Critics Challenge 2010
Wine of the Year

Chateau Ste. Michelle 2009 Dry Riesling, Columbia Valley ($9)

Best of Show Sparkling

Perrier-Jouet 2002 Fleur de Champagne, France ($140)

Best of Show Red

Girard 2007 Petite Sirah, Napa Valley ($28)

Best of Show White

Chateau Ste. Michelle 2009 Dry Riesling, Columbia Valley ($9)

Best of Show Rose

Uptick Vineyards 2009 Hilda's Rose, Russian River Valley ($19)

Best of Show Dessert

V. Sattui Winery Angelica, Napa Valley ($30)

Best Chardonnay

Jordan Winery 2008 Chardonnay, Russian River Valley ($29)

Best Cabernet Sauvignon

Sawyer 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Rutherford, Napa Valley ($48)

Best Bordeaux Blend

Dry Creek Vineyard 2006 The Mariner, Dry Creek Valley ($40)

Best Pinot Noir

Stoller 2006 Pinot Noir, Estate, Dundee Hills, Oregon ($40)

2010 Critics Challenge Medal Winners

181
 Critics Gold 2008 Merlot Lodi $15.00 Mineral-berry, dry, forward fruit, bright. Good texture and length. - Gerald D. Boyd

337
 Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon Lodi $15.00 Thick, rich, smooth, harmonious. - Elin McCoy

A Mano
 Critics Silver 2007 Primativo, Puglia IGT Italy $8.00 Strawberries and jam. Sort of sleek and red-fruited, nice balance, clean, well-balanced red. - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Grigio, Delle Venezie IGT Italy $8.00 Crisp, edgy, simple summer quaffer. - Elin McCoy

Acre
 Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay Central Coast $16.00 Medium mineral nose, good fruit, balanced. - Gerald D. Boyd

Alderbrook Vineyards
 Critics Silver 2006 Carignane, School House Creek Vineyard Dry Creek Valley $19.00 Simple, juicy, fluid, quite concentrated, a touch of tannin but less coarse than so many Carignans. A touch rustic but has acidity and spice. - Stephen Brook
 Critics Silver 2006 Zinfandel, Estate Dry Creek Valley $25.00 Dark fig and blackberry, lots of mocha and very dense on palate, forceful. - Patrick Comiskey

Alice White
 Critics Silver 2008 Shiraz South Eastern Australia $8.00 Ripe berry nose. Low intensity fruit, medium palate. - Gerald D. Boyd
 Critics Gold 2009 Chardonnay South Eastern Australia $8.00 An elegant, graceful wine with light, pear, apple, vanilla aromas and flavors sparked by vibrant acidity. - Rebecca Murphy

Ambas
 Critics Silver 2008 Malbec Mendoza $5.00 A subtle chamomile edge to raspberry jam and cassis. Juicy and elegant. - Jon Bonne

Ancient Peaks Winery
 Critics Gold 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon Paso Robles $16.00 Rich, ripe and very nicely focused. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Gold 2007 Merlot Paso Robles $16.00 Earthy, leathery depth adds compelling complexity. - Paul Lukacs   
 Critics Silver 2008 Sauvignon Blanc Paso Robles $12.00 Glowing with intense, ripe fruit flavors -- think white peaches -- followed by a lingering green-apple finish. - Nick Passmore

Artezin
 Critics Silver 2007 Zinfandel Dry Creek Valley $25.00 Ripe, round, ravishingly Zin-like. - Marguerite Thomas

Astoria Vini
 Critics Gold 2009 Cuvee Tenuta Val De Brun, Prosecco di Valdobbiadene DOC Italy $24.00 Very nicely balanced, especially for such an opulently sweet wine. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Silver NV Cuvee Astoria Lounge, Prosecco DOC Italy $14.00 Citrus and summer stone fruit flavors.  Bright and frothy. - Paul Lukacs

Baigorri
 Critics Gold 2005 Rioja Crianza Spain $22.00 Smoky aromas lead to a serious palate of dark berry fruit and spice notes. Complex but still light-hearted.   - Leslie Sbrocco

Baileyana Winery
 Critics Platinum 2007 Pinot Noir, Grand Firepeak Cuvee Edna Valley  $33.00   An earthy red with scents of black cherry and earth, sweetened by brown sugar. Palate is generous with flavors of caramel and strawberry, a bright  intensity drives the wine, the texture marked by earth notes.  - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay, Grand Firepeak Cuvee Edna Valley  $30.00 Rich and savory. Pears and lees and apples. Good presence, fairly thick, but well made wine.  - Patrick Comiskey

Ballatore Champagne Cellars
 Critics Gold NV Gran Spumante California $8.00 Full and rich. Outstanding. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Silver NV Rosso Spumante California $8.00 Clean and fresh with just enough acidity for balance. - Paul Lukacs

Bandit
 Critics Platinum 2008 Merlot California $9.00   Very fresh and supple, with bright fruit and a firm but not astringent structure.  Impressive quality.  A super party wine. - Paul Lukacs                                                     
 Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay California $9.00  Simple but solid, this shows rather shy aromas but nice clean fruit on the palate and good balancing acidity in the finish. - Michael Franz

Banfi
 Critics Silver 2007 Belnero, Toscana IGT Italy $39.00   Short on aromatic impact, but full of delicious flavors and very nicely textured. - Michael Franz
 Critics Gold 2007 Centine Rosso, Toscana IGT Italy $12.00   Packed with character, this shows lots of leathery aroma on top of a dark cherry core, with lots of acidity and tannin to firm up the ripe fruit.  - Michael Franz
 Critics Gold 2008 Centine Rose, Toscana IGT Italy $12.00   Delicate, dry and aromatic Rose ready for summertime. A reason to drink pink. - Leslie Sbrocco
 Critics Silver 2009 Rosa Regale, Brachetto d'Acqui DOCG Italy $24.00   Juicy strawberry fruit. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Silver 2009 San Angelo, Pinot Grigio, Toscano IGT Italy $18.00   Though bright and zesty it still sported a creamy kick on the palate.  - Leslie Sbrocco

Barboursville Vineyards
 Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Franc, Reserve Virginia $23.00  Delicate understated raspberry nose. Medium-bodied but has a sleek texture and fine supporting tannins, with fresh acidity to enliven the finish. Not much depth of flavour or complexity but well made and enjoyable. - Stephen Brook
 Critics Silver 2007 Nebbiolo, Reserve Virginia $32.00   Parmesan rind. Fairly saline, marine, seaweed.  - Patrick Comiskey

Barefoot Bubbly
 Critics Silver NV Moscato Spumante California $11.00   Juicy and full of warm weather fun. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Silver NV Brut Cuvee California $10.00   Really dry and crisp -- refreshing. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Platinum NV Extra Dry California $10.00   Genuinely off-dry but focused and balanced, so not at all cloying or heavy.  A very pretty wine. - Paul Lukacs

Barefoot Cellars
 Critics Gold NV Shiraz California $7.00   Nose like warm blackberries and leather. Juicy texture and very pure fruit flavors. - Elin McCoy
 Critics Gold NV Zinfandel Lodi $7.00   All that Zinfandel can be. Classic and lovely. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Gold NV Pinot Grigio California $7.00   Made in a lush style with rounded mouthfeel, this is a succulent sip packed with ripeness.  - Leslie Sbrocco

Barokes Wines
 Critics Gold NV Cabernet / Shiraz / Merlot, Bin 121 South Eastern Australia $4.00   Bright and fresh, with real character. - Paul Lukacs 
 Critics Silver NV Bubbly Chardonnay / Semillon, Bin 242 South Eastern Australia $4.00   A good everyday quaffer. - Ed McCarthy

Bella Sera
 Critics Gold 2008 Chianti DOCG Italy $7.00   Well-balanced; great with pasta. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Noir, Pavia IGT Italy $7.00   The chalky mineral edge is winning, with straightforward cranberry flavors that make it something to start a meal. - Jon Bonne

Beringer Founders' Estate
 Critics Gold 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon California $11.00   Relatively light but has freshness and vigour, not does it lack concentration. Finely tuned and has staying power on the palate. Good acidity and length. - Stephen Brook
 Critics Silver 2008 Sauvignon Blanc California $11.00   Discreet citric nose. Lean, silky, reasonably concentrated, has some freshness and zest, tangy lemon-drop finish.  - Stephen Brook   

Big Ass
 Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $18.00  A bit tight now, this wine should open with more bottle age to reveal the nicely ripened black fruit. The structure is there now. - Linda Murphy
 Critics Gold 2008 Zinfandel Sonoma County $15.00  Complex and concentrated with blackberry, black plum flavors with a smattering of cedar and wood spice finishing with mellow tannins. - Rebecca Murphy

Big House 
 Critics Platinum 2007 The Lineup GSM Central Coast $12.00  Leads with a leafy, rubber scent accenting black cherry. Deep Grenache and Mourvedre note, flavors are red fruited and lithe. The wine has a lot of juicy intensity, a lot of energy especially in the finish. - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Platinum 2007 The Slammer Syrah Santa Barbara County $12.00   Wow! Syrah at its best. Impressive, complex and full. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Silver 2009 The Birdman Pinot Grigio Monterey $12.00   Simple, light varietal character. - Gerald D. Boyd
 Critics Silver 2008 Red California $22.00   Soft, soothing, with hints of berry fruit. - Marguerite Thomas
 Critics Silver 2009 White California $22.00   Moderately sweet, yet bright and juicy, for those who enjoy a touch of residual sugar in their wines. Serve this one well-chilled, on the patio on a hot summer afternoon. - Linda Murphy

Big Kahuna
 Critics Silver NV Chardonnay South Eastern Australia $2.00 Lots of oak, sweet fruit, medium finish. - Gerald D. Boyd

Biltmore
 Critics Silver 2008 Passport, Reserve Sonoma County $18.00   Pleasantly soft and accessible, this is well balanced and integrated. - Michael Franz
 Critics Silver NV Cardinal's Crest Red American $13.00   Interesting blend. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon, Reserve North Carolina $18.00   Smoky oak notes lead the way here, followed by soft, ripe fruit that finishes a little on the sweet side. - Michael Franz
 Critics Silver NV Sangiovese American $19.00  Plush and generous fruit balanced by zingy acidity. - Nick Passmore
 Critics Silver 2009 Riesling, Estate North Carolina $15.00  Mineral-floral aroma. Brisk, good varietal. - Gerald D. Boyd

Bin 36
 Critics Gold 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon California $16.00  Interesting and complex. Shows appealing elegance and restraint. - Nick Passmore
 Critics Gold 2006 Merlot California $16.00  Cherry with some horehound and cola bean. Good complexity and balance. - W. Blake Gray
 Critics Silver 2006 Syrah Central Coast $16.00   Sweet and spicy. - Paul Lukacs

Bixler Vineyards
 Critics Silver 2008 Union Island White California $15.00   Tart, lemony, crisp and refreshing, with a slight floral note in the background. - W. Blake Gray

Black Swan
 Critics Silver 2009 Merlot South Eastern Australia $8.00  Sweet and lush.  - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Grigio South Eastern Australia $8.00   Juicy fruit flavored paired with a nice ping of lemon/lime freshness.  - Leslie Sbrocco
 Critics Gold 2009 Riesling South Eastern Australia $8.00   Off dry with a clean, zesty minerality. Balanced and bright, it's an ideal summertime sipper. - Leslie Sbrocco

Blackstone Winery
 Critics Silver 2006 Rubric, Sonoma Reserve Sonoma County $23.00   Big and powerful, a  giant of a wine. Lots of chewy tannin.  - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Silver 2007 Merlot, Sonoma Reserve Sonoma County $20.00   Bright zingy red currant and blackberry flavors. - Nick Passmore
 Critics Silver 2007 Pinot Noir, Sonoma Reserve Sonoma County $20.00   This Pinot shows nice depth of flavor and an appealingly spicy finish. - Michael Franz
 Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay, Sonoma Reserve Sonoma County $17.00   Fragrant wine with floral and earthy notes. Well-balanced on the palate, with citrus fruit and a hint of pine needle. - W. Blake Gray

Blufeld
 Critics Silver 2009 Riesling, Medium Sweet Mosel $11.00   Distinctly sweet attack, concentrated, juicy, has weight and even some power. There's grip on the finish too. Imposing rather than elegant. - Stephen Brook

BOHO
 Critics Silver 2008 Old Vine Zinfandel California $22.00   Plum and black cherry, balanced red.  - Patrick Comiskey

Bolla
 Critics Silver 2008 Valpolicella DOC Italy $8.00   Cherry and red currant fruit with a light body and firm tannins - W. Blake Gray

Boro Hills
 Critics Silver 2008 Sauvignon Blanc Marlborough $10.00   Medium fruit, grassy, dry. - Gerald D. Boyd

Bortolomiol
 Critics Silver NV Prior Brut, Prosecco di Valdobbiadene DOC  Italy $15.00   Dry and clean in the finish.  Refreshing. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Silver 2007  Filanda Rose Brut, Millesimato Riserva VSQ Italy $22.00   Delicious. - Ed McCarthy

Bota Box
 Critics Gold 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon California $19.00   Yes! A very good wine. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Silver 2009 Malbec California $19.00   Decent, easy-drinking. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Gold 2008 Merlot California $19.00   Firm tannins and very well-balanced. - Paul Lukacs   
 Critics Silver 2008 Old Vine Zinfandel California $19.00   Decent red, good red cherry fruit, clean. - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Grigio California $19.00   Lightbodied, lively and crisp - a crowd pleaser and everyday sipper. - Linda Murphy

Brancott Vineyards
 Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Noir South Island $13.00   Sweet cherry fruit. - W. Blake Gray
 Critics Gold 2006 Pinot Noir, Reserve Marlborough $21.00   Nice cranberry fruit with a smooth mouth feel. - W. Blake Gray

Brassfield Estate
 Critics Silver 2006 Eruption, Volcano Ridge High Valley    $20.00   Rubbery, lots of oak, chewy, dark, tannic.  - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Gold 2008 Serenity High Valley    $14.00   Floral, mineral, citrusy flavors. Balanced, good blend. - Gerald D. Boyd
 Critics Gold 2007 Pinot Noir, High Serenity Ranch High Valley    $20.00   Complex wine with a long, spicy finish. Balanced fruit and oak notes combine with a supple texture. - Leslie Sbrocco
 Critics Gold 2006 Zinfandel, Round Mountain Volcano High Valley    $20.00   Dense raspberry nose, with a touch of oak. Quite rich and full-bodied, seamless fruit, light tannic backbone but essentially forward and quaffable, with sufficient acidity to give it some zest.  - Stephen Brook
 Critics Silver 2008 Sauvignon Blanc, High Serenity Ranch High Valley    $14.00   Floral lime nose. Medium-bodied but has an attractive texture.  Some gooseberry and grapefruit character on the finish. - Stephen Brook   

Brazin
 Critics Silver 2007 Old Vine Zinfandel Lodi $17.00   Big and bold but not quite obvoius, this Zin shows some meaty, savory character that provides interest along with the ripe, juicy fruit. - Michael Franz
 Critics Gold 2007 Old Vine Zinfandel Dry Creek Valley $19.00   Here is a Zin with structure and enough acidity to temper the ripe fruit. The oak influence is obvious, but it's not obtrusive, and adds texture and a creamy vanillin note. - Linda Murphy

Brokenwood
 Critics Gold 2007 Shiraz Hunter Valley $36.00   Dark and dense and eminently serious from stem to stern, this Shiraz shows impressive depth of flavor and plenty of structure to keep the sheer size of the wine in balance. - Michael Franz
 Critics Silver 2004 Semillon, Oakey Creek Vineyard Hunter Valley $32.00   Mature Semillon aroma, medium fruit, good acidity. - Gerald D. Boyd

Ca' Momi Wines
 Critics Gold 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $18.00  Muted smoky black fruits nose, has subtlety as well as some power. Supple, rounded, juicy, quite concentrated, with good sweetness of fruit and a light structure.  Not for long keeping, but fresh and appealing. - Stephen Brook
 Critics Silver 2007 Zinfandel Napa Valley $15.00  Ripe smoky berry fruit. Plump, lush, rounded, juicy, full-bodied. Well made, balanced, and enjoyable.  - Stephen Brook
 Critics Silver 2008 Muscat California $10.00  Good varietal aroma, medium sweetness and fruit. Good length. - Gerald D. Boyd
 Critics Gold 2009 Chardonnay Napa Valley $15.00  Lush aromatic tropical fruit nose, has weight and richness. Firm and full-bodied, with considerable concentration, its slight sweetness balanced by some acidity and minerality. Long tangy finish. - Stephen Brook   
 Critics Gold 2009 Sauvignon Blanc Napa Valley $15.00   Ripe, fruit-driven style with appealing plumpness on the palate. Succulent.  - Leslie Sbrocco

Cafe by Gallo Family Vineyards
 Critics Silver NV Chardonnay California $6.00   Sweet, pleasant pear and apple fruit. Good balance. Light. - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Silver NV Zinfandel California $6.00   Floral notes and wild strawberry add interest to this very sweet wine. - W. Blake Gray

Cakebread Cellars
 Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $61.00   Oaky nose, big tannins, medium fruit and length. - Gerald D. Boyd
 Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Dancing Bear Ranch Howell Mountain $106.00   Mineral-berry nose, medium palate. Balanced. - Gerald D. Boyd
 Critics Silver 2007 Syrah Carneros $51.00   Persistent cranberry fruit with a hint of pomegranate. - W. Blake Gray
 Critics Silver 2007 Zinfandel Red Hills, Lake County $41.00   Low intensity nose. Sweet fruit, medium tannins, length. - Gerald D. Boyd
 Critics Gold 2008 Chardonnay Napa Valley $37.00   Fresh, appley, good kiss of oak without dominating, clean, direct. - Patrick Comiskey

Callaway Vineyard and Winery
 Critics Silver 2009 Rose of Sangiovese, Special Selection Temecula   $18.00   A rich, round easy-drinking quaffer. - Nick Passmore
 Critics Silver 2009   Late Harvest Cabernet Sauvignon, Winemaker's Reserve Temecula Valley $28.00 Quite delicious. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Gold 2009 Gewurztraminer, Special Selection California $18.00   Brilliant fruit, peach and lichi, syrupy feel to the finish.  - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Silver 2009 Late Harvest Chardonnay, Winemaker's Reserve Temecula Valley $28.00   Tropical aromas and hint of herbs. Flavors rich and fairly powerful. - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Silver 2009 Sauvignon Blanc, Special Selection Temecula   $18.00   Floral-mineral, good fruit, length. - Gerald D. Boyd

Camelot 
 Critics Silver NV Cabernet Sauvignon California $9.00   Smoky, curranty-cassis nose, very refined and lean. Good structure. - Elin McCoy
 Critics Silver NV Merlot California $9.00   Mineral nose, bright berry. Balanced, good length. - Gerald D. Boyd
 Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay California $9.00   Mineral and spice, ripe fruit, medium finish. - Gerald D. Boyd

Cameron Hughes Wine
 Critics Gold 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon, Lot 140 Chalk Hill $16.00   Raspberries and chalk. Bright and carbonic almost. Good bright chewy wine.  - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Lot 146 Diamond Mountain District $22.00   Oak, dark and chewy.  Short and tannic. - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Silver 2007 Pinot Noir, Lot 142 Carneros $18.00   Scents of earth and red cherry. Lean brisk red with sweet red cherry fruit and terse tannins.  - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Gold 2007 Shiraz, Lot 131 McLaren Vale $14.00   Meaty and packed with flavor and substance, this shows lots of sweet fruit but also enough savory character and tannin to achieve a complex profile. - Michael Franz
 Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay, Lot 159 Santa Barbara County $14.00   Good straightforward American white. Balanced, fresh, good weight. - Patrick Comiskey

Campo Viejo
 Critics Silver 2002 Rioja Gran Reserva Spain $21.00   Dense, powerful, intense and modern. - Mary Ewing-Mulligan
 Critics Silver 2005 Rioja Reserva Spain $14.00   A dense, well-knit style, fresh and modern, well-made. - Mary Ewing-Mulligan

Campomaccione
 Critics Gold 2007 Morellino di Scansano DOCG Italy $15.50   Heady aromas and full body on this big, tannic wine. It has marvelous acidity, and likely will be better in two to three years. Promising future. - Linda Murphy

Cape Peak Collection
 Critics Silver 2009 Syrah Rose Western Cape $4.00   Full-bodied for rose, a mouthful of fresh cherry and strawberry flavor. - Mary Ewing-Mulligan
 Critics Silver 2009 Syrah Western Cape $5.00   Soft and savory, an easy drinking wine with black cherry fruit and black pepper spice. - Rebecca Murphy

Carlo Rossi
 Critics Silver NV White Zinfandel, Reserve California $7.00   Interesting herbal notes distinguish this sweet confection. - W. Blake Gray
 Critics Silver NV Merlot, Reserve California $7.00   Soft berry flavors, medium body. - Paul Lukacs                         

Carmel Road Winery
 Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Noir Monterey $20.00   Mineral-earthy nose, sweet fruit. Stylish, good length. - Gerald D. Boyd
 Critics Silver 2006 Pinot Noir Arroyo Seco $33.00   Nice purity of fruit throughout long finish. - W. Blake Gray

Cask & Cream
 Critics Silver NV Original Temptation, Cream Liqueur California $11.00   How delicious. Great way to end a dinner. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Gold NV Chocolate Temptation, Cream Liqueur California $11.00   Rich and sensuous -- a milkshake for grownups. - Paul Lukacs   

Cecchi
 Critics Silver 2008 Chianti DOCG Italy $16.00   Fresh, lively, well-balanced. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Silver 2007 Chianti DOCG Natio Italy $16.00   Impressive genuinely Tuscan bouquet, full of leather and spice. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Platinum 2008 Bonizio, Sangiovese di Maremma IGT Italy $10.00   Keenly  focused and with a tannic structure that promises a long life in the cellar. Hints of graphite and anise add complexity, and I love the minerally finish. Great balance. - Linda Murphy

Cellar No. 8
 Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon California $10.00   Light smoky nose. Quite concentrated and almost earthy, a dense style.  - Stephen Brook
 Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Noir California $10.00   Robust red-fruits aromas, plenty of oak and quite opulent. Rich and broad. Perhaps a bit too fleshy for Pinot and lacking some acidity, but a sumptuous style that will give much pleasure even if purists might criticize its lack of typicity.  - Stephen Brook

Cerulli Spinozzi
 Critics Platinum 2004 Torre Migliori, Montepulciano d'Abruzzo Colline Teramane DOCG Italy $15.00   Real depth of flavor with an earthy, spicy character.  Would be great with tomato-based pasta sauces or pizza. - Paul Lukacs    

Champagne Henriot
 Critics Gold NV Rose Brut Reims $65.00    Bright berry flavor enhanced by citrus and a hint of toast. - Paul Lukacs

Chateau Calage
 Critics Platinum 2007 La Mejanelle Languegoc $8.00   Dark, a little smoky. Silky black fruit, deep and fluid, good weight, fairly powerful. - Patrick Comiskey

Chateau Frank
 Critics Silver 1999 Brut, Prestige Cuvee Finger Lakes $30.00   Rich. - Ed McCarthy

Chateau Grand Traverse
 Critics Silver 2008 Ship of Fools White Table Wine Old Mission Peninsula $16.00   Baked apple aromas, round peachy, apple flavors.  - Rebecca Murphy
 Critics Silver 2008 Dry Riesling Old Mission Peninsula $13.00   Inviting orange blossom aromas and flavors, this is an easy-going, juicy Riesling that is a pleasure to drink. - Linda Murphy

Chateau Ste. Michelle
 Critics Platinum 2006 Meritage, Artist Series Columbia Valley $50.00   Muscular, intense and very young, it has the stuffing to age for 10 years or more. Dense black fruit, some savory notes, creamy vanillin and ideal, refreshing acidity. - Linda Murphy
 Critics Silver 2006 Merlot, Canoe Ridge Estate Horse Heaven Hills $28.00   Soft and simple but very tasty, this shows lots of juicy plum and dark cherry fruit and soft structure in the finish. - Michael Franz
 Wine of the Year 2009 Dry Riesling Columbia Valley $9.00   This wine shows lovely balance between its freshly sweet floral aromas and peachy flavors and an energetic streak of citrus acidity that lifts the fruit and drives the finish.  Excellent fruit rendered with real style and structure. - Michael Franz
 Critics Silver 2008 Eroica Riesling Columbia Valley $24.00   Mineral-citrus aroma. Sweet fruit, good length. - Gerald D. Boyd

Clean Slate
 Critics Platinum 2009 Riesling Mosel $11.00   Powerful focused. Sings to the Heavens, glorious harmony of sweet and crisp fruit flavors. - Nick Passmore

Cline Cellars
 Critics Silver 2008 Cashmere California $16.00   Flavors of brett and dark plum notes. Sweet finish. - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Silver 2008 Mourvedre, Ancient Vines Contra Costa County $16.00   Sweet spicy fruit with a soft texture.  - Paul Lukacs                                                       
 Critics Gold 2009 Viognier North Coast $12.00   Peach and mineral, sweet and a little phenolic on the finish. - Patrick Comiskey

Clos Du Bois
 Critics Platinum 2005 Marlstone Alexander Valley $50.00   Sweet and ripe, but with a nice spicy, meaty character as well, this shows very nice depth of flavor and an enduring finish that is enhanced by the very subtle oak that leaves the concentrated fruit in the forefront. - Michael Franz
 Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Reserve Alexander Valley $22.00   A dusty, curious edge to brambly dark fruit. Solid, lavish and satisfying. - Jon Bonne
 Critics Gold 2005 Briarcrest Cabernet Sauvignon Alexander Valley $42.00   Assertive and robust, a take-no-prisoners cab. - Nick Passmore
 Critics Platinum 2007 Pinot Noir North Coast $20.00   Beautifully balanced, with ripe fruit, firm structure, supple tannins and ideal acidity. The finish lingers with true Pinot flavors. - Linda Murphy
 Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay North Coast $15.00   Soft vanilla, pear flavors with roused by mouthwatering acidity. It lingers on the tongue and in the memory. - Rebecca Murphy
 Critics Silver 2007 Calcaire-Chardonny Russian River Valley $25.00   Rich wine with solid fruit. - W. Blake Gray

Cocca Di Papa
 Critics Platinum 2008 Chianti DOCG Italy $12.00   Well-balanced; classic; well done. - Ed McCarthy

Columbia Crest
 Critics Gold 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon Horse Heaven Hills $15.00   Concentrated and full of flavor, this is thankfully oaked in a subtle way, leaving the dark cherry and blackberry fruit free to shine. - Michael Franz
 Critics Silver 2007 Merlot Horse Heaven Hills $15.00   Juicy and ripe and full of tasty fruit, this might not show enough acidity or tannin for the masochist set, but it will surely provide a lot of pleasure for hedonists. - Michael Franz
 Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay Horse Heaven Hills $15.00   Light apple-pear, dry, delicate, low intensity oak. - Gerald D. Boyd

Concannon Vineyard
 Critics Silver 2007 Merlot, Selected Vineyard Central Coast $10.00   Dark cherry with notes of slate. The nose is herbaceous but this doesn't carry to the palate. - W. Blake Gray
 Critics Silver 2007 Merlot, Conservancy Livermore Valley $14.00   Cherry fruit with a hint of dark chocolate. - W. Blake Gray
 Critics Gold 2007 Petite Sirah, Selected Vineyard Central Coast $10.00   Well-balanced wine with blackberry and black currant fruit and a firm body. - W. Blake Gray
 Critics Gold 2007 Petite Sirah, Conservancy Livermore Valley $14.00   Intense, concentrated with a solid structure highlighted by deep, black fruit that flirts with wisps of lavender. Needs a juicy, rare steak.  - Rebecca Murphy
 Critics Gold 2007 Shiraz, Selected Vineyard Central Coast $10.00   Medium weight but full of flavor -- and not just fruit. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay, Conservancy Livermore Valley $14.00   Ripe and rounded, but still with some shape and focus thanks to balancing acidity in the finish. - Michael Franz
 Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Grigio, Selected Vineyard Central Coast $10.00   Mineral, floral, dry, citrus peel, short finish. - Gerald D. Boyd

Cook's
 Critics Gold NV Spumante California $7.00   Juicy and bright.  Just plain fun. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Silver NV Brut California $7.00   Quite delicious. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Gold NV Grand Reserve California $7.00   Full, rich, and round. - Ed McCarthy

Copa Del Rey
 Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay Rapel Valley $12.00   Rich, full-bodied wine with nice lemon fruit and notes of vanilla. Well-made for this style. - W. Blake Gray

Coyote Creek
 Critics Silver 2008 Merlot California $8.00   Very juicy and soft, this might not be substantial or structured enough for everyone's taste, but it will appeal to many on the strength of its open, fruity character. - Michael Franz

Crooked Vine
 Critics Gold 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon, Estate Grown Livermore Valley $32.00   Soft and sexy but sneaky in its power and depth of flavor, this shows lots of appeal. - Michael Franz
 Critics Silver 2007 Petite Sirah, Estate Grown Livermore Valley $34.00   Bold, intense, with pepper and licorice flavors. Ideal wine for steak.  - Elin McCoy
 Critics Platinum 2007 Syrah, Del Arroyo Vineyards, Estate Grown Livermore Valley $30.00   Intense cherry fruit with notes of licorice, slate, cocoa powder and charcoal - W. Blake Gray

Crossing Vineyards And Winery
 Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Franc Pennsylvania $22.00   Ripe but slightly porty nose. Soft, juicy, rounded, could as easily be Merlot as Cab Franc, but nonetheless an enjoyable wine with ample fruit and weight. - Stephen Brook
 Critics Silver 2007 Merlot Pennsylvania $20.00   Earthy-mineral nose.  Cherry-berry flavors, dry finish. - Gerald D. Boyd

Cumbre
 Critics Silver 2007 Pinot Noir, Raffaelli Vineyard Santa Cruz Mountains $59.00   A mouthful of powerful mountain Pinot! - Robert Whitley
 Critics Gold 2007 Pinot Noir, Hicks Family Vineyard Santa Cruz Mountains $59.00   Sweet. Ripe, succulent black cherry fruit. A real crowd pleaser. - Robert Whitley

Cupcake
 Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon Central Coast $14.00   Olives and black currant flavors frolic with mellow tannins in this smooth drinking wine.  - Rebecca Murphy
 Critics Gold 2007 Merlot Central Coast $14.00   Sweet cherry fruit that finishes with food-friendly acidity - W. Blake Gray
 Critics Silver 2008 Shiraz Barossa Valley $14.00   Discreet nose with stylish plummy fruit. Medium-bodied, no blockbuster, but a wine with some finesse though not at the expense of fruit ripeness. Long peppery finish. - Stephen Brook
 Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay Central Coast $14.00   A rich, generous Chardonnay that stays in focus on the strength of some spiciness and a little dash of acidity that lifts and firms the finish. - Michael Franz
 Critics Silver 2009 Riesling Columbia Valley $14.00   A plump mouthful of ripe pear and citrus fruit, with subtle sweetness and a pleasantly bitter bite on the finish. People will love this wine. - Linda Murphy
 Critics Silver 2009 Riesling Mosel $14.00   Jazzy, bright, tropical fruit.  - Elin McCoy
 Critics Platinum 2009 Sauvignon Blanc Marlborough $14.00   A seriously intense, energetic Sauvignon Blanc that never quite proves overbearing in its intensity.  With lovely dried herb aromas and terrific acidity that is beautifully tuned to the ripe fruit, this is a great case in point of a wine with very energetic components that are almost perfectly counterbalanced against one another. - Michael Franz

Curtis Winery
 Critics Silver 2006 Heritage Cuvee Santa Barbara County $20.00   Sweet and milky notes, chewy and dark.  - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Platinum 2008 Heritage Blanc Central Coast $18.00   Slight parsley like note, and golden apple. Lean, fresh, persistent, savory, nice sweetness and firm acids. Apple skin on the finish. Fresh and floral finish. - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Silver 2006 Syrah, Ambassador's Vineyard Santa Ynez Valley $22.00   Densely packed, hints of mocha and dark savory notes. - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Gold 2006 Syrah, Crossroads Vineyard Santa Ynez Valley $32.00   Dark and chewy. Graham cracker. Bright plum and dark. Nice well balanced red with direct notes of black cherry and dark leathery bottom note.  - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Gold 2006 Syrah, Rock Hollow Vineyard Santa Ynez Valley $38.00   Milk chocolate and black fruits. Has a smoky, meaty note, and concentrated flavors of plum and milk chocolate. - Patrick Comiskey

Cycles Gladiator
 Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon California $10.00   Perfumey, with clove and violet notes on the nose. Blackberry fruit. Chewy tannins. - W. Blake Gray
 Critics Gold 2008 Syrah California $10.00   Deeply flavored, perfect with rich barbecue. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Gold 2008 Chardonnay California $10.00   Full of flavor and quite generous in style, this nevertheless shows nice freshness and finishes with plenty of bright acidity to maintain its balance. - Michael Franz

D & S
 Critics Silver 2007 Proprietary Red California $22.00   Sleek and furry, dark plum and hint of olive. - Patrick Comiskey

D'Arenberg
 Critics Silver 2007 Ironstone Pressings McLaren Vale $65.00   Root beer and black plum. Black cherry, chewy and dark. - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Gold 2006 The Sticks and Stones McLaren Vale $35.00   A big wine with cedar, lemon oil aromas, black fruit balanced with acidity and finishing with sturdy tannins. Needs a steak, but definitely yummy. - Rebecca Murphy
 Critics Gold 2007 Coppermine Road Cabernet Sauvignon McLaren Vale $65.00   Smells and tastes of cool-climate growing conditions, with gentle herbs and mint accompanying the black cherry and cedar character. It's classic, old-school Cabernet, in need of service with food.  - Linda Murphy
 Critics Platinum 2007 The Footbolt Shiraz McLaren Vale $19.00   Loads of licorice, tar and black pepper to go with the mulberry fruit. The nose hints at roasted game, and the finish is pure and lingering. - Linda Murphy
 Critics Gold 2007 The Dead Arm Shiraz McLaren Vale $65.00   Packed with juicy, open berry fruit but still serious by dint of fresh acidity and lots of fine-grained tannin. - Michael Franz
 Critics Gold 2007 The Laughing Magpie, Shiraz / Viognier McLaren Vale $29.00    Stylish oaky black fruits nose. Medium-bodied, very ripe and sleek, concentrated and bright, with ample ripe tannins. Spicy and long. - Stephen Brook

Darcie Kent
 Critics Silver 2007 Merlot, Crown Block Livermore Valley $32.00   Cherry fruit that sweetens slightly on finish. - W. Blake Gray
 Critics Gold 2007 Merlot, Picazo Vineyard Livermore Valley $30.00   Intense cherry fruit that persists. Tannins come in on finish to give it presence. - W. Blake Gray
 Critics Silver 2007 Zinfandel, DeMayo Vineyard Livermore Valley $30.00   Dark cherry fruit with some presence in the mouth. - W. Blake Gray
 Critics Gold 2009 Gruner Veltliner, Rava Blackjack Vineyard Monterey $18.00   Sweet but undeniably tasty, this Gruner is fresh and spicy and full of flavor and fun.  Please, let this wine be a harbinger of others of its kind from the New World! - Michael Franz
 Critics Silver 2009 Sauvignon Blanc, Rava Blackjack Vineyard Monterey $18.00   Juicy melon-like fruit. - Paul Lukacs

David Bruce Winery
 Critics Gold 2007 Pinot Noir Russian River Valley $30.00   Low intensity cherry-berry, bright fruity, balanced. - Gerald D. Boyd
 Critics Silver 2007 Pinot Noir Anderson Valley $42.00   Good Pinot Noir aromas. Medium fruit, dry, length. - Gerald D. Boyd

David Girard Vineyard
 Critics Gold 2008 Mourvedre, Estate Vineyard El Dorado $28.00   Good grip, lively. Pleasant finish. - Ed McCarthy

Davis Bynum Winery
 Critics Silver 2007 Pinot Noir Russian River Valley $35.00   Intense cherry fruit. - W. Blake Gray
 Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay Russian River Valley $25.00   Crisp and clean, with mouthwatering acidity. It's not terribly complex, yet it delivers quality and enjoyment. - Linda Murphy

Debonne Vineyards
 Critics Silver 2008 Riesling Lot 807, Reserve Grand River Valley $15.00   Juicy and ripe, with peach and flower taste and succulent balance of sweetness and acidity. Summer afternoon sipper. - Elin McCoy
 Critics Silver 2009 Riesling, Reserve Grand River Valley $12.00   Very light aromatics and flavors.  Light finish and fruit. - Gerald D. Boyd

Deep Sea
 Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Noir Santa Rita Hills $45.00   Very soft and sweet, this shows no hard edges and will be a crowd pleaser. - Michael Franz
 Critics Gold 2008 Chardonnay Santa Barbara County $28.00   Lemon fruit with floral notes and nice balance. - W. Blake Gray

Diamond Ridge Vineyards
 Critics Silver 2007 Aspects Lake County $28.00   Lead pencil, nice fruity finish. - Marguerite Thomas
 Critics Silver 2007 2 Jakes of Diamonds California $14.00   Bordeaux, with a touch of Petite Sirah.  - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Silver 2008 Petite Sirah Lake County $18.00   Dark earthy, a good petite syrah.  - Elin McCoy

Domaine Carneros
 Critics Gold 2007 Pinot Noir, Estate Carneros $35.00   Soft, supple and inviting. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Noir, Avant-Garde Carneros $24.00   Sweet vanilla and a soft texture. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Gold 2006 Pinot Noir, The Famous Gate, Estate Carneros $68.00   Bright cranberry and cherry fruit, with good balance and structure.  - Paul Lukacs

Domaine Carneros by Tattinger
 Critics Gold 2006 Brut  Carneros $26.00   Complete. Full and rich. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Silver NV Cuvee de la Pompadour, Brut Rose Carneros $36.00   Clean and fresh, with a bright character. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Gold 2004 Le Reve, Blanc de Blancs Carneros $85.00   Genuine depth of flavor, and very citrus-like. - Paul Lukacs

Domaine Laurier
 Critics Platinum 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon, Reserve Sonoma County $11.00   Satisfyingly complete and complex. Full of deep dark fruit flavor with echoes of chocolate and mocha in the finish.  Yum! - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Silver 2007 Merlot, Reserve Sonoma County $11.00   Sweet cherry and raspberry fruit -- soft and supple. - Paul Lukacs      
 Critics Silver NV Brut California $10.00   Rich, easy-drinking. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay, Reserve Sonoma County $11.00   Ripe and tropical, with pretty lime highlights to lift it. It's got great energy and hearty, big tree fruit flavors that give it appeal. - Jon Bonne

Domaine Ste. Michelle
 Critics Silver NV Blanc de Blancs Columbia Valley $13.00   Juicy apple fruit flavor. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Platinum NV Blanc de Noirs Columbia Valley $13.00   Excellent balance, with everything in near perfect focus.   - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Gold NV Brut Columbia Valley $13.00   Both fresh and full, with nuanced flavors and a refreshing finish. - Paul Lukacs

Domenico Wines
 Critics Platinum 2006 Aglianico Amador County $30.00   An eloquent wine speaking of salty seas and herb-covered hillsides. Tight and structured in the mouth with cherry, anise flavors and polished tannins. - Rebecca Murphy

Dr. Konstantin Frank Wine Cellars
 Critics Silver 2008 Rkatsiteli Finger Lakes $18.00   Floral, spicy, crisp acidity, good length. - Gerald D. Boyd
 Critics Silver 2008 Dry Riesling Finger Lakes $15.00   Clean and correct in a subtle style that is dry and difficult to pull off without overt sweetness to buffer acidity and hide flaws, this is an admirable winemaking--and winegrowing--performance. - Michael Franz
 Critics Silver 2009 Semi-Dry Riesling Finger Lakes $15.00   Some stone and petrol, with vibrant lime edges to ripe apple and peach fruit. Subtle, with lots of brightness to match the mildly sweet profile. - Jon Bonne

Dry Creek Vineyard
 Best of Class Blended Red Bordeaux 2006 The Mariner Dry Creek Valley $40.00   This shows a lot of firmness from oak in the finish, but also impressive depth of fruit that keeps the balance appealing.  The tannins are fine-grained and well weighted to the sweet, deeply flavored fruit, making this enjoyable now but also quite promising in terms of potential for future development. - Michael Franz
 Critics Platinum 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon Dry Creek Valley $25.00   Intense, saturated flavors of ripe fruit combine with vibrant finish. It's a Cabernet Sauvignon that pleases every part of your palate.  - Leslie Sbrocco
 Critics Silver 2007 Heritage Zinfandel Sonoma County $19.00   Well-balanced.  A very nice Zinfandel. - Ed McCarthy

Drytown Cellars
 Critics Platinum 2008 Cabernet Franc Amador County $18.00   Bright raspberry nose, with all the freshness and prettiness of Cab Franc. Medium-bodied but fresh, ripe, and balanced, with nicely judged tannin and no excesses. There's ample spice and zest on the finish. A well made wine that can't fail to give pleasure. - Stephen Brook
 Critics Silver 2007 Primitivo Amador County $18.00   Dark plum scents. Flavors are dark and deep fig and cherry fruit leather. Chunky ripe tannins. - Patrick Comiskey

Dutcher Crossing Winery
 Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon, Proprietor's Reserve Dry Creek Valley $29.00   Flavorful and nicely structured, this Cab shows good integration and will show well with many moderately robust meat dishes. - Michael Franz
 Critics Gold 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Taylor Reserve Dry Creek Valley $43.00   Dark and seriously extracted, this shows lots of depth and intensity. - Michael Franz
 Critics Gold 2008 Zinfandel, Maple Vineyard Dry Creek Valley $40.00   This shows lots of muscle and depth, with dark, deeply flavored fruit backed up by spicy oak that provides welcome firmness and focus in the finish. - Michael Franz
 Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay, Stuhlmuller Vineyard Alexander Valley $34.00   Good nose. Some spice, medium fruit. Balanced. - Gerald D. Boyd

Eberle Winery
 Critics Gold 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon / Syrah Paso Robles $29.00   Racy and zesty core that ís wrapped in a blanket of textural softness. It's a wine for pre-dinner sipping and tableside.  - Leslie Sbrocco
 Critics Silver NV Full Boar Red Paso Robles $15.00   Ripe blueberry pie filling with thick tannins and just enough acidity to keep it from being cloying. - W. Blake Gray
 Critics Gold 2009 Cotes-du-Robles Blanc Paso Robles $24.00   Very leesy and dark. Caramel, pineapple. Nice pretty Chardonnay-like palate. - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Gold 2009 Syrah Rose, Steinbeck Vineyard Paso Robles $17.00   Serious, full bodied Rose ready for meat lovers. With a touch of tannic grip, pair alongside BBQ ribs.  - Leslie Sbrocco
 Critics Gold 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon, Estate Paso Robles $34.00   Complex, dry. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Platinum 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon, Vineyard Selection Paso Robles $19.00   Superb depth of flavor!  A deliciously compelling wine. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Platinum 2008 Sangiovese Paso Robles $23.00   Luminescent with Sangiovese's bright earthy fruit. Balance, depth and perfect harmony. - Nick Passmore
 Critics Silver 2007 Syrah, Steinbeck Vineyard Paso Robles $21.00   French oak, big fruit and tannins. Long dry finish, some heat. - Gerald D. Boyd
 Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay, Estate Paso Robles $19.00   Stylish apricot nose with some well-judged toasty oak. Good attack, juicy and concentrated. - Stephen Brook   

Eddy Family Wines
 Critics Silver 2006 Elodian Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $18.00   Good firm cedary red. Fairly generous and dark. - Patrick Comiskey

Emiliana
 Critics Gold 2008 Carmenere, Natura Valle Central $11.00   Firm black cherry nose, lightly herbaceous, and with a touch of oak. Supple, juicy, with ample fresh acidity, lively, and with a long peppery finish. A good wine with charcuterie! - Stephen Brook
 Critics Gold 2009 Chardonnay, Natura Valle Casablanca $11.00   Discreet apricot and apple nose. Lean, good attack, brisk and lively, has some freshness and zest. Not a complex wine but well balanced and highly drinkable. - Stephen Brook   

Erath Winery
 Critics Gold 2008 Pinot Gris Oregon $14.00   Lemon fruit with a round mouth feel and long finish. - W. Blake Gray

Estancia 
 Critics Platinum 2007 Meritage, Reserve Paso Robles $30.00   The definition of balance! Fruit ripeness, tannins and acidity meld seamlessly together. The wine is fresh-tasting without being light, and secondary notes of chocolate, barrel spice and espresso complete the package. - Linda Murphy
 Critics Silver 2007 Merlot, Keyes Canyon Ranches Central Coast $12.00   Punchy and assertive, no wimpy merlot here. - Nick Passmore
 Critics Gold 2008 Pinot Noir, Pinnacles Ranches Monterey County $16.00   Soft and sweet and sexy, this Pinot shows attractive aromas and juicy, pure fruit with vivid notes of red and black cherries. - Michael Franz
 Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay, Pinnacles Ranches Monterey County $12.00   Lemon fruit with a floral note. - W. Blake Gray

Falkner Winery
 Critics Gold 2006 Meritage, Special Selection Temecula Valley $40.00   Very aromatic, with forest floor, cedar and vibrant black fruit nose. The palate is equally energetic, with succulence and fine-grained tannins. Beautiful integration.  - Linda Murphy
 Critics Platinum 2006 Syrah, Rock Creek Vineyard Temecula Valley $27.00   Rich and satisfying, with coffee and chocolate nuances that give the wine complexity and gain force in the finish. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Platinum 2009 Sauvignon Blanc, Estate Grown Temecula Valley $19.00   Classic, lime zest, grapefruit, grassy aromas with crisp, clean and refreshing flavors animated by snappy acidity. - Rebecca Murphy

Fallbrook Winery
 Critics Silver 2008 Malbec, 33D North, Gracie Hill Vineyard, Estate Grown South Coast $30.00   A heavy overlay of oak gives way to a solid mix of berry fruit. - Jon Bonne
 Critics Gold 2008 Syrah, 33D North, Gracie Hill Vineyard, Estate Grown South Coast $30.00   Refreshingly dry. Complex. - Ed McCarthy

Fat Bastard
 Critics Gold 2009 Rose, Vin De Pays d'Oc France $10.00   A fruit bowl of flavor, this Rose is dry and simply delicious. - Leslie Sbrocco
 Critics Gold 2008 Pinot Noir, Vin De Pays France $11.00   Quite fine; dry finish. - Ed McCarthy

Fat Monk
 Critics Gold 2007 Merlot Central Coast $10.00   Chewy, slight earthiness. Supple. Good length.  Gorgeous nose, nice balance of fruit and earth flavors .  Great buy! - Michael Apstein
 Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay Central Coast $10.00   A pretty wine with floral notes and a gentle mouth feel. - W. Blake Gray

Faustino I 
 Critics Gold 1998 Rioja Gran Reserva Spain $36.00   Not powerful or concentrated, but gentle and beautifully balanced. - Mary Ewing-Mulligan

Fenestra Winery
 Critics Silver 2006 Tourvanillo, Silvaspoons Vineyards, Reserve Lodi $28.00   Plush and juicy, with vibrant red fruits. It's not complicated, yet rewarding. - Linda Murphy
 Critics Silver 2007 Mourvedre, Estate Livermore Valley $25.00   An attractive earthiness lurks beneath the ripe cherry-scented fruit. - Paul Lukacs 
 Critics Gold 2007 Petite Sirah, Ghielmetti Vineyard Livermore Valley $25.00   Oak and fruit, lush, balanced tannins, no heat. - Gerald D. Boyd

Feudi Di San Gregorio
 Critics Silver 2008 Sannio Falanghina DOC Italy $16.00   Bright fruity aroma, good texture, length. - Gerald D. Boyd

Fire Station Red
 Critics Silver 2007 Engine Company 5 Red Wine Mendocino $14.00   Pleasant; well-balanced. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon, Vintage Engine Collection Mendocino $15.00   Intense herbal and cassis. Dark plum and cassis, chunky tannins, sweet middle palate.  - Patrick Comiskey

Flora Springs Winery
 Critics Gold 2007 Trilogy Napa Valley $65.00   Very complex and engagingly earthy, this is tinged with brettanomyces, and won't be to everyone's taste, but I found it filled with appealing character and enduring interest. - Michael Franz
 Critics Platinum 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $36.00   Ripe firm oaky nose, with strong black currant and blackberry aromas. Rich and very ripe, but with ample tannic backbone. A wine of considerable power, but enlivened by spice and decent acidity. Long toasty finish. Impressive, balanced, and stylish. - Stephen Brook
 Critics Platinum 2008 Chardonnay, Barrel Fermented Napa Valley $30.00   A Chardonnay that plays all the angles and does it well. Oak? Check. Ripe fruit? Check. Acidity? Check. Balanced? You bet.  - Leslie Sbrocco
 Critics Gold 2008 Sauvignon Blanc, Soliloquy Vineyard Oakville $20.00   Genuine varietal flavor in a creamy, rich package. - Paul Lukacs

Flying Winemaker
 Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay Santa Barbara County $14.00   Buxom blonde and perfumey. - Marguerite Thomas

Folie A Deux Winery
 Critics Silver 2008 Merlot Napa Valley $24.00   Red cherry and plum. focused, fine-textured, brisk. - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Silver 2007 Zinfandel Amador County $18.00   Big and sweet, red cherry and plum. - Patrick Comiskey

Fontana Candida
 Critics Silver 2008 Frascati Superiore DOC Italy $10.00   Low intensity earthy-herbal, dry medium fruit. - Gerald D. Boyd

Forest Glen
 Critics Gold 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon California $12.00   Sweet and satisfying. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Gold 2009 Pinot Grigio, Tehachapi Clone California $12.00   Fresh, clean and bright, a Pinot Grigio that brings sunshine to the glass.   - Leslie Sbrocco

Frank Family Vineyards
 Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $45.00   Toasted oak, medium varietal flavors. Good length and fruit. - Gerald D. Boyd
 Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Noir Carneros $35.00   Sweet and lush on the palate. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Silver 2007 Zinfandel Napa Valley $36.75   Fine tannin nose, elegance even. Briary.  I like this.  - Elin McCoy

Fresno State Winery
 Critics Silver 2006 Syrah, Sanez Vineyard California $23.00   A stalwart syrah with light herbal notes and hints of black pepper, smooth black fruit and chewy tannins.  - Rebecca Murphy
 Critics Silver 2009 Sauvignon Blanc, Duarte Linden Hills Vineyard San Joaquin County $10.00   A fresh, lively example of dry Sauvignon with clean fruit and a pleasant finish. - Michael Franz

Fulkerson Winery
 Critics Platinum 2008 Dry Riesling Finger Lakes $13.00   Lots of energy and vibrance in this wine. It's shy in aroma, yet has a sturdy backbone and attractive flinty minerality. Scintillating. - Linda Murphy

G.H. Mumm
 Critics Platinum NV Mumm de Cramant Champagne $75.00   Deep toasty flavors in a full-bodied, intense Champagne style.  A food wine more than an aperitif wine. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Gold NV Cordon Rouge Champagne $40.00   Beautiful balance and very impressive length. - Paul Lukacs

Gabbiano
 Critics Gold 2007 Chianti Classico DOCG Italy $12.00   Superb aromatics!  Earthy, dusty, and full of spice, with dark cherry fruit underneath.  The wine is extremely well-structured, suggesting a long life. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Silver 2005 Chianti Classico Riserva DOCG Italy $22.00   Shows definite oak influence but has lovely cheery, floral character and a delicacy of style. - Mary Ewing-Mulligan

Gallo Family Vineyards
 Critics Silver NV White Zinfandel California $5.00   Like drinking strawberry juice. - W. Blake Gray
 Critics Platinum NV Chardonnay California $5.00   Fine, delicate and restrained, a connoisseur's Chardonnay. - Nick Passmore

Genesis
 Critics Gold 2007 Meritage Columbia Valley $16.00   Ripe and fruity, but with some restraint as well, this is showing some emerging complexities that make it seem enduringly interesting. - Michael Franz
 Critics Gold 2008 Chardonnay Columbia Valley $16.00   Light, crisp apple, citrus flavors and tangy acidity. No oak was harmed in the making of this wine. - Rebecca Murphy
 Critics Silver 2008 Riesling Columbia Valley $16.00   Touch of petrol, medium fruit, good balance and length. - Gerald D. Boyd
 Critics Gold 2008 Viognier Columbia Valley $16.00   Sort of a Roussanne-like nose and palate. Good presence, focus. - Patrick Comiskey

Girard Winery 
 Best of Show Red 2007 Petite Sirah Napa Valley $28.00   Opaque red. Sweet ripe blackberry-jam nose. Rich, broad, fleshy, full-bodied and weighty without being too heavy. Tannic, of course, but not excessive. Plenty of extract, spice, and acidity, and good length. - Stephen Brook

Gloria Ferrer
 Critics Silver 2006 Pinot Noir, Estate Grown Carneros $28.00   Attractive fruit and earth flavors. Nice sweet fruit finish. - Elin McCoy
 Critics Silver 2005 Pinot Noir, Jose S. Ferrer Selection Carneros $35.00   Medium cherry-berry aroma, light delicate fruit. - Gerald D. Boyd
 Critics Silver 2005 Pinot Noir, Rust Rock Terrace, Vineyard Designate Carneros $40.00   Oaky nose, medium palate/fruit, length, little heat. - Gerald D. Boyd
 Critics Silver 2006 Pinot Noir, Gravel Knob, Vineyard Designate Carneros $40.00   Ripe sweet fruit. Pleasant. - Elin McCoy
 Critics Silver 2005 Blanc de Blancs Carneros $24.00   Very fine. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Gold NV Blanc de Noirs Carneros $20.00   Juicy red berry fruit with a clean, fresh finish. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Gold NV Brut Sonoma County $20.00   Nutty secondary aromas and flavors supporting citrus and apple primary ones -- a complete wine. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Platinum 2002 Royal Cuvee Carneros $35.00   A biscuit-like, baked brioche bouquet enhances a clean, crisp, and very long wine, with real complexity.  Extremely compelling! - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Silver NV Va de Vi, Ultra Cuvee Sonoma County $22.00   Juicy and fun. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Silver 1999 Carneros Cuvee Carneros $50.00   Sweet juicy fruit flavor. - Paul Lukacs

Gnarly Head
 Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon California $11.00   Smoky oak, medium-full flavors, fresh berry. - Gerald D. Boyd
 Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Noir California $11.00   Dark, savory, strawberries and sleek. Low acid, not particularly fresh but complete.  - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Platinum 2008 Old Vine Zinfandel Lodi $11.00   Has classic briar and black pepper character on the nose and palate. The fruit is very ripe, as is typical with Zin, yet it's balanced by firm acidity and ripe tannins. - Linda Murphy

Godwin Family Vineyards
 Critics Gold 2004 Merlot Sonoma Valley $35.00   Mocha, carob.  - Patrick Comiskey

Grizzly Republic
 Critics Platinum 2007 Tempranillo El Dorado $35.00   Well-done, in a modern style. - Ed McCarthy

Hacienda Altavina
 Critics Silver 2009 Carmenere Central Valley $5.00   No hard edges on this plush, soft red. Food-friendly vibrant fruit makes it an top table pick.  - Leslie Sbrocco

Hagafen
 Critics Platinum 2007 Cabernet Franc Napa Valley $36.00   Delicate aromas of rose petal and plum with elegant character and whispers of complexity. Like a classy woman with a twinkle in her eye.  - Leslie Sbrocco
 Critics Silver 2007 Merlot Napa Valley $32.00   Fresh ripe nose, has charm and some zest. Supple and juicy, rounded, yet has some tannin and grip on the finish. Needs a little more bottle age to soften the tannins. - Stephen Brook

Hahn Winery
 Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon Central Coast $12.00   An interesting wine with strong savory notes of bacon and smoked ham - W. Blake Gray

Handley Cellars
 Critics Gold 2007 Pinot Noir Anderson Valley $30.00   Scents of sweet raspberry. Flavors are milky and soft, berry melange. Plump and generous. - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Gold 2006 Brut Rose, Estate Anderson Valley $40.00   Lovely, delicate, subtle. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay, Handley Vineyard Dry Creek Valley $20.00   Savory style, slightly caramelly, dark.  - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Gris Anderson Valley $18.00   Intense citrus fruit with presence. Some earthiness adds interest. - W. Blake Gray

Harlow Ridge Winery
 Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon Lodi $9.00   Sweet and ripe. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Gold 2009 Pinot Noir Lodi $9.00   Rich fruit balanced by generous strawberry freshness. - Nick Passmore

Harthill Farms
 Critics Gold NV Chardonnay California $4.00   A balanced, moderated Chardonnay that offers tropical fruit, creamy vanillin, crisp acidity and a palate-cleansing finish. Fine balance. - Linda Murphy

Hayman & Hill
 Critics Gold 2008 Pinot Noir, Reserve Selection Santa Lucia Highlands $18.00   Lush, smooth texture, with suppleness consumers expect of Pinot Noir. Long, refreshing finish. - Linda Murphy
 Critics Gold 2008 Chardonnay, Reserve Selection Russian River Valley $15.00   Lemon fruit with an interesting earthy note. Good balance and a nice mouth feel. - W. Blake Gray

Hazlitt 1852 Vineyard
 Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Franc Finger Lakes $22.00   Medium-bodied, sleek, silky, has more texture than flavour, but pleasant and fresh and highly drinkable, with delicate acidity on the finish. - Stephen Brook
 Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay Finger Lakes $11.00   Flavorful with ripe pear and apple flavors and whisper of oakiness. Try alongside grilled salmon topped with pineapple salsa.  - Leslie Sbrocco
 Critics Gold 2008 Gewurztraminer Finger Lakes $15.00   Weighty spice and orange, with a powerful stony note that grounds it. Ripe and bold, and with a warm brown-spice edge to the finish. - Jon Bonne
 Critics Gold 2008 Vidal Blanc Ice Wine Finger Lakes $40.00   Pleasantly sweet and with balancing acidity. Not complex, but fresh and juicy. It doesn't try to be more than it is, and I love it for that. - Linda Murphy
 Critics Silver 2008 Riesling, Homestead Reserve Finger Lakes $18.00   Although this could be a bit more sharply defined, it shows winning aromas and flavors that counterbalance the light sweetness of the finish. - Michael Franz

Hearthstone Vineyard
 Critics Gold 2007 Lodestone Paso Robles $30.00   Black cherry, granular and dark. Finish is surprisingly long.  - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Gold 2007 Pearl Paso Robles $22.00   Quince and lemon curd. Sweet and direct,  fleshy, peachy tropical note. Impressive length and weight. - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Silver 2007 Grenache Paso Robles $28.00   Sweet cherry fruit that lingers on palate. - W. Blake Gray

Helfrich
 Critics Silver 2007 Riesling Alsace $15.00    The petrol aroma is pleasant and not overpowering, as this characteristic can be. The palate delivers well-ripened pear and apricot fruit, with a moderately acidic finish. - Linda Murphy
 Critics Silver 2006 Riesling, Steinklotz, Alsace Grand Cru France $25.00    Packed with minerality. - Nick Passmore

Henry Estate Winery
 Critics Platinum 2008 Pinot Noir Oregon $18.00    Yum!  Light and fresh, glowing with red berry fruit flavor. - Nick Passmore
 Critics Silver 2007 Syrah Umpqua Valley $25.00    Lean, very linear, some fineness. - Elin McCoy

Herding Cats 
 Critics Silver 2009 Chenin Blanc / Chardonnay Western Cape $10.00    Lemon fruit with a slight floral note that finishes with a lemonade-like sweetness. - W. Blake Gray

Herzog Wine Cellars
 Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon, Special Reserve Alexander Valley $38.00    Ripe and soft, this is a very rounded and approachable Cab for pairing with lighter meat dishes. - Michael Franz

Hess Collection
 Critics Gold 2007 19 Block Cuvee Mount Veeder $35.00    An impressive blend showing good concentration, depth of fruit and integration of structural components and fruit. - Michael Franz
 Critics Gold 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Estate Grown Mount Veeder $48.00    Full, rich. - Ed McCarthy

High Note
 Critics Gold 2008 Malbec, Elevated Mendoza $13.00    Fresh and elegant. - Nick Passmore

Hogue Cellars
 Critics Silver 2007 Red Table Wine Columbia Valley $10.00    Bright cherry and blackcurrant nose. Fresh, sleek, not super-concentrated but quite stylish, with a long finish.- Stephen Brook
 Critics Silver 2007 Merlot Columbia Valley $10.00    Fruity and pleasing. - Nick Passmore
 Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Grigio Columbia Valley $10.00    Floral, ginger ale aromatics, dry, medium fruit. - Gerald D. Boyd
 Critics Silver 2009 Late Harvest White Riesling Columbia Valley $10.00    Lively and precise apricot nose, has charm and finesse. Sweet and rather candied, but has plenty of acidity to keep it from being cloying. - Stephen Brook

Holesinsky Winery
 Critics Gold 2009 Rose! Antoinette, Gertschen Vineyard, Hagerman Snake River Valley $28.00    A sophisticated Rose from the partridge eye color to the long finish. Pink grapefruit with notes of beeswax and wild strawberry. A rare completely dry Rose, this is a pink wine meant to be taken seriously. - W. Blake Gray

HRM Rex Goliath
 Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay California $8.00    Waxy mouth feel with lemon fruit and a strong jasmine note. - W. Blake Gray

Huntington
 Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay Sonoma County $15.00    Good value Chardonnay. - Robert Whitley
 Critics Silver 2009 Sauvignon Blanc Dry Creek Valley $14.00   Subtle, with lime and other citrus fruits on the palate. Not an in-your-face wine. - W. Blake Gray

Husch Vineyards
 Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon, La Ribera Vineyards Mendocino $21.00   Lush smoky nose, packed with fruit. Broad, opulent, juicy. There's a lack of grip on the mid-palate, and a slight dryness  on the finish. Impressive weight of fruit but needs a year or two to integrate. - Stephen Brook
 Critics Gold 2008 Pinot Noir Anderson Valley $23.00    Sweet charming red fruits nose, perfumed, and with a good deal of oak, but it's all in balance. Medium-bodied, delicate, not a heavy-handed style and perhaps on the light side, but it has good intensity of flavour and some tannic backbone. Enjoyable now and worth keeping for medium-term drinking. - Stephen Brook
 Critics Platinum 2007 Pinot Noir, Reserve Anderson Valley $35.00    Sumptuous cherry aromas, quite oaky and luxurious. Rounded, juicy, quite opulent, with moderate acidity but fine concentration of flavour and good tannic support. Long and balanced. - Stephen Brook
 Critics Silver 2007 Syrah, La Ribera Vineyards Mendocino $28.00    Black currant, cassis and black plum, pure and generous. - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Gold 2009 Chenin Blanc, La Ribera Vineyards Mendocino $11.00    Leesy, fresh, touch of fennel.  Apple/pear fruit, bright and with good length.  - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay Mendocino $15.00    Lighter bodied and more delicate style of chardonnay with a kiss of oak that still captures the essence of the grape.  - Leslie Sbrocco
 Critics Gold 2008 Chardonnay, Special Reserve Mendocino $25.00    Elegant style with pretty aromatics and zesty finish. A chardonnay to pair with just about any fare at the dinner table.  - Leslie Sbrocco
 Critics Silver 2008 Sauvignon Blanc, La Ribera Vineyard Mendocino $13.50    Citrus freshness on the nose follows with a crunchy kick of acidity. A wine for poolside sipping.  - Leslie Sbrocco

Inniskillin
 Critics Gold 2007 Riesling Icewine, VQA Niagara Peninsula $85.00   Admirably fresh and lithe, this lovely wine shows lots of honeyed, lightly floral aroma and enough acidity to counterbalance the luscious sweetness. - Michael Franz
 Critics Silver 2007 Vidal Icewine, VQA Niagara Peninsula $59.00   Rich and very soft in texture, with just enough acidity to provide some cut in the finish. - Michael Franz

Irony
 Critics Gold 2008 Pinot Noir Monterey $15.00   Dark cherry, lean and a bit savory, good elegant red.  - Patrick Comiskey

J. Lohr Winery
 Critics Silver 2006 Cuvee POM Paso Robles $50.00   This is pushing its luck a little with a heavy overlay of vanilla, but it ultimately shows its merit. - Michael Franz
 Critics Gold 2006 Cuvee PAU Paso Robles $50.00   Polished and seductive,  with  gorgeous red and black fruit and judicial use of oak. It's complex and tannic, yet is approachable now. Delicious wine. - Linda Murphy
 Critics Gold 2006 Cuvee ST. E Paso Robles $50.00   An impressive wine showing good concentration and depth of fruit as well as firm oak framing. - Michael Franz
 Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon, Hilltop Vineyard Paso Robles $35.00   Layers of flavor, nice cassis fruit. Attractive. - Elin McCoy
 Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon, Seven Oaks Estates Paso Robles $17.00   Very ripe berry aroma.  Sweet fruit flavors, simple finish. - Gerald D. Boyd
 Critics Gold 2008 Pinot Noir, Fog's Reach Arroyo Seco $25.00   Long finish, earthy aromas and raspberry hints. - Marguerite Thomas
 Critics Silver 2007 Petite Sirah, Tower Road Paso Robles $35.00   Forward fruity nose, ripe flavors. Brisk acidity, good length. - Gerald D. Boyd

J.P. Chenet
 Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay / Colombard, Vin de Pays Vignobles France $9.00   Fine blend of flavors. - Elin McCoy

Jacob's Creek
 Critics Platinum 2004 Johann, Shiraz / Cabernet South Australia $55.00   Generous spicy plummy nose, vibrant. Full-bodied, broad, ample fruit here, and some density and weight, with ripe tannins to sustain it. The alcohol is fairly high but it's just about in check. Long and lively. - Stephen Brook
 Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon South Eastern Australia $8.00   Ripe and satisfying. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Reserve South Australia $13.00   Dry. Classic Cabernet. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, St Hugo Coonawarra $33.00   A menthol / eucalyptus note in the bouquet adds intrigue. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Silver 2009 Merlot South Eastern Australia $8.00   Pleasant. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay South Eastern Australia $8.00   Spicy and pungent. - Nick Passmore
 Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay, Reserve South Australia $13.00   Oaky and full-flavored with a balancing, crisp finish. - Nick Passmore
 Critics Silver 2005 Chardonnay, Reeves Point South Australia $28.00   A big leesy presence amid lively lemon confit, mineral and honeydew rind. There's a lean, focused approach to the palate, and it zips along even with its rich accents. That interplay works. - Jon Bonne
 Critics Gold 2009 Riesling, Reserve South Australia $13.00   Crisp and bracing but not overly tart, this is an admirably dry Riesling that really stands up to scrutiny despite the absence of sweetness to obscure flaws.  A terrific aperitif or a promising partner to subtle freshwater fish dishes. - Michael Franz
 Critics Gold 2007 Riesling, Steingarten Barossa $28.00   Lovely floral aromas lead to flavors that are delicate and precise, with  lots of energetic acidity and a truly dry finish.  A difficult task to make this wine seem complete and convincing without a little sweetness to round out the finish, but that task has been accomplished in this instance. - Michael Franz

Jacuzzi Family Vineyards
 Critics Gold 2007 Barbera Mendocino County $18.00   Bright fruit, some oak, fruity, tannin/fruit balance. - Gerald D. Boyd
 Critics Gold 2007 Merlot, Rosso di Sette Fratelli Carneros $12.00   Gutsy cherry nose, with a light herbaceous edge that's attractive. Soft, rounded, juicy, quite concentrated, not a complex wine but it has ample fruit and weight. Spicy and long. - Stephen Brook

Jordan Vineyard & Winery
 Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon Alexander Valley $52.00   An herbal bite here - dried thyme and caraway seed. It gives a welcome lift to the nuanced cassis and blue fruit. Tapered and precise. - Jon Bonne
 Best of Class Chardonnay 2008 Chardonnay Russian River Valley $29.00   Very bright lemon fruit with a soft mouth feel and long finish.  - W. Blake Gray

Judd's Hill Winery
 Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $45.00   Juicy and lush with a kick of fresh acidity to jumpstart your palate.  - Leslie Sbrocco
 Critics Gold 2006 Petite Sirah, Old Vine Lodi $30.00   Dense spicy plummy nose, vibrant, rather wild but has personality! Rich and bold, with robust tannins, a wine with power and force and not a trace of elegance. Splendid fruit here, but a touch high in alcohol. - Stephen Brook

Kate & Cassie
 Critics Gold NV Pinot Grigio California $12.00   Beautiful full-fruit harmony, all balance and class. - Nick Passmore

Kendall-Jackson
 Critics Gold 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon, Jackson Hills, Estate Grown Knights Valley $40.00   Full, sweet. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Silver 2007 Merlot, Grand Reserve, Estate Grown Sonoma County $25.00   Invitingly soft and supple. - Paul Lukacs                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         

Kenwood Vineyards
 Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Noir Russian River Valley $18.00   Soft and supple. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Silver 2009 Sauvignon Blanc Sonoma County $13.00   Delicate and crisp. - Marguerite Thomas

Kilikanoon
 Critics Gold 2007 Shiraz / Grenache, Killerman's Run South Australia $20.00   Plum and black cherry. Hint of tobacco leaf. Very ripe dark cherry, chewy tannins. Fairly ripe but generous. - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Gold 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon, Killerman's Run South Australia $20.00   Ripe and intense, this features blackberry fruit with just a bit of subtle oak framing. - Michael Franz
 Critics Silver 2006 Oracle Shiraz Clare Valley $70.00   Balanced and restrained Shiraz with dark berry flavors and kick of peppery spice.  - Leslie Sbrocco

Korbin Kameron
 Critics Silver 2006 Cuvee Kristin, Estate Grown Sonoma Mountain $50.00   There's a boatload of oak here, yet underneath is a core of ripe, appealing fruit flavor, with Asian spice and vanillin notes. It gets gold if the oak was less obtrusive.  - Linda Murphy
 Critics Platinum 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon Sonoma Valley $40.00   Toasty nose, quite powerful, with intense blackcurrant fruit. Rich, suave, juicy, an opulent style with a firm tannic backbone. Stylish, spicy, and long, with its power nicely held in check by its intensity of fruit. - Stephen Brook
 Critics Platinum 2006 Merlot, Estate Grown Sonoma Mountain $35.00   Intense and well-structured Merlot with lush but still racy mouth feel. Drink this beauty now with steak or grilled mushrooms and salmon, or hold to allow the noticeable tannins to smooth out.  - Leslie Sbrocco

La Parra Loca
 Critics Gold 2008 Sauvignon Blanc / Verdejo Castilla y Leon $7.00   Citrusy initially, with flavors that expand as it goes along. Grapefruit that segues into pungent passion fruit. - W. Blake Gray
 Critics Silver 2006 Tempranillo / Shiraz Castilla y Leon $7.00   Light, easy-drinking. - Ed McCarthy

La Rusticana D'Orsa
 Critics Gold 2007 Cinque Santa Cruz Mountains $45.00   I love this wine for its forever finish. The acidity is so crisp and it makes my mouth water. Energetic stuff. - Linda Murphy

Laboure-Roi
 Critics Silver 2006 Chablis Premier Cru, Reserve France $48.00   Pineapple, seawater. Mallow on palate. Golden apple, very dark, brown sugar. - Patrick Comiskey

Lake Sonoma Winery
 Critics Silver 2007 Zinfandel Dry Creek Valley $17.00   Plush with ripe tannins. - Marguerite Thomas
 Critics Gold 2009 Sauvignon Blanc Dry Creek Valley $14.00   Classically endowed with fresh grass and a brisk, racy finish. - Marguerite Thomas

LangeTwins
 Critics Platinum 2007 Proprietary Cabernet Sauvignon Lodi $35.00   Lush opulent smoky blackberry nose. Very rich, sumptuous fruit, admirable concentration without being excessively tannic. A lavish and spicy style. Very long and balanced. - Stephen Brook
 Critics Gold 2008 Viognier Clarksburg $16.00   Quite peachy and bright, good limpid fruit character. Sweet bright generous fruit. - Patrick Comiskey

Laurier Vineyards
 Critics Platinum 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon Alexander Valley $15.00   Deep and intense, gains complexity with every sip. - Paul Lukacs

Leaping Lizard
 Critics Silver 2007 Merlot Napa Valley $13.00   Firmly structured but with enough dark berry fruit to leave a balanced impression. This is a serious rendition of Merlot that really requires meat or aged cheese. - Michael Franz
 Critics Gold 2008 Zinfandel Sonoma County $13.00   Tangy wine with notes of cherry and barbecue sauce. Good balance; is it fair to call it under the top? Would love to have this with some dry-rubbed pork ribs. - W. Blake Gray

Left Coast Cellars
 Critics Silver 2008 Left Bank Pinot Blanc Willamette Valley $21.00   Apples on the nose, with a hint of tropical fruit. Lush, rounded, full of fruit though a slightly heavy style with a musky tropical fruit character. - Stephen Brook   
 Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Gris, The Orchards Willamette Valley $18.00   Lean, decisive style with citrus, pear flavors and nervy acidity. - Rebecca Murphy

Lindemans
 Critics Gold 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon, Bin 45 South Eastern Australia $7.00   Very toasty nose, rather overripe but has power. Rich, supple, and juicy, a fleshy and fruit-forward style.  A crowd-pleaser. - Stephen Brook
 Critics Silver 2008 Shiraz, Bin 50 South Eastern Australia $7.00   Forward fruit, cherry-plumy.  Good length, structure. - Gerald D. Boyd

Little Penguin
 Critics Gold 2009 Shiraz South Eastern Australia $7.00   Oak and fruit, sweet fruit flavors, good length, no heat. - Gerald D. Boyd
 Critics Gold 2009 Chardonnay South Eastern Australia $7.00   Firm oaky nose, not very expressive now but doesn't lack fruit. Soft, rounded, reasonably concentrated, has some weight and enough acidity to refresh the finish, which is toasty and quite long. - Stephen Brook   

Lockwood Vineyard
 Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon, Estate Grown Monterey $15.00   Ripe and smooth.  - Elin McCoy

Loredona
 Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Grigio Monterey $11.00   Full, intense mouth-feel with a lingering, dry aromatic finish. - Nick Passmore

Luis Canas
 Critics Gold 2006 Rioja Crianza Spain $14.00   Sweet elegant nose, not too oaky. Supple, with light tannins, and some refreshing acidity. Well balanced and has a lively finish, with good length. This should age well, but is also excellent to drink now. - Stephen Brook

Mad Housewife Cellars
 Critics Silver 2008 White Zinfandel California $9.00   Sweet pink wine with a pleasant strawberry flavor. - W. Blake Gray

Maggio
 Critics Platinum 2006 Petite Sirah Lodi $10.00   Generous oaky black cherry nose, packed with fruit and a bracing eucalyptus character. Lush and sumptuous, concentrated and with considerable depth of flavour, spicy and vigorous, and surprisingly good acidity. Complex and long. - Stephen Brook

Marques de Casa Concha
 Critics Platinum 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon, Puente Alto Chile $22.00   Herbal echoes in the bouquet add interest and complexity, resulting in a truly compelling Cabernet. - Paul Lukacs

Maschio
 Critics Platinum NV Treviso Brut Prosecco DOC Italy $13.00   Classic peach and citrus Prosecco flavors.  Delicious on a warm summer evening. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Gold NV Maschio dei Cavalieri, Prosecco di Valdobbiadene DOC Italy $13.00    Rich, full-flavored. A fine Prosecco. - Ed McCarthy

Masked Rider
 Critics Gold 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon, Six Gun California $9.00    Yes! Full and rich. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Noir, Sagebrush California $9.00   Cranberry and cherry fruit, with a clean finish. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Silver 2007 Petite Sirah, Outlaw California $9.00   Deeply-hued red with dark berry fruit flavors. The attraction is its still vibrant quality, which makes it easy to pair with food.  - Leslie Sbrocco

Matuco
 Critics Gold 2008 Malbec Mendoza $10.00    A subtle smoky edge to the nose, with robust blackberry and a chewy, gutsy profile. - Jon Bonne

McGuigan 
 Critics Gold 2008 Shiraz, Hand Made Barossa $9.00    Simply delicious. Juicy, plump fruit flavors, racy acidity, supple tannins and a flash of earthy minerality. A touch of finishing heat keeps it from Plantinum status. - Linda Murphy

Meridian
 Critics Gold 2007 Merlot California $9.00    Showcasing characteristic softness, this medium-bodied, fruit-driven Merlot goes down easy while still offering layers of flavor.  - Leslie Sbrocco
 Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay California $9.00    Discreet apricot nose, with some weight of fruit. Juicy attack, reasonably concentrated, a touch sweet but there's also some fairly fierce acidity to give some vigour. - Stephen Brook
 Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Grigio California $9.00    Fresh nose, pears, has some precision. Quite juicy and ripe, with a touch of sweetness but plenty of acidic bite too. Has some citric zest and freshness.  - Stephen Brook   

Mettler Family Vineyards
 Critics Gold 2005 Petite Sirah Lodi $25.00    Oaky savory nose, very ripe and jazzy. Broad, lush, relatively soft for Petite Syrah, but plenty of mouth-coating fruit and a long spicy finish. - Stephen Brook

Middle Sister
 Critics Silver NV Drama Queen Pinot Grigio California $12.00    Nicely balanced, clear, pure fruit and unpretentiously appealing. - Nick Passmore

Mikami Vineyards
 Critics Silver 2008 Zinfandel Lodi $35.00    Funky and olivey. Red berry notes.  - Patrick Comiskey

Milbrandt Vineyard
 Critics Gold 2009 Rose, Traditions Columbia Valley $13.00    Intense and brimming with a flinty minerality. - Nick Passmore
 Critics Gold 2007 Merlot, The Estates Wahluke Slope $25.00   Subtle oak, good fruit, nicely balanced with length and structure. - Gerald D. Boyd

Monogamy
 Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon North Coast $12.00    Medium fruit nose.  Bright flavors, good balance. - Gerald D. Boyd

Montcadi
 Critics Silver NV Cava, Semi-Seco Spain $6.00    Sweet and juicy.  Wedding cake? - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Gold NV Cava Rose Spain $7.00    Bright strawberry fruit flavors with a clean, fresh profile. - Paul Lukacs

Montevina Winery
 Critics Silver 2007 Barbera Amador County $12.00    Some of that typical Barbera acidity and not sweet. - Elin McCoy
 Critics Gold 2008 Chardonnay California $10.00    Minerals underpinning base of apple-pear fruit. - Marguerite Thomas
 Critics Gold 2008 Pinot Grigio California $10.00    Aromatic, intense and spicy. - Nick Passmore

Morlanda
 Critics Silver 2004 Crianca Priorat $48.00   Cedar notes dominate aromas with big black fruit on the palate. Tannins are smooth. Very pleasant wine. - Rebecca Murphy

Motos Liberty Cellars
 Critics Silver 2008 Merlot California $8.00   Sour cherry and herbs. Straightforward red cherry and a hint of herb. - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Noir California $8.00    A bit ripe, but delicious. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Gold 2008 Chardonnay California $8.00    A bit of a musque note, with apple blossom and Bosc pear. Clean, lively and well-knit, with brightness to match all that sweet fruit. - Jon Bonne
 Critics Platinum 2008 Pinot Grigio California $8.00    Round, full flavor followed by a clean, crisp finish. - Nick Passmore

Mount Aukum Winery
 Critics Silver 2008 4 Of A Kind El Dorado $22.00   Mallow cup white nougat and quince, grapey finish. - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Silver 2006 Petite Sirah, Reserve El Dorado $35.00   Big forward fruit, bright and fresh. Balanced tannins, good length. - Gerald D. Boyd

Mouton Cadet
 Critics Gold 2007 Rouge Bordeaux $10.00    Dark cherry fruit, good balance, with an appealing red plum high note - W. Blake Gray
 Critics Silver 2008 Blanc Bordeaux $10.00    Citrus-mineral, brisk acidity, medium fruit. - Gerald D. Boyd

Mumm Napa
 Critics Silver NV Brut Prestige Napa Valley $22.00    Clean and crisp. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Silver NV Brut Reserve Napa Valley $26.00    Fruity and frothy, full of favor. - Paul Lukacs

Napa Cellars
 Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $26.00    Sweet and tannic.  - Patrick Comiskey

Napa Creek Winery
 Critics Platinum 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $11.00   Sort of leathery and dark. Dark sweet fig fruit, elegant tannins, softly contoured, clean,  - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay Napa Valley $11.00   Clean and precise even with the distinct oak edge. - Jon Bonne

Napa Landing Winery
 Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $9.00   Mocha, cassis, dark cherry. Generous dark plum and cassis fruit, good herbed note on finish.  - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Gold 2006 Merlot Napa Valley $9.00   Plum.  Chewy black cherry.  Ripe pleasing flavors. - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Gold 2008 Chardonnay Napa Valley $9.00    Clean, pure and fresh. - Nick Passmore

Napa Ridge Winery
 Critics Silver 2007 Merlot Napa Valley $13.00   An elegant wine with black cherry flavors and graphite-like tannins. Good weight, some life. - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Gold 2005 Syrah Napa Valley $13.00   Big oak nose. Lots of berry fruit. Good length, no heat. - Gerald D. Boyd

Navarro Vineyards
 Critics Silver 2008 Navarrouge Mendocino $14.00    Light-bodied, easy to sip blend with pleasant raspberry fruit.  - W. Blake Gray
 Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon Mendocino $35.00    Inky and deeply-flavored. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Noir, South Hill, Planter's Reserve Anderson Valley $29.00    A fine mineral edge to ripe cherry fruit gives a fulfilling presence bolstered by a fine subtle backbone. Gratifying. - Jon Bonne
 Critics Gold 2008 Pinot Noir, Deed-End Blend Anderson Valley $49.00    Minty, berry-filled and edged by a charming orange-peel accent. Pinot with definition and verve. - Jon Bonne
 Critics Silver 2009 Sauvignon Blanc Mendocino $18.00   Hay and lemon rind scents, with a full, ripe profile of guava and peach. A weightier effort but it pays off. - Jon Bonne

Newman's Own
 Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay California $12.00    Lees and apples. Fairly honest, brisk fruit, good clean fruit character. - Patrick Comiskey

Nobilo
 Critics Gold 2009 Sauvignon Blanc, Regional Collection Marlborough $14.00    Piquant herbal, lime zest aromas, rounded and rich grapefruit, melon flavors buoyed by vivid acidity.   - Rebecca Murphy
 Critics Silver 2009 Sauvignon Blanc, Icon Marlborough $22.00    A pungent wine in the New Zealand style, with nice tropical fruit notes. Intense. - W. Blake Gray

Northstar
 Critics Gold 2006 Merlot Walla Walla Valley $60.00    Beautifully balanced and complex. Polished tannins, perfectly ripe dark-red fruit, touches  of licorice and mineral, and a long, crisp finish. A complete merlot. - Linda Murphy

Oak Leaf
 Critics Platinum NV Shiraz California $3.00    An intriguing herbaceous note adds complexity to this rich, complete wine. - Paul Lukacs

Ogio
 Critics Silver NV Prosecco, Extra Dry Italy $9.00    Quite delicious. - Ed McCarthy

Ombretta
 Critics Silver 2008 Chianti DOCG Italy $5.00    A gentle Chianti, without astringency or bite. - Paul Lukacs

Ortman Family Vineyards
 Critics Silver 2007 Sangiovese Paso Robles $22.00    Hearty and mouth filling, full of rich, oak-edged cherry fruit. Pizza time. - Jon Bonne
 Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay Edna Valley  $24.00    Ripe and juicy, yet really enlivened by a spiciness in the finish that is thankfully not accompanied by lots of overt oak. This is a very well made wine that proves enduringly interesting. - Michael Franz

Pacific Rim Winemakers
 Critics Gold 2008 Riesling, Solstice Vineyard Yakima Valley $32.00    Zesty with a mineral-tinged fruit. - Nick Passmore
 Critics Silver 2009 Riesling Columbia Valley $11.00    Lean precise stylish nose. Light but fresh and quite crisp, an enjoyable aperitif style. - Stephen Brook
 Critics Gold 2009 Sweet Riesling Columbia Valley $11.00    A succulently sweet yet balanced white that will pair ideally with savory dishes but can also go to the dessert table and pair with sweets. Very versatile.  - Leslie Sbrocco

Palo Alto
 Critics Silver 2008 Red Reserve Maule Valley $13.00    Medium-bodied, fresher than the nose, light fruit and ample acidity. Overall, a simple wine but well made. - Stephen Brook

Palro Estate
 Critics Silver 2008 Rose Mendoza $4.00    Cheerful strawberry fruit with a note of pink grapefruit. Pleasant. - W. Blake Gray

Palumbo Family Vineyards & Winery
 Critics Silver 2007 Tre Fratelli, Estate Meritage Temecula Valley $38.00    Soft and straightforward, this shows very appealing fruit that is pure and softly structured. - Michael Franz
 Critics Silver 2006 Syrah, French Clone 877 Temecula Valley $34.00    Easy-drinking. - Ed McCarthy

Parallel
 Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon, Estate Napa Valley $125.00    Cherry fruit, a blood orange note.  Firm but well-managed tannins.  - W. Blake Gray

Paso Creek
 Critics Gold 2007 Zinfandel Paso Robles $17.00    Nice midweight wine with harmony of spice and fruit.  Unusual class and refinement for Zinfandel. - Michael Apstein

Pasos Vineyard
 Critics Gold 2007 Reserve Dastarte Lodi $60.00    Boldly oaked, but with enough stuffing to back it up, this shows strong potential for future development but is nevertheless quite appealing already. - Michael Franz

Pedroncelli Winery
 Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon, Morris Fay Vineyard Alexander Valley $18.00    French oak and fruit. Dry, good fruit and tannins, length. - Gerald D. Boyd
 Critics Silver 2007 Zinfandel, Bushnell Vineyard Dry Creek Valley $18.00    Balanced, juicy, spicy, even zingy.  - Elin McCoy
 Critics Silver 2009 Sauvignon Blanc, East Side Vineyards Dry Creek Valley $12.00    Floral, bright, snappy, crispy, gulp me. - Elin McCoy

Peirano Estate Vineyards
 Critics Silver 2008 Zinfandel, The Immortal Zin, Old Vine Lodi $13.00    Soft and juicy with loads of dark berry fruit, it's a crowd pleaser.  - Leslie Sbrocco

Penley Estate
 Critics Gold 2007 Condor Cabernet Sauvignon / Shiraz Coonawarra $20.00    Muted nose, black fruits. Rich, broad, juicy black fruits, solid and robust rather than elegant, with some spice on the finish. - Stephen Brook
 Critics Gold 2008 Phoenix Cabernet Sauvignon Coonawarra $20.00    Ripe and soft in texture, but still focused and firm in structure in the finish thanks to fine-grained tannin and fairly subtle oak.  A well made Cabernet. - Michael Franz
 Critics Gold 2007 Hyland Shiraz Coonawarra $20.00    Full bodied and bold, it has power but still deft touch. - Leslie Sbrocco
 Critics Platinum 2005 Shiraz, Special Select, The Traveler Coonawarra $50.00    Muscular and intense. A red for those who love big and bold.   - Leslie Sbrocco

Perrier-Jouet 
 Critics Silver NV Grand Brut Champagne $45.00    Clean and fresh. - Paul Lukacs
 Best of Show Sparkling 2002 Fleur de Champagne Champagne $140.00    Great Champagne marries great depth of flavor with bright freshness and vivacity.  That ís what this superb wine does. - Paul Lukacs

Pietra Santa Winery
 Critics Gold 2005 Vache, Signature Collection Red Blend Cienega Valley $45.00    Lovely dark berry fruit notes lead the way here, with subtle oak providing additional interest around the edges. - Michael Franz
 Critics Silver 2006 Sassolino Cienega Valley $18.00    Tight black fruit with hints of mushroom in a tightly held structure.  - Rebecca Murphy
 Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon Cienega Valley $20.00    Cassis. Palate flavors extremely chunky and dark, weighty. - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Gold 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon, Signature Collection Cienega Valley $50.00    Toasty spicy nose has complexity and vigour. Medium- bodied, supple, juicy, straightforward. Has good acidity, but the finish is a touch hot. - Stephen Brook
 Critics Silver 2006 Sangiovese, Estate Grown Cienega Valley $18.00    Fresh and earthy. - Nick Passmore

Pizzulli Family Winery
 Critics Gold 2007 Barbera Santa Barbara County $37.00    French oak nose, medium fruit, good acidity and length. - Gerald D. Boyd
 Critics Silver 2008 Dolcetto Santa Barbara County $37.00    Quite tasty, but a bit soft. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Platinum 2007 Nebbiolo Santa Barbara County $37.00    Bright sweet cherry. Rose. Good top note of fruit blossom. Flavors deep and straightforward, full on, fresh, delicious. - Patrick Comiskey

Planeta
 Critics Silver 2008 La Segreta, Sicilily IGT Italy $15.00   Has lovely soft texture that balances the firm tannins. Concentration of dark fruit character. - Mary Ewing-Mulligan

Plantagenet
 Critics Gold 2007 Shiraz Great Southern $29.00    Smoky, fresh. - Leslie Sbrocco
 Critics Gold 2007 Omrah Shiraz Western Australia $20.00    Bit rugged, like a cowboy. Wild berry fruit flavors and grippy tannins make for an interesting wine.  - Leslie Sbrocco

Polka Dot
 Critics Silver 2008 Riesling Pfalz $12.00    Rich, full-bodied for Riesling, has some weight and extract. Plenty of fruit here and no cloying sweetness. - Stephen Brook

Ponzi Vineyards
 Critics Gold 2008 Pinot Noir Willamette Valley $35.00    Elegant nose with bright cherry fruit. Suave texture, juicy but stylish, this is delicious and quite lively, with a long mouth-watering finish. - Stephen Brook

Principe Corsini
 Critics Silver 2007 Birillo Maremma Toscana $19.00    Flamboyantly fruity and lush on entry, it turns brisk and slightly astringent on the finish. Begs for a hunk of meat. - Linda Murphy

Quady Winery
 Critics Silver 2008 Elysium Black Muscat California $17.00    Fresh fruit in a bright package. - Ed McCarthy   
 Critics Gold NV Essensia Orange Muscat California $17.00    Beautiful balance.  Bright orange and peach fruit.  A long finish. - Paul Lukacs 

Quail Ridge
 Critics Silver 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $15.00    Tobacco leaf and plum.  Good persistence. - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Gold 2008 Pinot Noir Napa Valley $15.00    Has the sexy mouth feel that Pinot lovers crave. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay Napa Valley $15.00    Lemony fresh. - Nick Passmore

Quinta Da Zaralhoa
 Critics Silver 2006 Reserva, Douro DOC Portugal $20.00   Firmly structured with acidity and tannin, but with enough ripe fruit to achieve balance.  Shows plenty of character. - Michael Franz

R & B Cellars
 Critics Gold NV Fortissimo Dessert Wine Madera $20.00   Good balance of sweetness and fire. - Michael Apstein
 Critics Platinum 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon,  Bingham Ranch, Reserve Napa Valley $50.00   Spicy oaky nose, stylish oak. Medium-bodied, not a massive or weighty style but has fine concentration of fruit, powerful tannins, and great depth of flavor. Perhaps a touch high in alcohol but very impressive in its fruit quality. Long. - Stephen Brook
 Critics Silver 2007 Swingsville Zinfandel Lodi $12.00   Not overly complex but awfully easy to drink. Lush and sippable.  - Leslie Sbrocco

Rancho Zabaco Winery
 Critics Silver 2008 Zinfandel, Heritage Vines Sonoma County $18.00   Very brambly Zin with a rustic edge.  - Paul Lukacs                                     

Ravenswood Winery
 Critics Silver 2007 Zinfandel, Vintner's Blend California $10.00   Nice spice and fruit.  Lovely mid-weight Zin that shows the uniqueness of the varietal.  Good value. - Michael Apstein

Re del Castello
 Critics Gold 2007 Chianti Classico DOCG Italy $10.00   Rich, lovely. - Ed McCarthy

Recoleta
 Critics Silver 2008 Malbec / Bonarda Mendoza $3.00   Well-balanced. - Ed McCarthy

Redwood Creek
 Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon California $8.00    Sweet and lush. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Gold 2008 Zinfandel Lodi $8.00    Satisfyingly long, with bright berry fruit and plenty of spice. - Paul Lukacs 
 Critics Gold 2008 Chardonnay California $8.00    The crisp finish provides an nice counterpoint to the full, rich oakiness. - Nick Passmore

Reflexion
 Critics Gold 2003 Rioja Reserva Spain $10.00    A supple, high-acid, fairly traditionally style Rioja with the graciousness of age. - Mary Ewing-Mulligan

Renwood Winery
 Critics Silver 2007 Zinfandel, Grandpere Amador County $40.00    Zippy, lively, classic Zin. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Silver 2007 Zinfandel, Jack Rabbit Flat Amador County $30.00    Sweet and ripe, full of juicy fruit flavor. - Paul Lukacs                                                    

Rideau Vineyard
 Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay, Bien Nacido Vineyard Santa Barbara County     Nice lemon fruit with notes of beeswax and spice. - W. Blake Gray

Riunite
 Critics Silver NV Movendo Moscato, Pavia IGT Italy $10.00    Juicy sweet fruit in a soft refreshing style. - Paul Lukacs 

Robert Hall Winery
 Critics Silver 2006 Meritage, Hall Ranch Paso Robles $40.00    Nicely balanced between ripeness and restraint, this is made in a very versatile and appealing style. - Michael Franz
 Critics Gold 2007 Rhone de Robles Central Coast $18.00    Heavy, ripe and dark. Scents of plum, eucalyptus, black cherry. Good weight, intensity, texture is chewy and dark. Quite tannic, low acid. - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Platinum 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon Paso Robles $18.00    Subtle mocha and cassis aromas lead to an elegant, beautifully textured palate. The finish is extraordinarily long and mouthwatering. - Linda Murphy

Robert Mondavi Private Selection
 Critics Silver 2008 Merlot California $10.00    Pleasing mellow fruit tinged with a dry earthiness. - Nick Passmore
 Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Noir California $10.00    Lightly sweet but not candied, this is very attractive. - Michael Franz
 Critics Gold 2008 Chardonnay California $10.00    Lemon fruit with a jasmine note and pleasant mouth feel. - W. Blake Gray
 Critics Gold 2009 Pinot Grigio California $10.00    Delicate charming nose, pears and honeydew melon. Generous fruit without being over the top, creamy texture, and some depth of flavour. - Stephen Brook   

Robert Oatley Vineyards
 Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon / Merlot Mudgee $18.00    Very appealing in a relatively simple style showing vivid dark cherry fruit that remains pure and fresh. - Michael Franz
 Critics Silver 2009 Rose of Sangiovese Mudgee $15.00    Muted red fruits nose. Quite rich, juicy, full-bodied, concentrated, slightly heavy but has plenty of fruit.  - Stephen Brook   
 Critics Gold 2009 Pinot Grigio South Australia $16.00    A slight raspberry edge to the apple and peach, with just a touch of copper color that signals its more serious tones. Comes with a certain depth, edged by charming acidity, that makes me think versatile. - Jon Bonne
 Critics Silver 2009 Sauvignon Blanc Pemberton $16.00    Medium grassy aroma. Tart, light-medium fruit. - Gerald D. Boyd

Robert Traverso
 Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon Oakville $60.00    Medium nose and fruit.  Balanced.  Berry notes. - Gerald D. Boyd
 Critics Silver 2007 Zinfandel Russian River Valley $40.00    It's not as complex as some, but it has super energy and juiciness, and plenty of acidity to refresh the palate. - Linda Murphy
 Critics Gold 2008 Chardonnay Russian River Valley $40.00    Nice zippy white. Apples and hint of caramel. Flavors are bright and a tad citrusy with a core of apples and pear, mineral finish. - Patrick Comiskey

Rock Wall Wine Co.
 Critics Gold 2008 Cabernet Franc, Holbrook Mitchell Vineyards Napa Valley $25.00    Sweet ripe but not jammy nose, with plenty of aromatic vigour. Lush but not heavy, perhaps not obviously Cab Franc, but spicy and concentrated, and not in the least vegetal. Spice and coffee on the finish. Vigorous and long. - Stephen Brook
 Critics Gold 2008 Montepulciano Contra Costa County $22.00    Soft, easy-drinking and delicious. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Platinum 2008 Zinfandel Sonoma County $25.00    Picture perfect!  Full of ripe, brambly character, with real depth, and excellent length.  What Zin should taste like! - Paul Lukacs                                                                                           
 Critics Gold 2008 Zinfandel, Jesse's Vineyard Contra Costa County $28.00    Really good Zin. Not overly ripe. Hurrah. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay Russian River Valley $35.00    Ripe oaky stone-fruits nose. Plump, ripe, has some swagger and zest, concentrated, a touch of minerality, adds up to a fairly complex wine. - Stephen Brook   

Rodney Strong Vineyards
 Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon, Estate Vineyards Alexander Valley $22.00    Dark in color and nicely ripe, this is soft and sweet and open. - Michael Franz
 Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Noir, Estate Vineyards Russian River Valley $20.00    Pleasant earthiness on the nose with cranberry fruit on the palate. - W. Blake Gray
 Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay Sonoma County $13.50    Lovely balance of ideally ripe fruit, vanillin and citrusy acidity. Mouth-filling and juicy.  - Linda Murphy
 Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay, Estate Vineyards Chalk Hill $20.00    Ripe and rich but still balanced and convincing, this is a finely crafted Chardonnay that will work well with rich dishes but also with more moderate fare.  Very well crafted. - Michael Franz

Root: 1
 Critics Gold 2008 Carmenere Colchagua Valley $12.00    Capturing the spicy character of Carmenere, this supple red is ideal for fare from burgers to barbeque.  - Leslie Sbrocco
 Critics Gold 2009 Sauvignon Blanc Casablanca Valley $12.00    Juicy and refreshing. - Marguerite Thomas

Rosemount Estate
 Critics Silver 2008 Shiraz, Diamond Label South Eastern Australia $10.00    Up-front fruity aroma, dry good fruit. Some heat, length - Gerald D. Boyd
 Critics Gold 2008 Chardonnay, Diamond Label South Eastern Australia $10.00    Crisp and bright with balanced oak character. It's the kind of wine that makes you smile.  - Leslie Sbrocco

Rosenthal - The Malibu Estate
 Critics Silver 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon Malibu-Newton Canyon $39.00   Quite lovely. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Gold 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon, Block M, Single Vineyard Malibu-Newton Canyon $70.00    Deep and satisfying, with cedar-like aromas. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Gold 2007 Merlot, The Devon Vineyard Malibu-Newton Canyon $27.00    Delightful.  Well-balanced. - Ed McCarthy

Roth Estate
 Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon Alexander Valley $29.00    Rich black fruit flavors and velvety texture make this a very likeable wine. - Rebecca Murphy
 Critics Silver 2009 Sauvignon Blanc Alexander Valley $15.00    Fresh and zesty at every turn, this opens with cut grass and dried herb aromas that lead into crisp citrus fruit, with just a little sweetness to buffer the acidity in the finish. - Michael Franz

Rotta Winery
 Critics Silver NV Black Monukka California $25.00    Well-structured and harmonious. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Silver 2005 Cabernet Franc, Dino Boneso Vineyard Paso Robles $22.00    Light, fresh, and zesty, not a wine with great depth of flavour, but quite concentrated and lively. Delicate red fruits on the finish. - Stephen Brook
 Critics Gold 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon, Proprietor's Paso Robles $16.00    Fetching black cherry and blackberry fruit glides along fluid tannins.  - Rebecca Murphy

Russian Hill Estate Winery
 Critics Gold 2007 Pinot Noir, Tara Vineyard, Estate Grown Russian River Valley $46.00    I like the Christmas spice on the nose and the cranberry fruit on the palate. Completely dry, unlike so many others that claim to be. - W. Blake Gray
 Critics Gold 2006 Syrah, Estate Vineyards Russian River Valley $28.00    Cherry and cranberry fruit with a raw meat note and good acidity. Good typicity; this is Syrah being Syrah - W. Blake Gray

Rutherford Vintners
 Critics Silver 2007 Merlot Napa Valley $13.00    Sullen, chewy, slightly bitter almond note. Slick red for ribs. - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay Napa Valley $13.00    Dried herbs, fig and peach skin. A crispness that keeps it straight forward and eminently drinkable. - Jon Bonne

Saludas
 Critics Silver 2009 Rose Tierra De Castilla $2.99    Light ruby color with forward berry fruit and piquant acidity. - Rebecca Murphy
 Critics Gold 2009 Red Tierra De Castilla $2.99    Lovely, very quaffable. - Ed McCarthy

Santa Ana 
 Critics Silver 2008 Torrontes, Reserve Mendoza $12.00    Bright fruity aroma, peachy-spicy, length. - Gerald D. Boyd

Sartori
 Critics Gold 2005 Amarone Della Valpolicella DOC Italy $40.00    Powerful wine that manages to stay nimble. Rich cherry fruit fills the mouth, and a wash of acidity keeps it from clinging. It's powerful without being heavy. - W. Blake Gray
 Critics Silver 2005 Regolo Rosso, Veronese IGT Italy $21.00    Sweet cherry, like cherry pie filling, with a darker fruit note - W. Blake Gray

Sawyer Cellars
 Critics Silver 2006 Bradford Meritage Rutherford $44.00    Relatively lean for this category, but admirably focused and long. - Michael Franz
 Best Of Class Cabernet Sauvignon 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon Rutherford $48.00    Fresh if oaky nose, cherry fruit. Rich, suave, textured, very concentrated but not excessive. Ripe yet lifted and the extraction is kept in check., A finely balanced wine that should keep well for some years. - Stephen Brook
 Critics Silver 2006 Merlot Rutherford $39.00    Delicate and aromatic Merlot that wraps itself with a silky texture.  - Leslie Sbrocco

SeaGlass
 Critics Gold 2009 Sauvignon Blanc Santa Barbara County $13.00    Gooseberry and a hint of lime pith. Lean, phenolic, New Zealand style white with brisk acidity. - Patrick Comiskey

Segura Viudas
 Critics Gold 2003 Mas D'Avanyo Tempranillo Reserva Penedes $15.00    Spicy and long, with a firm but unastringent structure. - Paul Lukacs

Seven, by Bodegas Osborne
 Critics Silver NV Red Blend Spain $22.00    Well-structured and balanced, with satisfying depth of flavor. - Paul Lukacs 

Shoofly
 Critics Silver 2007 Aussie Salute Adelaide   $14.00    Cherries and menthol. Sweet, ripe, dark, chewy.  - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Gold 2008 Buzz Cut Adelaide   $14.00    Quite earthy, especially on the nose, but also has chunky Meyer lemon fruit, like lemon confit.  - W. Blake Gray
 Critics Silver 2009 Shiraz Adelaide   $14.00    Broad, fleshy, opulent. A heavy style of Shiraz, but it certainly has ample fruit and will give pleasure to those who seek a fruit-forward style. - Stephen Brook
 Critics Gold 2008 Chook Raffle Chardonnay Adelaide Hills $14.00    Lush and opulent without being overblown, this is a strong example of Chardonnay in the fuller style that manages to remain balanced and restrained. - Michael Franz

Sierra Madre Vineyard
 Critics Gold 2007 Pinot Noir Santa Maria Valley $42.00    Big, modern style pinot with dark berry intensity and fleshy texture. Hubba, hubba.  - Leslie Sbrocco

South Coast Winery
 Critics Silver 2009 Grenache Rose California $14.00    Lots of flavor, for those who enjoy a sweeter rose that's still a respectable wine. - Mary Ewing-Mulligan
 Critics Silver 2008 Petite Sirah, Wild Horse Peak South Coast $38.00    Tar, oaky. Medium  sweet fruit, a little herbal. - Gerald D. Boyd
 Critics Silver 2006 Syrah, Wild Horse Peak South Coast $48.00    Nice blend of oak and fruit, medium palate. - Gerald D. Boyd
 Critics Gold NV Blanc de Blanc Temecula Valley $28.00    Rich, fine. - Ed McCarthy

St. James Winery
 Critics Gold 2008 Chambourcin Ozark Mountain $7.00    Juicy, low tannin wine with great depth of color and fruit intensity. For those who love a light and fruity red with sweet fruit notes (though it is a dry wine), this is the ticket.  - Leslie Sbrocco

St. Supery Vineyards & Winery
 Critics Platinum 2006 Elu Napa Valley $60.00    Has an enticing wild raspberry aroma, and a palate full of succulent red and black fruit. Subtle hints of vanilla, toast spice and black cherry. Complex intense, with firm tannins for cellaring. - Linda Murphy
 Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $35.00    Lovely.  Easy  to drink. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Silver 2005 Merlot Napa Valley $25.00    Firm structure -- a wine with backbone. - Paul Lukacs 

Starborough
 Critics Silver 2008 Sauvignon Blanc Marlborough $13.00    Distinctly herbal, with bit grass and bell-pepper, and a softer citrus burst to bring it to life. - Jon Bonne

Stoller Family Vineyard & Winery
 Critics Gold 2007 Pinot Noir, JV Estate Dundee Hills $25.00    Leathery, earthy undertones add complexity and give it intrigue. - Paul Lukacs
 Best of Class Pinot Noir 2006 Pinot Noir, SV Estate Dundee Hills $40.00     Sweet cherry and red berry fruit, with a spicy finish.  Complete and complex.  - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay, Estate Grown Dundee Hills $28.00    Full and soft. - Marguerite Thomas

Stoneleigh 
 Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Noir Marlborough $16.00    Earthy aroma with good cranberry fruit. - W. Blake Gray
 Critics Platinum 2009 Sauvignon Blanc Marlborough $16.00    Crisp and mouthwatering, with gooseberry and citrus leading the nose and then palate. Gently herbaceous (think jalapeno) and structured, it's balanced and complex. - Linda Murphy

Stony Ridge
 Critics Silver 2005 Trifecta Livermore Valley $24.00    Spicy and sweet, with a long finish. - Paul Lukacs  
 Critics Silver 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon, Reserve Livermore Valley $26.00    A riper style, with bold blackberry/cherry aromas and flavors. There is enough acidity to carry the mature fruit, and the finish is clean and fresh. - Linda Murphy
 Critics Gold 2005 Petite Sirah Livermore Valley $26.00    Ripe plums, very balanced, not too much oak, almost lip smacking. - Elin McCoy
 Critics Silver 2006 Syrah, Estate Grown Livermore Valley $25.00    Sweet cherry, a mellow wine for simple, pleasurable sipping. - W. Blake Gray

Surfrider
 Critics Silver 2006 Hang Ten Red California $25.00    Spicy, rustic and full of character, this hearty red is one to savor and debate.  - Leslie Sbrocco
 Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay Edna Valley  $21.00    Ripe and rounded but still balanced and enduringly interesting, this is a very well made rendition of Chardonnay. - Michael Franz

Tangent
 Critics Gold 2009 Viognier, Paragon Vineyard Edna Valley  $20.00    Biscuits and grass. Sweet pear fruit, pure, good energy. Rich but not cloying, bright and fresh. - Patrick Comiskey

Tapena
 Critics Gold 2008 Garnacha Tierra De Castilla $10.00    Pomegranate fruit with a lighter body. Tastes like a wine from the south of France. - W. Blake Gray
 Critics Gold 2008 Tempranillo Tierra De Castilla $10.00    Subtle and sophisticated, with superb length on the palate. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Silver 2008 Verdejo Tierra De Castilla $10.00    Mouth-filling and succulent, with perfectly ripened pear and citrus fruit, a shake of spice. The fragrance is lovely.- Linda Murphy

Tefft Cellars
 Critics Gold 2007 Tempranillo Rattlesnake Hills $28.00    Lots of spicy oak but also enough sweet juicy fruit to stay in focus. - Paul Lukacs

Terra d'Oro
 Critics Gold 2008 Rose Amador County $14.00    Gentle rose petals. - Nick Passmore
 Critics Silver 2007 Zinfandel, Home Vineyard Amador County $30.00    Mineral nose.  Low intensity fruit. Medium finish, heat. - Gerald D. Boyd

Thacher Winery
 Critics Gold 2007 Controlled Chaos Paso Robles $33.00    Peppery spice adds intrigue.  A satisfying sipper. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Silver 2007 Zinfandel, Triumvirate Reserve Paso Robles $36.00    Big fruit aroma. Thick and fruity. Sweet fruit, lots of Zin character. - Gerald D. Boyd

The Four Graces
 Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Noir Willamette Valley $29.00    Delicate cherry fruit on the nose, a touch of oak. Medium-bodied, quite tannic, with pronounced acidity. But there's an attractive energy to the wine, which should harmonize with a bit more bottle age. - Stephen Brook

Three Coins
 Critics Gold 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $30.00    Showy but structured, a wine that ties together the best of both worlds.  - Leslie Sbrocco
 Critics Silver 2007 Syrah, Betsy's Vineyard Knights Valley $28.00    Red plum and black cherry, notes of leather and of oak.  - Patrick Comiskey

Tilia
 Critics Gold 2008 Malbec Mendoza $10.00    Restrained and sophisticated, a grownup's wine. - Nick Passmore

Tin Roof 
 Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon California $10.00    Straight forward and satisfying, this shows appealing fruit with medium-plus body and very little oak, making it a good choice for moderately robust grilled foods. - Michael Franz
 Critics Silver 2006 Merlot California $10.00    Berry and French oak nose. Dry, medium fruit, good length. - Gerald D. Boyd

Trefethen Vineyards
 Critics Silver 2006 Merlot Oak Knoll District $35.00    Very intense nose. Lots of flavors.  Fine tannins, plush texture. - Elin McCoy
 Critics Silver 2009 Dry Riesling Oak Knoll District $22.00    It starts out fruity and ends in a crisp, crunchy acid finish. It's delicate in style, more nuance than obvious, which is its attraction. - Linda Murphy

Trivento
 Critics Silver 2007 Malbec, Lujan De Cuyo, Golden Reserve Mendoza $22.00    Stylish and oak-edged, with gobs of blackberry fruit to chew on. - Jon Bonne
 Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay, Golden Reserve Mendoza $22.00    Sassy and juicy Chardonnay that captures the freshness of the variety. Not overwhelmed with oak, it's just an easy drink - Leslie Sbrocco

Turning Leaf
 Critics Silver 2008 White Zinfandel California $8.00    Lovely and sweet strawberry, raspberry fruit with a clean finish. - Rebecca Murphy
 Critics Silver 2008 Merlot California $8.00    Quite concentrated. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Gold 2009 Pinot Grigio California $8.00    Lush and ripe, like a fruit bowl of flavor. Pair alongside spicy fare or salmon topped with fruit salsa.  - Leslie Sbrocco

Twisted
 Critics Gold 2008 Old Vine Zinfandel California $8.00    Juicy and soft, but also with some interesting savory notes and a carpaccio undertone that makes this enduringly interesting. - Michael Franz
 Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Grigio California $8.00    Light, fresh and zingy with green apples. - Nick Passmore

Unionville Vineyards
 Critics Silver 2007 Cam Jam #1, Red Montage New Jersey $19.00    A spicy sweet profile. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Gold 2008 Revolutionary Red New Jersey $12.00    This blend works well; quite delicious. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Silver 2007 Dry Riesling New Jersey $14.00    Bone-dry and austere, it likely will benefit from time in bottle. There is a hint of resiny greenness that I find attractive, though it might not be a crowd-pleaser. - Linda Murphy

Uptick Vineyards
 Best of Show Rose 2009 Hilda's Rose Russian River Valley $19.00    Pale pink, light, bright and refreshing with subtle berry fruit enlivened by spirited acidity. Perfect warm weather wine. - Rebecca Murphy
 Critics Gold 2008 Old Vine Zinfandel Russian River Valley $37.00    Intense ripe black fruit with spicy clove and cedar that's well structured with tangy acidity and husky tannins. - Rebecca Murphy

V. Sattui Winery
 Critics Silver 2007 Sattui Family Red, 30th Anniversary California $18.00    Symmetrical and well integrated, this is quite appealing and will prove versatile with many food options. - Michael Franz
 Best of Show Dessert NV Angelica California $30.00    A sumptuous orange-scented wine -- an alternative to Grand Marnier, with less alcoholic heat.  - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Silver 2009 Gamay Rouge California $18.00    Sweet herbal cherry flavors with moderate acidity and a clean finish. - Rebecca Murphy
 Critics Platinum 2007 Cabernet Franc Alexander Valley $30.00    Very deep red. Voluptuous oaky nose, hard to recognize as Cab Franc as it's more like Cab Sauvignon, but has aromatic power. Very rich, opulent, highly concentrated. A lavish mouthful of wine, but it's not overdone. Quite oaky on the finish. One could fault this for lack of typicity, but it's a very impressive wine. - Stephen Brook
 Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon, Preston Vineyard Napa Valley $45.00    Solid bramble fruit amid a big load of oak, with some edgy coffee accents. - Jon Bonne
 Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Noir, Sattui Family Los Carneros $29.00    A solid, well-made Pinot with good varietal character and a relatively delicate style. - Michael Franz
 Critics Silver 2007 Pinot Noir, Reserve Stock Los Carneros $45.00    Polished and suave, with nicely ripened fruit and refreshing acidity, - Linda Murphy
 Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Noir, Henry Ranch Los Carneros $36.00    A little shy on the nose, but then shows lots of expressive fruit, with good depth and length. - Michael Franz
 Critics Silver 2007 Petite Sirah North Coast $25.00    The spicy, clove and black fruit aromas invite you in, but the chewy tannins aren't quite ready for company, unless the company brings grilled red meat. - Rebecca Murphy
 Critics Platinum 2007 Syrah Napa Valley $29.00    Rich and ripe but at the same time deep and satisfying because not just sweet fruit.  A luscious example of Syrah! - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Silver 2007 Zinfandel, Eagle Point Ranch Mendocino County $30.00    Sweet cherry and raspberry fruit with chewy tannins. - W. Blake Gray
 Critics Silver 2007 Zinfandel, Gilsson Vineyard Russian River Valley $35.00    Nice ripeness and spice. Supple .  Lovely interplay of ripe black fruit and spice. - Michael Apstein
 Critics Silver 2007 Zinfandel, Ramazzotti Vineyard Dry Creek Valley $36.00    Black fruit. Nice briary edge. Succulent finish. - Michael Apstein
 Critics Platinum 2007 Prestige Cuvee Brut Napa Valley $22.00    Yes! The complete package.  Rich and full. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Silver 2009 Moscato California $24.00    Peachy and fun. - Paul Lukacs                                                  
 Critics Silver 2008 Select Late Harvest White Riesling Napa Valley $29.00    Lively, sweet sipping pleasure. - Elin McCoy
 Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay Napa Valley $19.00    This is a big, luscious, unapologetic oaky chardonnay with ripe, rich apple, vanilla, toasty flavors.  - Rebecca Murphy
 Critics Silver 2009 White Riesling Anderson Valley $24.00    Quite rounded and overtly sweet, and yet it works in this style, with a flowery lusciousness that is impossible to dislike even if a little more defining acidity would do it good. - Michael Franz
 Critics Gold 2009 Early Harvest White Riesling Napa Valley $18.00    I love the balance of sunny, juicy fruit with the crunchy acidity and hint of minerality. It has more weight than many dry Rieslings.  - Linda Murphy

Val de Vid
 Critics Platinum 2008 Condesa Eylo Rueda $14.00    An exciting, intense rendition of Verdejo, this shows very expressive aromas of dried herbs and subtle flowers, along with crisp citrus fruit and a very lively, acidic finish. - Michael Franz

Valdubon
 Critics Gold 2003 Crianza Ribera Del Duero $18.00    Heavy wood notes, intense secondary notes. Good density, hints of Chinese vinegar and tobacco, rawhide. Heavy tannins. - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Gold 2004 Reserva Ribera Del Duero $24.00    Dense, chewy, plum and fig notes. - Patrick Comiskey

Valentin Bianchi
 Critics Platinum 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Famiglia Bianchi San Rafael $19.00    Alluring black olive and cassis aromas lead to layered black currant and berry fruit supported by ripe tannins. A seductive wine. - Rebecca Murphy

Valley of the Moon
 Critics Silver 2007 Cuvee de la Luna Sonoma County $30.00    Plush, juicy and creamy mouth feel. Delivers immediate pleasure. - Linda Murphy
 Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Noir Carneros $16.00    A bit ripe, but lovely. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay, Unoaked Sonoma County $16.00    Mineral attack, lightly mineral middle palate. - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Gold 2008 Pinot Blanc Sonoma County $16.00    Pear-scented, medium bodied wine crafted with a deft touch.  - Leslie Sbrocco

Vendange
 Critics Gold NV Shiraz California $9.00    Dry, powerful. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Silver NV Sauvignon Blanc California $9.00    Citrus with depth. - Paul Lukacs

Ventana Vineyards
 Critics Gold 2008 Pinot Noir, Estate Grown Arroyo Seco $28.00    Rich, broad, fleshy, quite concentrated, with real weight of fruit. Bold and spicy, and has good acidity and length. - Stephen Brook
 Critics Silver 2007 Syrah, Estate Grown Arroyo Seco $18.00    Oaky and smokey. Hint of black pepper and leather. Extremely rich, tannic, furry and short. - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Gold 2008 Gewurztraminer, Estate Grown Arroyo Seco $16.00    Delicate rose petal-ish, fairly voluptuous with a clean finish. - Marguerite Thomas
 Critics Silver 2009 Pinot Gris, Estate Grown Arroyo Seco $18.00    Fragrant, light and pretty.  - W. Blake Gray
 Critics Silver 2008 Sauvignon Blanc, Estate Grown Arroyo Seco $16.00    Lovely restrained fruit, thankfully gooseberry-juice-free, a fine example of sauvignon blanc purity. - Nick Passmore

Villa Maria
 Critics Platinum 2009 Riesling, Cellar Selection Marlborough $20.00    A very fine and interesting wine with expressive aromas of fresh lemons and green apples and a driving, dry-seeming finish that shows just enough sweetness to avoid seeming overly tart. - Michael Franz
 Critics Gold 2009 Sauvignon Blanc, Private Bin Marlborough $17.00    Light grassy aroma, balanced acidity. Good finish. - Gerald D. Boyd

Villa Mt. Eden
 Critics Silver 2007 Pinot Noir, Grand Reserve, Bien Nacido Vineyard Santa Maria Valley $25.00    Mineral, cedar. Medium fruit, length. - Gerald D. Boyd

Villa San-Juliette Winery
 Critics Gold 2008 Petite Sirah Paso Robles $15.00    Velvety smooth wine with good dark fruit and notes of vanilla.  - W. Blake Gray

Vina del Frade
 Critics Platinum 2007 Ribera Del Duero Spain $8.00    Wood smoke, tobacco, black plum. Rich, pure and composed. Very majestic wine, with exquisite balance and length. - Patrick Comiskey

Vina Robles
 Critics Silver 2008 RED 4, Huerhuero Paso Robles $16.00    Concentrated black fruit with wisps of spicy black pepper. A mouthful with chunky tannins. - Rebecca Murphy
 Critics Gold 2009 WHITE 4, Huerhuero Paso Robles $16.00    Light, floral, delicate, dry, crisp and delightful.   - Rebecca Murphy
 Critics Gold 2007 Petite Sirah, Jardine Paso Robles $26.00    A teeth-stainer wine that throws caution to the wind. It's big, it's bold, it's a beauty.  - Leslie Sbrocco
 Critics Silver 2009 Sauvignon Blanc, Jardine Paso Robles $15.00    Ripe fruity lime nose. Broad, lush, quite full-bodied but not heavy, plenty of fruit here. Moderate length. - Stephen Brook   

Vine Hill
 Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay Santa Cruz Mountains $27.00    Earthy on the nose with bright lemon fruit and some toast on the finish. - W. Blake Gray

Vionta 
 Critics Silver 2008 Albarino, Limited Release Riax Baixas $19.00    Crisp and touched with a hint of spiciness. - Nick Passmore

Vivid Bliss
 Critics Silver NV Blanc de Blancs Brut France $17.00    Easy drinking. - Ed McCarthy

Wagner Vineyards
 Critics Silver 2008 Riesling, Dry Finger Lakes $13.00    The aromas are muted, yet the flavors burst with ripe yellow stone fruit and tangerine flavors. Exceptional acidity level balances the ripe, juicy flavors. - Linda Murphy
 Critics Gold 2008 Riesling, Semi Dry Finger Lakes $13.00    Ripe pink grapefruit and citrus aromas paired with juicy fruit flavors pack this wine. It's a style that will appeal to both lovers of dry whites and those who like a dash of sweetness.  - Leslie Sbrocco

Wente Vineyards
 Critics Silver 2007 Pinot Noir, Reliz Creek Arroyo Seco $25.00    Cranberry fruit with good intensity. - W. Blake Gray
 Critics Gold 2008 Chardonnay, Morning Fog, Estate Grown Livermore Valley $15.00    Has all the bells and whistles -- oak, vanilla, richness and body -- for Chardonnay, and all are in balance, making for a rewarding, mouthful of wine. - Linda Murphy
 Critics Silver 2009 Sauvignon Blanc, Louis Mel Livermore Valley $15.00    Green-flesh melon, pear and tangy citrus make for a crowd-pleasing wine with a full palate impression. - Linda Murphy

Wild Horse Winery
 Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon Paso Robles $20.00    Shows an earthy Cabernet authenticity. - Nick Passmore
 Critics Gold 2007 Merlot Paso Robles $19.00 Powerful fruit, all balance and harmony. - Nick Passmore
 Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Noir Central Coast $25.00    Fresh flavors and a nicely spicy finish mark this attractive Pinot. - Michael Franz
 Critics Gold 2008 Chardonnay Central Coast $17.00    Earthy, lemon fruit, a floral note in the background. Interesting, subtle, sophisticated wine. - W. Blake Gray

William Fevre 
 Critics Platinum 2008 Chablis, Champs Royaux France $23.00    Butter, cream, lime. Palate is all lime and lemon, crisp and appley. Good mineral texture, ideal for oysters. - Patrick Comiskey

Windsor Sonoma
 Critics Gold 2008 Chardonnay Russian River Valley $20.00    Lean tight lemony nose, assertive though subdued now. Firm and rich, with a subtle sweet and sour tone, concentrated and tangy, with some bite and minerality on the finish. Long. - Stephen Brook   

Wine Cube
 Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon California $16.00    Sweet fruit and a long finish. - Paul Lukacs
 Critics Silver 2008 Merlot California $16.00    Very pleasant. An easy-drinking wine. - Ed McCarthy
 Critics Silver 2009 Chardonnay California $16.00    A slightly buttery style, with nicely ripened pear and apple fruit and a caressing mouthfeel. - Linda Murphy
 Critics Silver 2009 Riesling California $16.00    An off-dry Riesling that shows good varietal aromas and a soft but balanced finish. - Michael Franz

Winesmith
 Critics Gold 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon Lodi / Napa Valley $18.00    Pure fruit notes recalling dark cherries and blackberries are vivid and very nicely ripened, with subtle oak edging and a nicely lingering finish that shows impressive symmetry, with all the flavor notes tailing off evenly. - Michael Franz

Wollersheim Winery
 Critics Silver 2009 Prairie Blush Wisconsin $9.00    Light spritz gives the wine life and refreshing energy. - Mary Ewing-Mulligan
 Critics Silver 2009 Prairie Fume American $9.00    Lush and aromatic but with a long, citrus finish. - Nick Passmore
 Critics Silver NV Dry Riesling American $9.00    Slightly herbaceous in the nose, and the palate is all about well-ripened yellow and orange fruit juiciness. Even though it's in the dry category, there is some perceptible sweetness. - Linda Murphy

Woodbridge Winery
 Critics Silver 2009 Muscato California $8.00   Aromatic, nice balance, pretty.  - Elin McCoy
 Critics Gold 2008 Chardonnay California $8.00    A beautiful melange of pear, apple, vanilla aromas and flavors that are incredibly smooth going down. - Rebecca Murphy

Wrath
 Critics Gold 2008 Pinot Noir, San Saba Vineyard Monterey $49.00    Excellent length, with  seductively soft texture. - Paul Lukacs

Wyndham Estate
 Critics Silver 2008 Shiraz, Bin 555 South Eastern Australia $9.00    Opaque, very intense, spicy-blueberry. Spicy oak finish. - Elin McCoy
 Critics Gold 2006 Shiraz, George Wyndham, Founder's Reserve Langhorne Creek $17.00    Minty and gently herbaceous, it screams of cool climate viticulture, and has structure to match. Great acidity balances the deep black fruit, and I enjoy the eucalyptus character. It's not a wine for everyone, but it is for me. - Linda Murphy

Zimmermann
 Critics Silver NV Riesling Germany $10.00    Long finish and nicely balanced flavors. - Elin McCoy

Zontes Footstep
 Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon, Avalon Tree Langhorne Creek $16.00    It tastes sweet but it's not actually.  The suggestion of sweet ripe blackberry is strong. - W. Blake Gray
 Critics Silver 2009 Viognier, Lady of the Lake Langhorne Creek $14.00   Pinot gris like nose. Palate pears, white peaches.  - Patrick Comiskey
 Critics Gold 2009 Verdelho, Sea Mist Langhorne Creek $14.00   An exciting, intense rendition of Verdejo, this shows very expressive aromas of dried herbs and subtle flowers, along with crisp citrus fruit and a very lively, acidic finish.- Michael Franz