum 2010 Chardonnay California $10.99 Here is a chardonnay with minerality and bracing acidity, and with a mid-palate of juicy pear and apple. It's got a little bit of everything, which adds up to a lot: balance. - Linda Murphy Godwin Family Vineyards
Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay, Floral Clone Russian River Valley $28.00 Good ripeness and richness without being cloying, showing hints of pear and tropical fruit against a backdrop of sweet brown spices. - Robert Whitley Gonzalez Byass
Critics Silver NV Tio Pepe, Fino Muy Seco, Jerez DDO Spain $17.99 Almonds on the nose. Palate is briny and dry, with almonds, heat. Finish is long and spiced with white pepper. - Katherine Cole; - Very attractive bouquet, followed by dry, almost pasty flavors. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Gold NV Oloroso Dulce, Solera 1847, Jerez DDO Spain $19.99 Cola color. nose of molasses, gingerbread. palate is smooth and silky, delicately spiced. undertones of earth and quinine. Length to the subtle ginger-spiced, woody finish. Balanced and vibrant. - Katherine Cole; - Luscious and seductive. one sip makes you want another, and another, and another . . . - Paul Lukacs Graffigna Centenario
Critics Silver 2010 Pinot Grigio, Reserve, San Juan Argentina $12.99 Attractive floral nose, crisp acidity with lemon and stonefruit mix. Dry, refreshing, old world style! - Rich Cook Green Truck
Critics Silver 2009 Zinfandel Mendocino County $12.99 Medium red color; bright red fruit aroma, with anise, fine and appealing; ripe raspberry flavors; excellent; lively aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong Guerra Family Cellars
Critics Silver 2008 Petite Sirah, Attitude, Pepper Tree Ranch San Benito County $32.00 Marked by restraint and a finely-hued structure - Nick Passmore
Critics Silver 2009 Viognier, Attitude, Pepper Tree Ranch San Benito County $24.00 It smells earthy but tastes fruity and lively, with plenty of golden apple and some floral notes. - W. Blake Gray Hacienda Altavina
Critics Gold 2010 Carmenere, Central Valley Chile $5.49 Very fine; well-balanced - Ed McCarthy Hagafen
Critics Silver 2007 Cuvee De Noir Napa Valley $36.00 Delicious. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay Oak Knoll District $24.00 Lively, with lemon fruit, floral notes and a hint of melon - W. Blake Gray
Best of Show White 2010 Riesling, Devoto Vineyards Lake County $18.00 White flowers. White peaches. Delicate and long. - Michael Apstein
Critics Gold 2010 Riesling, Rancho Wieruszowski Vineyard Napa Valley $24.00 Ripe peaches. lovely acidity. Great balance and interplay between fruit and acid. - Michael Apstein; - Yummy, sweet and lively peachy flavors with zesty acidity. Have it with foie gras, legal or not. - Rebecca Murphy Hahn Winery
Critics Gold 2010 G S M Central Coast $12.00 Spicy, but at the same time fruit-filled, with meaty undertones. a super barbecue wine. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2009 Cabernet Sauvignon Central Coast $12.00 Herbal notes balance ripe black fruit. - Michael Apstein
Critics Platinum 2009 Merlot Central Coast $12.00 Dense black cherry nose. rich, full-bodied, creamy, has weight and concentration. Vigorous, spicy, and long, with excellent balance and a sturdy finish. - Stephen Brook
Critics Gold 2009 Pinot Gris Monterey $12.00 Lots of green spices, full, rich, lemongrass elegance - Elin McCoy; - Delicate, refined and elegant - Nick Passmore Handley Cellars
Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Noir Mendocino County $25.00 Juicy cherry fruit with depth. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay, Estate Vineyard Anderson Valley $20.00 Restrained and elegant, showing notes of green apple and pear, with good balance. - Robert Whitley; - Nice intensity, with plenty of upfront lemon fruit. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Gold 2010 Gewurztraminer Anderson Valley $18.00 Spicy, with a hint of rose petal and juicy acidity. - Robert Whitley
Critics Platinum 2009 Pinot Gris Anderson Valley $18.00 Very intense, dry, full and filled with flavor, long finish; tang and style! - Elin McCoy; - Irresistibly seductive. the plush ripe fruit upfront gives an entirely misleading impression of sweetness -- on the long, mineral rich finish it's bone dry. - Nick Passmore Harbes Family Vineyard
Critics Silver 2007 Merlot, Old Barn North Fork of Long Island $20.00 Lively; refreshing - Ed McCarthy Haute
Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Noir, Haute Red California $11.99 Concentrated - Ed McCarthy Hazlitt 1852 Vineyard
Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Franc Finger Lakes $22.00 Pale rim. Caramel on nose. Green bell pepper. Tannic. Juicy acidity at finish, with lingering white pepper and spice. Oak is expressed in well-integrated butterscotch. - Katherine Cole
Critics Gold 2008 Merlot Finger Lakes $22.00 Easy-drinking. - Ed McCarthy.
Critics Silver 2008 Riesling, Homestead Reserve Finger Lakes $18.00 Reticent in aroma, this wine blossoms in the mouth with tangy white peach and grapefruit flavors and is quite appealing. - Linda Murphy Hearthstone Vineyard And Winery
Critics Silver 2009 Pearl Paso Robles $24.00 Nose: honeysuckle. Palate is clean and smooth. Some heat here, but also some acidity that lingers on the finish with notes of white tea, peach. - Katherine Cole
Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Noir Paso Robles $40.00 Funky but fine - Ed McCarthy Henry Estate Winery
Critics Silver 2008 Henry V Umpqua Valley $25.00 Ripe red plum flavor makes this wine cheerful and charming. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Platinum 2008 Pinot Noir Oregon $18.00 The rich earthiness is beautifully complemented by glowing red berry fruit. - Nick Passmore
Critics Gold 2008 Gewurztraminer, Dry Umpqua Valley $13.00 Dry; understated; well-done - Ed McCarthy Hogue Cellars
Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Grigio Columbia Valley $10.99 Has some heft, hints of pear - Marguerite Thomas; - Medium straw color; bright citrus aroma, quite good; medium bodied, racy and rich on the palate; dry, nice acidity, well balanced; bright, ripe lemony flavors, excellent concentration; medium to lingering finish, brisk aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Silver 2009 Riesling Columbia Valley $10.99 Vibrant and floral. Nicely balanced. - Michael Apstein Houdini Vineyards
Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon, Glendale Ranch Napa Valley $49.95 An elegant wine with nice cherry fruit and a silky mouthfeel. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Gold 2007 Merlot Oakville $39.95 Well-done; excellent balance - Ed McCarthy HRM Rex Goliath
Critics Silver NV Free Range Red California $7.50 Really juicy and voluptuous! Wild blackberry, notes of licorice, orange peel and dark chocolate, wrapped in velvety tannins and with a brisk finish. For fans of fruit-driven wines. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver NV Pinot Noir Italy $7.50 Light raspberry nose, quite pretty. Supple, ripe, and shows a light touch. Not a big wine but has some typicity. - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver NV Chardonnay California $7.50 A lively, refreshing chardonnay, with fine balance and a crisp finish. - Paul Lukacs Hughes Wellman
Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon St. Helena $50.00 Softish, ample, with lots of ripe fruit, while still retaining cab firmness - Mary Ewing-Mulligan Huntington
Critics Gold 2009 Cabernet Sauvignon California $14.00 Subtle black olive notes add complexity to cassis and other black-fruit elements. Polished tannins. Lovely balance of sweet fruit and savory elements. Good value. - Michael Apstein
Critics Silver 2009 Sauvignon Blanc Dry Creek Valley $14.00 Zesty citrus notes - Michael Apstein Husch Vineyards
Critics Gold 2010 Pinot Noir Vin Gris Anderson Valley $18.00 Delicate melon aroma and flavor, good balancing acidity-- food friendly - Mary Ewing-Mulligan
Critics Gold 2009 Pinot Noir Anderson Valley $23.00 Bright red fruit character, fresh acidity; very dry, herbal nuance; has delicacy & charm. A light pinot noir, but has lots of integrity - Mary Ewing-Mulligan
Critics Gold 2010 Late Harvest Gewurztraminer Anderson Valley $20.00 Pale color. Clean, fresh nose of rose water, lychee. Palate is smooth and silky. A bit of acidity, too--nice for gewurz. This would be delicious with poundcake, fresh fruit, strawberry shortcake. - Katherine Cole
Critics Gold 2010 Chenin Blanc, La Ribera Vineyards Mendocino $11.00 Lovely pear and melon notes, beautifully balanced with juicy acidity. - Robert Whitley; - A delightful wine with ripe peach flavor and pretty floral notes. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay, Vine One Anderson Valley $18.00 Light dusty, apple, citrus aromas and flavors, lively acidity. - Rebecca Murphy
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay Mendocino $15.00 Nice cocktail style chard. Tropical and citrus fruits with a light butterscotch note. - Rich Cook
Critics Silver 2009 Gewurztraminer, T-Bud Dry Cuvee Anderson Valley $17.00 Stone fruit flavors with floral notes. A pretty wine, perfect for porch sipping -- or dinner. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Gold 2009 Gewurztraminer Anderson Valley $14.00 Lots of flavor; great varietal character - Ed McCarthy Hyatt Vineyards
Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon Rattlesnake Hills $11.00 Medium dark, ruby color; ripe and sexy with loads of ripe fruit and sweet oak, excellent depth, perhaps a bit too much in the barrel department; medium bodied, rounded and layered on the palate; dryish, soft to medium acidity, could have some residual sugar, balanced; ripe, red and black fruit flavors with a definite shading of oak; medium finish. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Gold 2010 Riesling Rattlesnake Hills $11.00 Sweet but not at all cloying, instead, crisp and bright, but lusciosuly sweet. - Paul Lukacs I Heart California
Critics Gold NV Cabernet Sauvignon California $7.99 A riper, sweeter style than some, though properly cab, with juicy cassis and blackberry flavors, a hint of cedar and toast, and a crisp finish. - Linda Murphy; - Very ripe, juicy, black cherry nose, has vibrancy. Lush, juicy, very ripe, quite concentrated, but lively and long, with some tannic grip. - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver NV Pinot Grigio California $7.99 Appealing citrus nose. Pineapple. Palate: mineral and light citrus. A bit of leesy texture. Very light, smooth, pleasing aperitif. - Katherine Cole Inniskillin
Best of Show Dessert 2007 Vidal Ice Wine, VQA Niagara Peninsula $60.00 Lavish and lush, with honeyed apricot flavors and a long, lingering, ever-evolving finish. delectable! - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2007 Riesling Ice Wine, VQA Niagara Peninsula $80.00 Very tasty, but on the edge of being out of balance, the sweet fruit being so intense. Still, for drinking right now, it's yummy. - Paul Lukacs J. Lohr Winery
Critics Silver 2007 Cuvee PAU Paso Robles $50.00 Soft and fleshy, a dry wine on the plump side thanks to its rich, ripe fruit character - Mary Ewing-Mulligan; - Ripe red fruit and a silky mouthfeel make this wine a pleasure. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Gold 2007 Cuvee POM Paso Robles $50.00 Ripe fruit and good balance: A wine that might disappear from the glass quickly. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Gold 2009 Pinot Noir, Falcon's Perch Monterey County $17.00 Warm spice flows over here -- mace and allspice, accenting a mellow cherry and surprising mineral bite. offering both broad appeal and some real intrigue. - Jon Bonne
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay, October Night Arroyo Seco $25.00 Rich lemon fruit with a custardy feel. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay, Arroyo Vista Arroyo Seco $25.00 Crisp and refreshing, showing hints of citrus, pear and oak vanillin. - Robert Whitley
Critics Gold 2009 Sauvignon Blanc, Carol's Vineyard Napa Valley $25.00 Delicate, polished and lady-like. - Nick Passmore Jacob's Creek
Critics Silver 2009 Shiraz Cabernet South Eastern Australia $7.99 Fresh and dried red plums with some savory notes. Good value. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Silver 2009 Cabernet Sauvignon, Reserve Coonawarra $13.99 Medium deep ruby color; ripe, almost watermelon-like aroma, red berries and oak, medium depth; medium bodied, brief on the palate; dry, nice acidity, well balanced; tart, red fruit flavors, on the shy side; short finish, tart aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Silver 2010 Merlot South Eastern Australia $7.99 Lively, bouncy wine, fresh and clean - Marguerite Thomas; - Medium ruby color; herbal, red fruit aroma, very good depth, kind of rustic; medium bodied, good weight, layered; dusty, red fruit flavors; some coffee grinds in the aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Gold 2007 Shiraz, Reserve Barossa $13.99 Red plum and pomegranate fruit with savory notes. Tasty. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Gold NV Sparkling Moscato Australia $7.99 Light appley nose. Lean, bright, grapey and fresh, pretty and lively. Quite long. - Stephen Brook
Critics Gold 2010 Moscato South Eastern Australia $7.99 A spritzy muscat, delicate of flavor and very fresh, a la moscato d'asti - Mary Ewing-Mulligan; - A light and lively, refreshing wine with pretty peach fruit and some jasmine notes. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay, Reserve Adelaide Hills $13.99 Nicely balanced lemony creamy notes - Michael Apstein
Critics Silver 2010 Pinot Grigio South Eastern Australia $7.99 Surprisingly soft and supple, like lemon custard. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Platinum 2010 Dry Riesling, Reserve Barossa $13.99 Wet slate, crushed minerals, lemongrass, dried apricot and very brisk acidity are a complete package for this serious riesling. - Linda Murphy James Oatley Tic Tok
Critics Gold 2009 Sauvignon Blanc / Semillon Western Australia $14.00 Nose: mineral, gooseberry. palate is clean, dry, with some floral end notes. Fresh and invigorating with some papaya/tropical fruit notes on the finish. - Katherine Cole Jargon
Critics Gold 2009 Pinot Noir California $10.99 Excellent pinot noir character; well-balanced - Ed McCarthy Jarhead
Critics Gold 2008 Jarhead Red California $13.00 Well-made; quite fine. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Franc, Reserve Santa Ynez Valley $24.00 Pretty garnet color. Wow, juicy aromatics. Palate is bell pepper, black pepper. Fresh. Good acidity, well-integrated tannins. - Katherine Cole; - Genuine varietal character, with a faintly herbaceous edge, and firm tannins. - Paul Lukacs Jefferson Vineyards
Critics Silver 2009 Petit Verdot Monticello $19.95 Nice balance of fresh fruit and Mediterranean summer herbs - Nick Passmore
Critics Gold 2010 Chardonnay, Reserve Monticello $21.95 Ripe pear and lemon oil nuance, with fresh acidity and a gentle whiff of oak vanillin. - Robert Whitley Jenica Peak
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay, Coastal Series California $8.99 Nose is fragrant, floral. Palate has some nice notes of yellow apple. Pleasing creamy texture. a crowd-pleaser. - Katherine Cole John Duval
Critics Gold 2008 SGM, Plexus Barossa Valley $40.00 Dark to rim. Nose is dried fruit, sagebrush. Palate is ripe plums, sundried tomato, green pepper, with dried herbs and spices on the finish. Plush texture. Dried sage at the finish. complex. - Katherine Cole
Critics Gold 2010 MRV, Plexus Barossa Valley $29.00 Rich and lush but at the same time bright and refreshing, a beguiling combination. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Platinum 2006 Shiraz, Eligo Barossa Valley $100.00 Muscular, rich and spicy with a fine backbone of defining acidity - Nick Passmore Jordan Vineyard & Winery
Critics Gold 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon Alexander Valley $52.00 Not the biggest cab, but has concentration and integrity - Mary Ewing-Mulligan; - Pretty cherry and raspberry fruit. Elegant. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Gold 2009 Chardonnay Russian River Valley $29.00 A balanced chardonnay with attractive lemon fruit and a svelte body. - W. Blake Gray Jose Maria Da Fonseca
Critics Gold 2008 Periquita, Peninsula de Setubal Portugal $9.99 Tannic structure gives the wine a particular character; herbal aromas are appetite fresh. - Marguerite Thomas; - Medium brick red color; wild, leather, earthy aroma, a hint of red fruit, quite nice, very good depth; medium bodied, nice weight on the palate, fine structure; dry, nice acidity, well balanced; bright, ripe red fruit flavors, excellent clarity; medium finish, zippy, yet rewarding aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong Judd's Hill
Critics Silver 2007 Founder's Art, Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $65.00 Vibrant acidity lifts the cassis and black cherry fruit to great heights, and the very subtle herbal note, barrel spice and hint of vanillin. one for the cellar. - Linda Murphy Kalbarri
Critics Silver 2010 Merlot, Bin Select 770 South Eastern Australia $9.99 Well-structured, without any of the sappiness that mars many merlots at this price range. A serious wine that offers excellent value. - Paul Lukacs Kayra
Critics Gold 2006 Imperial, Okuzgozu Blend Turkey $25.00 Rich suave plummy nose, smoky oak, excellent fruit. Medium-bodied but concentrated, with robust tannins creeping up on the palate. Solid and spicy, and not for wimps. good length. - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver 2008 Vintage, Okuzgozu, Aydincik, Elazig Turkey $18.00 Chewy, robust and bursting with deep dark fruit. - Jon Bonne
Critics Silver 2009 Shiraz, Guney Denizli Turkey $15.00 A well-constructed red, fairly dry with good fruit-tannin balance - Mary Ewing-Mulligan Kenwood Vineyards
Critics Silver 2008 Merlot, Jack London Vineyard Sonoma Valley $22.00 Soft, ripe, spicy. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2009 Pinot Noir Russian River Valley $16.00 Substantive, well-balanced - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2008 Zinfandel Sonoma County $14.00 Fresh berries. nice spice. Not a bombastic style, but that allows the flavors to shine. - Michael Apstein
Critics Gold 2010 Pinot Gris Russian River Valley $16.00 Pungent and earthy with a mineral-rich finish - Nick Passmore
Critics Platinum 2010 Sauvignon Blanc Sonoma County $12.00 Refreshing and lively with citrus, grapefruit aromas and flavors with a hint of lychee energized by crisp acidity. - Rebecca Murphy Kilikanoon
Critics Gold 2009 Shiraz-Grenache, Killerman's Run South Australia $20.00 A serious, substantial red wine, with juicy red fruit flavors enhanced by notes resembling pepper, spice, saddle leather and much more. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Gold 2009 Cabernet Sauvignon, Block's Road Clare Valley $30.00 Very fine; excellent cab - Ed McCarthy
Critics Platinum 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon, Block's Road Clare Valley $30.00 A leathery, heady effort -- with suede, bay leaf, blackberry bramble and sandalwood. Chewy, hearty and ready to rock. - Jon Bonne
Critics Gold 2009 Grenache, Prodigal Clare Valley $30.00 Well made wine, light to medium body, fruit well integrated - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Silver 2008 Shiraz, Covenant Clare Valley $40.00 Lively character, bitter chocolate. . a wine for spicy mexican with mole - Paul Lukacs.
Critics Silver 2009 Shiraz, Parable McLaren Vale $40.00 Creamy polish and elegance - Nick Passmore
Critics Platinum 2010 Riesling, Watervale, Mort's Block Clare Valley $20.00 Graceful appley nose, slightly oily but in an attractive way. Rich, bold, full-flavoured, firm and dry, shows some evolution and maturity, with a mineral bite on the finish, which is very long. - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver 2010 Riesling, Watervale, Mort's Reserve Clare Valley $35.00 Ripe apple compote nose, with a mineral tang. Rounded, juicy, full-bodied, has some heft, though balanced by lively acidity, giving a perky finish. - Stephen Brook
Critics Gold 2009 Semillon, Barrel-Fermented Clare Valley $18.00 Depth, richness, complexity -- and it's very harmonious - Elin McCoy; - Plush fruit and a bracing acidity combine in a come-hither beauty. - Nick Passmore Kiona Vineyards
Critics Silver 2010 Chenin Blanc Columbia Valley $14.99 Very fruity with pear and melon notes and good balance. - Robert Whitley
Critics Gold 2010 Dry Riesling, Reserve Red Mountain $14.99 Elegant apple and apricot nose. Lean, crisp, lightly sweet but not to excess, has concentration and grip, well balanced, with a long piquant finish. - Stephen Brook Korbel Champagne Cellars
Critics Silver NV Brandy XS California $12.00 Medium brown; spiced savory; full bodied; spiced - Wilfred Wong
Critics Silver NV Brandy VSOP, Gold Reserve California $15.00 Mellow butterscotch and caramel aromas translate directly to flavors on the palate - quite long and lightly smoky with good richness. - Rich Cook
Critics Silver NV Chardonnay Champagne California $11.00 Lots of character - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver NV Blanc De Noirs California $11.00 Delicious. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold NV Brut California $11.00 Lots of flavor here; very good - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2008 Natural Russian River Valley $13.00 Quite fine; delicious; ready to drink - Ed McCarthy; - A bit anodyne and tight, but the ripeness of the anjou pear and Meyer lemon gives it great definition, and a stony berry tone rounds it out. Taut and refreshing. - Jon Bonne
Critics Gold NV Brut Rosè California $11.00 Excellent; very fine - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver NV Sweet Rosè California $15.00 An eminently happy, peppy raspberry and apricot verve. Brunchify yourself with this! - Jon Bonne Kris
Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Noir, Provincia di Pavia IGT Italy $14.00 Tart and focused, it brings a light step to the party with lots of tangy cranberry and a dry-earth edge. - Jon Bonne
Critics Gold 2009 Pinot Grigio, Delle Venezie IGT Italy $14.00 Very bright and fresh, with good length and a crisp finish. - Paul Lukacs La Parra Loca
Critics Silver 2008 Tempranillo Shiraz, Tierra De Castilla y Leon Spain $7.29 Ripe vibrant cherry nose, with a good dose of oak. medium-bodied, fairly light, but has freshness and charm, and enough tannin to give some grip on the finish. Quite long. - Stephen Brook La Rusticana D'Orsa
Critics Gold 2008 Cinque Santa Cruz Mountains $45.00 For people who like their Bordeaux blends old style. It's daring enough to lead with fresh herbs, unfashionable these days, but it's actually ripe enough, with nice red plum fruit and well-managed tannins. - W. Blake Gray Lafond Winery
Critics Platinum 2009 Pinot Noir, S R H Sta. Rita Hills $27.00 Very good concentration and precision of flavor, and dry - Mary Ewing-Mulligan
Best Pinot Noir 2006 Pinot Noir, Lafond Vineyard Sta. Rita Hills $48.00 Outstanding; excellent balance; a winner - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2007 Pinot Noir, Lafond Vineyard, Pommard Clone Sta. Rita Hills $50.00 A bit heavy, but quite good - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay, Sanford & Benedict Vineyard Sta. Rita Hills $38.00 Creamy and long on the palate, with notes of lemon oil and ripe pear, finishing with a hint of spice. - Robert Whitley Lake Sonoma Winery
Critics Gold 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon Alexander Valley $20.00 Smoky tones bolster the bold dark fruit here, with a mustard-seed accent that's winning. - Jon Bonne Laurier Vineyards
Critics Silver 2009 Cabernet Sauvignon Alexander Valley $14.99 Black tea, cocoa powder, olives and herbs, tight on palate, chewy tannins. Needs some time. - Rebecca Murphy
Critics Gold 2007 Merlot Alexander Valley $14.99 Fresh and lively. Nicely balanced. Earthy notes are an attractive counterpoint to red fruit flavors. Suave tannins. - Michael Apstein Le Grande Courtage
Critics Silver NV Grand Cuvee, Blanc De Blancs, Brut France $18.99 Delicious, drink now - Ed McCarthy Leirana
Critics Silver 2009 Albarino, Rias Baixas DDO Spain $30.00 This fresh albarino exhibits pretty lime/citrus aroma with good acidty - Robert Whitley; - Like a bowl of stone fruit in a glass. - W. Blake Gray Liberty School
Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon Paso Robles $14.00 Subtle back fruit and spice aromas, smooth on palate, fluid tannins - Rebecca Murphy Lindemans
Critics Gold 2010 Pinot Noir, Bin 99 South Eastern Australia $7.00 Bravo! Fine balance, freshness, crisp acidity and a long, vibrant finish. Great to sip on its own and a fine foil for food. - Linda Murphy Little Penguin
Critics Silver 2009 Cabernet Sauvignon South Eastern Australia $7.00 Rich smoky oaky nose, black fruits. Rich, rounded, full-bodied, has weight though the tannins are supple. Spicy and quite long, if a touch sweet on the finish. - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver 2009 Shiraz South Eastern Australia $7.00 Deep ruby color; ripe fruit aroma, pleasing and effective; medium bodied, easy and pleasing on the palate; ripe red fruit flavors, quite nice and definitely in the consumer sweet spot; medium finish, easy, amicable aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong Lockwood Vineyard
Critics Gold 2007 Partners' Reserve Red Wine Monterey $24.99 Cedary notes in the bouquet, followed by dark fruit flavors supported by firm tannins. A very well-balanced and structured wine. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Gold 2008 Merlot, Estate Grown Monterey $14.99 Lush oaky cherry nose. Quite rich and juicy, with reasonable fruit concentration. Has some grip and weight, and enough acidity to give length and some ageing potential. - Stephen Brook
Critics Gold 2009 Chardonnay, Estate Grown Monterey $11.99 I embrace delicate, medium-bodied chardonnays, and this is one. It's not showy or opulent, yet there is a crisp, citrusy, focused sense to it that I can envision enjoying with food. - Linda Murphy Loken
Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Franc, Lot 4, Reserve Nevada County $25.95 Spicy and fun, but is too much of the spice derived from oak? - Paul Lukacs Long Country
Critics Gold 2009 Cabernet Sauvignon, Gran Reserva, Valle de Colchagua Chile $7.49 This is a lot of wine for the price: classic cab character of cassis, forest floor, hints of cedar and oak spice, and while the tannins are obvious, they nicely integrated. - Linda Murphy; - Oaky black fruits nose, suggesting a generous use of chips, but it has vigour and typicity. Broad, rich, a touch flat, but doesn't lack concentration and even spice on the finish. - Stephen Brook Lucas Vineyards
Critics Silver 2009 Cabernet Franc, Limited Reserve Finger Lakes $19.99 Pale rim, pretty ruby color. Bright fruit on nose, with gravel. Fruit is understated and clean on palate. Bright green pepper, but tannins are green also -- pips and stems. I like the fact that this winemaker is not relying on oak for flavor. - Katherine Cole
Critics Platinum 2009 Dry Riesling Finger Lakes $13.99 Brisk nose, pears. lean but fresh and crisp, lively acidity, tangy and long, with a bracing finish. - Stephen Brook
Critics Gold 2010 Dry Riesling Finger Lakes $13.99 Fresh lime nose. Quite rich and fleshy, broad but concentrated, with good depth of fruit, firm acidity, a long finish. - Stephen Brook
Critics Gold 2009 Semi Dry Riesling Finger Lakes $13.99 Bright and pure. Mineraly. Gorgeous fruitiness offset by bright acidity. Long and seductive. - Michael Apstein; - Lovely mineral, floral aromas, stone fruit and snappy acidity. - Rebecca Murphy
Critics Gold 2010 Semi Dry Riesling Finger Lakes $13.99 Peachy. Floral. Good bright uplifting finish - Michael Apstein Lucky Star
Critics Gold 2009 Pinot Noir California $8.99 Delicate raspberry nose. Sleek, a touch sweet, but has a lovely texture, quite good acidity, and it tastes like pinot, with a long finish. - Stephen Brook Main & Geary
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay Sonoma County $14.99 A welcome delicate touch. Pleasant fruitiness and bright acid - Michael Apstein; - Pure apple, citrus aromas and flavors with balancing acidity - Rebecca Murphy
Critics Silver 2010 Pinot Grigio California $12.99 Fresh nose. orange blossom. Palate is pleasant and creamy with a nice briny finish. - Katherine Cole Manny O. Wines
Critics Silver 2007 Bibulus, Chateau La Chandelliere, Cru Bourgeois Medoc France $22.00 Pale at rim. Earthy aromatics with green pepper, fresh herbs. Juicy acidity. Palate is grippy, juicy. Fresh green bell pepper, white pepper. Finish is subtle. - Katherine Cole
Critics Silver 2008 Agapito Branco, Alentejano Portugal $12.00 An intense white that needs a big rich fish stew - Elin McCoy
Critics Gold 2008 Agapitos Rosè, Alentejano Portugal $12.00 A rose I'd like to drink, has some weight, fills the mouth with flavor and is relatively dry - Mary Ewing-Mulligan
Critics Gold NV Celebrus, Blanquette de Limoux France $17.00 Classic; not champagne, but a very fine bubbly - Ed McCarthy Martini & Rossi
Critics Gold NV Spumante Rosè Italy $12.99 Outstanding, very fine. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver NV Prosecco DOC Italy $14.99 Quite delicious, fruity - Ed McCarthy Maschio
Critics Gold NV Treviso Brut Prosecco DOC Italy $13.00 Lots of flavor here; well-balanced - Ed McCarthy Masked Rider
Critics Silver 2007 Petite Sirah, Outlaw California $9.99 A raspberry-infused smokiness plays off the restrained oak and mellow aroma of wet leaves. - Nick Passmore Massimo
Critics Silver 2008 Rioja DDOC Spain $10.99 Distinct bright sweet fruit, a floral hint, refreshing finish - Marguerite Thomas; - Light ruby color; sweet earthy, red fruit aroma, medium depth, pleasing; medium bodied, rounded on the palate, probably a higher ph, textured; dryish, balanced; tart red fruit flavors, light concentration; medium finish, crisp, easy aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong Matuco
Critics Platinum 2010 Cabernet Sauvignon, Mendoza Argentina $7.99 Dense black cherry nose. Rich, dense, packed with fruit, black cherries and blackberries. Spicy, earthy, and has complexity and drive, long finish. - Stephen Brook Mendelson Vineyards
Critics Silver NV Pinot Gris Dessert Wine, Reserve Lot 1 Napa Valley $40.00 Amber color. Root beer/sarsaparilla plus caramel, butterscotch on palate. A bit of ginger spice to finish. - Katherine Cole
Critics Platinum NV Muscat Canelli Mendocino County $40.00 The proverbial different kettle of fish! Nutty, honeyed, with an attractive hint of oxidation, very long, and very different. I don't know if I ever have tasted anything like it, but it's absolutely delicious. - Paul Lukacs Meridian
Critics Silver 2009 Merlot California $9.00 Mid garnet to rim. Powdered sugar dusted blueberries on nose. Palate is restrained and green after that sweet nose and approach. Still, in this price range, it's enjoyable. - Katherine Cole Milbrandt Vineyard
Critics Silver 2010 Syrah Rosè, Traditions Columbia Valley $13.00 Has gentle, played-out flavors, very delicate. Lovely - Mary Ewing-Mulligan
Critics Silver 2008 Merlot, Traditions Columbia Valley $15.00 Sweet vanillin and spice make for an attractive nose; the palate is crisp and focused, though the chewy tannins need a bit more bottle age. - Linda Murphy Montcadi
Critics Silver NV Cava Rosè Spain $6.99 Fine; delicious. - Ed McCarthy Monte De Oro Winery
Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon Temecula Valley $32.00 Fine entry-level cabernet - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2007 Syrah, Estate Grown, Vista del Monte Vineyard Temecula Valley $34.00 Raspberry and smoke, surprising delicacy for syrah - Marguerite Thomas; - Deep ruby color; heady aroma, both savory and black-fruited; full bodied; hot on the palate; smoky, black fruit flavors; medium finish. - Wilfred Wong MontGras
Critics Silver 2009 Quatro, Colchagua Valley Chile $14.99 Raspberry flavor, bright and fresh, sweetish but a popular style well done. - Mary Ewing-Mulligan Morlanda
Critics Gold 2004 Crianca DDOQ Priorat $48.00 Fresh, juicy fruitiness, nice slightly grainy tannins - Marguerite Thomas; - Medium red, brickish color; dusty, hint of coconut and american oak, orange rind aroma, a touch murky and wild, fine, medium depth; tart, red fruit flavors, a shading of leather, medium concentration; medium finish. - Wilfred Wong Most Wanted Wine Co.
Critics Gold 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon, Garcia Family Vineyard California $60.00 Hedonistic and generous, with succulent and ripe blackberry fruit hugged by creamy vanillin. Ready to drink now, or in 5 to 7 years. - Linda Murphy; - Very oaky nose, charred, but has plenty of fruit too. Medium-bodied, has some elegance and bite, with a bit too much oak. Attractive acidity gives some lift, and though not a massive wine, it's balanced and has personality and length. - Stephen Brook
Critics Gold 2009 Chardonnay Russian River Valley $35.00 Elegant and balanced, exhibiting flavors of ripe pear and apple, with good length. - Robert Whitley Motos Liberty Cellars
Critics Silver 2008 Merlot California $8.99 Dark to rim. Touch green pepper to nose. tannins are green and chewy. Bitter component would be a good food match. Mocha notes on the finish. - Katherine Cole; - Soft, supple and easy to enjoy. a tasty picnic red. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Gold 2009 Pinot Noir California $8.99 This wine has the classic woodsy truffle aroma missing in most pinot noirs at this price. Perfectly ripened red fruits, plus red licorice and spice, give it true deliciousness. flavors. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay California $8.99 Sweet and seductive, with a buttery, vanilla-tinged finish, and just enough acidity for balance. - Paul Lukacs Mouton Cadet
Critics Gold 2008 Rouge, Bordeaux France $10.00 Very well-structured, with genuine Bordelaise characteristics- black fruit, a touch of green herbs, and a hint of cedar in the bouquet. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2009 Blanc Bordeaux $10.00 Nose is soft, hay. Delicate spritz and softness to palate. Lingering white pepper. This wine is all about texture. - Katherine Cole Mt. Beautiful
Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Noir, North Canterbury New Zealand $22.99 Bright fruit, spice. Lively with uplifting acidity. - Michael Apstein Naked Grape
Critics Gold NV Cabernet Sauvignon California $7.99 For lovers of cabs with black plum and blackberry flavors, lots of spice and firm structure. It should open a bit with time, yet will stand up beautifully to a steak today. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver NV Pinot Grigio California $7.99 Soft and easy to drink, with zesty citrus flavors. - Paul Lukacs Napa Cellars
Critics Silver 2008 Merlot Napa Valley $22.00 Modest and well-hewn, with a breakfast-tea grip to the hearty cherry fruit. It's polished enough to play well with others but has just a bit of scarface in it. - Jon Bonne
Critics Gold 2009 Pinot Noir Napa Valley $26.00 Oak is definitely operative here, but the concentration of fruit character suggests that this is just a moment in time; concentrated fruit on finish - Mary Ewing-Mulligan; - A juicy, cherry-fruity wine with a serious side. Notes of tobacco in the aroma and good structure give it gravitas, but mainly it's fun and quaffable. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Silver 2008 Zinfandel Napa Valley $22.00 Blackberry, bramble berry fruit with good acid balance finishing with dusty tannins - Rebecca Murphy Napa Family Vineyards
Critics Platinum 2009 Cabernet Sauvignon, Reserve Napa Valley $9.99 Rich, chocolatey, balanced, smooth, will please a lot of people, and astonishingly good for under $10; - complex & intriguing blend of wet leaves, mellow earthiness and summer strawberries. - Nick Passmore
Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay, Reserve Napa Valley $9.99 Apple and pear fruit, with good balance. - Paul Lukacs Napa Ridge Winery
Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Noir Napa Valley $12.99 It glows with cherry and raspberry flavors - Nick Passmore
Critics Gold 2008 Chardonnay Napa Valley $12.99 Delicate pear and golden apple aroma, with a beautiful balance of ripe pear/apple fruit, acidity and volume. Gains complexity from gentle oak spice, and closes refreshingly. - Linda Murphy; - Ripe apple and apricot nose. Rich, full-bodied, creamy, has weight and some power, and some welcome spice on the finish. Quite long. - Stephen Brook Navarro Vineyards
Critics Gold 2009 Pinot Noir Mendocino $19.00 Dry; lovely; long finish - Ed McCarthy
Critics Platinum 2009 Pinot Noir, Deep End Blend Anderson Valley $49.00 - A beautiful dried-ginger and loam edge to the sultry dark fruit. Bergamot, sage and a brooding mineral presence. This is deep, canonical pinot. - Jon Bonne
Critics Silver 2010 Muscat Blanc, Late Harvest, Cluster Select Anderson Valley $59.00 Nose has a hay aspect to it. Palate is spritzy, with some preserved apricot, dried peach and minerality. Lemon curd on the finish. Pleasant and balanced. - Katherine Cole
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay, Premiere Reserve Anderson Valley $25.00 Very attractive pear fruit, with good balance and judicious restraint. - Robert Whitley
Critics Silver 2009 Gewurztraminer, Late Harvest Anderson Valley $35.00 Light and delicate, with juicy pear and lychee flavors and a refreshing, moderately sweet finish. - Linda Murphy Naveran
Critics Silver 2009 Perles Roses, Cuvee Antonia Spain $38.00 Delicate; very dry - Ed McCarthy Newman's Own
Critics Gold 2009 Cabernet Sauvignon California $13.99 - Marguerite Thomas; - Medium ruby color; black currant aroma, pretty good, medium depth; medium bodied, zippy on the palate; dry, nice acidy, balanced; red fruit flavors, tight; short to medium finish. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay California $11.99 Ripe apple and citrus aromas and flavors. Pleasant. - Rebecca Murphy Night Harvest
Critics Silver NV Merlot California $6.99 Lead pencil, delicate leafy green elements, very lean and appealing - Marguerite Thomas; - Medium ruby color; red fruit aroma, fine, bright and fresh, fine depth; medium bodied, soft, very nice; dry, good acidity, well balanced; fresh red fruit flavors; medium finish. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Silver NV Chardonnay California $6.99 Medium yellow color; apple, hard candied aroma, ok; medium bodied, balanced on the palate; pleasant apple flavors; easy aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong Nobilo
Critics Gold 2010 Sauvignon Blanc, Regional Collection Marlborough $14.00 Minerality, fresh sage, crisp--cries out for oysters! - Marguerite Thomas Northstar
Critics Gold 2007 Merlot Columbia Valley $41.00 Soft on the palate but nonetheless displaying real depth of flavor. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2007 Merlot Walla Walla Valley $60.00 Blueberries and vanilla on nose. Coffee and blueberries on palate. Oak adds sumptuous layers of vanilla, caramel and spice. - Katherine Cole; - Sweet fruit and an oak-filled finish, - Paul Lukacs Ombretta
Critics Gold 2008 Chianti DOCG Italy $5.29 Garnet to edges. Alluring ripe blueberry nose with roasted pig, leather. Bright tart fruit, plums. Good acidity and pleasing bitterness to finish. Nice spice, white pepper. - Katherine Cole Open Field
Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Noir Santa Barbara County $19.99 Dense and robust black fruit offers a bass line here, with a sweet, gutsy, nutmeg-edged take on the sort of pinot that's perfectly comfortable at a cocktail party. - Jon Bonne
Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Gris Santa Barbara County $9.99 Opolo Vineyards
Critics Gold 2009 Montagna Mare Paso Robles $28.00 A very pretty wine, with a well-defined structure, firm but not oppressive tannins, and an evolving finish. - Paul Lukacs Ora
Critics Gold 2008 Montepulciano D'Abruzzo DOC Italy $4.99 Terrific ripeness and richness of fruit - Mary Ewing-Mulligan; - Outstanding value. Nice red fruit, good structure, excellent acidity and an interesting aroma. You could drink this every day. - W. Blake Gray Pacific Rim Winemakers
Critics Platinum 2008 Dry Riesling Columbia Valley $10.99 A complete and complex dry riesling, with a wet granite character on the nose, mouthwatering white peach, unripe pear and lime fruit flavors, and energetic aicity to support. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver 2010 Riesling Columbia Valley $10.99 Soft, round, sweet peachy flavors, with balancing acidity. Great with a fruit dessert - Rebecca Murphy
Critics Gold 2010 Sweet Riesling Columbia Valley $10.99 Touch of petrol on nose. Palate is light and fresh, with fresh apple and juicy acidity. Admirable understatement. - Katherine Cole Paco & Lola
Critics Gold 2010 Albarino, Rias Baixas DDO Spain $20.00 Nicely structured, with excellent richness and persistence of flavor. - Robert Whitley Pahrump Valley Winery
Critics Silver 2010 Symphony California $11.95 An easy to drink medium-sweet wine that would go well with a cheese plate. - W. Blake Gray Paraiso Vineyards
Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Noir Santa Lucia Highlands $25.00 Ruby color, earthy, black cherry aromas, medium bodied, round black cherry fruit with balancing acidity - Rebecca Murphy
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay Santa Lucia Highlands $18.00 Straightforward and fruit-driven, without any baby fat and with a refreshing close of acidity. - Linda Murphy; - Light appley nose, with a whisper of oak. medium-bodied, sleek, pleasant, quite well balanced, with a tangy finish. - Stephen Brook Paul Masson
Critics Silver NV Brandy, VS Grande Amber Kentucky $11.99 Medium brown; caramel and pretty fine; classical; hot and spirity; long and lush. - Wilfred Wong Pebble Bay
Critics Gold 2009 Sauvignon Blanc Marlborough $4.99 Phew, that's sauv blanc on the nose! Hay, gooseberry, nettles. grassy, zesty, grapefruit palate. typicity. - Katherine Cole Peirano Estate Vineyards
Critics Platinum 2008 Tempranillo, Heritage Collection Lodi $12.99 Rich smoky nose. Rich, firm tannins, concentrated, has density and weight and tannins that are present but under control. Has swagger. Long spicy finish. - Stephen Brook Penley Estate
Critics Silver 2009 Cabernet Sauvignon, Phoenix Coonawarra $20.00 Tannic, but good structure - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Reserve, Estate Grown Coonawarra $50.00 A gutsy, powerful, extractive cab but also dry - Mary Ewing-Mulligan
Critics Silver 2008 Shiraz, Hyland Coonawarra $20.00 Well-made, velvety textured, very sweet fruit -- too sweet for some, but others will love this - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay, Aradia Coonawarra $20.00 Mouth-filling ripe pear fruit, with lenngth and richness on the palate. - Robert Whitley; - You taste both the lemon and its peel in this well-balanced wine. - W. Blake Gray Perfil de Mibal
Critics Silver 2005 Ribera Del Duero DDO, Cosecha Spain $82.00 Big, chunky wine, fullfilling in aroma and flavor - Marguerite Thomas; - Deep ruby color; high toast and ripe fruit aroma, very good; medium bodied, layered on the palate; very ripe fruit flavors; medium finish; fresh and bright aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong Perrier-Jouet
Critics Silver NV Champagne, Grand Brut Epernay $45.00 Quite good - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold NV Champagne, Blason Rosè Epernay $75.00 Very fine. - Ed McCarthy Peter Lehmann of the Barossa
Critics Silver 2009 Layers Red Barossa $17.00 Opulent blackberry nose. Rich, suave, concentrated, ample ripe fruit and moderate acidity to lift the finish. - Stephen Brook Picket Fence
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay Russian River Valley $14.99 Smells and tastes of spiced poached pears, and that's a good thing. Judicious use of oak, fine balance and medium-rich, not at all over the top. - Linda Murphy Pine Ridge Vineyards
Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $54.00 Very oaky, also very tasty - Mary Ewing-Mulligan Prix Vineyards
Critics Gold 2006 Melange Reserve Napa Valley $75.00 Well-balanced; tannic, but with great fruit. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Platinum 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Reserve, Weir Family Vineyard, JMT Block Napa Valley $60.00 Mouthwatering wild blackberry fruit and brisk acidity make this an energetic Cab, at a time when too many of them offer little refreshment. Perfectly ripened fruit, subtle use of oak and fine-grained tannins complete the racy package. - Linda Murphy PromisQous
Critics Silver NV Red California $11.99 Floral and juicy, full of cherry zing and a dried-orange intrigue. Drink up! - Jon Bonne Quady Winery
Critics Silver 2009 Elysium, Black Muscat California $24.99 Very fresh bright nose, with juicy ripe cherries on the palate. Good acidity. The fresh fruitiness is appealing but lacks complexity. - Katherine Cole; - Long and luscious, a seductive sweet wine. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Gold 2009 Essensia, Orange Muscat California $24.99 Sweet baked apple on the nose. Apple pie with cinnamon on the palate, with some sweet tea. Nice acidity. ginger-spiced finish. - Katherine Cole R & B Cellars
Critics Gold 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Reserve, Lyric of the Vine Napa Valley $50.00 Cherry fruit with good structure. A well-balanced wine. - W. Blake Gray Ravenswood Winery
Critics Silver 2007 Zinfandel, Teldeschi Vineyard Dry Creek Valley $35.00 Ripe oaky cherry and raspberry nose, graphite. Medium-bodied, quite stylish and lifted, has freshness, but not that concentrated. acidity gives a refreshing finish. - Stephen Brook
Critics Platinum 2009 Zinfandel, Vintners Blend California $9.99 Powerful yet succulent, with big black cherry and blackberry flavors, a band of dark chocolate running through, muscular tannins that need some bottle age, yet with s mouthwatering finish. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver 2009 Zinfandel, Old Vine Napa Valley $12.00 Florally aromatic, with crisp blackberry fruit, licorice, a pleasant herbal character in the background, and plenty of acidity on the finish. - Linda Murphy Recoleta
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay, Mendoza Argentina $3.29 A surprisingly complex wine for this price - Marguerite Thomas; - Light straw, green color; dull earthy, low fruit aroma; medium bodied, perky on the palate; dry, medium acidity, good balanced; tart apple flavors; pretty zesty in the aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong Red Soles Winery
Critics Silver 2009 Zinfandel, Estate, Miracles Ranch Paso Robles $34.00 Full bodied and full of sweet fruit, a little fun funkiness on the finish and oddly appealing - Marguerite Thomas; - Medium to deep ruby color; pleasant berry aroma; medium bodied; low keyed, but pleasant fruit flavors; astringent aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Gold 2010 Viognier, Estate, Miracles Ranch Paso Robles $26.00 Pretty peach note with a hint of honey. - Robert Whitley; - Elegant, pretty wine with apple and some stone fruit - W. Blake Gray Red Truck Winery
Critics Silver 2008 Red Wine California $9.99 Vivacious; lively - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2008 Merlot Central Coast $9.99 Dark to rim. bitter spice nose. Dark coffee and black currant. Long spicy finish with exotic notes of ginger, cardamon. Satisfying for this price. - Katherine Cole Redwood Creek
Critics Silver 2009 Malbec, Mendoza Argentina $8.00 Rich, earthy and pungent. - Nick Passmore
Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Noir California $8.00 Reserved cherry nose. Rich, quite full-bodied, and has some structure and grip. It's not very pinot, but it does have concentration and some weight. - Stephen Brook Renwood Winery
Critics Silver 2008 Zinfandel, Jack Rabbit Flat Amador County $28.95 Ripe fruit with oak presence - Marguerite Thomas; - Medium dark ruby color; finely ripened berry aroma; medium to full bodied, rounded on the palate; loaded with berries in the flavors; berries in the aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong Reustle-Prayer Rock Vineyards
Critics Gold 2009 Syrah, Masada Bloc Umpqua Valley $32.00 Grainy tannins, ripe fruit, substance - Marguerite Thomas; - Deep ruby color; rich and fine; ripe fruit and sweet oak, fine depth; medium to full bodied; lots of ripe berries and sweet oak; creamy aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Platinum 2009 Tempranillo, Timnah Bloc Umpqua Valley $26.00 Voluptuous black fruit, loads of black spice, mouth-filling texture and ideal tannic structure make this wine near perfection. Lingering finish, thanks to fabulous acidity. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver 2009 Tempranillo, Reserve Umpqua Valley $38.00 Powerful and potent, all black berries, black-peppery spice. Voluptuous black fruit, loads of black spice, mouth-filling texture and ideal tannic structure make this wine near perfection. Lingering finish, thanks to fabulous acidity that is tempered by the size of the tannins. - Linda Murphy Rigg Estate Vineyards
Critics Gold 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Reserve Livermore Valley $75.00 Dense smoky blackcurrant nose, opulent. very rich, unctuous, big but ripe tannins, splendid weight of fruit, assertive and shows just a touch of heat on the finish. Impressive wine with good length. - Stephen Brook Rioja Vega
Critics Silver 2009 Rioja DDOC Spain $11.99 Classic flavors, a chewy finish - Marguerite Thomas; - Medium ruby color; fresh, red fruit aroma, very nice, medium depth; medium bodied, firm on the palate; dusty, red fruit flavors, quite fine, excellent concentration; medium finish. - Wilfred Wong Riverstar Vineyards
Critics Silver 2009 Merlot Paso Robles $20.00 Lively - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2009 Zinfandel Paso Robles $18.00 A bowl of ripe blackberries, blueberries and black raspberries, with a dollop of creamy vanillin on top. Brisk acidity keeps it all in check. - Linda Murphy Robert Mondavi Private Selection
Critics Platinum 2009 Meritage California $10.99 Lovely nose. Ripe and polished. Some spice and toasty notes. Ripe, but not overdone. Good balancing acidity keeps it fresh. Great value. Suave and classy. - Michael Apstein; - Seamless and refined with blackberry, currant fruit, vibrant acidity and polished tannins - Rebecca Murphy
Critics Gold 2009 Chardonnay California $10.99 Fresh appley nose, has some charm. Medium weight but quite concentrated, with firm acidity to balance the fruit. A lean but attractive style. Good length. - Stephen Brook Robert Oatley Vineyards
Best of Show Rose 2010 Rosè of Sangiovese Mudgee $15.00 Juicy and ripe berry flavors with some mild citrus and a light body; it's bright and refreshing. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Platinum 2009 Tempranillo, King Valley Australia $20.00 Shy on the nose, yet forward in its black cherry and blackberry fruit, solid tannins and full body. Very well made and balanced. - Linda Murphy; - Ripe cherry and vanilla nose, a lot of oak but enough fruit to balance it. Rich, suave, concentrated, but has freshness and vivacity too. Lively and long, with a hint of chocolate on the finish. - Stephen Brook
Critics Gold 2010 Gewurztraminer, Cumbandry Vineyard Mudgee $25.00 Lovely lychee flavor with pretty rose petal notes. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Gold 2010 Sauvignon Blanc, Pemberton Australia $16.00 Grapefruit tinged herbal notes. Lovely bite and finish. More complexity than most at this price. - Michael Apstein Rocca Family Vineyards
Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon, Grigsby Vineyard Yountville $75.00 Very oaky nose, a touch heavy-handed, but there's enough dark fruit to balance it. Rich, broad, juicy, concentrated and tannic, still a bit severe with brooding black fruits and a trace of tar. Quite long. - Stephen Brook Rock Hollow
Critics Gold 2009 Sauvignon Blanc, Vintner's Selection Santa Barbara County $12.00 Nice marriage of lime-like flavors and tropical notes - Michael Apstein; - A lean style wine with dried straw and citrus aromas and flavors and crisp acidity. - Rebecca Murphy Rodney Strong Vineyards
Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon Sonoma County $17.00 Personality, fruit and a slightly dusty quality - Marguerite Thomas; - Medium ruby color; coconut, woody, red currant aromas, a bit volatile; medium bodied, firm on the palate, kind of tannic; dry, medium acidity, balanced; woody, ripe fruit flavors, some leather notes; medium finish. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Gold 2007 Merlot Sonoma County $17.00 Lovely black cherry notes. Good acidity. Fresh. Good length - Michael Apstein
Critics Gold 2008 Zinfandel, Knotty Vines, Estate Vineyards Northern Sonoma $18.50 Sastifying classic beautifully ripe and balanced zin - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Gold 2009 Chardonnay, Estate Vineyards Chalk Hill $20.00 Gorgeous pear and apple aroma with a hint of lemon creme and spice. Richly layered but well balanced and elegant. - Robert Whitley Rosemount Estate
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay, Show Reserve Hunter Valley $21.00 The toasty, charred oak will please some, annoy others, but for me it's an attractive accent that complements the ripe pear aroma without making it all about the barrel. - Robert Whitley Rosenthal - The Malibu Estate
Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon Malibu-Newton Canyon $39.00 Dark to rim. Fresh. Black currants, allspice. a bit of heat. some bitter herbs. a good steak wine -- well-made. - Katherine Cole
Critics Gold 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Block M, Single Vineyard Malibu-Newton Canyon $70.00 Here is a cab with good grip and enough fruity flesh on its bones to satisfy now and reward the patient later. I love the clean, refreshing finish. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay Malibu-Newton Canyon $25.00 Taut and lean, this is a chardonnay built for food, or the long haul. Or both. - W. Blake Gray Roza Ridge
Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon Rattlesnake Hills $15.00 Medium dark, ruby color; attractive pencil lead and ripe fruit aroma, nice depth; medium bodied, active on the palate, soft; dry, medium acidity, good balance; pleasing flavors, easy; medium finish, soft aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Platinum 2008 Petite Verdot Rattlesnake Hills $20.00 All green olives and Provence spices - Nick Passmore Ruffino
Critics Silver 2009 Chianti DOCG Italy $9.99 Hint of meat on nose, bit of barnyard. Soft palate. Nice spice at finish. Smoky. Balsamic. - Katherine Cole
Critics Gold 2010 Pinot Grigio, Lumina, Delle Venezie IGT Italy $9.99 Delicate fruit flavors and fine crisp finish - Marguerite Thomas; - Pale straw, green color, ripe citrus aroma, very good, medium depth; medium bodied, tart and lively on the palate; dry, nice acidity, well balanced; ripe, citrus flavors; medium to lingering finish, zesty aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong Rutherford Vintners
Critics Silver 2007 Merlot Napa Valley $12.99 Ripe black cherry notes balanced by fresh acidity. - Michael Apstein
Critics Gold 2008 Pinot Noir Napa Valley $12.99 Bursting with luscious ripe fruit, soft supple tannins - Nick Passmore
Critics Platinum 2009 Chardonnay Napa Valley $12.99 A rich, full style that benefits from brisk acidity and deft winemaking. Up front, it's pears with a hint of tropical fruit; at the finish, lemony acidity keeps it quite fresh. - Linda Murphy; - Delicate apple and lime nose, aromatic. Richer than the nose suggests, but there's enough acidity to balance and refresh the wine. Spicy, finely tuned, tangy, and long. - Stephen Brook Sartori
Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Noir, Provincia di Pavia IGT Italy $11.00 SeaGlass
Critics Platinum 2009 Pinot Noir Santa Barbara County $13.00 Superb Pinot character; excellent texture, structure - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2010 Riesling Monterey County $13.00 The pale pink color is pretty on the eye, the delicate finesse pretty in the mouth - Nick Passmore Segura Viudas
Critics Gold 2007 Creu de Lavit Penedes $15.00 Beeswax in honey, very round and rich, with lemony overtones in finish -- seems a good candidate for aging - Elin McCoy Shannon Ridge
Critics Gold 2009 Sauvignon Blanc, Ranch Collection Lake County $16.00 Delicate, and bright and zingy in mid-palate - Marguerite Thomas; - Light straw green color; fine herbal, dried citrus aroma; medium bodied, zesty on the palate; dry, nice acidity, good balance; ripe citrus, herbal flavors; medium finish. - Wilfred Wong Sherwood House Vineyards
Critics Silver 2006 Sherwood Manor, Estate Grown North Fork of Long Island $55.00 Has great depth, a wine of elegance rather than power. - Mary Ewing-Mulligan; - On the knife edge of ripeness, this juicy wine falls on the side of food-friendliness. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Platinum 2008 Chardonnay, Estate Grown North Fork of Long Island $30.00 A wine that unfolds with layers of lemon fruit and toast. Long finish. - W. Blake Gray Silver Birch
Critics Silver NV Sauvignon Blanc New Zealand $24.00 Racy zesty sauv blanc nose: grass, hay, nettles. Palate is zesty, grapefruit pith, refreshing. White pepper. - Katherine Cole; - Well-balanced, clean, crisp and refreshing, with bright citrus fruit flavors. - Paul Lukacs Silver Ridge
Critics Gold 2008 Merlot California $9.99 Excellent structure and balance. A very well-made wine at a great price. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Gold 2009 Pinot Noir California $9.99 Inviting dark cherry and raspberry aromas are mirrored on the palate, which is medium-rich and juicy. a gentle hint of leafy herbs adds interest and complexity. Cracklingly crisp acidity leaves the mouth watering for more. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay California $9.99 Fresh-tasting, with hints of vanilla enhancing the more forward pear and apple fruit. - Paul Lukacs Simply Naked
Critics Silver 2010 Chardonnay California $9.99 Honeydew and praline on the nose. Clean ripe fruit on the palate. Peaches, melon. white pepper. Approachable. - Katherine Cole Snoqualmie Vineyards
Critics Silver 2009 Naked Riesling Columbia Valley $10.00 Nicely balanced. Peachy notes. Bright acidity balances the sweetness and prevents it from being cloying. - Michael Apstein; - Petrol aromas, sweet apple, peach fruit with moderately high acidity - Rebecca Murphy Sparkling Pointe
Critics Silver 2005 Blanc De Blancs North Fork of Long Island $42.00 Toasty and leesy, a chardonnay powerhouse with fizz that offers great depth amid its polished lines. - Jon Bonne
Critics Platinum 2007 Brut North Fork of Long Island $29.00 Wow! Here we have a world-class bubbly. Outstanding - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver NV Cuvee Carnaval North Fork of Long Island $24.00 A pleasant bite and persistence to the lemon curd and peach, giving it a bright kick to match its sweetness. - Jon Bonne
Critics Platinum NV Topaz Imperial North Fork of Long Island $33.00 Subtle and floral -- iris, orange blossom, wild strawberry and lemon confit, with a stony, fresh underpinning. Vivacious and lovely. - Jon Bonne
Critics Gold 2001 Brut Seduction North Fork of Long Island $50.00 Long finish; very fine - Ed McCarthy St. George
Critics Silver 2009 Cabernet Sauvignon, Select Reserve California $7.99 A juicy, easy-to-drink cab that may not be as complex as some, but it is just the sort of wine consumers seek at this price. - Linda Murphy St. James Winery
Critics Silver NV Country White American $6.99 Beautiful balance of ripe fruit and crispness - Marguerite Thomas; - Medium straw color; fine, foxy aroma, clean and fresh; medium bodied, very sweet; foxy flavors; sweet and long finish. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Silver 2009 Chambourcin Ozark Mountain $6.99 Delicate raspberry aroma, medium body and a spine of tannin? An interesting change of pace, but drink now - Mary Ewing-Mulligan; - A wine to be drunk right away that will remind some of aged Bordeaux. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Silver 2009 Cynthiana Ozark Highlands $6.99 Ambitious, with oak styling and smooth flesh - Mary Ewing-Mulligan; - Bright red plum with richness and depth. Ambitious. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Silver NV Velvet Red American $6.99 Surprisingly fresh and delicate, like a great glass of juice with a bit of bite. - Jon Bonne
Critics Gold NV Velvet White American $6.99 The very distinctive aroma leads into a flavor so accurate that you can imagine the grape. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Silver NV Podium Series, The Meadow, Traminette American $12.99 Delicate, spicy and slightly sweet, with effusive lichee and floral aromas; great summer sipper. - Linda Murphy; - Lemon pie nose. Soft, rounded, juicy, lightly sweet, with a creamy texture. Has some length. - Stephen Brook
Critics Gold 2010 Vignoles Ozark Highlands $9.99 An ambrosia fruit salad of pears, apples and white peaches; medium-sweet, with enough acidity to provide a refreshing finish. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver NV Riesling, Semi-Dry American $9.99 Ripe peaches on nose. Soft ripe peach gelato on palate. Bright and fresh. - Katherine Cole St. Supery Vineyards & Winery
Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon, Estate Grown Napa Valley $30.00 A soft, subtle expression of cabernet, gentle, even delicate. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Gold 2007 Merlot, Estate Grown Napa Valley $25.00 Well-done, lively, well-balanced - Ed McCarthy Stag's Leap Wine Cellars
Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon, Artemis Napa Valley $55.00 All in balance - Mary Ewing-Mulligan Stoller Vineyards
Critics Platinum 2007 Pinot Noir, Estate Grown Dundee Hills $40.00 Sleek, bright fruited and showing a classic hint of funk, with subtle texture and some real endurance to it. Tangy strawberry and berry leaf, bayberry and tobacco. An eloquent, elegant thing. - Jon Bonne Stony Ridge
Critics Gold 2008 Trifecta Livermore Valley $24.00 Lush oaky nose. Rich, full-bodied, black fruits and vanilla. Shows good concentration and acidity and vigour. Long. - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon, Estate Produced Livermore Valley $26.00 Pretty because it's sweet and succulent. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay, Estate Produced Livermore Valley $19.00 Fresh appley nose. Quite rich, sappy, full-bodied, has some oak influence that gives complexity. Concentrated, spicy, and long. - Stephen Brook Surfrider
Critics Silver 2007 Hang Ten Red California $21.00 Really racy for a red wine, with wild blackberries, black licorice, zippy acidity and a clean, refreshing finish. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay Central Coast $21.00 This is like a visit to the tropics: mango, papaya, lime. All that's missing is the coconut. - W. Blake Gray Sweet Cheeks Winery
Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Gris Willamette Valley $15.00 Clean, fresh, lively, pleasant drinking. - Elin McCoy; - Clean, lean, dry and mineral infused. - Nick Passmore Tampesta
Critics Platinum 2010 Rosado, Prieto Picudo, Tierra de Leon Spain $15.00 Wonderfully of-a-piece. Try it! - Mary Ewing-Mulligan Tangent
Critics Gold 2009 Albarino, Paragon Vineyard Edna Valley $17.00 A focused wine with lime fruit and a food-friendly profile - W. Blake Gray
Critics Silver 2010 Sauvignon Blanc Edna Valley $13.00 Light straw, green color; tart, lemongrass aromas; medium bodied, alive on the palate; fine ripe citrus flavors; lingering finish. - Wilfred Wong Tapena
Critics Gold 2009 Tempranillo, Tierra de Castilla Spain $10.00 Truly delicious! Fruity and supple, an inexpensive wine with great character. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver 2009 Verdejo, Tierra de Castilla Spain $10.00 Bright and clean, this wine shows good acid and ripe tropical notes. - Robert Whitley; - A pretty wine with nice stone fruit flavors and notes of jasmine. - W. Blake Gray Target Wine Cube
Critics Silver 2009 Cabernet Sauvignon California $15.99 An inexpensive cab built for the long haul. Tannic now, yet there is enough fruit and acidity to allow it to mellow with cellaring. - Linda Murphy
Critics Gold 2009 Pinot Noir California $15.99 Delicate nose, with cherry and raspberry aromas and a touch of cola. Medium-bodied, not very concentrated, but tastes like pinot and it's balanced and good value. - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver 2010 Pinot Grigio California $15.99 Hmm, interesting nose. Vanilla bean. Palate has fresh juicy peach and a lively citrus finish. - Katherine Cole Tefft Cellars
Critics Platinum 2008 Tempranillo Yakima Valley $30.00 Dense oaky spicy nose, powerful, with black cherry fruit. rich, robust, firm cherry fruit and weighty tannins. Assertive, but spicy and vigorous. There's a lot of oak here but it's balanced. Has drive and length. - Stephen Brook Terra
Critics Silver 2010 Kalecik Karasi Roze Turkey $10.00 Fabulous rich, silky texture, and not at all watery - Mary Ewing-Mulligan
Critics Silver 2010 Kalecik Karasi, Beyaz, Dry Rosè Turkey $10.00 Pretty sweetheart pink color, very light and delicate - Marguerite Thomas; - Light pink in color; slightly medicinal aroma; medium bodied, dry; kind of bitter in the aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Gold 2010 Kalecik Karasi, Denizli Guney Platosu Turkey $10.00 Very pleasant; easy-drinking - Ed McCarthy The Vineyard House
Critics Gold 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $175.00 Smooth, savory, very balanced, delicious, lovely long finish - Elin McCoy. Thirty First State
Critics Silver 2009 Merlot California $9.99 Pale at rim. Alluring ripe berries on nose: strawberries, blueberries. Palate is light, understated, some green tannins, but a food-friendly wine for this price range. - Katherine Cole
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay California $9.99 Some pleasant citrus and apple to the creamy palate. A nice wine for the price. - Katherine Cole Toad Hollow Vineyards
Critics Silver 2009 Erik's The Red California $12.99 Nice integration of well-ripened black fruit and black spice; chewy tannins need some time. - Linda Murphy
Critics Gold 2010 Eye of the Toad Dry Rosè of Pinot Noir Sonoma County $12.99 Light, elegant dried cherry and orange peel flavors make this a refreshing summer wine. - W. Blake Gray Toasted Head
Critics Silver 2008 Untamed Red, Barrel Aged California $12.99 Ideal balance of exuberant wild berry fruit, vanillin oak, acidity and supple tannins. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay California $12.99 Ripe tropical fruit nose, pineapple. Rich, juicy, quite concentrated, with ample acidity to balance the fruit. Indeed, it's rather too assertive, but at least shows some vigour. - Stephen Brook Totus Tuus
Critics Gold NV Cava Brut, Reserva Spain $15.00 A distinctive weight anchors this -- luscious apple and stone notes that give depth while not sacrificing neither precision nor opulence. With its tree-fruit and pastry flavors, this could easily mask for a blanc de blancs champagne. - Jon Bonne Trailhead
Critics Gold 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $29.99 Great balance; fine wine - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2009 Sauvignon Blanc Napa Valley $17.99 Mix of citrus and tropical notes - Michael Apstein Treana Winery
Critics Silver 2009 White Central Coast $23.00 Darker gold color. Nose is subtle white fruit. Palate is mouth-coating, waxy. Almonds, pineapple, sake. A bit hot, but will please certain palates. - Katherine Cole Trenza
Critics Gold 2009 Blanco Edna Valley $20.00 Straw color. subtle nose. Palate is soft and gentle with nice acidity and lingering finish. Peach, tangerine, honeydew melon. a hint of almond, a hint of ginger. This would be a delicious summer wine if served well chilled. - Katherine Cole Trivento
Critics Gold 2010 Malbec, Reserve, Mendoza Argentina $11.00 Finely balanced, soft, juicy and deliciously accessible. - Nick Passmore Turning Leaf
Critics Silver 2009 Cabernet Sauvignon California $8.00 Rich smoky blackberry nose. Broad, supple, moderately concentrated, has some weight and spice and a firm black fruits character on the finish. - Stephen Brook
Critics Platinum 2009 Merlot California $8.00 Impressively rich and elegant, with plenty of length, fresh fruit, and hint of oak. - Marguerite Thomas; - Deep ruby color; ripe fruit and oak in the aroma, quite nice, fine depth; medium bodied, firm and built on the palate; dryish, with some threshold residual sugar; ripe cherry flavors, a shading of oak; rich aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Gold 2009 Pinot Noir California $8.00 Text book pinot aromas of bright cherry, earth lead to a palate of juicy red fruits, gentle herb shading and judicious oak texture. The finish is long and satisfying. Great value. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver 2010 Pinot Grigio California $8.00 Bright and zesty, so very refreshing. - Paul Lukacs V. Sattui Winery
Critics Silver 2008 Paradiso Napa Valley $60.00 A savory effort with lots of heady sandalwood, cassia, brambly fruit and a smoky tobacco-leaf tinge. Surprisingly light on its feet for the style. - Jon Bonne
Critics Silver 2008 Sattui Family Red California $17.75 Ripe, lifted, red fruits nose, with some toasty oak. Quite rich, suave, not too extracted, but concentrated and textured, with discreet tannins to give some backbone. Quite long. - Stephen Brook
Critics Gold 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon, Sattui Family California $22.00 Swet aromatics inrtroduce a finely balanced and well-structured wine, with genuine varietal character. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $32.00 Dark to rim. Dark juicy fruit on nose. Tannic, peppery. Lasting finish. - Katherine Cole; - Sweet but nicely balanced. Succulent and seductive. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon, Morisoli Vineyard Napa Valley $55.00 Very well put together - Mary Ewing-Mulligan
Critics Gold 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon, Vittorio's Vineyard Napa Valley $44.00 Wonderful depth on a not-too-big cab with good concentration of fruit - Mary Ewing-Mulligan
Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon Mount Veeder $42.00 Juicy cherry fruit with firm structure. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Gold 2008 Merlot Napa Valley $25.00 Well-balanced, spicy - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Noir, Henry Ranch Los Carneros $37.00 Ripe fruit-focused pinot noir - Michael Apstein
Critics Gold 2008 Zinfandel, Old Vine, Crow Ridge Vineyard Russian River Valley $35.00 Opulent nose, very oaky, a bit tarry, black fruits. Soft, voluptuous, but not quite as impressive on the palate as the nose. full-bodied and concentrated, but has vigour and complexity too. - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver 2010 Dry Muscat California $26.00 Limpid and aromatic, with a darker, earthier edge to the pretty citron and peach. - Jon Bonne
Critics Gold 2010 Secco Riesling Napa Valley $23.00 Expertly made, combining ideally ripened fruit with just a touch of sweetness, with racy acidity and a long, refreshing finish. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver 2010 Riesling Anderson Valley $24.00 Delicate appley nose. soft, rounded, juicy, a touch too sweet for the acidity, but has a tangy finish. Long. - Stephen Brook
Critics Gold 2009 White Riesling, Late Harvest Napa Valley $31.00 Darker gold color. Dried apricot on nose. Nice acidity and spice on finish. Lingering notes of tangerine, ginger. An enjoyable dessert wine. - Katherine Cole
Critics Gold 2009 Sauvignon Blanc, Vittorio's Vineyard Napa Valley $24.00 Very crisp and refreshing. Lemon, lime, bright minerality and cleansing acidity. Great balance! - Rich Cook Valdubon
Critics Silver 2008 Ribera Del Duero DDO, Cosecha Spain $15.00 Very lean, narrow - Marguerite Thomas; - Medium to dark ruby color; pencil lead, black fruit and oak, medium depth; medium bodied, firm and built on the palate, a bit too rounded; dryish, soft acidity, good balance; ripe fruit, oak and charred flavors; medium finish, too much wood in the aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong Valley of the Moon
Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Noir Carneros $18.00
Critics Silver 2008 Syrah Sonoma County $16.00
Critics Gold 2008 Zinfandel Sonoma County $16.00 Plummy and spicy. Relatively delicate for zinfandel. Lovely floral component and great length. - Michael Apstein; - Blackberry fruit, rich berry flavors well balanced with acid and alcohol followed by dusty tannins - Rebecca Murphy
Critics Silver 2010 Chardonnay, Un-Oaked Russian River Valley $14.00 Light floral, dusty, apple pear aromas, ripe apple fruit, moderate acidity, pleasant apple aftertaste - Rebecca Murphy
Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Blanc Sonoma County $14.00 Bright and fresh, with enough body to make it very food friendly. - Paul Lukacs Vendange
Critics Silver NV Cabernet Sauvignon / Shiraz California $4.99 Lots of funky Rhonish flavors in a smooth wine - Mary Ewing-Mulligan
Critics Silver NV Symphony California $4.99 Fabulous perfumy aroma, - Marguerite Thomas; - Medium straw, yellow color; aromatic and pleasing aroma, some stalkiness; slightly sweet; pleasing; medium finish. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Silver NV Cabernet Sauvignon California $4.99 Keenly focused black cherry fruit, undertone of oak and good grip -- very nice at this price. - Linda Murphy; - Delicate smoky cherry nose. Medium-bodied, supple, has some weight of fruit if little cabernet character. Quite persistent. - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver NV Merlot American $4.99 Has surprising length and clarity of flavor for a wine at this price, with medium-light body and flavor. - Marguerite Thomas; - Light ruby color; fresh, pleasing red fruit aroma, medium depth; medium bodied, juicy on the palate; dry, nice acidity, good balance; ripe, red fruit flavors with a note of dust; medium finish. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Silver NV Zinfandel California $4.99 Ripe berries. Bright and fresh. Great value! Good choice with burgers. - Michael Apstein; - Bramble berry aromas, soft and easy in the mouth. - Rebecca Murphy
Critics Gold NV Sauvignon Blanc California $4.99 Not especially true to the variety, but well-crafted, with fine balance and good length. Especially in the under $10 category, this is a very satisfying and pleasing wine--great for warm-weather sipping. - Paul Lukacs Ventana Vineyards
Critics Silver 2008 La Mistral Red Wine Monterey County $45.00 Dark to rim. nose is blueberry cruller, mocha. Palate is soft spiced blueberries, ripe blackberries. plush. Oak sweetens and softens it. Dark chocolate. - Katherine Cole
Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Noir, Estate Grown Arroyo Seco $29.00 For those who like their oak apparent, this is a pinot with lush fruit and spicy oak flavors followed by structured tannins. - Rebecca Murphy Viansa Winery
Critics Silver 2008 Barbera Sonoma Valley $34.00 Intense ruby black color, dense black fruit with noticable acidity. - Rebecca Murphy Victor Hugo Vineyards & Winery
Critics Silver 2007 Opulence, Estate Paso Robles $28.00 Sweet brambly berry fruit, with an impressively long finish. - Paul Lukacs Vilarnau
Critics Silver NV Cava Brut Spain $15.99 Very good cava; well-balanced - Ed McCarthy
Critics Platinum 2008 Cava Brut Nature Spain $17.99 Steely and stony at first approach, with seashell and mandarin orange leading to a subtly opulent profile. there's refinement here, with the tang and bite of champagne but just a bit more stoic in its mien. Beautifully done. - Jon Bonne
Critics Gold NV Cava Brut Rosè Spain $17.99 Lots of flavor; excellent - Ed McCarthy; - A pleasing bite to the red berry and thyme flavors, with aggressive fizz that's meant for a meal. There's a great red-fruit depth -- a cava that demands to be taken seriously. - Jon Bonne Villa San-Juliette Winery
Critics Silver 2008 Merlot Paso Robles $17.00 A rich and velvety wine with black cherry fruit, tobacco, and cloves. - Rebecca Murphy
Critics Silver 2009 Petite Sirah Paso Robles $17.00 Solid varietal character - Muscular tannins, dry blueberry/blackberry fruit and spice. Age it and reap the rewards! - Rich Cook
Critics Silver 2009 Zinfandel Paso Robles $17.00 Dark chocolate, berries, vanilla: full dessert in a wine glass - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Platinum 2009 Sauvignon Blanc Paso Robles $15.00 Subtle creamy notes intertwined with the piercing signature citrus flavors gives this sauvignon blanc a wonderful sophisticated edge. - Michael Apstein Villa Yambol
Critics Silver 2009 Merlot, Thracian Valley Bulgaria $10.00 A rich, almost opulent merlot, though the substantial tannins suggest it will be even better after a few years in the cellar. Well-ripened plum and black cherry fruit gets a kiss of oak. - Linda Murphy; - Subdued but dense nose. Quite rich and juicy, rather hollow, but doesn't lack concentration or fruit. - Stephen Brook Vina Robles
Critics Silver 2009 RED4 Paso Robles $16.00 Robust leathery and gutsy, with a certain tartness that keeps it interesting. Slightly mysterious in its mien. - Jon Bonne
Critics Silver 2010 WHITE4 Paso Robles $16.00 The viognier shines through, dominating the chardonnay, with lovely floral nose and fresh acidity in finish - Elin McCoy; - Floral and pretty, with a bone-dry finish - Nick Passmore
Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon, Huerhuero, Estate Paso Robles $22.00 Well-structured, with good balance and a long finish. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Gold 2007 Syree Paso Robles $39.00 Touch of menthol, seductive fruit - Marguerite Thomas; - Deep ruby, black color; sweet, ripe fruit aromas; medium to full bodied, zippy on the palate; quite nice; bright berries in the flavors; zesty aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong Vinas Del Vero
Critics Gold 2005 Secastilla, Somontano DDO Spain $29.99 Delivers a mouthful of ripe fruit balanced by a good clean finish - Marguerite Thomas; - Dark ruby color; earthy, red fruit flavors; pretty good, medium to full depth; medium to full bodied, layered and rich on the palate; dry, medium acidity; tasty raspberry and earthy flavors; medium finish, flavorful aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Silver 2007 Garnacha, La Miranda de Secastilla, Somontano DDO Spain $14.99 Nicely balanced between fruit and acid, a little hint of chocolate - Marguerite Thomas; - Medium to deep ruby color; dusty, sweet earthy aroma, nice berries; medium bodied, pert on the palate; dry, nice acidity, good balance; very good red fruit flavors, medium concentration; medium finish, tangy aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Gold 2009 La Miranda de Secastilla, Somontano DDO Spain $14.99 Pure & fresh, a delightful, fruit-filled multi-purpose Spanish sipper - think grilled calamari and Serrano ham. - Nick Passmore Wagner Vineyards
Critics Silver 2009 Riesling Dry Finger Lakes $14.99 Inviting wet stone and white blossom aromas are followed by lean, dry citrus flavors and rapier acidity. - Linda Murphy; - Fruity apricot nose. Quite rich, juicy, full-bodied, with quite good underlying acidity, giving it a sherbet tang. Weighty and long. - Stephen Brook
Critics Gold 2008 Riesling Semi Dry Finger Lakes $12.99 Delicate and pretty with the substantial sweetness balanced by fresh-fruit acidity. A bargain winner - Nick Passmore
Critics Silver 2009 Riesling Semi Dry Finger Lakes $14.99 Diplaying a big, rich mouth-feel filled out by aromas of cherries and honeydrew mellon - Nick Passmore Wakefield Estate
Critics Gold 2009 Cabernet Sauvignon Clare Valley $16.99 Lovely interplay of sweet and savory flavors. Good value. - Michael Apstein
Critics Gold 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, St. Andrews Clare Valley $49.99 A richly powerful cab, your money's worth - Mary Ewing-Mulligan
Critics Silver 2008 Shiraz Clare Valley $16.99 A rich, juicy wine with nice cherry flavor. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Silver 2010 Riesling Clare Valley $16.99 Apple and lemon-rind nose. Fresh attack, brisk, has a light touch and some lift and elegance. Grapefruity finish. - Stephen Brook
Critics Platinum 2009 Sauvignon Blanc Adelaide Hills $16.99 Deliciously crisp, - Marguerite Thomas; - Medium straw color; ripe melon aroma, very good; medium bodied, zesty on the palate; ripe lemon flavors; medium finish. - Wilfred Wong Wakefield Promised Land
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay South Australia $11.99 Strong on citrus character and lemony acidity; I'm thinking corn chowder or a cream sauce for this crisp chard. - Linda Murphy Waters Crest Winery
Critics Silver 2009 Night Watch, Late Harvest North Fork of Long Island $44.99 A nutty, slightly bitter almond character adds intrigue given the sweet, ripe, honeyed fruit. - Paul Lukacs Wheelhouse Wine Cellars
Critics Gold 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $17.99 Medium to full body, sweep of fresh ripe fruit - Marguerite Thomas; - Medium to deep ruby color, ripe berry aroma, nice depth, medium bodied, pert on the palate, with some layers and dry, medium acidity, good balance. Ripe red and black fruit flavors with fresh and frisky aftertaste.- Wilfred Wong White Hall Vineyards
Critics Gold 2009 Viognier Monticello $16.99 Beautiful aromas of honeysuckle and stone fruits - Robert Whitley; - Pretty apple fruit with a hint of the apple blossom flower. - W. Blake Gray White Truck
Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Grigio California $9.99 Light straw color; tart citrus aroma, very good, medium depth; medium bodied, layered and bright on the palate, a bit elevated; dry, medium acidity, good balanced; ripe fruit flavors, medium concentration; pretty good; medium finish, active aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong Wild Horse Winery
Best Cabernet Sauvignon 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon Paso Robles $19.99 Ripe and sweet, but herbal notes add complexity. Fine tannins lend support without intruding. Intense without being overpowering. Great length. Classy cabernet and good value - Michael Apstein
Critics Gold 2008 Merlot Paso Robles $16.99 I appreciate the freshness in this wine, with the acidity perking up the rich plum fruit; licorice and a slight herbal note add complexity. - Linda Murphy Windmill Ridge Winery
Critics Silver 2007 Souzao, Estate Tracy Hills $18.00 Plenty of acidity on finish makes this a good wine for food - Marguerite Thomas; - Deep ruby color, a bit murky but fine; wild, savage aroma, black fruit and leather, fine depth; medium bodied, a trace narrow on the palate, fine structure; dry, active acidity, good balance; bright, tart red fruit flavors; medium depth; medium finish, jazzy aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong Winesmith
Critics Platinum 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon, Crucible Napa Valley $100.00 Do the math: deep complexity, freshness, extra-long finish, keen balance, cellar-worthy. - Linda Murphy Wink
Critics Silver NV Risque Red California $3.99 Delicious, easy drinking. - Ed McCarthy; - Juicy and straightforward, with a subtle cherry sweetness in the mix. - Jon Bonne
Critics Gold 2009 White Zinfandel California $3.99 A wine snob's white zin - strawberry, white pepper, cherry and peach, with balanced acidity and a clean finish. - Rich Cook
Critics Silver NV Moonstruck Moscato California $3.99 A pretty wine with stone fruit and violet notes. Sweet but not cloying. - W. Blake Gray Wolf Blass
Critics Gold 2008 Shiraz, President's Selection South Australia $18.00 Ripe cherry fruit that makes you smack your lips. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Silver 2008 Shiraz, Yellow Label South Australia $12.00 Ripe, sweet cherry fruit. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay, Yellow Label South Australia $12.00 Sweet tropical fruit nose. Rich, full-bodied, has heft and some concentration, a good example of the crowd-pleasing style. - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver 2008 Dry Riesling, Yellow Label South Australia $12.00 Charming nose, floral, apricots, with a hint of noble rot. Medium-bodied, supple, concentrated, more grippy than the nose suggests. Quite long. - Stephen Brook Wollersheim Winery
Critics Gold 2010 Prairie Fume American $9.00 Light and lively, with delicious apricot fruit and a restrained level of sweetness that makes it a great choice for Thai food. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Gold NV Dry Riesling American $9.00 Full-flavored, with juicy Meyer lemon and kaffir lime flavors that are dry and crisp. Lip-smacking acidity. Delicious. - Linda Murphy Woodbridge Winery
Critics Silver 2009 Cabernet - Merlot California $7.99 Really good value; very pleasant - Ed McCarthy; - Solid and showing a softer side, with dried-herb intrigue amid a pronounced sweetness. - Jon Bonne
Critics Silver 2010 Moscato California $7.99 Lively; great dessert wine - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2010 Pinot Grigio California $7.99 Light straw, green color; dried citrus, mineral aroma, medium depth; medium bodied, zippy and clean on the palate; dry, fine acidity, well balanced; tart, lemony flavors; medium finish, racy aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong Wyndham Estate
Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon, Bin 444 South Eastern Australia $9.99 Firm blackcurrant nose, has some typicity. Fresh but light and simple, but the finish is zesty and brisk and attractive. - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver 2008 Shiraz, Bin 555 South Eastern Australia $9.99 Deep ruby color; red fruit aromas, nice; medium bodied, soft and smooth on the palate; ripe fruit, pleasant flavors; medium finish, fresh and fruit laden aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Gold 2007 Shiraz, George Wyndham Founders Reserve Langhorne Creek $17.99 Cherry fruit, good structure. A ripe wine, but not overripe. - W. Blake Gray
Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay, Bin 222 South Eastern Australia $9.99 A delicate balance of fruit and acidity, not a fancy wine but enjoyable - Marguerite Thomas Ysios
Critics Silver 2004 Rioja DDOC, Reserva Spain $29.99 Medium red, ruby color, on the darker side; ripe, almost jammy, porty aroma, fine depth; medium bodied, layered and firm on the palate; dry, medium acidity well balance; deep, red and black fruit flavors, with a real note of barrel; medium finish. - Wilfred Wong Zardetto
Critics Silver NV Treviso Brut Prosecco DOC Italy $14.00 Dry, fruity - Ed McCarthy Zina Hyde Cunningham Winery
Critics Gold 2009 Pinot Noir, Reserve Anderson Valley $60.00 A pretty wine with delicate cherry flavor, - Marguerite Thomas; - Medium to deep red, ruby color; ripe strawberry, almost smoky, fine depth, quite good; medium bodied, firm active palate, sweet tannins; long finish, perky aftertaste. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Gold 2007 Zinfandel Dry Creek Valley $36.00 Robust oaky nose, black cherries, a hint of red fruits too, coffee. Rich, suave, concentrated, juicy, with firm tannins to give some structure. Built to last, and still tastes very young. Long. - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver 2007 Zinfandel, Old Vine, Reserve Russian River Valley $40.00 Very ripe and slightly jammy nose. Surprisingly light though fresh on the palate, quite elegant for zin, with good acidity to balance the fruit. - Stephen Brook
Critics Gold 2009 Chardonnay North Coast $28.00 Notes of pineapple and other tropical, with good length through the mid-palate and a spicy, juicy finish. - Robert Whitley
Critics Silver 2009 Riesling, Dry Russian River Valley $22.00 Effusive aromas of pear blossom and white peach are enticing, and the similar flavors are caressing and full, with a keen balance of residual sugar. - Linda Murphy; - Dumb nose. Bright attack, lightly sweet, but has enough acidity to refresh the palate and keep it lively. Quite good length. - Stephen Brook
Critics Gold 2009 Sauvignon Blanc Russian River Valley $20.00 Mouth-filling and intense. - Nick Passmore Zonte's Footstep
Critics Platinum 2010 Sangiovese Barbera, Canto Di Lago Langhorne Creek $16.00 Pale around rim. Gorgeous aromatics: red roses plus fresh, ripe, juicy red cherries. Elegant light body, subtle spice growing on finish. Wood expresses itself in a vanilla smoothness to the texture but these light notes are countered by some graphite, bitter herb components. Good acidity and lasting finish. An enjoyable wine, it would be a terrific companion for food. - Katherine Cole
Critics Silver 2010 Cabernet Sauvignon, Avalon Tree Langhorne Creek $16.00 Medium to red ruby color; pert and fine red currant aroma, medium bodied, very focused on the palate; bright, currant flavors; medium finish. - Wilfred Wong
Critics Silver 2010 Pinot Grigio, Doctoressa Di Lago Fleurieu Peninsula $14.00 Bright and refreshing, with an almond-like note in the finish that adds interest. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Platinum 2010 Verdelho, Sea Mist Langhorne Creek $14.00 A thirst-quenching wine with mango fruit and a steely mouthfeel. - W. Blake Gray
|
2011 Medal Winners by Category
BLENDED RED BORDEAUX
Critics Silver Manny O. Wines Bibulus, Chateau La Chandelliere, Cru Bourgeois Medoc France 2007 $22.00
Critics Gold Mouton Cadet Rouge, Bordeaux France 2008 $10.00
BLENDED RED BORDEAUX RHONE
Critics Gold Big Kahuna Cabernet / Shiraz / Petite Verdot South Eastern Australia NV $1.99
Critics Silver Eberle Winery Cabernet Sauvignon / Syrah Paso Robles 2008 $29.00
Critics Silver Henry Estate Winery Henry V Umpqua Valley 2008 $25.00
Critics Silver Jacob's Creek Shiraz Cabernet South Eastern Australia 2009 $7.99
Critics Silver MontGras Quatro, Colchagua Valley Chile 2009 $14.99
Critics Silver Vendange Cabernet Sauvignon / Shiraz California NV $4.99 BORDEAUX VARIETALS - A
Critics Silver Woodbridge Winery Cabernet - Merlot California 2009 $7.99 BORDEAUX VARIETALS - B
Critics Silver Cameron Hughes Meritage California 2009 $15.00
Critics Silver Cameron Hughes Meritage, Lot 254 Santa Ynez Valley 2008 $15.00
Critics Gold Cameron Hughes Meritage, Lot 213 Napa Valley 2008 $13.00
Critics Silver Glen Carlou Grand Classique, Paarl South Africa 2008 $17.00
Critics Platinum Robert Mondavi Private Selection Meritage California 2009 $10.99 BORDEAUX VARIETALS - C
Critics Gold Blackstone Winery Rubric, Sonoma Reserve Sonoma County 2007 $22.99
Critics Gold Donati Family Vineyard Ezio Paicines 2007 $34.99
Critics Gold Lockwood Vineyard Partners' Reserve Red Wine Monterey 2007 $24.99
Critics Silver Victor Hugo Vineyards & Winery Opulence, Estate Paso Robles 2007 $28.00 BORDEAUX VARIETALS - D
Critics Gold Chateau Ste. Michelle Meritage, Artist Series Columbia Valley 2007 $50.00
Critics Silver Clos Du Bois Marlstone Alexander Valley 2006 $50.00
Critics Gold J. Lohr Winery Cuvee POM Paso Robles 2007 $50.00
Critics Silver J. Lohr Winery Cuvee PAU Paso Robles 2007 $50.00
Critics Gold La Rusticana D'Orsa Cinque Santa Cruz Mountains 2008 $45.00
Critics Silver Sherwood House Vineyards Sherwood Manor, Estate Grown North Fork of Long Island 2006 $55.00 BORDEAUX VARIETALS - E
Critics Gold Prix Vineyards Melange Reserve Napa Valley 2006 $75.00
Critics Silver V. Sattui Winery Paradiso Napa Valley 2008 $60.00 CHIANTI
Critics Silver Banfi Chianti Classico DOCG Italy 2008 $13.00
Critics Gold Bella Sera Chianti DOCG Italy 2009 $6.99
Critics Silver Benedetto Chianti DOCG Italy 2009 $10.99
Critics Gold Caposaldo Chianti DOCG Italy 2009 $10.00
Critics Silver Fontana D'Italia Chianti DOCG Italy 2009 $10.99
Critics Gold Ombretta Chianti DOCG Italy 2008 $5.29
Critics Silver Ruffino Chianti DOCG Italy 2009 $9.99 CHIANTI APPELLATION RISERVA
Critics Platinum Banfi Chianti Classico DOCG Riserva Italy 2007 $18.00
Critics Silver Gabbiano Chianti DOCG Riserva Italy 2006 $23.00 BLENDED RED ITALIAN VARIETALS
Critics Gold Opolo Vineyards Montagna Mare Paso Robles 2009 $28.00
Critics Platinum Zonte's Footstep Sangiovese Barbera, Canto Di Lago Langhorne Creek 2010 $16.00 BLENDED RED DRY
Critics Silver Amalaya Vino Tinto de Altura, Valle Calchaqui Argentina 2009 $17.00
Critics Gold Clos LaChance Lila's Cuvee Red Wine, Estate Vineyard Central Coast 2008 $50.00
Critics Silver D & S Red Blend California 2007 $22.00
Critics Silver Eberle Winery Full Boar Red Paso Robles NV $15.00
Critics Platinum Emiliana Coyam, Los Robles Estate, Colchagua Valley Chile 2008 $34.00
Critics Silver Estraie Sortie Red Sonoma County 2006 $14.00
Critics Platinum Francis Ford Coppola Cinema, Director's Cut Sonoma County 2008 $50.00
Critics Silver HRM Rex Goliath Free Range Red California NV $7.50
Critics Gold Jarhead Jarhead Red California 2008 $13.00
Critics Gold Kayra Imperial, Okuzgozu Blend Turkey 2006 $25.00
Critics Silver Peter Lehmann of the Barossa Layers Red Barossa 2009 $17.00
Critics Silver PromisQous Red California NV $11.99
Critics Silver Red Truck Winery Red Wine California 2008 $9.99
Critics Gold Stony Ridge Trifecta Livermore Valley 2008 $24.00
Critics Silver Surfrider Hang Ten Red California 2007 $21.00
Critics Silver Toad Hollow Vineyards Erik's The Red California 2009 $12.99
Critics Silver Toasted Head Untamed Red, Barrel Aged California 2008 $12.99
Critics Silver V. Sattui Winery Sattui Family Red California 2008 $17.75
Critics Silver Vina Robles RED4 Paso Robles 2009 $16.00 BLENDED RED MEDIUM SWEET
Critics Silver Wink Risque Red California NV $3.99 BLENDED RED PORTUGESE VARIETALS
Critics Gold Jose Maria Da Fonseca Periquita, Peninsula de Setubal Portugal 2008 $9.99
Critics Silver Windmill Ridge Winery Souzao, Estate Tracy Hills 2007 $18.00 BLENDED RED RIBERA
Critics Silver Perfil de Mibal Ribera Del Duero DDO, Cosecha Spain 2005 $82.00
Critics Silver Valdubon Ribera Del Duero DDO, Cosecha Spain 2008 $15.00 BLENDED RED RHONE VARIETALS
Critics Silver Cameron Hughes Syrah / Grenache / Mourvedre, Lot 251 Arroyo Seco 2009 $15.00
Critics Silver Curtis Winery Heritage Cuvee Santa Barbara County 2007 $20.00
Critics Platinum David Girard Vineyard Coda Rouge, Estate Vineyard El Dorado 2007 $30.00
Critics Gold Eberle Winery Cotes-du-Robles Paso Robles 2008 $21.00
Critics Gold Hahn Winery G S M Central Coast 2010 $12.00
Critics Gold John Duval SGM, Plexus Barossa Valley 2008 $40.00
Critics Gold Kilikanoon Shiraz-Grenache, Killerman's Run South Australia 2009 $20.00
Critics Silver Ventana Vineyards La Mistral Red Wine Monterey County 2008 $45.00 BLENDED RED SPANISH VARIETALS
Critics Gold Morlanda Crianca DDOQ Priorat 2004 $48.00 BLENDED RED TUSCAN ROSSO DOC
Critics Gold Castello Banfi Rosso di Montalcino DOC Italy 2009 $19.00 BRUNELLO
Critics Silver Castello Banfi Brunello di Montalcino DOCG Italy 2006 $55.00 BORDEAUX APPELLATION - WHITE
Critics Silver Mouton Cadet Blanc Bordeaux 2009 $10.00 BLENDED WHITE BORDEAUX VARIETALS
Critics Gold James Oatley Tic Tok Sauvignon Blanc / Semillon Western Australia 2009 $14.00 BLENDED WHITE HYBRIDS DRY
Critics Silver Vendange Symphony California NV $4.99 BLENDED WHITE HYBRIDS MEDIUM SWEET
Critics Silver St. James Winery Country White American NV $6.99 BLENDED WHITE RHONE VARIETALS
Critics Silver Eberle Winery Cotes-du-Robles Blanc Paso Robles 2009 $24.00
Critics Silver Hearthstone Vineyard And Winery Pearl Paso Robles 2009 $24.00
Critics Gold John Duval MRV, Plexus Barossa Valley 2010 $29.00
Critics Silver Treana Winery White Central Coast 2009 $23.00 BLENDED WHITE SPANISH VARIETALS
Critics Gold Trenza Blanco Edna Valley 2009 $20.00 BLENDED WHITE DRY
Critics Silver Banfi Centine Bianco, Toscana IGT Italy 2009 $11.00
Critics Silver Manny O. Wines Agapito Branco, Alentejano Portugal 2008 $12.00
Critics Silver Vina Robles WHITE4 Paso Robles 2010 $16.00 BLENDED WHITE MEDIUM DRY
Critics Silver Brassfield Estate Serenity High Valley 2009 $10.00
Critics Silver Cameron Hughes Riesling / Chenin Blanc, Lot 259 Columbia Valley 2010 $11.00
Critics Gold Foxhorn Pinot Grigio / Chardonnay South Eastern Australia NV $8.00 BLENDED WHITE VARIETALS SWEET
Critics Silver Gallo Family Vineyards Sweet Chardonnay California NV $5.99 CHAMPAGNE BRUT NON-VINTAGE
Critics Gold G.H. Mumm Champagne, Mumm de Cramant, Grand Cru Reims NV $75.00
Critics Gold G.H. Mumm Champagne, Cordon Rouge, Brut Reims NV $35.00
Critics Silver Perrier-Jouet Champagne, Grand Brut Epernay NV $45.00 CHAMPAGNE ROSE NON VINTAGE
Wine of the Year G.H. Mumm Champagne, Brut Rose Reims NV $70.00
Critics Gold Perrier-Jouet Champagne, Blason Rosè Epernay NV $75.00 GRAPE BRANDY
Critics Silver Korbel Champagne Cellars Brandy VSOP, Gold Reserve California NV $15.00
Critics Silver Korbel Champagne Cellars Brandy XS California NV $12.00
Critics Silver Paul Masson Brandy, VS Grande Amber Kentucky NV $11.99 FORTIFIED RED OTHER
Critics Silver Quady Winery Elysium, Black Muscat California 2009 $24.99 FORTIFIED WHITE OTHER
Critics Silver Mendelson Vineyards Pinot Gris Dessert Wine, Reserve Lot 1 Napa Valley NV $40.00
Critics Gold Quady Winery Essensia, Orange Muscat California 2009 $24.99 FORTIFIED WINE SHERRY DRY
Critics Silver Gonzalez Byass Tio Pepe, Fino Muy Seco, Jerez DDO Spain NV $17.99 SHERRY OLOROSO SWEET
Critics Gold Gonzalez Byass Oloroso Dulce, Solera 1847, Jerez DDO Spain NV $19.99 ORGANIC OR BIODYNAMIC WHITE
Critics Silver Snoqualmie Vineyards Naked Riesling Columbia Valley 2009 $10.00 CHAMBOURCIN
Critics Silver St. James Winery Chambourcin Ozark Mountain 2009 $6.99 RED HYBRID NORTON
Critics Silver St. James Winery Cynthiana Ozark Highlands 2009 $6.99 RED HYBRID OTHER SWEET
Critics Silver St. James Winery Velvet Red American NV $6.99 RIOJA CRIANZA
Critics Silver Beronia Rioja DDOC, Crianza Spain 2008 $14.99
Critics Gold Campo Viejo Rioja DDOC, Crianza Spain 2007 $9.99 RIOJA GRAN RESERVA
Critics Silver Beronia Rioja DDOC, Gran Reserva Spain 2004 $27.99 RIOJA
Critics Silver Massimo Rioja DDOC Spain 2008 $10.99
Critics Silver Rioja Vega Rioja DDOC Spain 2009 $11.99 RIOJA RESERVA
Critics Silver Campo Viejo Rioja DDOC, Reserva Spain 2006 $13.99
Critics Silver Ysios Rioja DDOC, Reserva Spain 2004 $29.99 ROSE DRY
Critics Gold Banfi Centine Rosè, Toscana IGT Italy 2009 $11.00
Critics Silver Francis Ford Coppola Sofia Rosè Monterey County 2010 $17.00
Critics Gold Husch Vineyards Pinot Noir Vin Gris Anderson Valley 2010 $18.00
Critics Gold Manny O. Wines Agapitos Rosè, Alentejano Portugal 2008 $12.00
Critics Silver Milbrandt Vineyard Syrah Rosè, Traditions Columbia Valley 2010 $13.00
Best of Show Rose Robert Oatley Vineyards Rosè of Sangiovese Mudgee 2010 $15.00
Critics Platinum Tampesta Rosado, Prieto Picudo, Tierra de Leon Spain 2010 $15.00
Critics Silver Terra Kalecik Karasi Roze Turkey 2010 $10.00
Critics Gold Toad Hollow Vineyards Eye of the Toad Dry Rosè of Pinot Noir Sonoma County 2010 $12.99 ROSE MEDIUM DRY
Critics Silver Callaway Vineyard And Winery Rosè of Sangiovese, Special Selection Temecula Valley 2010 $18.00
Critics Silver Terra Kalecik Karasi, Beyaz, Dry Rosè Turkey 2010 $10.00 ROSE MEDIUM SWEET
Critics Silver Barefoot Cellars White Zinfandel California NV $6.99
Critics Silver Foxhorn White Zinfandel American NV $8.00
Critics Gold Wink White Zinfandel California 2009 $3.99 BARBERA
Critics Silver Viansa Winery Barbera Sonoma Valley 2008 $34.00 CABERNET FRANC
Critics Silver Acorn Winery Cabernet Franc, Alegria Vineyards Russian River Valley 2008 $30.00
Critics Gold Frogtown Cellars Cabernet Franc Lumpkin County 2006 $29.99
Critics Silver Hazlitt 1852 Vineyard Cabernet Franc Finger Lakes 2008 $22.00
Critics Silver Jarhead Cabernet Franc, Reserve Santa Ynez Valley 2008 $24.00
Critics Silver Loken Cabernet Franc, Lot 4, Reserve Nevada County 2007 $25.95
Critics Silver Lucas Vineyards Cabernet Franc, Limited Reserve Finger Lakes 2009 $19.99 CARMENERE
Critics Gold Casillero Del Diablo Carmenere, Reserve, Rapel Valley Chile 2009 $12.00
Critics Gold Hacienda Altavina Carmenere, Central Valley Chile 2010 $5.49 CABERNET SAUVIGNON - A
Critics Silver Alice White Cabernet Sauvignon South Eastern Australia 2009 $6.99
Critics Silver Almaden Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon, Heritage California NV $18.00
Critics Silver Bandit Cabernet Sauvignon California NV $8.99
Critics Gold Bouchon Cabernet Sauvignon, Superior California 2009 $8.99
Critics Silver Foxhorn Cabernet Sauvignon South Eastern Australia NV $8.00
Critics Gold I Heart California Cabernet Sauvignon California NV $7.99
Critics Silver Little Penguin Cabernet Sauvignon South Eastern Australia 2009 $7.00
Critics Gold Long Country Cabernet Sauvignon, Gran Reserva, Valle de Colchagua Chile 2009 $7.49
Critics Platinum Matuco Cabernet Sauvignon, Mendoza Argentina 2010 $7.99
Critics Gold Naked Grape Cabernet Sauvignon California NV $7.99
Critics Platinum Napa Family Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon, Reserve Napa Valley 2009 $9.99
Critics Silver St. George Cabernet Sauvignon, Select Reserve California 2009 $7.99
Critics Silver Target Wine Cube Cabernet Sauvignon California 2009 $15.99
Critics Silver Turning Leaf Cabernet Sauvignon California 2009 $8.00
Critics Silver Vendange Cabernet Sauvignon California NV $4.99
Critics Silver Wyndham Estate Cabernet Sauvignon, Bin 444 South Eastern Australia 2007 $9.99 CABERNET SAUVIGNON - B
Critics Gold Ancient Peaks Winery Cabernet Sauvignon Paso Robles 2009 $17.00
Critics Silver Blackstone Winery Cabernet Sauvignon, Sonoma Reserve Sonoma County 2007 $19.99
Critics Silver Casillero Del Diablo Cabernet Sauvignon, Reserve, Central Valley Chile 2009 $12.00
Critics Gold Clos Du Bois Cabernet Sauvignon North Coast 2008 $14.99
Critics Silver Columbia Crest Cabernet Sauvignon, Grand Estates Columbia Valley 2008 $12.00
Critics Platinum Domaine Laurier Cabernet Sauvignon, Reserve Sonoma County 2009 $12.99
Critics Gold Donati Family Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon Paicines 2007 $18.99
Critics Gold Eberle Winery Cabernet Sauvignon, Vineyard Selection Paso Robles 2008 $19.00
Critics Silver Hahn Winery Cabernet Sauvignon Central Coast 2009 $12.00
Critics Gold Huntington Cabernet Sauvignon California 2009 $14.00
Critics Silver Hyatt Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon Rattlesnake Hills 2008 $11.00
Critics Silver Jacob's Creek Cabernet Sauvignon, Reserve Coonawarra 2009 $13.99
Critics Silver Laurier Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon Alexander Valley 2009 $14.99
Critics Silver Liberty School Cabernet Sauvignon Paso Robles 2008 $14.00
Critics Gold Newman's Own Cabernet Sauvignon California 2009 $13.99
Critics Silver Rodney Strong Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon Sonoma County 2008 $17.00
Critics Silver Roza Ridge Cabernet Sauvignon Rattlesnake Hills 2006 $15.00
Critics Gold Wakefield Estate Cabernet Sauvignon Clare Valley 2009 $16.99
Critics Gold Wheelhouse Wine Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley 2008 $17.99
Best Cabernet Sauvignon Wild Horse Winery Cabernet Sauvignon Paso Robles 2007 $19.99
Critics Silver Zonte's Footstep Cabernet Sauvignon, Avalon Tree Langhorne Creek 2010 $16.00 CABERNET SAUVIGNON - C
Critics Silver Biltmore Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon Alexander Valley 2008 $24.99
Critics Silver Callaway Vineyard And Winery Cabernet Sauvignon, Special Selection Temecula Valley 2008 $28.00
Critics Gold Cameron Hughes Cabernet Sauvignon, Lot 211 Napa Valley 2008 $22.00
Critics Gold Chandelle Cabernet Sauvignon Sonoma County 2007 $20.00
Critics Silver Chateau Ste. Michelle Cabernet Sauvignon, Ethos Reserve Columbia Valley 2007 $38.00
Critics Silver Chateau Ste. Michelle Cabernet Sauvignon, Cold Creek Vineyard Columbia Valley 2008 $30.00
Critics Silver Darcie Kent Cabernet Sauvignon, Madden Ranch Livermore Valley 2008 $24.00
Critics Silver Dry Creek Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon Dry Creek Valley 2007 $25.00
Critics Silver Eberle Winery Cabernet Sauvignon Paso Robles 2007 $34.00
Critics Silver Folie A Deux Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley 2008 $28.00
Critics Silver ForeFront by Pine Ridge Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon Napa, San Luis Obispo, Lake Counties 2008 $24.00
Critics Gold Frogtown Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon Lumpkin County 2006 $29.99
Critics Platinum Kilikanoon Cabernet Sauvignon, Block's Road Clare Valley 2007 $30.00
Critics Gold Kilikanoon Cabernet Sauvignon, Block's Road Clare Valley 2009 $30.00
Critics Gold Lake Sonoma Winery Cabernet Sauvignon Alexander Valley 2008 $20.00
Critics Silver Monte De Oro Winery Cabernet Sauvignon Temecula Valley 2007 $32.00
Critics Silver Penley Estate Cabernet Sauvignon, Phoenix Coonawarra 2009 $20.00
Critics Silver Rosenthal - The Malibu Estate Cabernet Sauvignon Malibu-Newton Canyon 2006 $39.00
Critics Silver St. Supery Vineyards & Winery Cabernet Sauvignon, Estate Grown Napa Valley 2007 $30.00
Critics Silver Stony Ridge Cabernet Sauvignon, Estate Produced Livermore Valley 2007 $26.00
Critics Gold Trailhead Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley 2007 $29.99
Critics Silver V. Sattui Winery Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley 2008 $32.00
Critics Gold V. Sattui Winery Cabernet Sauvignon, Sattui Family California 2008 $22.00
Critics Silver Vina Robles Cabernet Sauvignon, Huerhuero, Estate Paso Robles 2008 $22.00 CABERNET SAUVIGNON - D
Critics Silver Antler Hill Cabernet Sauvignon, The Biltmore Collection Napa Valley 2006 $48.00
Critics Gold Clos LaChance Cabernet Sauvignon, Whitestone Vineyard Central Coast 2008 $40.00
Critics Silver Crooked Vine Jim's Cabernet Sauvignon Rutherford 2008 $42.00
Critics Silver Dutcher Crossing Winery Cabernet Sauvignon, Taylor Reserve Dry Creek Valley 2007 $43.00
Critics Silver Eponymous Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley 2007 $58.99
Critics Silver Houdini Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon, Glendale Ranch Napa Valley 2007 $49.95
Critics Silver Hughes Wellman Cabernet Sauvignon St. Helena 2007 $50.00
Critics Gold Jordan Vineyard & Winery Cabernet Sauvignon Alexander Valley 2007 $52.00
Critics Gold Penley Estate Cabernet Sauvignon, Reserve, Estate Grown Coonawarra 2006 $50.00
Critics Silver Pine Ridge Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley 2007 $54.00
Critics Gold R & B Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon, Reserve, Lyric of the Vine Napa Valley 2006 $50.00
Critics Silver Stag's Leap Wine Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon, Artemis Napa Valley 2007 $55.00
Critics Silver V. Sattui Winery Cabernet Sauvignon Mount Veeder 2008 $42.00
Critics Gold V. Sattui Winery Cabernet Sauvignon, Vittorio's Vineyard Napa Valley 2008 $44.00
Critics Silver V. Sattui Winery Cabernet Sauvignon, Morisoli Vineyard Napa Valley 2008 $55.00
Critics Gold Wakefield Estate Cabernet Sauvignon, St. Andrews Clare Valley 2006 $49.99 CABERNET SAUVIGNON - E
Critics Platinum Bracey Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon, TKL Oakville 2006 $75.00
Critics Platinum Bracey Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon Howell Mountain 2007 $70.00
Critics Platinum Cakebread Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley 2008 $61.00
Critics Silver Judd's Hill Founder's Art, Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley 2007 $65.00
Critics Gold Most Wanted Wine Co. Cabernet Sauvignon, Garcia Family Vineyard California 2008 $60.00
Critics Platinum Prix Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon, Reserve, Weir Family Vineyard, JMT Block Napa Valley 2006 $60.00
Critics Gold Rigg Estate Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon, Reserve Livermore Valley 2006 $75.00
Critics Silver Rocca Family Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon, Grigsby Vineyard Yountville 2007 $75.00
Critics Gold Rosenthal - The Malibu Estate Cabernet Sauvignon, Block M, Single Vineyard Malibu-Newton Canyon 2006 $70.00
Critics Platinum Winesmith Cabernet Sauvignon, Crucible Napa Valley 2005 $100.00 CABERNET SAUVIGNON - F
Critics Gold The Vineyard House Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley 2006 $175.00 GRENACHE
Critics Silver Curtis Winery Grenache Santa Ynez Valley 2007 $25.00
Critics Gold Kilikanoon Grenache, Prodigal Clare Valley 2009 $30.00
Critics Silver Vinas Del Vero Garnacha, La Miranda de Secastilla, Somontano DDO Spain 2007 $14.99
Critics Gold Vinas Del Vero Secastilla, Somontano DDO Spain 2005 $29.99 LAMBRUSCO
Critics Silver Dolce Vita Lambrusco, Del Emiliaght IGT Italy NV $3.99 RED VARIETAL ITALIAN
Critics Gold Acorn Winery Dolcetto, Alegria Vineyards Russian River Valley 2008 $30.00
Critics Silver Domenico Wines Dolcetto California 2006 $28.00
Critics Gold Feudi Di San Gregorio Rubrato Aglianico, Irpinia IGT Italy 2008 $15.99
Critics Gold Ora Montepulciano D'Abruzzo DOC Italy 2008 $4.99 MALBEC
Critics Silver Ambas Malbec, Mendoza Argentina 2009 $4.99
Critics Silver Clos LaChance Malbec, Estate Central Coast 2008 $35.00
Critics Silver Cupcake Malbec, Mendoza Argentina 2010 $14.00
Critics Silver Diseno Malbec, Old Vine, Mendoza Argentina 2010 $10.99
Critics Silver Redwood Creek Malbec, Mendoza Argentina 2009 $8.00
Critics Gold Trivento Malbec, Reserve, Mendoza Argentina 2010 $11.00 MERLOT - A
Critics Gold Barefoot Cellars Merlot California NV $6.99
Critics Gold Black Box Merlot California 2009 $24.99
Critics Silver Fat Cat Cellars Merlot California 2009 $8.99
Critics Silver Fish Eye Merlot South Eastern Australia 2010 $8.00
Critics Gold Flipflop Merlot California 2009 $7.00
Critics Silver Jacob's Creek Merlot South Eastern Australia 2010 $7.99
Critics Silver Kalbarri Merlot, Bin Select 770 South Eastern Australia 2010 $9.99
Critics Silver Meridian Merlot California 2009 $9.00
Critics Silver Motos Liberty Cellars Merlot California 2008 $8.99
Critics Silver Night Harvest Merlot California NV $6.99
Critics Gold Red Truck Winery Merlot Central Coast 2008 $9.99
Critics Gold Silver Ridge Merlot California 2008 $9.99
Critics Silver Thirty First State Merlot California 2009 $9.99
Critics Platinum Turning Leaf Merlot California 2009 $8.00
Critics Silver Vendange Merlot American NV $4.99 MERLOT - B
Critics Gold Beringer Merlot, Founders Estate California 2009 $10.00
Critics Silver Blackstone Winery Merlot, Winemaker's Select California 2009 $19.99
Critics Silver Blackstone Winery Merlot, Sonoma Reserve Sonoma County 2008 $19.99
Critics Silver Cameron Hughes Merlot, Lot 210 Napa Valley 2008 $12.00
Critics Silver Cellar No. 8 Merlot California 2008 $10.00
Critics Silver Cupcake Merlot Central Coast 2009 $14.00
Critics Silver Cycles Gladiator Merlot California 2009 $10.99
Critics Silver Domaine Laurier Merlot, Reserve Sonoma County 2007 $12.99
Critics Gold Donati Family Vineyard Merlot Paicines 2007 $17.99
Critics Silver Fattoria Cardella Merlot, Cardella Ranch, Vineyard 22 Fresno County 2009 $14.99
Critics Platinum Hahn Winery Merlot Central Coast 2009 $12.00
Critics Gold Laurier Vineyards Merlot Alexander Valley 2007 $14.99
Critics Gold Lockwood Vineyard Merlot, Estate Grown Monterey 2008 $14.99
Critics Silver Milbrandt Vineyard Merlot, Traditions Columbia Valley 2008 $15.00
Critics Gold Rodney Strong Vineyards Merlot Sonoma County 2007 $17.00
Critics Silver Rutherford Vintners Merlot Napa Valley 2007 $12.99
Critics Silver Villa San-Juliette Winery Merlot Paso Robles 2008 $17.00
Critics Silver Villa Yambol Merlot, Thracian Valley Bulgaria 2009 $10.00
Critics Gold Wild Horse Winery Merlot Paso Robles 2008 $16.99 MERLOT - C
Critics Silver Callaway Vineyard And Winery Merlot, Winemaker's Reserve Temecula Valley 2008 $38.00
Critics Silver Chateau Meroux Merlot, Reserve Bennett Valley 2007 $24.99
Critics Silver Darcie Kent Merlot, Picazo Livermore Valley 2008 $30.00
Critics Silver Falkner Winery Merlot Temecula Valley 2007 $24.95
Critics Silver Harbes Family Vineyard Merlot, Old Barn North Fork of Long Island 2007 $20.00
Critics Gold Hazlitt 1852 Vineyard Merlot Finger Lakes 2008 $22.00
Critics Gold Houdini Vineyards Merlot Oakville 2007 $39.95
Critics Silver Kenwood Vineyards Merlot, Jack London Vineyard Sonoma Valley 2008 $22.00
Critics Silver Napa Cellars Merlot Napa Valley 2008 $22.00
Critics Silver Riverstar Vineyards Merlot Paso Robles 2009 $20.00
Critics Gold St. Supery Vineyards & Winery Merlot, Estate Grown Napa Valley 2007 $25.00
Critics Gold V. Sattui Winery Merlot Napa Valley 2008 $25.00 MERLOT - D
Critics Silver Bargetto Winery Merlot, Reserve Santa Cruz Mountains 2008 $40.00
Best of Show Red Cakebread Cellars Merlot Napa Valley 2007 $54.00
Critics Gold Frogtown Cellars Merlot, Kritzer Family Reserve Lumpkin County 2006 $48.99
Critics Gold Northstar Merlot Columbia Valley 2007 $41.00 MERLOT - E
Critics Silver Northstar Merlot Walla Walla Valley 2007 $60.00 MOURVEDRE
Critics Gold David Girard Vineyard Mourvedre, Estate Vineyard El Dorado 2009 $34.00 NEBBIOLO
Critics Silver Domenico Wines Nebbiolo Amador County 2006 $28.00 RED VARIETAL OTHER DRY
Critics Silver Bouchaine Vineyards Pinot Meunier, Estate Carneros 2009 $40.00
Critics Gold Frogtown Cellars Tannat Lumpkin County 2006 $29.99
Critics Silver Kayra Vintage, Okuzgozu, Aydincik, Elazig Turkey 2008 $18.00
Critics Gold Terra Kalecik Karasi, Denizli Guney Platosu Turkey 2010 $10.00 PINOT NOIR - A
Critics Silver Barefoot Cellars Pinot Noir California NV $6.99
Critics Silver Cloud Valley Pinot Noir California 2009 $7.99
Critics Silver Fat Cat Cellars Pinot Noir California 2009 $8.99
Critics Silver Forest Glen Pinot Noir California 2009 $9.99
Critics Silver HRM Rex Goliath Pinot Noir Italy NV $7.50
Critics Gold Lindemans Pinot Noir, Bin 99 South Eastern Australia 2010 $7.00
Critics Gold Lucky Star Pinot Noir California 2009 $8.99
Critics Gold Motos Liberty Cellars Pinot Noir California 2009 $8.99
Critics Silver Redwood Creek Pinot Noir California 2009 $8.00
Critics Gold Silver Ridge Pinot Noir California 2009 $9.99
Critics Gold Target Wine Cube Pinot Noir California 2009 $15.99
Critics Gold Turning Leaf Pinot Noir California 2009 $8.00 PINOT NOIR - B
Critics Silver Barrel Ranch Pinot Noir California 2009 $11.99
Critics Silver Brassfield Estate Pinot Noir, High Serenity Ranch Vineyard High Valley 2009 $15.00
Critics Gold Cameron Hughes Pinot Noir, Lot 255 Yorkville Highlands 2009 $15.00
Critics Silver Cameron Hughes Pinot Noir, Lot 227, Casablanca Valley Chile 2009 $15.00
Critics Gold Cellar No. 8 Pinot Noir California 2009 $10.00
Critics Gold Cupcake Pinot Noir Central Coast 2009 $14.00
Critics Gold Erath Winery Pinot Noir Oregon 2009 $18.00
Critics Silver Fat Monk Pinot Noir Central Coast 2009 $15.00
Critics Silver Haute Pinot Noir, Haute Red California 2009 $11.99
Critics Platinum Henry Estate Winery Pinot Noir Oregon 2008 $18.00
Critics Gold J. Lohr Winery Pinot Noir, Falcon's Perch Monterey County 2009 $17.00
Critics Gold Jargon Pinot Noir California 2009 $10.99
Critics Gold Kenwood Vineyards Pinot Noir Russian River Valley 2009 $16.00
Critics Silver Kris Pinot Noir, Provincia di Pavia IGT Italy 2009 $14.00
Critics Silver Napa Ridge Winery Pinot Noir Napa Valley 2009 $12.99
Critics Gold Navarro Vineyards Pinot Noir Mendocino 2009 $19.00
Critics Silver Open Field Pinot Noir Santa Barbara County 2009 $19.99
Critics Gold Rutherford Vintners Pinot Noir Napa Valley 2008 $12.99
Critics Silver Sartori Pinot Noir, Provincia di Pavia IGT Italy 2008 $11.00
Critics Platinum SeaGlass Pinot Noir Santa Barbara County 2009 $13.00
Critics Silver Valley of the Moon Pinot Noir Carneros 2009 $18.00 PINOT NOIR - C
Critics Platinum Baileyana Winery Pinot Noir, Grand Firepeak Cuvee Edna Valley 2008 $33.00
Critics Gold Biltmore Reserve Pinot Noir Russian River Valley 2009 $24.99
Critics Gold Bin 36 Pinot Noir Monterey 2007 $26.00
Critics Gold Bouchaine Vineyards Pinot Noir Carneros 2008 $30.00
Critics Silver Clos LaChance Pinot Noir Santa Cruz Mountains 2008 $32.00
Critics Silver Crossing Vineyards And Winery Pinot Noir Pennsylvania 2008 $22.00
Critics Gold Darcie Kent Pinot Noir, West Pinnacles Vineyard Monterey County 2008 $24.00
Critics Silver Domaine Carneros Pinot Noir, Estate Carneros 2008 $35.00
Critics Silver Erath Winery Pinot Noir, Estate Selection Willamette Valley 2008 $36.00
Critics Gold Francis Ford Coppola Pinot Noir, Director's Sonoma Coast 2009 $21.00
Critics Gold Frank Family Vineyards Pinot Noir Carneros 2009 $35.00
Critics Platinum Gloria Ferrer Pinot Noir, Estate Grown Carneros 2007 $22.00
Critics Silver Handley Cellars Pinot Noir Mendocino County 2008 $25.00
Critics Gold Husch Vineyards Pinot Noir Anderson Valley 2009 $23.00
Critics Platinum Lafond Winery Pinot Noir, S R H Sta. Rita Hills 2009 $27.00
Critics Silver Mt. Beautiful Pinot Noir, North Canterbury New Zealand 2009 $22.99
Critics Gold Napa Cellars Pinot Noir Napa Valley 2009 $26.00
Critics Silver Paraiso Vineyards Pinot Noir Santa Lucia Highlands 2009 $25.00
Critics Silver V. Sattui Winery Pinot Noir, Henry Ranch Los Carneros 2009 $37.00
Critics Silver Ventana Vineyards Pinot Noir, Estate Grown Arroyo Seco 2009 $29.00 PINOT NOIR - D
Critics Gold Bracey Vineyards Pinot Noir, Doctor's Vineyard Santa Lucia Highlands 2009 $49.00
Critics Silver Bracey Vineyards Pinot Noir, La Encantada Vineyard Sta. Rita Hills 2009 $49.00
Critics Gold Cadre Pinot Noir, The Architects Central Coast 2007 $45.00
Critics Silver David Bruce Winery Pinot Noir Santa Cruz Mountains 2008 $55.00
Critics Gold David Bruce Winery Pinot Noir, Winemakers Reserve Anderson Valley 2008 $55.00
Critics Gold Gloria Ferrer Pinot Noir, Gravel Knob Vineyard Carneros 2006 $40.00
Critics Platinum Gloria Ferrer Pinot Noir, Rust Rock Terrace Vineyard Carneros 2006 $40.00
Critics Silver Hearthstone Vineyard And Winery Pinot Noir Paso Robles 2008 $40.00
Critics Silver Lafond Winery Pinot Noir, Lafond Vineyard, Pommard Clone Sta. Rita Hills 2007 $50.00
Best Pinot Noir Lafond Winery Pinot Noir, Lafond Vineyard Sta. Rita Hills 2006 $48.00
Critics Platinum Navarro Vineyards Pinot Noir, Deep End Blend Anderson Valley 2009 $49.00
Critics Platinum Stoller Vineyards Pinot Noir, Estate Grown Dundee Hills 2007 $40.00 PINOT NOIR - E
Critics Platinum Domaine Carneros Pinot Noir, Famous Gate Carneros 2008 $68.00
Critics Gold Zina Hyde Cunningham Winery Pinot Noir, Reserve Anderson Valley 2009 $60.00 PETITE SIRAH
Critics Gold Concannon Vineyard Petite Sirah, Conservancy Livermore Valley 2008 $14.00
Critics Silver Guerra Family Cellars Petite Sirah, Attitude, Pepper Tree Ranch San Benito County 2008 $32.00
Critics Silver Masked Rider Petite Sirah, Outlaw California 2007 $9.99
Critics Silver Villa San-Juliette Winery Petite Sirah Paso Robles 2009 $17.00 PETIT VERDOT
Critics Silver Jefferson Vineyards Petit Verdot Monticello 2009 $19.95
Critics Platinum Roza Ridge Petite Verdot Rattlesnake Hills 2008 $20.00 SHIRAZ - A
Critics Silver Black Opal Shiraz South Eastern Australia 2009 $7.00
Critics Silver Little Penguin Shiraz South Eastern Australia 2009 $7.00
Critics Silver Wyndham Estate Shiraz, Bin 555 South Eastern Australia 2008 $9.99 SHIRAZ - B
Critics Silver Angoves Shiraz, Vineyard Select McLaren Vale 2007 $19.75
Critics Silver Chateau Tanunda Shiraz, Grand Barossa Barossa 2008 $18.99
Critics Gold Jacob's Creek Shiraz, Reserve Barossa 2007 $13.99
Critics Silver Wakefield Estate Shiraz Clare Valley 2008 $16.99
Critics Silver Wolf Blass Shiraz, Yellow Label South Australia 2008 $12.00
Critics Gold Wolf Blass Shiraz, President's Selection South Australia 2008 $18.00
Critics Gold Wyndham Estate Shiraz, George Wyndham Founders Reserve Langhorne Creek 2007 $17.99 SHIRAZ - C
Critics Silver Penley Estate Shiraz, Hyland Coonawarra 2008 $20.00 SHIRAZ - D
Critics Platinum John Duval Shiraz, Eligo Barossa Valley 2006 $100.00
Critics Silver Kilikanoon Shiraz, Parable McLaren Vale 2009 $40.00
Critics Silver Kilikanoon Shiraz, Covenant Clare Valley 2008 $40.00 SYRAH - B
Critics Gold Concannon Vineyard Shiraz, Selected Vineyards Central Coast 2008 $10.00
Critics Silver Cycles Gladiator Syrah California 2009 $10.99
Critics Silver Kayra Shiraz, Guney Denizli Turkey 2009 $15.00
Critics Silver Valley of the Moon Syrah Sonoma County 2008 $16.00 SYRAH - C
Critics Silver Acorn Winery Syrah, Axiom, Alegria Vineyards Russian River Valley 2008 $29.00
Critics Silver Antler Hill Syrah, The Biltmore Collection Napa Valley 2006 $35.00
Critics Gold Curtis Winery Syrah, Ambassador's Vineyard Santa Ynez Valley 2007 $22.00
Critics Silver Monte De Oro Winery Syrah, Estate Grown, Vista del Monte Vineyard Temecula Valley 2007 $34.00
Critics Gold Reustle-Prayer Rock Vineyards Syrah, Masada Bloc Umpqua Valley 2009 $32.00
Critics Gold Vina Robles Syree Paso Robles 2007 $39.00 SYRAH - D
Critics Gold David Girard Vineyard Okei-San El Dorado 2008 $70.00 TEMPRANILLO
Critics Silver Finca Constancia Tempranillo, Parcela 23, Tierra de Castilla Spain 2009 $20.99
Critics Silver La Parra Loca Tempranillo Shiraz, Tierra De Castilla y Leon Spain 2008 $7.29
Critics Platinum Peirano Estate Vineyards Tempranillo, Heritage Collection Lodi 2008 $12.99
Critics Silver Reustle-Prayer Rock Vineyards Tempranillo, Reserve Umpqua Valley 2009 $38.00
Critics Platinum Reustle-Prayer Rock Vineyards Tempranillo, Timnah Bloc Umpqua Valley 2009 $26.00
Critics Platinum Robert Oatley Vineyards Tempranillo, King Valley Australia 2009 $20.00
Critics Gold Tapena Tempranillo, Tierra de Castilla Spain 2009 $10.00
Critics Platinum Tefft Cellars Tempranillo Yakima Valley 2008 $30.00 ZINFANDEL
Critics Silver Bluenose Wines Zinfandel Sonoma County 2007 $19.99
Critics Silver Bota Box Zinfandel California 2010 $18.99
Critics Silver Cameron Hughes Zinfandel, Lot 221 Lodi 2009 $12.00
Critics Silver Cameron Hughes Zinfandel, Lot 219, Monte Rosso Vineyard Sonoma Valley 2009 $12.00
Critics Silver Cameron Hughes Zinfandel, Lot 191 Lodi 2009 $12.00
Critics Silver Campus Oaks Zinfandel, Old Vine Lodi 2008 $10.99
Critics Silver Candor Zinfandel, Lot 3 California NV $16.00
Critics Silver Cellar No. 8 Zinfandel California 2008 $10.00
Critics Gold Dry Creek Vineyard Zinfandel, Heritage Sonoma County 2009 $19.00
Critics Silver Dutcher Crossing Winery Zinfandel, Proprietors Reserve Dry Creek Valley 2009 $29.00
Critics Silver Flying Winemaker Zinfandel, Ancient Vine Lodi 2009 $13.00
Critics Gold Four Vines Zinfandel, The Sophisticate Sonoma County 2008 $25.00
Critics Gold Gnarly Head Zinfandel Lodi 2009 $10.99
Critics Silver Green Truck Zinfandel Mendocino County 2009 $12.99
Critics Gold Kenwood Vineyards Zinfandel Sonoma County 2008 $14.00
Critics Silver Napa Cellars Zinfandel Napa Valley 2008 $22.00
Critics Silver Ravenswood Winery Zinfandel, Old Vine Napa Valley 2009 $12.00
Critics Platinum Ravenswood Winery Zinfandel, Vintners Blend California 2009 $9.99
Critics Silver Ravenswood Winery Zinfandel, Teldeschi Vineyard Dry Creek Valley 2007 $35.00
Critics Silver Red Soles Winery Zinfandel, Estate, Miracles Ranch Paso Robles 2009 $34.00
Critics Silver Renwood Winery Zinfandel, Jack Rabbit Flat Amador County 2008 $28.95
Critics Silver Riverstar Vineyards Zinfandel Paso Robles 2009 $18.00
Critics Gold Rodney Strong Vineyards Zinfandel, Knotty Vines, Estate Vineyards Northern Sonoma 2008 $18.50
Critics Gold V. Sattui Winery Zinfandel, Old Vine, Crow Ridge Vineyard Russian River Valley 2008 $35.00
Critics Gold Valley of the Moon Zinfandel Sonoma County 2008 $16.00
Critics Silver Vendange Zinfandel California NV $4.99
Critics Silver Villa San-Juliette Winery Zinfandel Paso Robles 2009 $17.00
Critics Silver Zina Hyde Cunningham Winery Zinfandel, Old Vine, Reserve Russian River Valley 2007 $40.00
Critics Gold Zina Hyde Cunningham Winery Zinfandel Dry Creek Valley 2007 $36.00 CAVA BRUT NON-VINTAGE
Critics Silver Casteller Cava Brut Spain NV $10.00
Critics Gold Totus Tuus Cava Brut, Reserva Spain NV $15.00
Critics Silver Vilarnau Cava Brut Spain NV $15.99 CAVA BRUT VINTAGE
Critics Platinum Vilarnau Cava Brut Nature Spain 2008 $17.99 CAVA ROSE
Critics Silver Montcadi Cava Rosè Spain NV $6.99
Critics Silver Naveran Perles Roses, Cuvee Antonia Spain 2009 $38.00
Critics Gold Vilarnau Cava Brut Rosè Spain NV $17.99 SPUMANTE BIANCO
Critics Silver Barefoot Bubbly Moscato Spumante California NV $10.99
Critics Silver Cook's Spumante California NV $6.99 SPUMANTE ROSSO
Critics Gold Banfi Rosa Regale, Brachetto d'Acqui DOCG Italy 2010 $23.00
Critics Gold Martini & Rossi Spumante Rosè Italy NV $12.99 PROSECCO BRUT
Critics Silver Caposaldo Brut Prosecco DOC Italy NV $15.00
Critics Gold Maschio Treviso Brut Prosecco DOC Italy NV $13.00
Critics Silver Zardetto Treviso Brut Prosecco DOC Italy NV $14.00 PROSECCO EXTRA DRY
Critics Silver Cupcake Prosecco DOC, Extra Dry Italy NV $14.00
Critics Silver Martini & Rossi Prosecco DOC Italy NV $14.99 SPARKLING WINE BLANC DE BLANCS
Critics Silver Chateau Frank Blanc De Blancs Finger Lakes 2006 $29.99
Critics Gold Gloria Ferrer Blanc De Blancs Carneros 2006 $24.00
Critics Silver Korbel Champagne Cellars Chardonnay Champagne California NV $11.00
Critics Silver Le Grande Courtage Grand Cuvee, Blanc De Blancs, Brut France NV $18.99
Critics Silver Sparkling Pointe Blanc De Blancs North Fork of Long Island 2005 $42.00 SPARKLING WINE BLANC DE NOIRS
Critics Silver Domaine Ste. Michelle Blanc De Noirs Columbia Valley NV $13.00
Critics Gold Gloria Ferrer Blanc De Noirs Carneros NV $20.00
Critics Silver Hagafen Cuvee De Noir Napa Valley 2007 $36.00
Critics Silver Korbel Champagne Cellars Blanc De Noirs California NV $11.00 SPARKLING WINE BRUT NON-VINTAGE
Critics Silver Barefoot Bubbly Brut Cuvee California NV $9.99
Critics Silver Biltmore Estate Brut American NV $24.99
Critics Silver Domaine Laurier Brut California NV $9.99
Critics Silver Domaine Ste. Michelle Brut Columbia Valley NV $13.00
Critics Silver Gloria Ferrer Brut Sonoma County NV $20.00
Critics Gold Korbel Champagne Cellars Brut California NV $11.00 SPARKLING WINE BRUT VINTAGE
Critics Silver Chateau Frank Brut Finger Lakes 2005 $24.99
Critics Gold Domaine Carneros by Tattinger Brut Carneros 2007 $26.00
Critics Silver Gloria Ferrer Royal Cuvee Carneros 2002 $32.00
Critics Platinum Sparkling Pointe Brut North Fork of Long Island 2007 $29.00 SPARKLING WINE BRUT ZERO / NATURAL
Critics Gold Korbel Champagne Cellars Natural Russian River Valley 2008 $13.00 SPARKLING WINE EXTRA DRY
Critics Silver Cook's Extra Dry California NV $6.99
Critics Silver Gloria Ferrer Va de Vi, Ultra Cuvee Sonoma County NV $22.00
Critics Silver Sparkling Pointe Cuvee Carnaval North Fork of Long Island NV $24.00 SPARKLING NON-TRADITIONAL GRAPES
Critics Silver Barefoot Bubbly Pinot Grigio California NV $10.99
Critics Gold Manny O. Wines Celebrus, Blanquette de Limoux France NV $17.00 SPARKLING WINE ROSE
Critics Gold Gloria Ferrer Brut Rosè Carneros 2006 $42.00
Critics Gold Korbel Champagne Cellars Brut Rosè California NV $11.00
Critics Platinum Sparkling Pointe Topaz Imperial North Fork of Long Island NV $33.00 SPARKLING SWEET
Critics Silver Korbel Champagne Cellars Sweet Rosè California NV $15.00 SPARKLING WINE TETES DE CUVEE
Critics Silver Domaine Carneros by Tattinger La Reve Blanc de Blancs Carneros 2005 $95.00
Critics Gold Sparkling Pointe Brut Seduction North Fork of Long Island 2001 $50.00 WHITE HYBRID MEDIUM SWEET
Critics Silver Pahrump Valley Winery Symphony California 2010 $11.95 WHITE HYBRID OTHER SWEET
Critics Gold St. James Winery Velvet White American NV $6.99 WHITE HYBRID SEYVAL
Critics Gold Wollersheim Winery Prairie Fume American 2010 $9.00 WHITE HYBRID TRAMINETTE
Critics Silver St. James Winery Podium Series, The Meadow, Traminette American NV $12.99 WHITE HYBRID VIDAL BLANC
Critics Silver Cedar Creek Winery Vidal American NV $8.50 WHITE HYBRID VIGNOLES
Critics Gold St. James Winery Vignoles Ozark Highlands 2010 $9.99 MUSCAT FRIZZANTE
Critics Gold Jacob's Creek Sparkling Moscato Australia NV $7.99 MUSCAT MEDIUM DRY
Critics Silver V. Sattui Winery Dry Muscat California 2010 $26.00 MUSCAT MEDIUM SWEET
Critics Silver Alice White Lexia Moscato South Eastern Australia 2010 $6.99
Critics Silver Bella Sera Moscato, Puglia IGT Italy 2010 $6.99
Critics Silver Woodbridge Winery Moscato California 2010 $7.99 MUSCAT SWEET
Critics Silver Barefoot Cellars Moscato California NV $6.99
Critics Gold Gallo Family Vineyards Moscato, Valencia DDO Spain NV $5.99
Critics Gold Jacob's Creek Moscato South Eastern Australia 2010 $7.99
Critics Silver Wink Moonstruck Moscato California NV $3.99 WHITE PREMIUM DESSERT WINE
Critics Gold Bouchaine Vineyards Bouche D'Or, Late Harvest Chardonnay Carneros 2010 $30.00
Critics Gold Husch Vineyards Late Harvest Gewurztraminer Anderson Valley 2010 $20.00
Critics Platinum Mendelson Vineyards Muscat Canelli Mendocino County NV $40.00
Critics Silver Navarro Vineyards Muscat Blanc, Late Harvest, Cluster Select Anderson Valley 2010 $59.00
Critics Silver Waters Crest Winery Night Watch, Late Harvest North Fork of Long Island 2009 $44.99 ALBARINO
Critics Silver Leirana Albarino, Rias Baixas DDO Spain 2009 $30.00
Critics Gold Paco & Lola Albarino, Rias Baixas DDO Spain 2010 $20.00
Critics Gold Tangent Albarino, Paragon Vineyard Edna Valley 2009 $17.00 CHENIN BLANC
Critics Gold Husch Vineyards Chenin Blanc, La Ribera Vineyards Mendocino 2010 $11.00
Critics Silver Kiona Vineyards Chenin Blanc Columbia Valley 2010 $14.99 CHARDONNAY - A
Critics Silver Cadet D'Oc Chardonnay, Pays d'Oc France 2009 $9.99
Critics Silver Foodies Chardonnay California 2009 $7.99
Critics Silver Forest Glen Chardonnay California 2009 $9.99
Critics Silver HRM Rex Goliath Chardonnay California NV $7.50
Critics Silver Jenica Peak Chardonnay, Coastal Series California 2009 $8.99
Critics Silver Motos Liberty Cellars Chardonnay California 2009 $8.99
Critics Silver Napa Family Vineyards Chardonnay, Reserve Napa Valley 2008 $9.99
Critics Silver Night Harvest Chardonnay California NV $6.99
Critics Silver Recoleta Chardonnay, Mendoza Argentina 2009 $3.29
Critics Silver Silver Ridge Chardonnay California 2009 $9.99
Critics Silver Simply Naked Chardonnay California 2010 $9.99
Critics Silver Thirty First State Chardonnay California 2009 $9.99
Critics Silver Wyndham Estate Chardonnay, Bin 222 South Eastern Australia 2009 $9.99 CHARDONNAY - B
Critics Silver Beringer Chardonnay, Founders Estate California 2009 $10.00
Critics Gold Biltmore Chardonnay Sur Lies American NV $10.99
Critics Silver Blackstone Winery Chardonnay, Sonoma Reserve Sonoma County 2007 $16.99
Critics Silver Cameron Hughes Chardonnay, Lot 212 Carneros 2009 $13.00
Critics Gold Cupcake Chardonnay Central Coast 2009 $14.00
Critics Silver Domaine Laurier Chardonnay, Reserve Sonoma County 2008 $12.99
Critics Silver Fog Head Chardonnay, Highland Series Reserve Monterey 2009 $13.99
Critics Silver Glen Carlou Chardonnay, Paarl South Africa 2009 $17.00
Critics Platinum Gnarly Head Chardonnay California 2010 $10.99
Critics Silver Husch Vineyards Chardonnay Mendocino 2009 $15.00
Critics Silver Husch Vineyards Chardonnay, Vine One Anderson Valley 2009 $18.00
Critics Silver Jacob's Creek Chardonnay, Reserve Adelaide Hills 2009 $13.99
Critics Gold Lockwood Vineyard Chardonnay, Estate Grown Monterey 2009 $11.99
Critics Silver Main & Geary Chardonnay Sonoma County 2009 $14.99
Critics Gold Napa Ridge Winery Chardonnay Napa Valley 2008 $12.99
Critics Silver Newman's Own Chardonnay California 2009 $11.99
Critics Silver Paraiso Vineyards Chardonnay Santa Lucia Highlands 2009 $18.00
Critics Silver Picket Fence Chardonnay Russian River Valley 2009 $14.99
Critics Gold Robert Mondavi Private Selection Chardonnay California 2009 $10.99
Critics Platinum Rutherford Vintners Chardonnay Napa Valley 2009 $12.99
Critics Silver Stony Ridge Chardonnay, Estate Produced Livermore Valley 2009 $19.00
Critics Silver Toasted Head Chardonnay California 2009 $12.99
Critics Silver Valley of the Moon Chardonnay, Un-Oaked Russian River Valley 2010 $14.00
Critics Silver Wakefield Promised Land Chardonnay South Australia 2009 $11.99
Critics Silver Wolf Blass Chardonnay, Yellow Label South Australia 2009 $12.00 CHARDONNAY - C
Critics Silver Baileyana Winery Chardonnay, Grand Firepeak Cuvee Edna Valley 2008 $28.00
Critics Silver Bouchaine Vineyards Chardonnay, Estate Carneros 2009 $25.00
Critics Silver Bracey Vineyards Chardonnay, Split Rock Vineyard Sonoma Coast 2009 $38.00
Critics Gold Chateau Ste. Michelle Chardonnay, Canoe Ridge Estate Horse Heaven Hills 2008 $24.00
Critics Gold Clos Du Bois Chardonnay, Calcaire Russian River Valley 2008 $25.00
Critics Silver Darcie Kent Chardonnay, DeMayo Vineyard Livermore Valley 2009 $30.00
Critics Gold Davis Bynum Winery Chardonnay Russian River Valley 2008 $25.00
Critics Silver Dry Creek Vineyard Chardonnay, Foggy Oaks Russian River Valley 2008 $20.00
Critics Gold Francis Ford Coppola Chardonnay, Director's Cut Russian River Valley 2009 $21.00
Critics Gold Frank Family Vineyards Chardonnay Carneros 2009 $32.50
Critics Silver Godwin Family Vineyards Chardonnay, Floral Clone Russian River Valley 2008 $28.00
Critics Silver Hagafen Chardonnay Oak Knoll District 2009 $24.00
Critics Silver Handley Cellars Chardonnay, Estate Vineyard Anderson Valley 2009 $20.00
Critics Silver J. Lohr Winery Chardonnay, Arroyo Vista Arroyo Seco 2008 $25.00
Critics Silver J. Lohr Winery Chardonnay, October Night Arroyo Seco 2009 $25.00
Critics Gold Jefferson Vineyards Chardonnay, Reserve Monticello 2010 $21.95
Critics Gold Jordan Vineyard & Winery Chardonnay Russian River Valley 2009 $29.00
Critics Gold Lafond Winery Chardonnay, Sanford & Benedict Vineyard Sta. Rita Hills 2007 $38.00
Critics Gold Most Wanted Wine Co. Chardonnay Russian River Valley 2009 $35.00
Critics Silver Navarro Vineyards Chardonnay, Premiere Reserve Anderson Valley 2009 $25.00
Critics Silver Penley Estate Chardonnay, Aradia Coonawarra 2009 $20.00
Critics Gold Rodney Strong Vineyards Chardonnay, Estate Vineyards Chalk Hill 2009 $20.00
Critics Silver Rosemount Estate Chardonnay, Show Reserve Hunter Valley 2007 $21.00
Critics Silver Rosenthal - The Malibu Estate Chardonnay Malibu-Newton Canyon 2009 $25.00
Critics Platinum Sherwood House Vineyards Chardonnay, Estate Grown North Fork of Long Island 2008 $30.00
Critics Silver Surfrider Chardonnay Central Coast 2009 $21.00
Critics Gold Zina Hyde Cunningham Winery Chardonnay North Coast 2009 $28.00 CHARDONNAY - D
Critics Gold David Bruce Winery Chardonnay Santa Cruz Mountains 2008 $55.00 GEWURZTRAMINER DRY
Critics Gold Handley Cellars Gewurztraminer Anderson Valley 2010 $18.00
Critics Silver Husch Vineyards Gewurztraminer, T-Bud Dry Cuvee Anderson Valley 2009 $17.00
Critics Gold Robert Oatley Vineyards Gewurztraminer, Cumbandry Vineyard Mudgee 2010 $25.00 GEWURZTRAMINER MEDIUM DRY
Critics Gold Dr. Konstantin Frank Wine Cellars Gewurztraminer, Reserve Finger Lakes 2009 $24.99
Critics Gold Henry Estate Winery Gewurztraminer, Dry Umpqua Valley 2008 $13.00
Critics Gold Husch Vineyards Gewurztraminer Anderson Valley 2009 $14.00 GEWURZTRAMINER SWEET
Critics Silver Navarro Vineyards Gewurztraminer, Late Harvest Anderson Valley 2009 $35.00 WHITE ICE WINE
Critics Silver Inniskillin Riesling Ice Wine, VQA Niagara Peninsula 2007 $80.00
Best of Show Dessert Inniskillin Vidal Ice Wine, VQA Niagara Peninsula 2007 $60.00 WHITE VARIETAL OTHER DRY
Critics Platinum Dr. Konstantin Frank Wine Cellars Rkatsiteli Finger Lakes 2009 $17.99 PINOT BLANC
Critics Silver Valley of the Moon Pinot Blanc Sonoma County 2009 $14.00 PINOT GRIGIO
Critics Silver Barefoot Cellars Pinot Grigio American NV $6.99
Critics Platinum Benedetto Pinot Grigio, Delle Venezie IGP Italy 2010 $10.99
Critics Silver Brancott Estate Pinot Grigio South Island 2008 $14.00
Critics Silver Brassfield Estate Pinot Grigio, High Serenity Ranch Vineyard High Valley 2009 $10.00
Critics Silver Clos Du Bois Pinot Grigio California 2009 $11.99
Critics Silver Cycles Gladiator Pinot Grigio California 2009 $10.99
Critics Silver Fat Cat Cellars Pinot Grigio California 2009 $8.99
Critics Silver Fontana D'Italia Pinot Grigio, Delle Venezie IGT Italy 2010 $10.99
Critics Silver Forest Glen Pinot Grigio, Tehachapi Clone California 2010 $8.99
Critics Silver Graffigna Centenario Pinot Grigio, Reserve, San Juan Argentina 2010 $12.99
Critics Silver Hogue Cellars Pinot Grigio Columbia Valley 2009 $10.99
Critics Silver I Heart California Pinot Grigio California NV $7.99
Critics Silver Jacob's Creek Pinot Grigio South Eastern Australia 2010 $7.99
Critics Gold Kris Pinot Grigio, Delle Venezie IGT Italy 2009 $14.00
Critics Silver Main & Geary Pinot Grigio California 2010 $12.99
Critics Silver Naked Grape Pinot Grigio California NV $7.99
Critics Gold Ruffino Pinot Grigio, Lumina, Delle Venezie IGT Italy 2010 $9.99
Critics Silver Target Wine Cube Pinot Grigio California 2010 $15.99
Critics Silver Turning Leaf Pinot Grigio California 2010 $8.00
Critics Silver White Truck Pinot Grigio California 2009 $9.99
Critics Silver Woodbridge Winery Pinot Grigio California 2010 $7.99
Critics Silver Zonte's Footstep Pinot Grigio, Doctoressa Di Lago Fleurieu Peninsula 2010 $14.00 PINOT GRIS
Critics Gold Hahn Winery Pinot Gris Monterey 2009 $12.00
Critics Platinum Handley Cellars Pinot Gris Anderson Valley 2009 $18.00
Critics Gold Kenwood Vineyards Pinot Gris Russian River Valley 2010 $16.00
Critics Silver Open Field Pinot Gris Santa Barbara County 2009 $9.99
Critics Silver Sweet Cheeks Winery Pinot Gris Willamette Valley 2009 $15.00 RIESLING DRY
Critics Gold Chateau Ste. Michelle Dry Riesling Columbia Valley 2009 $9.00
Critics Silver Dr. Konstantin Frank Wine Cellars Riesling, Dry Finger Lakes 2010 $14.99
Critics Silver Hazlitt 1852 Vineyard Riesling, Homestead Reserve Finger Lakes 2008 $18.00
Critics Platinum Jacob's Creek Dry Riesling, Reserve Barossa 2010 $13.99
Critics Silver Kilikanoon Riesling, Watervale, Mort's Reserve Clare Valley 2010 $35.00
Critics Platinum Kilikanoon Riesling, Watervale, Mort's Block Clare Valley 2010 $20.00
Critics Gold Kiona Vineyards Dry Riesling, Reserve Red Mountain 2010 $14.99
Critics Gold Lucas Vineyards Dry Riesling Finger Lakes 2010 $13.99
Critics Platinum Lucas Vineyards Dry Riesling Finger Lakes 2009 $13.99
Critics Platinum Pacific Rim Winemakers Dry Riesling Columbia Valley 2008 $10.99
Critics Silver V. Sattui Winery Riesling Anderson Valley 2010 $24.00
Critics Gold V. Sattui Winery Secco Riesling Napa Valley 2010 $23.00
Critics Silver Wagner Vineyards Riesling Dry Finger Lakes 2009 $14.99
Critics Silver Wakefield Estate Riesling Clare Valley 2010 $16.99
Critics Silver Wolf Blass Dry Riesling, Yellow Label South Australia 2008 $12.00
Critics Gold Wollersheim Winery Dry Riesling American NV $9.00
Critics Silver Zina Hyde Cunningham Winery Riesling, Dry Russian River Valley 2009 $22.00 RIESLING MEDIUM DRY
Critics Silver Dr. Konstantin Frank Wine Cellars Riesling, Semi-Dry Finger Lakes 2010 $14.99 RIESLING MEDIUM SWEET
Critics Silver Barefoot Cellars Riesling California NV $6.99
Critics Silver Bota Box Riesling California 2009 $18.99
Critics Gold Cupcake Riesling Mosel 2010 $14.00
Critics Platinum Falkner Winery Riesling Temecula Valley 2009 $16.95
Critics Gold Hagafen Riesling, Rancho Wieruszowski Vineyard Napa Valley 2010 $24.00
Best of Show White Hagafen Riesling, Devoto Vineyards Lake County 2010 $18.00
Critics Silver Hogue Cellars Riesling Columbia Valley 2009 $10.99
Critics Gold Lucas Vineyards Semi Dry Riesling Finger Lakes 2010 $13.99
Critics Gold Lucas Vineyards Semi Dry Riesling Finger Lakes 2009 $13.99
Critics Silver Pacific Rim Winemakers Riesling Columbia Valley 2010 $10.99
Critics Silver SeaGlass Riesling Monterey County 2010 $13.00
Critics Silver Wagner Vineyards Riesling Semi Dry Finger Lakes 2009 $14.99
Critics Gold Wagner Vineyards Riesling Semi Dry Finger Lakes 2008 $12.99 RIESLING SWEET
Critics Gold Hyatt Vineyards Riesling Rattlesnake Hills 2010 $11.00
Critics Gold Pacific Rim Winemakers Sweet Riesling Columbia Valley 2010 $10.99
Critics Silver St. James Winery Riesling, Semi-Dry American NV $9.99
Critics Gold V. Sattui Winery White Riesling, Late Harvest Napa Valley 2009 $31.00 SAUVIGNON BLANC - A
Critics Silver Barefoot Cellars Sauvignon Blanc California NV $6.99
Critics Gold Boro Hills Sauvignon Blanc Marlborough 2010 $9.99
Critics Gold Pebble Bay Sauvignon Blanc Marlborough 2009 $4.99
Critics Silver Silver Birch Sauvignon Blanc New Zealand NV $24.00
Critics Gold Vendange Sauvignon Blanc California NV $4.99 SAUVIGNON BLANC - B
Critics Silver Ancient Peaks Winery Sauvignon Blanc Paso Robles 2010 $14.00
Critics Silver Brassfield Estate Sauvignon Blanc, High Serenity Ranch Vineyard High Valley 2009 $10.00
Critics Gold Cameron Hughes Sauvignon Blanc, Lot 225, Leyda Valley Chile 2009 $10.00
Critics Silver Casillero Del Diablo Sauvignon Blanc, Reserve, Casablanca Valley Chile 2010 $12.00
Critics Silver Cupcake Sauvignon Blanc Marlborough 2010 $14.00
Critics Silver Emiliana Natura Sauvignon Blanc, Valle de Casablanca Chile 2010 $11.00
Critics Gold Fernz Sauvignon Blanc Marlborough 2010 $13.99
Critics Gold Francis Ford Coppola Sauvignon Blanc, Diamond Collection, Yellow Label California 2010 $17.00
Critics Silver Huntington Sauvignon Blanc Dry Creek Valley 2009 $14.00
Critics Platinum Kenwood Vineyards Sauvignon Blanc Sonoma County 2010 $12.00
Critics Gold Nobilo Sauvignon Blanc, Regional Collection Marlborough 2010 $14.00
Critics Gold Robert Oatley Vineyards Sauvignon Blanc, Pemberton Australia 2010 $16.00
Critics Gold Rock Hollow Sauvignon Blanc, Vintner's Selection Santa Barbara County 2009 $12.00
Critics Gold Shannon Ridge Sauvignon Blanc, Ranch Collection Lake County 2009 $16.00
Critics Silver Tangent Sauvignon Blanc Edna Valley 2010 $13.00
Critics Silver Trailhead Sauvignon Blanc Napa Valley 2009 $17.99
Critics Platinum Villa San-Juliette Winery Sauvignon Blanc Paso Robles 2009 $15.00
Critics Platinum Wakefield Estate Sauvignon Blanc Adelaide Hills 2009 $16.99 SAUVIGNON BLANC - C
Critics Silver Brancott Sauvignon Blanc Marlborough 2010 $26.00
Critics Gold Dutcher Crossing Winery Sauvignon Blanc Dry Creek Valley 2010 $22.00
Critics Gold J. Lohr Winery Sauvignon Blanc, Carol's Vineyard Napa Valley 2009 $25.00
Critics Gold V. Sattui Winery Sauvignon Blanc, Vittorio's Vineyard Napa Valley 2009 $24.00
Critics Gold Zina Hyde Cunningham Winery Sauvignon Blanc Russian River Valley 2009 $20.00 SEMILLON
Critics Gold Brokenwood Semillon, Oakey Creek Vineyard Hunter Valley 2006 $32.00
Critics Silver Brokenwood Semillon Hunter Valley 2010 $20.00
Critics Gold Kilikanoon Semillon, Barrel-Fermented Clare Valley 2009 $18.00 WHITE VARIETAL SPANISH
Critics Gold Segura Viudas Creu de Lavit Penedes 2007 $15.00
Critics Gold Vinas Del Vero La Miranda de Secastilla, Somontano DDO Spain 2009 $14.99 VIOGNIER
Critics Silver Eberle Winery Viognier, Mill Road Vineyard Paso Robles 2010 $21.00
Critics Silver Guerra Family Cellars Viognier, Attitude, Pepper Tree Ranch San Benito County 2009 $24.00
Critics Gold Red Soles Winery Viognier, Estate, Miracles Ranch Paso Robles 2010 $26.00
Critics Gold White Hall Vineyards Viognier Monticello 2009 $16.99 VERDELHO
Critics Platinum Zonte's Footstep Verdelho, Sea Mist Langhorne Creek 2010 $14.00 VERDEJO
Critics Silver Tapena Verdejo, Tierra de Castilla Spain 2009 $10.00
|
