|
|
 |
2009 Critics Challenge Award Winners The vote for Wine of the Year is the high point at the end of the long Critics Challenge International Wine Competition weekend. This year, the sixth for the Critics Challenge, was no exception. We had Best of Show winners from five broad categories -- sparkling, rose, red, white and dessert -- lined up for the vote and, as usual, there was a tete de cuvee Champagne blocking the path of the other four contenders. Tetes de cuvee Champagnes have won the Wine of the Year award three times in the previous five Challenges, and one would prove formidable again this year. So it was somewhat of a surprise that the 2000 Perrier-Jouet Fleur de Champagne ($139) was nudged in a close vote. What was stunning about the outcome was the fact that a Petite Sirah -- the 2006 Clayhouse Petite Sirah -- prevailed. This $25 red from Paso Robles won a number of converts in the process, inspiring one judge to comment: "I wouldn't buy Petite Sirah on a bet, but I loved that wine." Count me among those who don't have a strong affection for Petite Sirah, the big, bold, tannic California red that has developed something of a cult following in recent years. I've always liked the Ridge Petite, but have had a rocky relationship with others. I found the Clayhouse an exception to the rule, and was very impressed by its bright berry flavors and supple (all things are relative, so I say supple within the context of a Petite Sirah discussion) tannins. The Perrier-Jouet, of course, was the combination of power and elegance you would expect from a prestige Champagne. Others in the final vote included the 2008 La Cereza Viognier ($25) from Temecula; the 2008 Navarro Rose ($16.50) from Medocino; and the 2007 Navarro Cluster Select Late Harvest Riesling ($59), also from Mendocino, It's worth noting the Navarro Cluster Select also took Best of Show Dessert at the 2009 Monterey Wine Competition.
2009 Critics Challenge Wine of the Year Clayhouse 2006 Petite Sirah, Paso Robles, California Best Sparkling Perrier-Jouet 2000 Fleur de Champagne, France Best White La Cereza 2008 Viognier, Temecula, California Best Rose Navarro 2008 Rose, Mendocino, California Best Dessert Navarro 2007 Late Harvest Riesling, Cluster Select, Mendocino Winery of the Year, Europe Perrier-Jouet, Champagne, France Winery of the Year, Southern Hemisphere Graffigna, San Juan, Argentina Winery of the Year, Eastern U.S. St. James Winery, Missouri Winery of the Year, Western U.S. V. Sattui, Napa Valley, California Importer of the Year Pernod-Ricard, New York, NY 337
Critics Gold 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon Lodi $14.99 Concentrated and complex, this wine still manages to show its softer, stylish side. - Leslie Sbrocco Acordeon
Critics Silver 2008 Torrontes Cafayate Valley $9.00 Classic Torrontes floral aromas -- lilies of the valley and honeysuckle. - Marguerite Thomas Acorn Winery
Critics Silver 2006 Sangiovese, Alegria Vineyards Russian River Valley $26.00 Light American oak aromas, hints of ripe berries. Medium flavors, firm tannins. Short dry finish. - Gerald D. Boyd Ad Lib
Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay, Oaked, Hen and Chicken Western Australia $17.00 An interplay of oak and fruit. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Gold 2008 Chardonnay, No Oak, Tree Hugger Western Australia $17.00 Lots of charm in this wine, with delicate apple and pear overtones and a light, clean finish. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Silver 2008 Riesling, Wallflower Western Australia $17.00 Pleasant, flavorful. Nice finish - Ed McCarthy Adler Fels
Critics Gold 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon Russian River Valley $25.00 Lush, rich style that keeps everything in balance. When a grilled steak calls, this Cab answers. - Leslie Sbrocco Alice White
Critics Silver 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon South Eastern Australia $8.00 Oaky nose, low intensity berry notes. Dry chocolate accents. Medium finish. - Gerald D. Boyd Alta Cima
Critics Gold 2006 Syrah Valle del Lontue $13.95 Delicious! - Ed McCarthy Anam Cara Cellars
Critics Silver 2008 Rose of Pinot Noir, Nicholas Estate Chehalem Mountains $18.00 A plush, full-bodied and rich rose. - Nick Passmore
Critics Gold 2006 Pinot Noir, Mark I Chehalem Mountains $65.00 Tar and dark chocolate over a bed of cherries, it's a darkly compelling wine. - Marguerite Thomas Ancient Peaks Winery
Critics Gold 2006 Merlot Paso Robles $16.00 Some dark cherry fruit on the nose, which is very subdued. Rich, suave, juicy, quite concentrated with no rough edges and a fresh finish. A versatile food wine. - Stephen Brook
Critics Platinum 2007 Sauvignon Blanc Paso Robles $12.00 Toasty appley nose, stylish if lacking some varietal typicity. Quite rich, full-bodied, has weight and spice and considerable complexity, with integrated oak character and sufficient acidity to give it length. Elegant and balanced. - Stephen Brook Angove's
Critics Silver 2007 Shiraz / Viognier, Nine Vines South Australia $10.99 Easy-drinking. Delicious. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2007 Shiraz, Red Belly Black South Australia $11.99 Dry, lean. A good food wine. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2008 Viognier, Nine Vines South Australia $10.99 Aromatic and juicy, this is a viognier to sip as a cocktail or pair with fleshy fish dishes. - Leslie Sbrocco Antler Hill
Critics Platinum 2003 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $48.00 Gorgeous aromatics (because so nuanced and complete), followed by classic Cabernet character on the palate. The fruit tastes ripe but not overtly sweet, and the wine becomes ever more complex in the finish. Simply beautiful to drink. - Paul Lukacs Artezin
Critics Gold 2007 Zinfandel Mendocino County $18.00 Complex aromas of wild berry and wood are followed with a balanced, medium bodied texture. If you want elegant Zin, grab a bottle of this wine. - Leslie Sbrocco Astoria Vini
Critics Silver 2008 Cuvee Tenuta Val de Brun, Millesimato Prosecco di Valdobbiadene DOC $24.00 Lots of flavor. - Ed McCarthy Aurielle Vineyards
Critics Gold 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $90.00 Wonderfully lush and lavish on the palate, with fine balance and an impressively long finish, this is a beautiful wine. The fruit, though, is so ripe that the wine verges on sweetness. - Paul Lukacs AutoMoto
Critics Gold 2006 Chardonnay California $12.99 Fruity, yes, but has a serious side that delivers spiciness and structure. Ideal for the dinner table. - Leslie Sbrocco
Critics Gold 2007 Riesling California $12.99 Golden color, classic petrol in the fragrance, lush in the mouth. - Marguerite Thomas Aver Family Vineyards
Critics Silver 2006 Homage Red Wine Central Coast $35.00 Flavorful but still fresh and even bright, thanks to fine acidity. Red and black berry notes hold their own against a notable dose of smoky oak. - Michael Franz
Critics Gold 2006 Petite Sirah, Blessings Central Coast $55.00 Great flavors. Dry, well-balanced. - Ed McCarthy B.R. Cohn Winery
Critics Silver 2007 Zinfandel, Olive Hill Estate Vineyards Sonoma Valley $38.00 Pretty, restrained style of Zin that will pair well with food. - Leslie Sbrocco Bad Dog Ranch
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay California $8.99 Mineral and citrus nose. Dry medium flavors and finish. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Silver 2006 Pinot Grigio California $8.99 Oaky nose, earthy back note. Bright fruity flavors, tropical note. Clean finish. Stylish. - Gerald D. Boyd Baileyana Winery
Critics Silver 2006 Syrah, Grand Firepeak Cuvee Edna Valley $30.00 Inky blueberry nose, this has charm and lift. Medium-bodied, delicate, not a big fleshy style but has acidity and zest. A crowd-pleaser but none the worse for that. - Stephen Brook Balletto Vineyards
Critics Silver 2006 Pinot Gris, Estate Russian River Valley $14.00 Very nicely balanced -- harmonious. - Paul Lukacs Bandit
Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon California $7.99 Light black cherry nose. Quite rich, solid, juicy and succulent, a touch sweet but not excessively so, and there's a slight but welcome acidic bite on the finish. A quaffing red. - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay California $7.99 There is a good amount of residual sugar in this wine, yet beyond the sweetness, there is good Chardonnay character here, with fresh pear and apple flavors and a slightly creamy close. - Linda Murphy Banfi
Critics Platinum 2005 Belnero, Proprietor's Reserve Toscana $39.00 Very true to type, with rich fruit (cherry) undergirded by flavors that echo dusty spice. While reflecting new styles, it nonetheless tastes genuinely Tuscan, and is both complex and compelling. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2006 Centine Toscana $13.00 Nicely balanced, with bright Tuscan acidity and fresh dark cherry flavors. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2007 Rosa Regale Brachetto d'Acqui $25.00 Quite delicious! - Ed McCarthy Banknote Wine Company
Critics Silver 2006 The Vault Napa Valley $32.00 Very ripe, dark black fruits dominate. - Michael Apstein Barefoot Bubbly
Critics Gold NV Brut Cuvee California $9.99 Dry, clean, lively. Pleasant finish. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver NV Extra Dry California $9.99 Sweetness and fizz judiciously balanced. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Silver NV Pinot Grigio California $10.99 Mineral nose, then a fruity, effervescent palate packed with apple and pear fruitiness. A touch of residual sugar adds to the mouthfeel, and there is a super creaminess to this delicious picnic/poolside sparkler. - Linda Murphy Barefoot Cellars
Critics Silver NV Shiraz California $6.99 Sweet and jammy, with a scent of red raspberry filling. Lots of chewy tannins, a finish of milk chocolate. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Gold NV Zinfandel Lodi $6.99 Packed with hearty Zinfandel personality, this fruity, fresh red is one to stock up on by the case. - Leslie Sbrocco
Critics Silver NV Moscato California $6.99 Honeyed fruit sweetness touched by a distinctive minerality. - Nick Passmore
Critics Silver NV Pinot Grigio California $6.99 Flavorful, rich, well-balanced. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver NV Sauvignon Blanc California $6.99 Ripe citrus and green apple on the nose. Fairly lush and creamy, has some weight of fruit, a touch too heavy to be a refreshing sauvignon, but a satisfying mouthful of fruit. - Stephen Brook Barokes Wines
Critics Silver NV Blanc de Blancs, Vibrant White South Eastern Australia $3.99 Flashes with stony minerality. Very frothy and creamy -- ethereal -- and while it doesn't offer much complexity or structure, it's a fun wine to drink. - Linda Murphy Belasco De Baquedano
Critics Gold 2006 AR Guentota Malbec, Old Vine Mendoza $25.00 Rich smoky nose, plums and coffee. Plump, opulent, broad, dense and chocolatey with a lot of spice if not a great deal of acidity. But excellent fruit quality. Try with chorizo? - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver 2006 Swinto Malbec, Old Vine Mendoza $35.00 Sweet charred blackberry nose. Broad, lush, a touch soupy despite the tannins, but good to drink now, and has reasonable concentration. - Stephen Brook Bella Sera
Critics Gold 2006 Chianti Chianti DOCG $6.99 Dry, classic style. Great finish. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2007 Merlot Delle Venezie $6.99 Toasty and herbal notes atop red fruit. Good structure means it's best with dinner, not as an aperitif Merlot. - Michael Apstein Beringer
Critics Silver 2007 Merlot, California Collection California $6.00 Discreet but ripe cherry aromas. Medium-bodied, suave, light tannins, an attractive and balanced wine though with very little complexity. Drink young. - Stephen Brook Big House
Critics Silver 2008 White California $9.99 Subtle nose, pears and apricot. Medium-bodied, with an appealing juiciness of fruit, not complex but a good mouthful. - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver 2006 Petite Sirah, Prodigal Son Central Coast $14.99 Rich, ripe flavors. Great with Mexican cuisine. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Grigio, Birdman Central Coast $14.99 Smoky oak aromatics. Soft fruit, decent acidity and finish. Stylish. - Gerald D. Boyd Biltmore Estate
Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Reserve Alexander Valley $24.99 Well-structured, with firm but unaggressive tannins and plenty of ripe fruit. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver NV Tempranillo, Limited Release American $18.99 A more delicate expression of tempranillo with red berry fruit, floral notes and pretty! - Leslie Sbrocco
Critics Platinum NV Blanc de Blanc American $24.99 Clean, dry, complex. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay, Reserve Sonoma County $19.99 Pleasant wine leads with a generous note of pear and caramel. The flavors are juicy and ripe, in the realm of pear and peach,with plenty of sweet oak that drives the finish. - Patrick Comiskey Bin 36
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay Monterey $16.00 Sweet but balanced, though definitely should be drunk in the near-term. - Paul Lukacs Bixler Vineyards
Critics Silver 2007 Union Island White California $18.00 Very pretty stone-fruits nose. Lean, delicate, pleasant apricot fruit with a dash of acidity to keep it fresh. Moderate length. - Stephen Brook Black Opal
Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay South Eastern Australia $8.00 This brisk chardonnay leads with a firm mineral scent, slightly flinty and smoky. The flavors are terse and energetic, good mouthwatering acidity. - Patrick Comiskey Black Swan
Critics Silver 2008 Shiraz South Eastern Australia $8.00 Leads with aromas of chocolate frosting, dark, buttery, very sweet. Very generous red raspberry fruit, flashy and rich, simple. - Patrick Comiskey Blackstone Winery
Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay, Sonoma Reserve Sonoma County $16.99 Rich and ripe, with oodles of lavish fruit flavor. - Paul Lukacs Bluenose Wines
Critics Gold 2006 Zinfandel Sonoma County $24.99 Dark, powerful and packed with ripe fruit. - Marguerite Thomas Bonterra Vineyards
Critics Gold 2006 Merlot, Organic Grapes Mendocino County $15.99 Long and lush, with lavish fruit and hints of sweet spice. Yummy! - Paul Lukacs
Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay, Organic Grapes Mendocino County $13.99 Ripe apple and apricot. Straightforward, fresh and bright, with a fruit-driven momentum. - Jon Bonne Bortolomiol
Critics Gold NV Prosecco Brut, Prior Prosecco di Valdobbiadene DOC $14.99 Rich, flavorful; well-made. Delicious. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2007 Bandarossa, Extra Dry, Millesimato Prosecco di Valdobbiadene DOC $21.99 Rich; easy drinking; good food bubbly. - Ed McCarthy Bota Box
Critics Silver 2008 Shiraz California $4.50 A well-made, medium-bodied, well-mannered wine that delivers plenty of rich red/black fruit flavors, with hints of licorice and spice. - Linda Murphy
Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay California $4.50 Has admirable structure and palate-cleansing acidity to go with luscious pear and apple flavors. This is a terrific everyday-drinking wine and great for parties. - Linda Murphy Bouchard Pere & Fils
Critics Gold 2005 Bourgogne, Pinot Noir Burgundy $25.00 Spicy, mid-weight, subtle savory notes atop red fruit. A good wine for salmon. - Michael Apstein Braganini
Critics Silver 2007 Traminette, Michigan Reserve Lake Michigan Shore $14.99 Pleasant peach and and dried apricot flavors, hints of almond, and with a slightly sweet finish. Well-made. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver 2008 Sauvignon Blanc, Reserve Lake Michigan Shore $14.99 I like the assertively grassy nose, followed by the well-ripened fruit on the palate -- lime, pink grapefruit, kiwi fruit and a hint of passionfruit. All it lacks is a more structured, acidic, lengthy finish. - Linda Murphy Brancott Vineyards
Critics Gold 2007 Pinot Noir South Island $12.99 Delicious Pinot, just the right balance of fruit and earth, in an elegant rather than overbearing style. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Grigio South Island $12.99 Flavorful, nice finish. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2008 Sauvignon Blanc, Reserve Marlborough $17.99 An aromatically expressive wine that never quite turns pungent, this is an exciting Sauvignon that won't prove too challenging for those who shy from more intense renditions of this variety. Well grown and nicely crafted. - Michael Franz
Critics Silver 2008 Sauvignon Blanc Marlborough $12.99 Fresh and lifted, with very nice lemon-lime flavors and nicely integrated acidity. - Michael Franz Brassfield Estate
Critics Gold 2005 Eruption, Volcano Ridge High Valley $25.00 Attractive herb and leathery elements in the nose, followed by sweet fruit and fine tannins. Refreshingly midweight wine. Nicely balanced. Ready now. - Michael Apstein
Critics Silver 2007 Serenity High Valley $16.00 Fresh and faintly musky, with orange and apple, and a lanolin overtone. More vibrancy would push it even further. - Jon Bonne
Critics Gold 2005 Petite Sirah, Volcano Ridge High Valley $26.00 Mocha on the nose, then the wine opens to vibrantly fruity richness, with refreshing acidity to balance the huge tannins and toastiness. - Linda Murphy
Critics Gold 2007 Pinot Grigio, High Serenity Ranch High Valley $15.00 Lots of flavor. Well-balanced. A good food wine. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2007 Sauvignon Blanc, High Serenity Ranch High Valley $16.00 Delicate nose, with an appealing herbaceous edge. Lean, silky, lively acidity, finely tuned, with grapefruity flavours. Long and stylish. - Stephen Brook Buried Cane
Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon Washington $15.00 Warm, earthy nose, lots of wood tannin and drying astringency. Very young, needs lots of time. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay Washington $15.00 Pleasantly light and easygoing, with hints of ripe pear and a slight smoky finish. - Marguerite Thomas Burly
Critics Gold 2004 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $60.00 This is delicious Cab for drinking now and over the next four years. Lip-smacking, balanced and vibrant in its cassis/black cherry fruit and oak spice accents. A touch of residual sugar keeps it from a higher score, yet might make it more appealing to some. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $60.00 Black olive and cedar notes add interest to the nicely ripened black cherry and black currant fruit. Beautiful acidity plumps the fruit, and for those who love a chocolatey note to their wines, this one has it. - Linda Murphy Ca' Momi Wines
Critics Silver 2008 Bianco di California California $10.00 Faint nose, ripe apple. Medium-bodied, silky, juicy, an upfront fruity style with just a dash of acidity to keep it fresh. - Stephen Brook Cadaretta
Critics Platinum 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon Columbia Valley $40.00 Lovely cassis nose is followed by cassis, black cherry, forest floor and barrel spice. It's not at all shy, with a very firm backbone, yet has the acidity to balance the intensity of fruit and substantial tannins. A Cab for the long haul. - Linda Murphy Cafe by Gallo Family Vineyards
Critics Gold NV Chardonnay California $5.99 Rich, well-balanced. Delicious. - Ed McCarthy Cakebread Cellars
Critics Silver 2006 Syrah Carneros $51.00 There is plenty of leather in the aromas, with notes of carob and blackberry. Flavors fall into the realm of port, but there is enough lift to balance the ripeness. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay Napa Valley $36.00 A surprisingly lively Chard, with lemony nuances. - Marguerite Thomas Callaway Vineyard and Winery
Critics Gold 2008 Quartet, Winemaker's Reserve Temecula Valley $28.00 Citrus and apple on the nose, has delicacy and charm. Fairly rich, ample fruit, has plenty of weight and some appealing spice on the finish. Good length. - Stephen Brook
Critics Gold 2008 Muscat Canelli, Special Selection California $18.00 Aromas a bit unusual, more savory than fruit-like, but the palate shows a scented pear and orange blossom flavors, the texture fine, the finish long, complex, fine boned. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Gris, Special Selection California $18.00 Clean and crisp -- fun to drink. - Paul Lukacs Camelot
Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon California $8.99 Pretty aromas of black cherry and cola, and a pleasing round finish. - Robert Whitley
Critics Silver 2006 Chardonnay California $8.99 Big and bouncy, loaded with juicy fruit. - Marguerite Thomas Cameron Hughes Wine
Critics Silver 2007 Garnacha, Lot 128 Campo de Borja $20.00 There is plenty of juicy port-like fruit with aromas of smoke and black plum. Flavors are dense as fig bread, with a pleasing bitter black plumskin feel in the mouth. A bit tannic on the back end. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Platinum 2007 Garnacha, Lot 129 Campo de Borja $20.00 Inviting aromas of graham-cracker spice, graphite, black pepper and mocha all in the service of black plum. Its flavors of black cherry jam and tobacco are firmly reined in by smooth gripping tannins and a surprisingly mouthwatering acidity. Nice graphite quality with black cherry. Very inviting. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Gold 2007 Pinot Noir, Lot 110 Los Carneros $18.00 A rich juicy red with robust red cherry and a dark cloak of earthy fruit tannins. Good freshness. What it lacks in grace it makes up for in drive. - Patrick Comiskey Campo Viejo
Critics Gold 2006 Crianza Rioja $9.99 Earthiness and ripe fruit, medium body, a hint of oak -- all of it adds up to a highly quaffable wine. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Gold 2002 Gran Reserva Rioja $20.99 A very nicely balanced Gran Reserva, this is still abundantly furnished with primary fruit, which easily holds its own against the spicy oak. - Michael Franz Campus Oaks
Critics Silver 2007 Zinfandel, Old Vine Lodi $11.99 A compote of sweet red fruits. - Marguerite Thomas Caposaldo
Critics Silver NV Prosecco, VSAQ Brut Veneto $15.00 Flavorful. Pleasant finish. Quite good. - Ed McCarthy Cecchi
Critics Gold 2007 Natio Chianti Chianti DOCG $16.00 Dry, complexly flavored. Try it with pasta and wild boar. - Ed McCarthy Cedar Creek Winery
Critics Gold NV Waterfall Riesling American $9.00 Aromas of orange blossom and pear, with a bracing finish. - Marguerite Thomas Cerro Prieto Vineyard
Critics Gold 2006 Merlot, Reserve Paso Robles $39.00 Big, yet balanced Merlot with cocao nuances and a long, graceful finish. - Michael Apstein Cerruti Cellars
Critics Platinum 2008 Honker Blanc Napa Valley $12.00 This wine has it all -- steely minerality, crisp lemon-lime, granny apple and gooseberry fruit flavors, complex notes of fresh herbs and tangerine, and a long, mouthwatering, citrusy finish. This is a complete -- and completely rewarding -- wine. - Linda Murphy Chandelle
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay Sonoma County $20.00 Oaky nose. Medium fruit, soft structure. Light finish. - Gerald D. Boyd Chateau Chevalier Winery
Critics Gold 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon Spring Mountain District $24.99 Tons of tannin here, though give this youthful wine time and it should mature into something special. Blackcurrant, licorice, vanilla, black pepper and the slightest hint of fresh sage add intriguing complexity to the well-defined fruit. - Linda Murphy Chateau Frank
Critics Gold 2002 Blanc de Blancs Finger Lakes $29.99 Lots of flavor. Dry, but rich. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2002 Blanc de Noirs Finger Lakes $29.99 Slightly muted on the nose, a moist leesy depth and intriguing moss scents but it is a bit weighted down. - Jon Bonne
Critics Gold NV Celebre Rose New York $20.99 Autolytic nose. Rich, ripe red fruit. A flamboyant rose that maintains its manners, with mouthwatering acidity and some biscuity complexity. - Linda Murphy Chateau Julien
Critics Silver 2006 Black Nova Monterey County $78.00 Polished and elegant package of lush ripe fruit and soft, easy tannins. - Nick Passmore Chateau Ste. Michelle
Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Canoe Ridge Estate Horse Heaven Hills $28.00 Perfumed nose, light oak accents; rich berry and chocolate flavors; good length. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Gold 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Cold Creek Vineyard Columbia Valley $30.00 Low intensity nose but with big fruit flavors. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Silver 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon, Ethos Columbia Valley $38.00 Medium oak and fruit. Good texture, blackberry notes. Firm tannins. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Silver 2006 Merlot, Canoe Ridge Estate Horse Heaven Hills $26.00 A charming blend of rich earthiness and plush ripe fruit. - Nick Passmore
Critics Gold 2006 Merlot, Ethos Columbia Valley $38.00 An appealing combination of polished sophistication and zesty fruit exuberance. - Nick Passmore Cheapskate
Critics Silver 2005 Chenin Blanc, Surly Clarksburg $10.00 Tangy and boisterous, with a dry, edgy apple-tinged profile that's just right for seafood. - Jon Bonne Chesterfield Cellars
Critics Silver 2005 Brett's Barrel Blend Santa Ynez Valley $39.00 Berry and black plum fruit notes are pure and very nicely ripened, with fine-grained tannins that keep the finish soft and smooth in texture. - Michael Franz
Critics Gold 2005 Pinot Noir Sta. Rita Hills $45.00 Lightly floral, with orange peel, raspberries. Very elegant. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Gold 2005 Syrah, Murphy's Reserve Santa Ynez Valley $45.00 Delightful! - Ed McCarthy Christian Moueix
Critics Silver 2005 Merlot Encore Bordeaux $13.00 Sturdy red fruits nose. Quite rich, full-bodied, concentrated, some weight of fruit, peppery and lively, but a touch raw. Give it another year in bottle. - Stephen Brook Christopher Cameron Vineyards
Critics Gold 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Lambert Bridge Vineyard Dry Creek Valley $26.00 Sleek, racy Cabernet that sparkles with vibrancy. For those who crave a red to complement food, not overwhelm it, this is the one. - Leslie Sbrocco Chrysalis Vineyards
Critics Gold 2005 Norton Virginia $16.00 Vibrantly fresh and lively, with terrific acidity and mouthwateringly juicy wild berry fruit. Pure and focused. - Linda Murphy
Critics Gold 2008 Albarino Virginia $24.00 The ripeness is more present in this wine, scents of pear and vanilla. Fairly rich, with flavors of pineapple and a rich round texture, more oak driven than most albarinos. Excellent example of a rich style. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Gold 2008 Viognier Virginia $29.00 With New World fruit ripeness and full-bodied flare, this is a Viognier for lovers of lush. - Leslie Sbrocco Clayhouse Vineyard
Critics Silver 2008 Adobe White Central Coast $14.00 Chive, nectarine and a steely citrus core. A syrupy note on the latter half provides curious weight. - Jon Bonne
Wine of the Year 2006 Petite Sirah Paso Robles $25.00 A lip-smacking Petite Sirah that relies on crackling-crisp acidity to counter the dense black fruit and substantial tannins. Loaded with ripe, juicy blackberry and black plum fruit, licorice and subtle dried-herb complexity, with that racy acidity close. - Linda Murphy
Critics Gold 2006 Syrah Paso Robles $15.00 In a ripe style, leading with forward fruit aromas of black fig and black plum. Flavors fall more into black cherry and mocha, finishes with a note of carob and leather. A big wine, but with enough juiciness to lift the wine off the ground. - Patrick Comiskey Cline Cellars
Critics Silver 2007 Zinfandel California $11.99 Charred plum, with cranberry highlights and a citrusy twinge. Straightforward and balanced, with a big tannic load giving some whomp to the finish. - Jon Bonne Clos Du Bois
Critics Silver 2004 Marlstone Alexander Valley $50.00 Ripe and pleasantly sweet fruit recalls black cherries and dark berries, with subtle wood accents. - Michael Franz
Critics Gold 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Sonoma Reserve Alexander Valley $21.99 Intense aromas of cassis and blueberry, supported by fine dusty tannins. - Robert Whitley
Critics Silver 2006 Merlot, Sonoma Reserve Alexander Valley $21.99 A luscious and seductive approach is kept honest by ripe, soft tannic structure. - Nick Passmore
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay, Sonoma Reserve Russian River Valley $16.99 A bright, lively rendition of America's most popular white varietal. Great for warm weather sipping. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Gold 2007 Calcaire Russian River Valley $24.99 Lushly textured, but enhanced by bright acidity in the fresh, so simultaneously rich and refreshing. - Paul Lukacs Cockerell Family Wine Estates
Critics Silver 2007 Sauvignon Blanc, Terroir Coquerel Napa Valley $37.00 Rich but oily nose, which probably derives from oak; heady peach syrup aromas. Full-bodied, a tad heavy, but there is a good mouthful of fruit here, even if it's hard to spot as Sauvignon. - Stephen Brook Cocobon
Critics Silver 2006 Cocobon 75 Central Coast $12.99 Fresh red and black raspberry fruit notes work well with delicate, fine-grained tannins. - Michael Franz Concannon Vineyard
Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Selected Vineyard Central Coast $10.00 Proper, bright red cherry and currant, with a grippy, leafy definition. - Jon Bonne
Critics Gold 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Reserve Livermore Valley $25.00 Lilac, musk, sandalwood and cocoa for accents, with a core of juicy, delicious red berry and refined tannins. An eloquent, pretty Cabernet. - Jon Bonne
Critics Gold 2007 Merlot, Selected Vineyard Central Coast $10.00 Soft and supple, with genuine red varietal character-- just what Merlot should be (and too often is not). - Paul Lukacs
Critics Gold 2005 Merlot, Reserve Livermore Valley $25.00 Impressive structure, with firm tannins to give the wine grip, and real depth of flavor -- all too rare with this varietal these days. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Gold 2006 Petite Sirah, Limited Release Central Coast $15.00 Well-done. Restrained, quite elegant. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2005 Petite Sirah, Reserve Livermore Valley $38.00 Rich, tannic, dry. Try it with roast beef. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2006 Petite Sirah, Captain Joe's Livermore Valley $30.00 Flavorful, dry, well-balanced. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2006 Petite Sirah, Nina's Cuvee Livermore Valley $30.00 Well-balanced. Dry. Pleasant finish - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2004 Petite Sirah, Heritage Livermore Valley $49.99 Elegant, well-balanced. Nice texture - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2006 Syrah, Reserve Livermore Valley $25.00 Muted plummy aromas, with appealing weight of fruit. Broad, lush, rounded, not hugely concentrated but has some light tannins. Not much length but lavish and generously fruity. - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay, Selected Vineyard Central Coast $10.00 Snappy apple and a lean textural grip give it some pretty energy. - Jon Bonne
Critics Gold 2008 Sauvignon Blanc, Selected Vineyard Central Coast $10.00 A pungent aromatic note recalling dried herbs is pleasant and not too assertive, leading into ctirus fruit ntoes that are quite fresh and pleasant. True to the variety but intelligently styled in a way that can make it appealing for casual consumers as well as Sauvignon devotees. - Michael Franz
Critics Gold 2008 Sauvignon Blanc, Reserve Monterey County $18.00 Pretty grapefruit nose, with a slight grassiness that's appealing. Bright, fresh, lively, zesty, with some lemon rind tartness. Not complex, but pure and varietal and refreshing. - Stephen Brook Conn Creek Winery
Critics Silver 2005 Anthology Napa Valley $54.00 Soft and sweet but undeniably tasty, this is centered on plum and bing cherry fruit, with just a little whiff of wood on the margins. - Michael Franz
Critics Silver 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon, Limited Release Napa Valley $28.00 Subtle oak and berry aromas, green note; medium flavors, firm tannins; medium finish. - Gerald D. Boyd Cook's
Critics Gold NV Extra Dry California $4.99 Delicate and slightly fruity--makes one think of strawberries and cream, with just enough effervescence to keep it refreshing. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Gold NV Spumante California $4.99 Well-done! Clean, well-balanced. Delicious. - Ed McCarthy Corbett Canyon
Critics Silver NV Merlot California $10.00 Fine structure, voluptuous dark cherry flavors, and palate-cleansing acidity, with a gently leafy herbaceousness. Has a slightly sweet, mouthfilling finish. - Linda Murphy
Critics Gold NV Chardonnay California $10.00 Smells like a ripe pippin apple, with similar palate focus. Deliciously juicy and fruity, with a lively, palate-cleansing finish. - Linda Murphy Crooked Vine
Critics Silver 2007 Charve Livermore Valley $22.00 Spicy nose, peach and cooked pineapple. Soft and rounded, pleasant fruit, but lacks the energy that more acidity would have given it. But the residual sugar is well integrated and this is balanced. Quite long. - Stephen Brook
Critics Gold 2005 Petite Sirah Livermore Valley $34.00 Super-extracted, heady, but not excessively hot. A muscle-car sort of wine. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay Livermore Valley $22.00 Oaky nose with buttery notes. Soft palate, dry medium fruit with mineral accents to a light finish. - Gerald D. Boyd Cupcake
Critics Platinum 2007 Merlot Central Coast $13.99 Sweet (plum and cherry) fruit, but in no sense excessive because of the firm tannic structure, and impressively -- deliciously -- long and layered in the finish. A delectable example of the type. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2007 Petite Sirah Central Coast $13.99 Get past the massive tannins in this wine and there is an underlay of well-ripened black fruit -- dark cherry and plum. Slightly earthy and ragged now, it likely will see its edges softened with cellaring. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay Central Coast $13.99 Big butter notes upfront but then some pithy lemon and apple skin arrive, bringing a pleasant lift. - Jon Bonne Curtis Winery
Critics Silver 2006 Heritage Cuvee Santa Barbara County $20.00 Solid wine, easy to recommend; balanced mixture of herbs and red fruit. Mild tannins allow you to enjoy it now. - Michael Apstein
Critics Gold 2006 Syrah, Ambassador's Vineyard Santa Ynez Valley $22.00 Well done. Complex; well-balanced. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2006 Syrah, Vogelzang Vineyard Santa Ynez Valley $24.00 Well-balanced. A good food wine - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2006 Syrah, Crossroads Vineyard Santa Ynez Valley $32.00 Complex, well-balanced. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2007 Viognier Santa Ynez Valley $22.00 Curvaceous is a good word especially when it applies to Viognier. This one is round, juicy and full of style. - Leslie Sbrocco Cycles Gladiator
Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon California $10.00 Medium berry aroma, tart acidity, low level fruit. Pleasant finish. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Silver 2007 Syrah Central Coast $10.00 Light but ripe cherry aromas. Medium-bodied, a bit light and simple, but no rough edges. Good value. - Stephen Brook
Critics Platinum 2006 Chardonnay Central Coast $10.00 Very well-focused, with bright fruit flavor that remains fresh and lively as the wine exhibits excellent balance. Well-done, and a superb value! - Paul Lukacs D.H. Lescombes
Critics Silver 2007 Renaissance, Limited Release New Mexico $29.00 Very ripe nose, ripe black fruit. Succulent. Mild tannins allow you to drink it tonight with a steak. - Michael Apstein Dancing Bull
Critics Gold 2007 Zinfandel California $12.00 A zesty Zin that makes you smile. Juicy, fleshy and fun to sip with everything from burgers to BBQ. - Leslie Sbrocco DaVinci
Critics Platinum 2005 Chianti Classico Chianti Classico $24.00 Great Chianti. Complex, dry. Excellent fruit. - Ed McCarthy Davis Bynum Winery
Critics Gold 2006 Chardonnay Russian River Valley $35.00 Brazen oak says 'look at me' but with a complexity that delivers far more than just wood. Fruit is ripe and lush and the texture is mouth filling. A delicious drink. - Leslie Sbrocco Debonne Vineyards
Critics Platinum 2008 Riesling Grand River Valley $10.99 Well-done; flavorful; complex - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2007 Riesling, Reserve Lot 007 Grand River Valley $14.99 Rich and mellifluous. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Silver 2008 Riesling, Reserve Grand River Valley $11.99 Pleasant peach and tangerine fruit notes lead the way in this wine, which finishes with just enough acidity to freshen the considerable sweetness. - Michael Franz Diseno
Critics Silver 2007 Malbec Mendoza $10.99 Delicate nose, cherry and mint. Medium-bodied, supple, easygoing, not much depth of flavour, but lightly tannic and a fresh finish. A good summer red. - Stephen Brook Domaine Carneros
Critics Gold 2006 Pinot Noir, Famous Gate Carneros $68.00 Similar nose to 019 and 020. Same producer? Riper still and now with complexity with savory components that flow into an exceptional finish. Not just sweet cherry juice. - Michael Apstein
Critics Silver 2005 Brut Carneros $26.00 Full of flavor and quite soft in texture, this then shows a lifted finish when the effervescence and acidity kick in to counterbalance a light sweetness. - Michael Franz
Critics Silver NV Brut Rose, Cuvee de la Pampadour Carneros $36.00 Fresh and lively, with delicate strawberry and currant flavors. What it lacks in complexity, it delivers in an charm and cheerful fruitiness. - Linda Murphy
Critics Gold 2003 Le Reve, Blanc de Blanc Carneros $85.00 This is a delicate, classy sparkler that shows a very impressive balance between soft, broad texture and linear energy. Expressive but still restrained and long, this is a very tastefully styled sparkler. - Michael Franz Domaine Laurier
Critics Silver 2004 Cabernet Sauvignon, Reserve Sonoma County $12.99 Very seductive, in a contemporary ripe (sweet) style. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Gold 2006 Merlot, Reserve Sonoma County $12.99 An earthy style, with pleasant dried herb aromas. Blueberry, plum and dried-tea notes toward the finish. A subtle lift and juiciness give it potential. - Jon Bonne Domaine Ste. Michelle
Critics Silver NV Blanc de Blancs Columbia Valley $13.00 Good, medium-weight bubbly. - Ed McCarthy Domenico Wines
Critics Silver 2005 Zinfandel Russian River Valley $28.00 Deep bramble berry aroma; sweet fruit, medium palate, tart acidity. - Gerald D. Boyd Don Ernesto
Critics Platinum 2008 Vin Gris Rose Napa Valley $14.00 Polished, elegant and distinguished. - Nick Passmore Doukenie Winery
Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Franc Virginia $21.00 Fresh, lively fruit nicely balanced by an appealing earthy spiciness. - Nick Passmore
Critics Silver 2007 Merlot Virginia $33.00 Bright, ripe cherry-flavored fruit wih soft, supple tannins. Tasty. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2007 Sangiovese Virginia $30.00 Forward smoky oak and dark berry nose. Ripe flavors, firm tannins, good length. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Gold 2007 Syrah Virginia $34.00 Lush plummy nose, with a whiff of oak and vanilla. Lush, opulent, tannic, broad-shouldered, a big brawny style with plenty of tannin. There's no elegance here, but a hefty mouthful of fruit. Try it with venison. - Stephen Brook Dow's
Critics Platinum 2006 Vale Do Bomfim Douro Valley $12.00 Dark chocolate, cherries, a hint of earthiness, and soft, grainy tannins. It's a red wine lover's delight. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Gold NV 20 Year Tawny Port Douro Valley $56.00 Figs and caramel on the nose. Sweet, supple, tangy acidity, caramelised oranges, but lacks a little grip. Still, well balanced and attractive. - Stephen Brook Dr. Konstantin Frank Wine Cellars
Critics Silver 2007 Gewurztraminer Reserve Finger Lakes $24.99 Gewurz fruit aroma. Noticeable sweetness with good acidity. Medium finish. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Gold 2007 Riesling, Semi-Dry Finger Lakes $14.99 Lots of flavor. Delicious. Try it with Asian cuisine. - Ed McCarthy Duck Shack
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay Oakville $24.00 Not overly complex but showcases elegance and gentleness. A wine for delicate dishes. - Leslie Sbrocco Dutcher Crossing Winery
Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Proprietor's Reserve Dry Creek Valley $29.00 Savory nose, vine-ripe black cherry, sweet vanillin oak, and an interesting pine-needle note. Firmly tannic, a bit astringent now, yet textbook Cabernet. - Linda Murphy
Critics Platinum 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon, Taylor Reserve Dry Creek Valley $41.00 Smooth and polished, with deep black fruit and dusty, gently herbal notes. This is is a muscular wine -- perhaps made from mountain grapes? -- yet also keenly balanced and cellarworthy. Drink until 2018. - Linda Murphy
Critics Gold 2007 Zinfandel, Maple Vineyard Dry Creek Valley $40.00 A summer time BBQ wine for ribs and chicken. Sweet cherry fruit on nose with spicy, licorice notes on finish. Balanced and smooth. - Leslie Sbrocco
Critics Silver 2007 Zinfandel, Bernier Sibary Vineyard Dry Creek Valley $39.00 Briary, wild berry nose with hint of fresh herbal notes. Smooth and medium-full bodied. - Leslie Sbrocco
Critics Platinum 2007 Chardonnay, Stuhlmuller Vineyard Alexander Valley $34.00 For lovers of full-bodied beauties, this oaky but balanced Chardonnay with toasty notes and richness is stylized but not over the top. - Leslie Sbrocco
Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay, Saralee Russian River Valley $30.00 Pretty style with soft mouthfeel, juicy fruit and fresh aromas. A poolside sipper - Leslie Sbrocco
Critics Gold 2007 Sauvignon Blanc Dry Creek Valley $22.00 Full-bodied, lush tropical fruit supported by bracing acidity. Juicy pineapple, lemon and tangerine flavors, a touch of pleasant lemon pith and perhaps some residual sugar. It's a crowd-pleasing wine, made in a very drinkable style. - Linda Murphy Eberle Winery
Critics Gold 2007 Cotes-du-Robles Paso Robles $20.00 Riper style but not overdone. Succulent fruit complemented by hint of black peppers and smoke. Lush finish. Fine tannins balance the fruit. Easy to enjoy now. - Michael Apstein
Critics Silver 2008 Cotes-du-Robles Blanc Paso Robles $24.00 A rich wine, with aromas of golden pear, and a hint of apricot and golden syrup. Flavors are rich with a broad peachy note, somewhat oak driven, some heat mars the finish slightly. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Gold 2007 Barbera, Steinbeck and Christian-Lazo Vineyards Paso Robles $25.00 Great fruit. Delicious. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2007 Sangiovese Paso Robles $22.00 Smoky oak, low intensity fruit; rich texture, mouth coating, big fruit; good balance and length - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Gold 2008 Chardonnay Paso Robles $18.00 A well balanced, medium bodied wine designed to go with food--no extraneous oak or overabundant fruit, just plain deliciousness. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Silver 2008 Viognier, Mill Road Vineyard Paso Robles $20.00 Soft and easy to drink with floral and tropical fruit aromas. - Leslie Sbrocco Educated Guess
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay Napa Valley $16.99 Nicely balanced, with a crisp finish so that the ripe fruit never seems fat or flabby. - Paul Lukacs Edward's Block
Critics Silver 2007 Sauvignon Blanc, Reserve Napa Valley $23.00 Appley nose, more reminiscent of Chardonnay than Sauvignon. Medium-bodied, fresh, has an appealing light touch, delicate and balanced, though not a great deal of personality or typicity. - Stephen Brook El Portillo
Critics Silver 2007 Malbec Mendoza $9.99 Sweet oaky black cherry nose, has some vibrancy. Plump, sumptuous, concentrated, but just lacks a ltitle little and freshness. But admirable density of fruit and a long leathery finish. Not for long ageing, though. - Stephen Brook Estraie
Critics Silver 2007 Sauvignon Blanc North Coast $20.00 Oily nose. Broad, quite rich, fleshy, full-bodied, with a little acidity to refresh it and give some length of flavour. But lacks typicity. - Stephen Brook |
|
Falkner Winery
Critics Gold 2005 Amante, Special Selection South Coast $39.95 A good brickish color, aromas of iron, brown sugar, dried blood. It has an aged quality, and flavors are muted - this is not a fruit bomb, but rather a quiet and savory wine with an angular structure, fine tannins, modest sweetness. It feels like a fine aged Chianti. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Platinum 2007 Sauvignon Blanc, Estate Temecula Valley $18.95 Crackling acidity gives this wine al almost spiritzy mouthfeel. Full-flavored, and assertive in a positive way, with fresh green herbs, gooseberry and passionfruit leading the way. It's a mouthful of deep, lively, expressive fruit, with a rapier acidic finish. Oysters, anyone? - Linda Murphy Fallbrook Winery
Critics Silver 2006 Syrah, 33 Degrees North, Gracie Hill Estate Vineyard South Coast $30.00 Firm plummy nose. Supple, juicy, not a super-concentated style, but reasonably fresh. Lightweight for Syrah but well balanced. - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay, Sleepy Hollow Vineyard Monterey $25.00 Sweet, with a vanilla quality that enhances the sweet, tropical fruit. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Platinum 2008 Sauvignon Blanc, Reserve Monterey $16.00 Attractive lime nose. Rich and ripe, succulent, plenty of fruit here, and enough citric acidity to give it zest and length. Tangy and refreshing, and a bracing dry finish. - Stephen Brook Faustino
Critics Gold 2002 Reserva Rioja $21.49 Notes of dried and stewed cherries form the core of this wine's aromas and flavors, along with very appealing accents of saddle leather and vanilla. The fine-grained tannins are well tuned to the weight of the fruit, offering some firming but no drying in the wine's finish. - Michael Franz Fetzer Vineyards
Critics Silver 2007 Merlot, Valley Oaks California $8.99 Simple but seductive. Fun to sip. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Gold 2008 Chardonnay, Valley Oaks California $8.99 A sophisticated chardonnay. Melon, peach and fig flavors, and a good finish. - Marguerite Thomas Fiftyrow
Critics Gold 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $60.00 Very lush and opulent, with super-ripe, chocolate-tinged fruit flavors, and a long, sweet finish. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Gold 2005 Syrah Napa Valley $30.00 Complex, well-balanced. - Ed McCarthy Fire Station Red
Critics Gold 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon Central Coast $15.00 Black fruit, black olive and black tar/creosote mark this big, intense Cab. The tannins are tight and puckery now, yet this wine holds great promise for cellaring. - Linda Murphy Firehose
Critics Silver 2007 Gewurztraminer California $15.99 Low intensity spicy aroma. Medium sweetness but low fruit through medium finish. - Gerald D. Boyd Fish Eye
Critics Silver 2007 Shiraz California $17.99 Flamboyantly fruity, with ripe black cherry and wild berry flavors, with hints of cola. There is tons of mouthfilling flavor here, with complexity coming from black olive and leafy herb notes. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay California $17.99 Simple, clean, straightforward in its rewarding pear and apple flavors. Significant residual sugar gives the wine good mouthfeel, though the sugar is a bit too much for a higher score. - Linda Murphy
Critics Platinum 2008 Pinot Grigio California $17.99 A vibrant, mouthwatering wine with floral aromas and Meyer lemon and apple flavors, plus a hint of green melon. For those seeking richness, it's not here; for those seeking refreshment and food compatibility, this wine has them in spades. - Linda Murphy Five Rivers
Critics Gold 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon Paso Robles $10.99 Fruit-filled and generous, with tobacco hints on the nose, lots of cocoa-edged plum and a rich, round finish. - Jon Bonne
Critics Silver 2007 Pinot Noir California $13.99 Simple and chewy, with notes of green herb and red cherry; finish firm. - Patrick Comiskey Fleur de California
Critics Silver 2007 Pinot Noir Central Coast $15.00 Ripe red--raspberyy-like--fruit with smoky notes. A hint of woodsy flavors adds interest. - Michael Apstein Flora Springs Winery
Critics Gold 2006 Merlot Napa Valley $24.00 Earthy, attractive slightly funky element is a great counterpoint to succulent red fruits. Long and elegant. This is a classy wine. - Michael Apstein Flying Fish
Critics Silver 2007 Merlot Washington $14.99 Meaty aromas, 'not just fruit' nuances add intrigue to succulent black fruit flavors. - Michael Apstein
Critics Silver 2008 Riesling Washington $12.99 Sweet, soft fruit recalling baked apples and poached pears. - Michael Franz Flying Winemaker
Critics Gold 2007 Zinfandel, Ancient Vine Lodi $13.99 Light fruity aroma, raspberry and spice. Medium fruit and tannins. Long balanced finish. A Claret style Zin. - Gerald D. Boyd Fonterutoli
Critics Gold 2006 Chianti Classico Chianti Classico $28.49 Complex, well-balanced. Very fine. - Ed McCarthy Forest Glen
Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Noir California $11.99 Cassis and blueberry. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Silver 2008 Gewurztraminer California $8.99 Light gewurtz aroma. Sweet, hint of bitterness with medium fruit. Lacks varietal distinction. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Gold 2008 Pinot Grigio California $11.99 Ginger ale aroma. Medium texture and fruit. Balanced acidity, length. - Gerald D. Boyd Four Bears Winery
Critics Gold 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Sean Minor Napa Valley $17.00 A fine balance of dark berry fruit, hints of spice and a invigorating backbone of fine minerality. - Nick Passmore
Critics Silver 2006 Merlot, Sean Minor Napa Valley $17.00 Supple and soft on the palate, with sweet cherry fruit. - Paul Lukacs Frank Family Vineyards
Critics Silver 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $45.00 Nicely balanced and impressively structured. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay, Lewis Vineyard Carneros $40.00 On the sweet side, but a pleasant forward chardonnay all about vanilla scents and apple blossom. Flavors are rich and sweet with a mildly bitter finish. - Patrick Comiskey Frenchhouse
Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay Vin De Pays D'Oc $9.99 Young fruity aroma, spicy notes. Dry light fruit, medium finish. - Gerald D. Boyd Fresno State Winery
Critics Platinum 2004 Petite Sirah, Doarte Vineyard, Lindan Hills San Joaquin County $14.95 Classic Petite Sirah character, filled with briary, brambly fruit and spice, with a hint of Rhone-like earth, and a long finish. The wine impresses especially because for all its muscle and power, it never seems hot or heavy. A delicious barbecue partner! - Paul Lukacs
Critics Platinum 2006 Syrah, Saviez Vineyard Fresno County $22.95 Complex. Well-balanced. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2006 Solare California $29.95 Light gold. Sweet and creamy, juicy and voluptuous, and overall a tad heavy, but the fruit is peachy and sufficiently bright to keep it from being cloying, even though the wine could use a touch more acidity. - Stephen Brook G.H. Mumm
Critics Gold NV Cordon Rouge Champagne $35.00 Focused and nicely structured, with penetrating flavors and impressive persistency in the finish. The aromas are admirably complex, with fruit notes pleasantly intermingled with yeasty notes. - Michael Franz Gallo Family Vineyards
Critics Gold NV White Zinfandel, Twin Valley California $4.99 Imagine biting into sweet watermelon and tangy bing cherries. That's what sipping this wine is like. Chill well and enjoy on a summer day. - Leslie Sbrocco
Critics Silver NV Merlot, Twin Valley California $4.99 Succulent black fruit flavors dominate; spice lurks in the background - Michael Apstein
Critics Gold NV Chardonnay, Twin Valley California $4.99 A chardonnay sure to please. With ripe, juicy fruit flavors and a kick of freshness, it's a wine for dining and drinking. - Leslie Sbrocco Garfield Estates Winery
Critics Gold 2007 Cabernet Franc Grand Valley $16.99 Richly seductive. - Nick Passmore Geyser Peak Winery
Critics Gold 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon, Walking Tree Alexander Valley $25.00 Medium intensity French oak and berry. Dense fruity flavors. Balanced, good length and structure. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Silver 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon Alexander Valley $18.00 Deep spicy oak nose, low intensity berry notes; light to medium flavors, soft finish. - Gerald D. Boyd Glen Ellen
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay California $5.99 Honeyed and clean. Functions mostly upfront but the bright fruit keeps up the pace. - Jon Bonne Gloria Ferrer
Critics Platinum 2006 Pinot Noir, Estate Grown Carneros $28.00 Absolute harmony, red currant/cassis fruit, silky-smooth texture with a good grip on the finish. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Gold 2004 Pinot Noir, Jose S. Ferrer Selection Carneros $35.00 Finely tuned, just the right amount of red berry and cherry flavors. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Gold 2004 Pinot Noir, Rust Rock Terrace Vineyard Carneros $40.00 Nice fruit flavors, complex and delicatly balanced. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Gold 2004 Pinot Noir, Gravel Knob Vineyard Carneros $40.00 Delicious mouthfilling flavors, chocolate and cherries, hints of black olive, - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Silver 2005 Syrah, Estate Grown Carneros $19.00 Quite delicious. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2004 Blanc de Blancs Carneros $24.00 Rich; harmonious. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Platinum NV Blanc de Noirs Carneros $20.00 Fresh nectar, dough and strawberry. Bit on the creamy side but beautifully focused, with some real weight to it and a refined bead. - Jon Bonne
Critics Gold NV Brut Sonoma County $20.00 Complex, lots of flavor. Exceptional. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 1998 Carneros Cuvee Carneros $50.00 A rather dramatic sparkler, this shows impressive depth of flavor but also plenty of acidity in the finish that keeps it from seeming heavy or overblown. - Michael Franz Gnarly Head
Critics Gold 2007 Zinfandel, Old Vine Lodi $11.99 Classically styled, big and bold. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay California $11.99 Light aroma with subtle fruit notes. Bright entry, medium fruit. Dry light finish. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Grigio California $11.99 Very light, clean aroma. Brisk acidity, light tropical-citrus flavors. Crisp finish. - Gerald D. Boyd Godwin Family Vineyards
Critics Platinum 2003 Merlot Sonoma Valley $35.00 Lovely leafy and slight chocolate nuances intertwined with red fruit make this supple wine very appealing. Long suave finish. This is very classy wine! - Michael Apstein
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay, Floral Clone Russian River Valley $28.00 Lush fruit aromas wrapped in a full bodied texture. Little hot on finish. - Leslie Sbrocco Gordon Brothers Cellars
Critics Gold 2005 Syrah, Estate Grown Columbia Valley $20.00 A well made wine in a ripe style, leading with smoky oak, notes of olive skin overlaying plum pudding. Flavors are chocolatey and ripe, lots of sugar and plenty of oak on the back end. - Patrick Comiskey Graffigna
Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Centenario San Juan $12.99 Well-structured, with dark fruit and a long finish. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Platinum 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon, Grand Reserve San Juan $19.99 An elegant, genteel Cabernet, marked much more by finesse than muscle, with an attractive hint of dusty earth in the finish. Delicious because very harmonious. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Gold 2005 Malbec, Grand Reserve San Juan $19.99 Dense smoky oaky nose, quite leathery. Lush, juicy, super-ripe but not jammy, suave tannins and light acidity, complex and vigorous, with a long fresh finish. Great with roast beef. - Stephen Brook
Critics Gold 2008 Pinot Grigio, Centenario San Juan $12.99 Quite tasty, excellent fruit. - Ed McCarthy Graham's
Critics Platinum NV Six Grapes Port, Reserve Porto $23.00 A beautiful example of type, with ripe fruit but also plenty of spicy depth. Could be confused with a young vintage Port, though with less tannin so definitely more accessible. Bring on the stilton! - Paul Lukacs Grizzly Republic
Critics Silver 2005 Barbera Amador County $35.00 Delicious. Perhaps a bit too ripe. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Platinum 2006 Tempranillo El Dorado $35.00 A fuller, modern style of Tempranillo with sleek smoothness, a kick of licorice and dark berry fruit notes. Has the wine chops to pair with veal chops, lamb chops, and pork chops. - Leslie Sbrocco Hacienda Altavina
Critics Gold 2008 Carmenere Chile $4.99 Very well-structured, with distinct varietal character but no excessive weediness. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2008 Sauvignon Blanc Chile $4.99 Rather ripe and soft, but still pleasingly crisp and energetic, thanks to a freshening streak of acidity in the finish. - Michael Franz Hagafen Cellars
Critics Silver 2007 Pinot Noir Napa Valley $32.00 A light wine, gives off a faint red cherry scent with a hint of orange peel. Palate flavors are firm and direct red cherry, a touch austere for food. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Gold 2008 White Riesling, Devoto Vineyard Lake County $18.00 Fruit notes of mandarin orange and tangerine are vivid and very tempting, and the wine finishes clean despite a notable sweetness that marks the finish. - Michael Franz
Critics Silver 2008 White Riesling, Mayeri Vineyard Napa Valley $24.00 Sweetness balanced by citrus. - Marguerite Thomas Hahn Estates
Critics Silver 2007 Syrah Central Coast $14.00 Sweet black cherry nose. Soft, plump, rounded, light tannins, a fruit-forward style with enough acidity to give it some lift. No depth of flavour but enjoyable. Drink with charcuterie. - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay Monterey $14.00 Sweet and lush on the plate, with a hearty dollop of oak flavor. - Paul Lukacs Hahn SLH
Critics Platinum 2007 Pinot Noir Santa Lucia Highlands $29.00 Black cherry showing full ripeness, grounded by a hint of tar and earth. The palate flavors are all about velvety red cherry, mouthfilling, explosive, powerful and dark, about as pushed as pinot can get, yet it stays on the rails. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Silver 2006 Chardonnay Santa Lucia Highlands $25.00 A heady, powerful expression of Chardonnay, full of tropical fruit flavor and a full measure of wood. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Gold 2007 Pinot Gris Santa Lucia Highlands $20.00 Rich and ripe but also delightfully refreshing. - Paul Lukacs Hall Wines
Critics Platinum 2006 Merlot Napa Valley $28.00 Solid, straightforward red fruit, with a char and cocoa finish. A leathery profile gives it depth, with muscular structure that emerges on the finish. - Jon Bonne
Critics Silver 2008 Sauvignon Blanc Napa Valley $20.00 A softer, riper style of Sauvignon than is the international norm these days, this is nevertheless true to the variety and sufficiently fresh to be very versatile as a partner for food or for stand-alone sipping. - Michael Franz Handley Cellars
Critics Gold 2006 Pinot Noir Anderson Valley $30.00 Gentle strawberry, adorned by a mild dusting of fresh herbs and tar. Light, clean, high toned fruit, strawberry and herb - not much acid but persistent all the same. Very pretty in a feminine style. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Gold 2006 Pinot Noir, Holmes Ranch Anderson Valley $46.00 Ripe cherry jam fruit aromas, hint of brown sugar. Flavors are extremely ripe and forward, as sweet as strawberry jam, but enough acid to support that fruit. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Gold 2006 Syrah, Handley Vineyard Dry Creek Valley $20.00 Dense plummy nose. Rich, broad, generous, mouth-filling, fine-grained tannins and nicely concentrated, with some refreshing acidity on the finish. Balanced, and would work well with veal or guinea-fowl. - Stephen Brook
Critics Gold 2007 Gewurztraminer Anderson Valley $18.00 Richly balanced, with pineapple and fruit flavors flooding the palate, and a mineral enhanced finish. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Silver 2007 Sauvignon Blanc Dry Creek Valley $15.00 A smoky oak note offers additional complexity on top of the melon and citrus fruit notes. - Michael Franz Harbes Family Vineyard
Critics Silver 2008 Rose, Red Horse North Fork of Long Island $17.00 Punchy and assertive, a t-bone of a Rose - Nick Passmore
Critics Silver 2005 Merlot, Old Barn North Fork of Long Island $17.00 Bit of camphor and tart berry. A notably lighter style that trends toward delicate. - Jon Bonne Hardys Nottage Hill
Critics Silver 2006 Shiraz South Eastern Australia $9.99 Rich black cherry and blueberry nose, has some intensity. Broad, supple, juicy, a fruit-forward style, with a hint of sweetness but at an acceptable level. - Stephen Brook Harlow Ridge Winery
Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Noir Lodi $6.99 Plenty of red fruit flavors, and reminiscent as well of juicy summer peaches. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay Lodi $6.99 Light nose, mineral and citrus backnotes. Soft, bright fruit, medium finish. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Grigio Lodi $6.99 Light varietal aromas, mineral-citrus notes. Medium dry finish. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Gold 2007 Sauvignon Blanc Lodi $6.99 Medium-bodied, fresh, crisp, with a kiss of oak that gives it some grip. Good acidity too, and a bracing dry finish. - Stephen Brook Hawk And Horse Vineyard
Critics Gold 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon Red Hills $65.00 Fragrant oaky blackcurrant nose. Delicate, pretty, fresh, no heavyweight, but has some finesse, and there is enough acidity to keep it going. Good with veal or lighter meats. - Stephen Brook Hawk Crest
Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon California $14.00 Deep ripe berry nose; bright fruit, firm tannins and acidity; length and tartness. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay Monterey County $12.00 Bright and lively, a refreshing alternative to all the hot, heavy-handed Chardonnays on the market. - Paul Lukacs Hayman & Hill
Critics Gold 2006 Meritage, Reserve Selection Monterey County $15.00 Stylishly pure and admirably balanced and integrated, this shows fruit notes of red and black berries along with a streak of plum, along with a very subtle wood note and tannins that are ripe and fine in grain. - Michael Franz
Critics Platinum 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon, Reserve Selection Napa Valley $15.00 The thoughtful, perfumed nose and a bright mix of plum and currant, with deft cocoa hints, provide a sleek take on Cabernet, with ample grip and nuance. A classic approach. - Jon Bonne
Critics Platinum 2007 Pinot Noir, Reserve Selection Santa Lucia Highlands $15.00 Aromas of red cherry are accented by notes of tar and dry brush. Palate is clean and mineral, a creamy midpalate given nice contour from some fine mineral notes on the finish. Stylish and pleasing. Juicy finish; gathers. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay, Winemaker's Selection Russian River Valley $15.00 More subtle dry wood notes and proper balance. Notably restrained and soft-edged. - Jon Bonne Haywood Estate
Critics Gold 2006 Zinfandel, Los Chamizal Vineyard Sonoma Valley $30.00 Briary, with red fruit elements all nicely balanced. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Gold 2006 Zinfandel, Morning Sun Sonoma Valley $35.00 A judicious balance of raspberry, cherry, plum. Nothing overextracted. - Marguerite Thomas Hazlitt 1852 Vineyard
Critics Gold 2008 Gewurztraminer Finger Lakes $15.00 Fleshier than some Gewurzt, but overall harmonious with a nice complex finish. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Silver 2008 Riesling, Homestead Reserve Finger Lakes $18.00 Lovely earthy notes. Good citric acidity. Easy to recommend. - Michael Apstein Hearthstone Vineyard
Critics Gold 2006 Profundo Paso Robles $28.00 This ripe wine leads with notes of cedar, blood, sweet black cherry and tar. A lively wine with forward palate flavors, good persistence, not complex, but like a good Tuscan red, completely whole to itself, satisfying. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Platinum 2006 Pearl Paso Robles $23.00 Aromas of white peach and a touch of vanilla, nutmeg, a lees note that gives the impression of baked fruit-bread. The flavors are fruit driven, a ripe juicy pear note with a hint of peach, good balance, remains poised and even-toned. - Patrick Comiskey Hedgeline
Critics Gold 2008 Riesling Washington $17.99 Quite delicious. Great finish. - Ed McCarthy Helfrich
Critics Gold 2007 Gewurztraminer Alsace $12.99 Distinct lychee spice aroma. Good fruit, soft acidity, but good length with ample fruit. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Silver 2005 Gewurztraminer, Stinklotz, Grand Cru Alsace $24.99 Subtle spice and green tea notes. Sweet flavors, low acidity. Medium finish. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Platinum 2007 Pinot Gris Vin D'Alsace $12.99 A very impressive Pinot Gris made in a rich, honeyed Alsatian style. The wine is off-dry (and consumers need to know that), but it has just enough acidity for balance, and is lusciously, lavishly flavorful. Delicious! - Paul Lukacs
Critics Gold 2007 Riesling Vin D'Alsace $12.99 Excellent Riesling. Complexly flavored, quite delicious. - Ed McCarthy Henry Estate Winery
Critics Gold 2008 Muller Thurgau Umpqua Valley $12.00 Spicy; delicious; lots of flavor; would be great with Asian cuisine - Ed McCarthy Herding Cats
Critics Gold 2008 Chardonnay Viognier Western Cape $7.99 Stony, peach pit and racy lemon, with a softer, opulent weight that emerges. - Jon Bonne Hess Collection
Critics Silver 2006 19 Block Cuvee, Estate Grown Mount Veeder $35.00 This shows a notable dose of oak, but the fruit proves up to the challenge, as the density and depth of the dark berry flavors more than hold their own. - Michael Franz Hogue Cellars
Critics Gold 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Genesis Columbia Valley $11.00 More dark mineral and dry wood notes, with generous black fruit and a firm finish. - Jon Bonne
Critics Platinum 2006 Merlot Columbia Valley $11.00 Dry and complex fecundity, backed by an intriguing touches of slatey minerality make this a stand-out merlot. - Nick Passmore
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay, Genesis Columbia Valley $11.00 Slightly flinty, with a peachy weight and mineral grip amid the green herbal tinges. - Jon Bonne
Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Grigio Columbia Valley $11.00 Light fruity aroma. Bright flavors. Good texture. Length and good balance. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Gold 2008 Riesling Columbia Valley $11.00 Delicious flavors of white peach and baked apples are lifted by fresh acidity in the finish. Quite notably sweet but not at all cloying, this is a very nice aperitif or a fine end to a meal as a stand-alone sipper. - Michael Franz
Critics Silver 2008 Riesling, Genesis Columbia Valley $11.00 Stone fruit notes recalling peaches and ripe apricots are predominant, with a little lift in the finish from a hint of citrus acidity. - Michael Franz
Critics Gold 2008 Late Harvest Riesling Columbia Valley $11.00 Fragrant and graceful, with an appealing crisp and juicy finish. - Marguerite Thomas Hooker
Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Old Boys Napa Valley $30.00 Quite lively, with juicy dark berry and cherry fruit, vanillin creaminess at midpalate and a firm, crisp finish. Well-mannered, and built for drinking in the next five years. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver 2005 Syrah, Home Pitch, Lawer Family Vineyard Knights Valley $24.95 A big blue wine, with aromas of blood and ink. Its flavors are just as dark, plum and fig with a leathery structure, the finish a bit gripping and warm. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Gold 2006 Syrah, Home Pitch, Betsy's Vineyard Knights Valley $28.00 Initial scents of crude oil and tar start to give way to notes of olive and soil - plenty savory, plenty complex! Flavors are very savory and brooding, powerful and driving, the acids low, the tannins high. It needs food, but it will complement baby back ribs. - Patrick Comiskey Hughes Family Vineyards
Critics Gold 2006 Syrah, Savannah Vineyard Sonoma Mountain $32.00 In a ripe style, it leads with smoke and figgy scents, accented by the scent of chipped minerals and mocha. Dark, very ripe, black dried fig notes, brooding middle palate, but finishes with some fine peppery tannins. - Patrick Comiskey Hunt Cellars
Critics Silver 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon, Bon Vivant, Destiny Vineyard Paso Robles $38.00 Not as 'look at me' flashy as many cabs, this one is perfectly proportioned in its fruit volume, oaking, tannins and acid. It may not last 10 years, but it's terrific for drinking now, with sturdy red meats. - Linda Murphy Huntington Wine Cellars
Critics Platinum 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon California $14.00 Lovely blackberry and black cherry fruit, with soft, supple tannins. - Robert Whitley
Critics Silver 2007 Sauvignon Blanc Dry Creek Valley $15.00 This shows nice aromatics of dried herbs and fresh citrus fruit, and the flavor notes follow suit. A lightly smoky note works well with the other aromas and flavors. - Michael Franz Husch Vineyards
Critics Platinum 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon, Reserve, La Ribera Vineyards Mendocino $35.00 Classic cab tones of cedar and leather matched up with bright red berry fruit flavors. - Nick Passmore
Critics Silver 2006 Pinot Noir, Reserve Anderson Valley $35.00 A less opulent style of PN, it delivers an array of red fruit flavors and hints of earth. - Michael Apstein
Critics Silver 2008 Chenin Blanc, La Ribera Vineyards Mendocino $11.00 Generous and ripe. An intriguing sappy nose, with dried peach and talc in the mix. - Jon Bonne
Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay, Vine One Anderson Valley $18.00 Beguiling aromas, slightly floral, with touches of hay and lemon. Hints of mineral on the finish. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Platinum 2007 Chardonnay, Special Reserve Mendocino $25.00 Flinty approach initially, evolving into rich vanilla accented aromas. wonderfully long on the finish. - Marguerite Thomas Irony
Critics Gold 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $15.99 Hint of herbal notes on the nose with lovely fruit purity. - Leslie Sbrocco J. Lohr Winery
Critics Gold 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Hilltop Vineyard Paso Robles $35.00 Earthy nose. Big rich choco-berry flavors. Concentrated, good tannins. Nice length and complexity. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Gold 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon, Carol's Vineyard Napa Valley $40.00 Very deep color. Forward ripe berry aroma. Dense, concentrated, sweet fruit. Good length. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Platinum 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon, Seven Oaks Estates Paso Robles $17.00 Deep French oak and blackberry aroma. Structured rich fruit flavors. Good length. - Gerald D. Boyd Jacob's Creek
Critics Gold 2008 Chardonnay South Eastern Australia $8.00 A fruit bowl of flavor is packed into each glass. Chill well and pour with casual fare like grilled chicken with mango salsa or Hawaiian ham and pineapple pizza. - Leslie Sbrocco
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay, Reserve South Australia $13.00 Soft, supple and round makes this a sippable Chardonnay for cocktail hour and beyond. - Leslie Sbrocco
Critics Silver 2008 Riesling South Eastern Australia $8.00 Great nose of lovely floral notes followed by good minerality and vibrancy. Good length; balanced; mouth filling texture. - Michael Apstein
Critics Platinum 2008 Riesling, Reserve South Australia $13.00 Engaging firm stoniness; lemony finish; long and balanced. Great length and finesse. Its character and acidity will complement a wide range of food. This is why people love Riesling! - Michael Apstein James Judd & Son Vineyards
Critics Gold 2005 Barbera, Estate Grown, Shandon Vineyard Paso Robles $21.00 Absolutely delicious, despite perhaps a bit too much presence of oak. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon, A Cellar Full Of Noise Paso Robles $14.00 Soft and supple, with markedly sweet fruit. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2006 Tempranillo, A Cellar Full Of Noise Paso Robles $14.00 Extracted New World style with bold fruit flavors and smoky, meaty aromas. - Leslie Sbrocco Jarvis
Critics Gold 2004 Cabernet Franc, Estate Produced Napa Valley $90.00 Just explodes with pure dark berry fruit flavors. - Nick Passmore Jekel Vineyards
Critics Gold 2006 Merlot Arroyo Seco $14.99 A very impressive Merlot, with rich but not over-ripe fruit, spicy undertones, and a judicious dash of oak. - Paul Lukacs Jose Maria Da Fonseca
Critics Gold 2007 Twin Vines Vinho Verde $6.99 Bright zesty appley nose. Lean, racy, fresh, with plenty of drive and a long refreshing finish, with a twist of lemon peel. Has personality. - Stephen Brook Joseph Drouhin
Critics Platinum 2006 Les Clos, Grand Cru Chablis $101.25 With an overlay of toasty oak and spice, this stunning Chardonnay exhibits firm acidity and a brooding minerality that likely will take three to five years to emerge fully and reach its full potential. - Robert Whitley Judd's Hill Winery
Critics Silver 2005 Petite Sirah Lodi $30.00 Savory sage and graham cracker nose. Plump black plum and mulberry flavors, with beefy tannins and a touch of heat in the finish. Demands hearty red meat. - Linda Murphy |
|
Kallfelz Estate
Critics Silver 2007 Riesling Kabinett, Single Vineyard Mosel $19.99 Rich, easy-drinking. Try with chicken or other birds. - Ed McCarthy Kayra Vintage
Critics Gold 2007 Shiraz / Petite Verdot Turkey $30.00 This wine was pushed right to the edge of being over-oaked, as the spicy wood notes are very prominent, and yet the balance really works, as the density, sweetness and depth of the dark berry and black cherry fruit counterbalances the oak notes right through the persistent finish. Showy more than subtle, this will prove very appealing to those who like this basic profile. - Michael Franz
Critics Silver 2008 Chardonnay Turkey $30.00 Buttery, lots of oak. Some bitterness, light fruit. - Gerald D. Boyd Kendall-Jackson
Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Hawkeye Mountain Alexander Valley $55.00 Spicy French oak nose; big tannins and medium fruit; long dry finish. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Gold 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Trace Ridge Knights Valley $70.00 Medium oak and fruit aromas. Medium palate, dry, firm tannins. Good length. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa Mountain Mount Veeder $70.00 Oaky nose with low level berry aromas; soft entry, firm tannins, mouth coating, length. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Silver 2006 Merlot, Taylor Peak Bennett Valley $40.00 An elegant, polished structure supports a great red cherry tinged front palate. - Nick Passmore
Critics Silver 2006 Merlot, Boont Ridge Anderson Valley $55.00 Rich, plush and eminently approachable merlot. - Nick Passmore
Critics Gold 2007 Pinot Noir, Seco Highlands Arroyo Seco $35.00 Earth and tar and red cherry. It's very tightly wound, lots of forward fruit and just as much tannin in the structure. The tightness of the weave suggests a long life. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay, Camelot Highlands Santa Maria Valley $30.00 Rich and ripe in a seductively supple but sweet style. - Paul Lukacs Kenwood Vineyards
Critics Gold 2006 Merlot, Jack London Vineyard Sonoma Valley $30.00 Firm blackberry nose. Quite rich, suave, surprisingly tannic but not tough, good fruit concentration, robust and spicy with zesty acidity on the finish. Try with a goulash or other stew. - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver 2006 Merlot Sonoma County $16.00 Black cherry and Indian spice on the nose. Soft, juicy, plenty of upfront fruit, brisk and zesty, but little depth of flavour. An attractive mouthful. - Stephen Brook
Critics Gold 2006 Zinfandel Sonoma County $14.00 Zin appeals to so many because of its ripe, lush fruit character. This wine -- with fruitiness, fleshiness, and freshness -- will be the crowd favorite. - Leslie Sbrocco
Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay Sonoma County $15.00 Finesse and nuanced, with stone fruits and a moderately long finish. - Marguerite Thomas Killer Juice
Critics Gold 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon California $19.99 A serious cabernet sauvignon, with sturdy tannins, textbook black cherry fruit, with notes of cola and forest floor. It's admirably dry on the finish, and has the tannic structure to stand up to a medium-rare steak. - Linda Murphy King Fish
Critics Gold 2007 Merlot California $5.99 Lots of cocoa and sandalwood. A well-rounded effort with lots of rich cherry fruit and smoky tannins. - Jon Bonne
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay California $5.99 Lemony nose backed by mineral notes. Bright fruit, spicy notes. Soft finish with good sustained fruit. - Gerald D. Boyd La Cereza
Critics Platinum 2005 Shiraz Temecula Valley $18.95 Complex, dry. Long finish. - Ed McCarthy
Best of Show White 2008 Viognier Temecula Valley $24.95 Shows the balanced beauty of Viognier. Delicate aromas of melon and flowers invite you in then deliver roundness without a wallop of alcohol. - Michael Franz Lake Sonoma Winery
Critics Platinum 2006 Zinfandel Dry Creek Valley $17.00 Intriguing lavender, dry herb and bright red fruit. A racier, vivacious style with plenty of fine backbone. Kinetic and energetic for a Zin. - Jon Bonne
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay Russian River Valley $18.00 A bold wine charged with toasted coconut and tropical fruits. - Marguerite Thomas Laurier Vineyards
Critics Silver 2006 Merlot Alexander Valley $14.99 Lightly charry oak comes forward, some solid plum skin and blackberry fruit but a jamminess dominates. - Jon Bonne
Critics Silver 2006 Pinot Noir Los Carneros $16.99 Juicy fruit on the finish, this is bound to be a good food wine (bring on that salmon!) - Marguerite Thomas Lawer Family Vineyard
Critics Gold 2005 Syrah, Three Coins Knights Valley $28.00 Made in a ripe style with dark chocolate cake notes, complementing black raspberry - like Sachertorte. Its juicy sweet entry gives way to a certain firmness of tone black fig notes close with a finish of dark chocolate that resurrects the wine completely. - Patrick Comiskey Leaping Lizard
Critics Gold 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $15.00 Vibrant character with a touch of earthiness gives this racy Cab complexity. Sip alongside pork roast doused in mushrooms. - Leslie Sbrocco
Critics Silver 2006 Merlot Napa Valley $13.00 Musky and subtle, in a lighter style. Slightly roasted cherry and perfume, with tea-like tannins bolstering the bright profile. - Jon Bonne
Critics Silver 2007 Zinfandel Sonoma County $13.00 Discreetly styled Zin, should be a good match with pork, chicken, pasta and pizza. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay Napa Valley $13.00 Forward mineral aroma. Very soft, light fruit, citrus notes. Light finish. - Gerald D. Boyd Left Coast Cellars
Critics Gold 2006 Cali's Cuvee, Estate Willamette Valley $28.00 Nice but not too obvious fruit, plus a hint of smoke. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Gold 2006 Chardonnay, Estate Willamette Valley $24.00 A reserved wine with a delicate nose of slightly unripe pear, and a mildly wheaty scent. Flavors are clean, even a bit terse and focused flavors of pear and an angular finish of bitter almond. - Patrick Comiskey Little Black Dress
Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon California $12.99 Sharp eyed and full of lively blackberry and plum. A carefree, juicy glassful. - Jon Bonne
Critics Silver 2007 Merlot California $12.99 Lush on the palate, so easy to drink, with plenty of sweet, ripe fruit that delights. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2007 Pinot Grigio Delle Venezie $12.99 Dry, piquant flavors, well-integrated - Ed McCarthy Lockwood Vineyard
Critics Silver 2007 Malbec Monterey $14.99 Muted plummy nose. Light and fresh, uncomplicated with has enough tannin and fruit to give it interest and character. - Stephen Brook
Critics Gold 2006 Pinot Noir, Block 7 Monterey $14.99 Woodsy aromas and dark cherry flavors. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay Monterey $11.99 This simple chardonnay is airy and light, with mineral and saline scents to go with green apple. Its flavors are bright and Macon-like in their bright apple fruit. A very pleasant wine for an aperitif. - Patrick Comiskey Loredona
Critics Silver 2008 Riesling Monterey $11.99 Soft peach fruit notes work quite nicely against a backdrop of citrus acidity and a pleasantly bitter hint of citrus rind in the finish. - Michael Franz Lucchesi Vineyards
Critics Silver 2008 Sauvignon Blanc Sierra Foothills $16.00 A fresh, aromatically expressive wine that follows up with nice fruit and fine balancing acidity. - Michael Franz Luis Canas
Critics Silver 2001 Rioja Reserva, Seleccion de la Familia Rioja $30.00 Fresh, pleasantly sweet fruit is very nicely tuned to a vanilla note from the oak, and very fine-grained tannins provide framing without imparting any astringency to the finish. - Michael Franz MacRostie Winery
Critics Gold 2006 Pinot Noir Carneros $45.00 Yes! They get what Pinot Noir can deliver. Ripe black fruit, toasty oak, leafy notes all intertwined. Bright acid keeps it fresh. Mild tannins lend support but allow enjoyment without further aging. - Michael Apstein
Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay Carneros $23.00 Delivers a mouthful of ripe fruit flavors--melon, peach, pineapple--with accents of vanilla on the finish. - Marguerite Thomas Mahoney Vineyards
Critics Gold 2006 Pinot Noir, Mahoney Ranch Vineyard Carneros $28.00 Ripe, but earthy notes add complexity and reigns in the fruit element. Good acid amplifies the flavors in the finish. Grilled salmon, you've met your match. - Michael Apstein Maison Bouachon
Critics Gold 2005 La Tiare du Pape Chateauneuf-du-Pape $34.99 Not just fruit character. Great mixture of herbs, meaty flavors and black fruit. Balanced and elegant. - Michael Apstein Mandolin
Critics Platinum 2007 Pinot Noir Monterey $12.00 Lovely balance, sensual, with subtle hints of fruit and balsamic. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Silver 2007 Riesling Monterey $10.00 Medium-weight, well-integrated flavors. Well-balanced. - Ed McCarthy Marq Vineyards
Critics Gold 2007 The Fatted Otter Monterey County $12.99 Nice complexity of fruit and herbal notes. Firm, but not abrasive, tannins make it perfect for a steak, not as a before-dinner drink. - Michael Apstein Matua Valley
Critics Gold 2008 Pinot Noir Marlborough $14.00 A Pinot that is both earthy and delicate. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Silver 2008 Sauvignon Blanc Marlborough $13.00 Ripe and generous but still sharply focused thanks to energetic acidity, this is a well balanced, intelligently crafted Sauvignon. - Michael Franz Maurice Carrie Winery
Critics Silver 2008 Muscat Canelli Temecula Valley $14.95 Sweet orange peel and fennel. - Patrick Comiskey Mendelson Vineyards
Critics Gold 2000 Pinot Gris Dessert Wine Napa Valley $33.00 Burnt amber and roasting coffee flavors, leavened by just enough citrus acidity to keep it honest, mark this as a highly unusual and distinctive wine. - Nick Passmore
Critics Gold 2006 Pinot Noir, Sleepy Hollow Vineyard Santa Lucia Highlands $40.00 Sweet oak marries nicely with ripe - not overripe - fruit and hints of leafy elements. - Michael Apstein Meridian
Critics Silver 2007 Pinot Grigio California $10.00 Light mineral-fruity nose. Good texture, tropical fruit notes. Balanced finish. - Gerald D. Boyd Mettler Family Vineyards
Critics Silver 2005 Petite Sirah Lodi $24.99 A mouthwatering Petite Sirah that sings with bright dark-cherry fruit, with licorice and black pepper adding dimension. - Linda Murphy Middle Sister
Critics Silver NV Rebel Red California $12.00 Fresh herbal edges on the bright huckleberry flavors help define its juicy punch. - Jon Bonne Monkey Bay
Critics Gold 2008 Sauvignon Blanc Marlborough $13.00 A delicious Sauvignon that shows all the grassy, herbal aromatics that lovers of the variety would wish to see, but without turning too pungent or aggressive. The melon and citrus fruit notes are lifted and focused by acidity that is zesty but not grating, lending an integrated, coherent impression to the wine in overall terms. - Michael Franz Montcadi
Critics Silver NV Cava Rose, Metado Tradicional Spain $6.99 Rather sweet, juicy, ripe strawberry fruit, a crowd-pleasing style but has a dry finish that keeps it from being cloying. - Stephen Brook Montecillo
Critics Gold 2001 Gran Reserva Rioja $25.00 This is a very appealing Gran Reserva that shows the leathery accents of the traditional style set against very tasty fruit that recalls dried red cherries and red berries. Nice spice notes offer additional complexity, and the general impression lent by the wine is one of generous aroma and flavor on a usefully light platform. - Michael Franz
Critics Platinum 2003 Reserva Rioja $19.00 Complex and convincing, this is a Rioja Resaerva that shows lovely sweet fruit recalling red cherries and wild strawberries along with leathery, spicy accent notes. The oak is notable but neither distracting nor drying in the finish, making this an exemplary wine within its genre. - Michael Franz
Critics Silver 2008 Albarino, Verdamar Rias Baixas $14.00 Creamy golden apple scent, spritzed with lemon. Palate flavors are clean and driven by a racy acidity, good minerality. A little tight on the finish. - Patrick Comiskey Morlanda
Critics Gold 2004 Crianca Priorat $48.00 Concentrated, but not overdone. Spiced red fruit with leathery notes. Lovely savory elements add complexity. Nicely done! - Michael Apstein Mouton Cadet
Critics Gold 2008 Blanc Bordeaux $9.99 Graceful and pleasantly pungent. Balanced, crisp and fresh. Bright flavors unencumbered by oak. A wonderful value! - Michael Apstein Mumm Napa
Critics Gold 2006 Pinot Noir Napa Valley $38.00 A hint of cocoa, red fruit, and a supple texture. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Platinum NV Brut Prestige Napa Valley $19.00 Rich flavors, complex, dry. Exceptional value. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Platinum NV Brut Rose Napa Valley $24.00 Pretty strawberry aroma, subtle yeastiness, fine structure and very complex, with a creamy, mouthfilling mousse. An elegant, layered, long-finishing wine -- a real charmer. - Linda Murphy Napa Creek Winery
Critics Gold 2006 Merlot Napa Valley $12.99 Some serious backbone here. Stoic tea and mineral, with a freshness and gravelly red berry on the nose. Ropey and tight-knit, with fresh raspberry and darker fruit, and sticky tannins tying it all together. - Jon Bonne
Critics Silver 2005 Petite Sirah Stags Leap District $12.99 Sweet and rich -- surprisingly soft for Petite. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2005 Chardonnay Napa Valley $12.99 Perfumed nose, hints of grain. Medium fruit, good texture and length. - Gerald D. Boyd Napa Ridge Winery
Critics Silver 2005 Merlot Napa Valley $12.99 Subtle and high-toned, freshly herbal on the nose. There's pretty, sappy cherry fruit and bright citrus highlights amid a distinct oak presence. - Jon Bonne
Critics Gold 2007 Pinot Noir Napa Valley $12.99 A charmer, balanced fruit, supple texture. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Gold 2005 Syrah Napa Valley $12.99 Well-done. Great balance. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay Napa Valley $12.99 Spicy oak and mineral accents; soft texture, dry with medium fruit. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Silver 2007 Sauvignon Blanc Napa Valley $12.99 Ripe citric nose. Quite rich and plump, a bit too weighty for a sauvignon, but has good underlying acidity, which gives it persistence and character. - Stephen Brook Natura
Critics Silver 2008 Carmenere Valle Central $11.00 Attractively but not excessively herbal in a fairly supple, medium-weight style. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2008 Sauvignon Blanc Valle Casablanca $11.00 Medium-bodied, well-made, with lime and granny smith apple flavors riding a wave of crisp acidity. - Linda Murphy Navarro Vineyards
Best of Show Rose 2008 Rose Mendocino $16.50 A delicate, pale pink gem. - Nick Passmore
Critics Silver 2007 Pinot Noir Mendocino $20.00 Cherry and sweet spices. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Gold 2007 Pinot Noir, Deep End Blend Anderson Valley $52.00 Orange peel, a hint of plum, a soft, grainy finish. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Gold 2007 Syrah Mendocino $26.00 Serious, Rhone-style, excellent food wine - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2007 Muscat Blanc Anderson Valley $19.00 A Muscat that shows very expressive aromatics but a truly dry finish, and does so without any incoherence or disagreement between the aromatic and flavor impressions. This combination is quite difficult to achieve, and this is an impressive wine that would make a lovely aperitif but also work very nicely at the table, thanks to its classy, dry finish. - Michael Franz
Best of Show Dessert 2007 Late Harvest Riesling, Cluster Select Anderson Valley $59.00 Light gold. Heady peachy botrytis nose, with a light honeyed tone. Very sweet, creamy and unctuous, with delightful acidity to keep it from being too sugary or cloying. Well balanced and stylish, piquant and lively. Delicious and in no way heavy. - Stephen Brook
Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay, Premiere Reserve Anderson Valley $25.00 Very pleasant if confectionary nose of yellow cake, sweetened nuts, pear. Flavors are surprisingly austere, the fruit and sweet savory notes hidden behind a fierce acidity, suggesting acidulation. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay Mendocino $17.00 Slightly dusty dried pineapple aromas. Flavors are rich and cleanly rendered, a lemony flavor comes through with a very terse pithy acidity. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Gold 2007 Riesling Anderson Valley $18.00 Well-balanced. A great food wine. Try it with poultry or fish. - Ed McCarthy New Clairvaux Vineyard
Critics Silver 2006 Syrah, St. James Block Tehama County $16.00 Delicious, just a bit ripe. - Ed McCarthy New Zealand
Critics Silver 2007 Pinot Noir Marlborough $8.99 Leads with a mildly earthy note, a hint of bergamot mixed in with strawberry flavors. Quiet in its entry, focused, pure, if a little slight. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Gold 2007 Sauvignon Blanc Marlborough $6.99 True to the grape variety without becoming overly pungent or assertive, this is a very nicely styled wine that shows fresh citrus fruit and nice herbal aromatics. Broadly useful as an aperitif or a partner for a wide range of fish and shellfish dishes, this is quite well made. - Michael Franz Newman's Own
Critics Silver 2006 Chardonnay California $15.99 Aromas of pineapple and earth. Flavors are appley and bright, texture is quite firm and driven by a racy acidity. - Patrick Comiskey Nobilo
Critics Silver 2008 Sauvignon Blanc, Regional Collection Marlborough $14.99 Lightly sweet but still fresh and zesty, with citrus acidity that lends linear energy to the wine and balances the fruity sweetness in the finish. - Michael Franz Orfila Vineyards
Critics Silver 2005 Heritage, Estate San Pasqual Valley $35.00 Dry, well-balanced. - Ed McCarthy Origin
Critics Gold 2007 Chianti Chianti DOCG $9.99 Well-balanced. Great fruit. - Ed McCarthy Paco & Lola
Critics Platinum 2008 Albarino Rias Baixas $22.00 Rich sensuous scent of lemon and pear, with a bit of nutmeg and wet stones. High toned and firm on the palate, some weight to the palate and a ripe pear flavor, but totally reined in. slight bitter almond note on the finish. Very stylish wine. - Patrick Comiskey Pahrump Valley Winery
Critics Silver 2005 Nevada Ridge Zinfandel, First Crush Nevada $25.00 Leaner, almost claret style. Notably chewy and strong, but the floral lift on it -- lilies and dry lavender -- takes it somewhere intriguing. - Jon Bonne
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay, Winemaker's Select California $15.95 A rich wine from the get-go with notes of vanillin, clove, ghee. Flavors are rich as buttercream frosting. more about vanillin than fruit. For those who like their chardonnays rich. - Patrick Comiskey Palo Alto
Critics Gold 2008 Sauvignon Blanc, Reserve Maule Valley $12.99 Gently herbaceous and citrus-driven, this wine has a pretty floral perfume, lime and grapefruit flavors, and a clean, refreshing finish. It doesn't bowl me over with complexity, but rather sneaks up with a delicacy and freshness that invites another sip. - Linda Murphy Pedroncelli Winery
Critics Gold 2007 Pinot Noir Russian River Valley $18.00 Earthiness and hints of cherry. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Gold 2006 Petite Sirah, Family Vineyards Dry Creek Valley $16.00 Impressive because restrained but still full-flavored. This is a Petite one actually could drink through a whole meal. - Paul Lukacs Peju
Critics Gold 2007 Rose of Syrah Napa Valley $25.00 Beautiful. Summer strawberries backed up by a fine flinty minerality. - Nick Passmore Pepi
Critics Silver 2005 Sangiovese California $9.99 Lightly candied raspberry nose. Medium fruit, firm tannins. Tart cherry finish. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Gold 2006 Chardonnay Monterey $9.99 Elegance and grace in a glass. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Gold 2007 Pinot Grigio California $9.99 Flavorful. Nicely balanced. - Ed McCarthy Perrier-Jouet
Critics Silver NV Grand Brut Champagne $40.00 A delicate Champagne with refined aromas and flavors that are nicely accented with subtle yeast notes. Not the most showy rendition of the genre, but very tastefully crafted and nicely balanced. - Michael Franz
Best of Show Sparkling 2000 Fleur de Champagne Champagne $139.00 A soft, creamy texture makes this very pleasant in initial impression, but then a host of subtle complexities are revealed in the long, symmetrical finish that show the true excellence of the wine. Yeast, fruit and mineral notes are all beautifully intertwined, with acidity and a touch of sweetness counterbalancing one another very effectively. Fully mature but not yet tiring, this is a very impressive wine. - Michael Franz
Critics Platinum 2002 Fleur de Champagne Rose Champagne $299.00 Attractive onion skin color offers an initial indication of this fine rose's subtlety and delicacy, and those impressions are reinforced by the soft, broad texture, which is marked by very fine-grained effervesence. Aromas and flavors are subtle but expressive, and the aromatic and flavor components are admirably proportional and effectively integrated. - Michael Franz Pezzi King Vineyards
Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay Russian River Valley $26.00 Bold and oaky style that makes no apologies. When you want 'em big, this is the wine for you! - Leslie Sbrocco Picket Fence
Critics Silver 2006 Pinot Noir Russian River Valley $29.99 Has the distinct umami aromas of mushrooms, humus, adorning light strawberry notes. Palate flavors are rendered clean and fine, with a high tone, good pure red cherry flavor, composed, if a bit quiet. - Patrick Comiskey Pietra Santa Winery
Critics Silver Sacred Stone, Master's Red Blend California $10.00 A very tasty blend that melds soft berry fruit flavors -- both red and black ones -- with a subtle edge of oak. - Michael Franz
Critics Silver 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon, Signature Collection Cienega Valley $50.00 Oaky nose, light fruit, tart acidity. Dry, medium finish- Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Silver 2005 Merlot Cienega Valley $15.00 A good dose of funk on the nose, with darker, chocolately extracted notes and ample black fruit. Dense, dark mineral but the stiff tannins dominate. - Jon Bonne
Critics Platinum 2005 Sangiovese Cienega Valley $18.00 Very deep color. Deep oak and dark fruit aromas. Bright flavors, raspberry. Firm tannins. Good length. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Silver 2007 Zinfandel Central Coast $20.00 Smoky oak, light berry notes. Good berry flavors, hints of spice. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay, Signature Collection Cienega Valley $35.00 Citrus, low intensity mineral. Bright fruit. Good balance and finish. - Gerald D. Boyd Planeta
Critics Gold 2005 Santa Cecilia, Nero D'Avola Sicilia $39.99 Forward dark fruit aromas, traces of plums. Deeply set flavors, ripe raspberry. Firm tannins, good length. Good balance and complex flavors. - Gerald D. Boyd Principe Corsini
Critics Platinum 2006 Birillo Maremma Toscana $18.00 Simply gorgeous. Medium-bodied but multi-layered; and while balanced, not at all astringent or tart. A beautiful modern but legitimately regional Tuscan wine. - Paul Lukacs PromisQous
Critics Silver NV Pinot Grigio California $12.00 Piquant, pleasant, easy-drinking. - Ed McCarthy Purgatory Cellars
Critics Gold NV Persimmon Solera American $39.95 Sweetness and spice all wrapped up in a glass. - Marguerite Thomas |
|
Q Collection
Critics Silver 2007 Zinfandel, Lot #12 Howell Mountain $25.99 Earthiness, plus raspberries, red plums and other red fruits. - Marguerite Thomas Quady Winery
Critics Platinum NV Palomino Fino California $30.00 Robust tangy oxidative nose, bracing, amontillado style. Very rich, dense, spicy, concentrated, long. - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver NV Vya Vermouth Aperitif, Sweet California $20.00 Caramel and medicinal aromatics; sweet entry, touch of bitterness; pleasant finish. Pleasant but lacks complexity of an Italian Sweet Vermouth. - Gerald D. Boyd R & B Cellars
Critics Gold 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon, Reserve, Bingham Ranch Napa Valley $65.00 Ripe plums and red cherry dominate this bright, fruit-driven cab. - Nick Passmore
Critics Silver 2005 Merlot, Towne Ranch Napa County $18.00 Ripe cherry and raspberry nose. Bright, fresh, simple, no depth of flavour but lively and brisk. Fine with a chicken salad. - Stephen Brook
Critics Gold 2007 Zydeco Zinfandel, Bingham Ranch Napa Valley $28.00 Complexity and concentration combine with vibrant red fruit notes to make a stylish Zin that shines. - Leslie Sbrocco Rancho Arroyo Grande
Critics Platinum 2007 Mourvedre, Dry-Farmed Arroyo Grande Valley $45.00 Lovely classic nose of earth, a bit of tar and pepper, and brilliant red raspberry. Firm, focused, fresh, gorgeous forward raspberry fruit, firm texture, and a bit of chewy, mildly bitter tannins. Completely balanced and true to form. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Gold 2007 Zinfandel, Dry-Farmed San Luis Obispo County $45.00 Spicy-berry nose; dense, good tannin/fruit balance; big finish. - Gerald D. Boyd Rare Earth
Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay, Organic Grapes Mendocino County $12.99 Good fruit, mineral and spicy oak. Medium finish. - Gerald D. Boyd Ravenswood Winery
Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon Sonoma County $15.00 Subtle oak and berry aromas; tart acidity, medium fruit; dry medium finish. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Platinum 2007 Petite Sirah, Vintners Blend California $10.99 Really well-balanced, velvety texture, dry, complex flavors; fine wine - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2006 Zinfandel, Old Vine Lodi $12.00 Silky on the palate, soft tannins on the finish. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Silver 2006 Zinfandel, Old Vine Sonoma County $12.00 Brambly berry fruit that is well balanced, with good acidity and a persistence of flavor through a very long finish. - Robert Whitley Ray's Station
Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon North Coast $15.99 A dense and intense cab brimming with blackberries, black cherries and cedar highlights. - Nick Passmore Re del Castello
Critics Gold 2007 Chianti Classico Chianti Classico $8.99 Dry, complex flavors. Classic Chianti. - Ed McCarthy Red Guitar
Critics Gold 2007 Rose, Old Vine Navarra $12.00 Gorgeous salmon color; delicate strawberry notes. Balanced. Fresh and refreshing. Bottled summertime! - Michael Apstein Red Soles Winery
Critics Silver 2008 Flip Flop White Grape Wine Paso Robles $26.00 Light peachy nose. Lush, creamy, full-bodied. Doesn't have much acidity but has an appealing exotic fruit character. - Stephen Brook
Critics Platinum 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Estate Reserve, Miracles Ranch Paso Robles $40.00 Intense, extracted and rich, this muscular yet supple Cab has it all. - Leslie Sbrocco Redwood Creek
Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon California $7.99 Tannic and woody, although there is well-ripened black fruit here, touches of vanilla and cedar, and a finishing freshness that counters the strong oak influence. - Linda Murphy Reflexion
Critics Silver 2003 Rioja Reserva Rioja $9.99 A very nice Reserva that shows restrained oak that permits the sweet red cherry fruit to show to full advantage. Light- to medium-bodied, this is stylish in its proportionality and balance. - Michael Franz Rene Florancy
Critics Gold NV Brut, Premier Cru Champagne $27.99 Lovely creamy texture is balanced by energetic acidity that lifts and freshens the flavor through a long finish. Flavorful but fresh, this offers a nearly optimal balance between power and stylishness. - Michael Franz Renwood Winery
Critics Platinum 2006 Barbera Sierra Foothills $9.95 Great red wine. An excellent Barbera. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2005 Syrah Sierra Foothills $9.95 Great flavour. Easy drinking. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2006 Zinfandel, Jack Rabbit Flat Amador County $29.95 Pleasing bit of dust on the nose, with lacquered plum, dry moss, and sour cherry and a supple profile. Evocative, if still a heavy hitter. - Jon Bonne
Critics Silver 2006 Zinfandel, Sea of Grapes Amador County $19.95 Leathery, dusty cherry and a glossy rush. A spread of jammy, balanced fruit rounds it out. - Jon Bonne Richardson Vineyards
Critics Gold 2005 Synergy Carneros $18.00 Sweet, plummy succulent fruit with attractive herbal elements. Balanced. Good finish. Elegance speaks here. - Michael Apstein Rideau Vineyard
Critics Gold 2007 Roussanne, Iris Santa Ynez Valley $42.00 Softly driven aromas of white flowers and golden apple. Flavors are a bit neutral, as with some closed roussannes, but the wine has a terrific high firm tone and terrific balance. Great food wine I'm sure. generic nose, faint. Odd wine, almost no flavors, but lovely balance and fine even tone. - Patrick Comiskey Robert Hall Winery
Critics Gold 2008 Rose de Robles, Hall Ranch Paso Robles $14.99 Crisp, dry and elegantly quafable. - Nick Passmore
Critics Silver 2006 Syrah Paso Robles $19.99 Pleasant, easy-drinking. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2008 Chardonnay Paso Robles $19.99 Big, ripe, and forward, this chardonnay leads with broad golden apple scents. It's rich yet persistent on the palate, with an appealing richness and a firm, persistent finish. - Patrick Comiskey Robert Mondavi Private Selection
Critics Silver 2007 Meritage California $11.00 Dark and admirably concentrated, this is rich and flavorful but neither hard nor dry, making it a very promising partner for moderately robust foods. - Michael Franz
Critics Silver 2007 Pinot Noir California $11.00 Lots of chewy caramel oak, adorning strawberry and black cherry. A tad blunt, but people would like. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay California $11.00 Soft and seductive. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Grigio California $11.00 Light ginger ale aroma. Medium fruit, crisp acidity. Good length. - Gerald D. Boyd Robert Oatley Vineyards
Critics Gold 2007 Shiraz Mudgee $20.00 All smoke and olives at the outset, with a firm, violet-like savory note. Its flavors are intensely savory, flavors of black tea and dark inky fruit. Formidable. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay Mudgee $18.00 An enjoyable quaff with a ping of lemony freshness. Try with fish in buerre blanc sauce or a brie and chicken sandwich. - Leslie Sbrocco
Critics Silver 2008 Sauvignon Blanc Western Australia $18.00 Smoky/flinty nose, slightly reductive (may blow off). Citrus, pink grapefruit and slight grassy notes. There is bright, attractive fruit here, though I wish for more structure and depth. - Linda Murphy Robert Traverso
Critics Platinum 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon Stags Leap District $49.00 Full-bodied and weighty, with ripe black fruit, vanillin and substantial tannins, yet it is all equalized by a brisk, racy and long, fresh finish. For lovers of big, bold, yet balanced cabernet sauvignon. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver 2006 Zinfandel Russian River Valley $33.00 Oak and berry nose. Medium fruit. Dry good fruit through finish. - Gerald D. Boyd Rocca Family Vineyards
Critics Platinum 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Estate Napa Valley $85.00 Inviting, fresh-fruit aromas plus savory sage and gentle oak. Powerfully built, and very firm -- big though with perfectly ripe fruit, shadings of licorice and vanilla, a crisp, mouthwatering finish and no obvious alcoholic heat. - Linda Murphy Rodney Strong Vineyards
Critics Gold 2006 Symmetry Alexander Valley $60.00 Powerful but still stylish, this shows beautifully ripened fruit recalling dark berries and black cherries, along with a tastefully restrained accent from smoky oak. - Michael Franz
Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Reserve Alexander Valley $35.00 A robust and hearty cab with earthy undertones - great with steak. - Nick Passmore
Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon, Estate Vineyards Alexander Valley $20.00 Lean and elegant wine with a spicy zip to its long, fruity finish. - Nick Passmore
Critics Platinum 2007 Zinfandel, Estate Vineyards, Knotty Vines Sonoma County $25.00 When Zinfandel manages to showcase elegance, purity and power, it must be rewarded. This beauty balances it all. - Leslie Sbrocco Rosemount Estate
Critics Silver 2007 Shiraz South Eastern Australia $10.00 Quite delicious. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay South Eastern Australia $10.00 Chardonnay in a very ripe style, with scents of golden apple and a round rich palate of vanillin and apple tart. Very ripe apple, applesauce. - Patrick Comiskey Rosenthal - The Malibu Estate
Critics Silver 2005 Meritage Malibu-Newton Canyon $75.00 Sweet black cherry fruit is very appealing, and a subtle dose of vanillin oak offers a counterpoint without distracting attention from the fruit. - Michael Franz Rotta Winery
Critics Gold NV Black Monukka Dessert Wine California $25.00 Dark chocolate and toffee notes on the nose give way to a creme caramel and sweet brandy palate. Unique and appealing. - Nick Passmore Round Hill
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay California $8.00 Tenuously balanced, but still seductively sweet and tasty. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay, Oak Free California $12.00 Impressively balanced. So refreshing as well as rich, and full of autumn fruit flavor. Very enjoyable. - Paul Lukacs Route 128
Critics Silver 2007 Viognier, Opatz Family Vineyard Yorkville Highlands $26.00 Delicate aromas of spice and pear lead to a wine that shows structure and freshness. - Leslie Sbrocco Roxo Port Cellars
Critics Silver 2006 Ruby Tradicional Paso Robles $44.00 Candied cherries up front but already showing hints of the delicious forest floor and cigar box flavors that will only intensify with time. - Nick Passmore Sakonnet Vineyards
Critics Gold 2007 Vidal Blanc, Estate Southeastern New England $11.95 Wet stone on the nose, then the palate bursts with tangy apricot, yellow peach and citrus flavors. Lively and refreshing, with admirable complexity for an off-dry style. - Linda Murphy Santa Margherita
Critics Platinum NV Prosecco, Brut Valdobbiadene $19.99 A thoroughbred. Complex, exceptional. A great value! - Ed McCarthy Sartori
Critics Gold 2004 Amarone, Estate Collection Della Valpolicella $39.99 Rich, flavorful. Long finish. Very fine. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2007 Pinot Grigio Delle Venezie $9.00 Pleasant, easy-drinking, flavorful. - Ed McCarthy Scheid Vineyards
Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay, Estate Grown Monterey $22.00 Light and delicate, with hints of pear, refreshingly crisp. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Silver 2006 Sauvignon Blanc, Reserve, Estate Grown Monterey $25.00 Delicate lime nose, with some oak. Medium-bodied, supple, quite silky, just enough zest to keep it lively on the palate. - Stephen Brook Schnebly Redlands Winery
Critics Gold NV Passion Fruit Florida $17.95 It is rare to have a fruit wine that tastes legitimately like wine. This one does, and is very tasty in an off-dry style. Very impressive. - Paul Lukacs Scott Family Estate
Critics Gold 2006 Pinot Noir, Dijon Clone Arroyo Seco $39.00 Has a fine forest floor, redwood bark scent, a hint of leather and burnished red cherry. Flavors are rich but balanced, a creaminess to the texture, forward but not overdone. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay, Dijon Clone Arroyo Seco $25.00 Marked as much by oak as fruit, but that fruit tastes opulent. - Paul Lukacs Sebeka
Critics Platinum 2008 Chenin Blanc, Steen Western Cape $10.00 Sharp-edged and distinct, with a classic pine profile to kick things off, plus crisp citrus edges and a distinct brightness to it. Lively and friendly. - Jon Bonne Sequoia Grove Vineyards
Critics Platinum 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $34.00 Pleasing and accessible Cab thanks to its lovely ripe fruit made even more interesting by its subtle undertones of cedar and old leather. - Nick Passmore
Critics Gold 2005 Syrah, Stagecoach Vineyard Napa Valley $28.00 Smells like a compote of India ink and black raspberries, warm and complex at once. No doubt it's a ripe wine, and fairly tannic, but its fine tannins and firm taut structure give the wine some elegance. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay Carneros $28.00 Full and nicely structured, with loads of vibrant fruit. - Marguerite Thomas Sherwood House Vineyards
Critics Gold 2004 Blanc de Blanc, House of Sherwood North Fork of Long Island $37.00 Flavorful, rich. Pleasant finish. - Ed McCarthy Sierra Madre Vineyard
Critics Silver 2007 Pinot Noir Santa Maria Valley $42.00 A big and beefy interpretation of Pinot. - Marguerite Thomas Silver Palm
Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon North Coast $35.00 Rich and lush with just enough spicy undertones to keep it interesting. - Nick Passmore Smith & Hook Vineyards
Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon Central Coast $24.00 Oak and subtle berry notes. Dry, medium texture, crisp acidity; short finish. - Gerald D. Boyd Smith-Madrone Vineyards
Critics Platinum 2004 Cabernet Sauvignon Spring Mountain District $45.00 Fantastic bouquet -- rich, ripe, but also nuanced and harmonious -- followed by expressive dark fruit and spicy oak flavors. Very, very pretty! - Paul Lukacs Snoqualmie Vineyards
Critics Silver 2008 Naked Riesling, Organic Columbia Valley $10.00 Very flavorful in a Spatlese style. - Paul Lukacs Solaire by Robert Mondavi
Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon Central Coast $16.99 Minty nose. Light berry back notes. Soft entry, medium fruit, tart; medium finish. Stylish. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay Santa Lucia Highlands $14.99 A subtle creamy profile, with bright orange and pear. Lean, precise, with a curious mineral tinge. - Jon Bonne Sonoma Vineyards
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay Sonoma County $15.00 Ripe, tropical fruit shows off at first, but is backed up with vibrancy and a balanced kiss of oak. - Leslie Sbrocco South Coast Winery
Critics Silver NV Black Jack Port South Coast $38.00 Swet and juicy. Fun to sip by a winter fire. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2003 Merlot, Carter Estate, Private Reserve South Coast $48.00 Plump black cherry nose. Soft, rather heavy and tannic, but has plenty of spice. Although quite extracted, it has some vigour and complexity. Effortful but a serious wine with good weight of fruit. - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver 2006 Sangiovese, Thunderbolt Block, Wild Horse Peak South Coast $34.00 Nice balance of oak and fruit in nose. Big fruity flavors, dark plums, some heat. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Silver 2006 Syrah, Lone Boulder Ridge, Wild Horse Peak South Coast $44.00 Great fruit. Delicious. - Ed McCarthy St. James Winery
Critics Silver NV Country Red American $6.99 Nice balanced red wine with an herbal topnote and juicy red cherry flavors. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Gold NV Friendship School White American $7.99 Complex aromas include ripe peach. Big bodied, but beautifully light on the palate. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Silver NV Strawberry American $8.99 Like drinking Smuckers. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver NV Peach American $8.99 Lusciously sweet. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2005 Chambourcin Ozark Mountain $6.99 Inviting earth and red current aromas, followed by ripe, succulent berry and cherry flavors. Bright and succulent, in an easy-drinking style, yet with plenty of interest. - Linda Murphy
Critics Platinum 2005 Cynthiana Ozark Mountain $6.99 Chocolatey, with deep blackberry, black cherry and black plum fruit on a lush, juicy frame. Hints of tar, vanilla, and briar add complexity. Tannins are supple in this unabashedly fruity wine. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver NV Velvet Red American $6.99 This 'foxy' dessert wine is exhibits a cherry cola flavor, typical of many Eastern varietals, but is well balanced and not cloyingly sweet. Serve well chilled with fruit-based desserts. - Robert Whitley
Critics Platinum 2005 Norton Dessert Wine Ozark Mountain $17.99 Complex elements including summer blackberries espresso, spice. Powerful in both taste and texture, with a long finish. A truly impressive dessert wine. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Silver 2005 Catawba Dessert Wine Ozark Mountain $12.99 Nicely balance between sweet and spicy, - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Silver 2006 Concord Dessert Wine American $12.99 A soft and silky, elegantly crafted wine. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Silver NV Pink Catawba American $6.99 Light distinct Catawba aroma. Pleasant sweet fruit. Good balancing acidity but a little cloying in the finish. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Silver 2006 Chardonel, Reserve Ozark Mountain $9.99 Distinct slightly green pungent aroma. Medium flavors, buttery notes. Crisp balanced finish. Not distinguished but pleasant. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Silver 2006 Chardonel Ozark Mountain $6.99 Oaky nose. Soft plate, some sweetness. Pleasant fruity finish. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Gold 2005 Late Harvest Chardonel Ozark Mountain $9.99 Delicious. Great balance. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2006 Chardonel Dessert Wine Ozark Mountain $12.99 Well-balanced; very flavorful. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold NV Riesling Columbia Valley $9.99 Turpine and lemony, deftly touched by sweetness. - Marguerite Thomas St. Julian
Critics Silver NV White Heron Lake Michigan Shore $7.99 Sweet and rich, with a surprisingly long aftertaste - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Silver NV Solera Cream Sherry, Michigan Light Michigan $15.99 Light brown. The nose is entirely clean. Soft, very sweet, caramel and coffee, with plenty of spice on the finish. - Stephen Brook St. Supery Vineyards & Winery
Critics Silver 2005 Elu Napa Valley $70.00 A nice meaty character to the fruit is effectively accented with smoky oak. - Michael Franz
Critics Silver 2003 Merlot Napa Valley $27.00 Lush plummy nose, with some sweet oak aromas. Soft, juicy, quite concentrated, good texture and integrated tannins. Has some spice and vigour. Drink it young. - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver 2008 Sauvignon Blanc Napa Valley $23.00 Aromas of fresh-cut grass and green pepper/jalapeno. The palate is quite rewarding, and clean, with a subtle herbaceousness running through the granny apple and meyer lemon fruitiness. - Linda Murphy
Critics Gold 2008 Sauvignon Blanc, Dollarhide Napa Valley $37.00 Passionfruit and lime entices the nose, and the palate delivers the same, along with white pepper, green melon, and slightly pungent grassiness. Racy and long in the finish. - Linda Murphy Stag's Leap Wine Cellars
Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay, Karia Napa Valley $34.00 Marked by crisp apple-like fruit and a bright backbone of acidity to provide verve. - Paul Lukacs Starborough
Critics Silver 2008 Sauvignon Blanc Marlborough $13.00 Pungent, grassy aromas. Surprisingly soft entry firms up on the mid-plate, with juicy gooseberry and passionfruit flavors. Perfectly ripened and gentle in its herbaceousness, it only lacks a crisper texture and finish. - Linda Murphy Stone Cellars By Beringer
Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon California $8.00 Soft, supple, and somewhat sweet. Very pretty, but again, sweet. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2007 Merlot California $8.00 Ripe, juicy, and slightly cooked nose. Medium-bodied, rather slight, some fresh acidity give it some crispness. A light style, but well balanced. - Stephen Brook Stone Hill Winery
Critics Silver 2005 Norton Hermann $18.99 A lean, lighter-style of Norton that is clean and crisp, with pretty berry flavors, a gentle leafy note and fine acidity. Almost chianti-like, and meant for food. - Linda Murphy Stoneleigh
Critics Gold 2007 Pinot Noir Marlborough $15.99 Raspberries, a little spice and a whiff of smoke. - Marguerite Thomas Stoney Mesa Winery
Critics Silver 2007 Riesling Colorado $12.00 Aromatic and honeyed, a treat for lovers of sweet wine. - Marguerite Thomas Stony Ridge
Critics Silver 2005 Petite Sirah Livermore Valley $26.00 Powerful stuff, full of brambly fruit and spice. Perfect for barbecue. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Gold NV Malvasia Bianca Livermore Valley $15.00 Lots of flavor; well-balanced. - Ed McCarthy Surfrider
Critics Silver 2005 Red Wine Malibu-Newton Canyon $29.00 Plum and berry fruit notes are pure and very pleasant, with wood accents that are sufficiently restrained to lend a bit of complexity without distracting attention from the tasty core of fruit. - Michael Franz
Critics Gold 2007 Pinot Gris Santa Barbara County $19.00 Richly-fruited, but also clean and fresh -- a difficult but delicious combination. - Paul Lukacs Talus
Critics Silver 2007 White Zinfandel California $7.99 Delicate aromas and flavors with a touch of sweetness make this a crowd-pleasing sipper. - Leslie Sbrocco
Critics Silver 2007 Pinot Noir Vin de Pays $7.99 Primary forward red raspberry fruit, resembling Beaujolais. Flavors are bright and simple, good quaffing red for an afternoon barbecue. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Gold 2006 Shiraz Lodi $7.99 Ripe minty nose, with a dash of oak. Medium-bodied, supple, easygoing, not a very concentrated style. Drink young - perhaps with lamb. Good value - promoted to Gold when I learnt the price (at double the price would have been a Silver). - Stephen Brook Tangent
Critics Gold 2008 Albarino, Paragon Vineyard Edna Valley $17.00 A rich wine, with a creamy pineapple scent. Flavors are ripe and firm, flavors and especially texture more citrusy, with a mineral finish. - Patrick Comiskey Tapena
Critics Silver 2008 Rose La Tierra De Castilla $10.00 A round and full-bodied party pleaser - Nick Passmore
Critics Silver 2007 Verdejo La Tierra De Castilla $10.00 Dry. Needs food, especially seafood, fish. - Ed McCarthy Terra Blanca
Critics Gold 2005 Onyx, Estate Vineyard Red Mountain $45.00 Rich and impressively concentrated but neither over-ripe nor overly aggressive, this shows pleasantly sweet fruit recalling dark berries and black cherries, along with a subtle wood note and very fine-grained tannins that firm up the finish just a bit while keeping the lingering flavors of fruit quite prominent. - Michael Franz
Critics Silver 2003 Syrah, Block 8, Estate Reserve Red Mountain $42.00 Dense nose, Indian spices, black fruits and a touch of mint. Rich, suave, but there is a distinct greenness that hardens the wine. If you like Syrah that is tangy with some cranberry tartness, then this is for you. - Stephen Brook Terra d'Oro
Critics Silver 2008 Rose Amador County $14.00 Bursting with ripe summer strawberries. - Nick Passmore
Critics Gold 2006 Zinfandel Amador County $18.00 A dense, layered nose, with pencil shavings and plum skin, and a rich, cocoa-tinged palate. Eloquent and heady, though with plenty of alcohol arriving on the finish. - Jon Bonne
Critics Platinum 2008 Moscato California $16.00 All ripe summer cantalopes and fall comice pears dripping honey kept interesting by a drop of citrus acidity. - Nick Passmore The Four Graces
Critics Silver 2007 Pinot Gris Dundee Hills $18.00 Light and lively. A fine summer aperitif wine. - Paul Lukacs The Yard
Critics Gold 2008 Riesling, Whispering Hill Vineyard Mount Barker $24.00 Delicate stoniness. Vibrant without being aggressive. Great length and balance. A star! - Michael Apstein Three Coins
Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $30.00 Shy in aroma and somewhat soft on entry, this is a smooth, polished Cab with well-ripened fruit and a tannic effect that kicks in on the finish. If Cabernet Sauvignon can be pretty, this one is. Ready to drink now. - Linda Murphy
Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay Oakville $24.00 A restrained style of Chardonnay that intrigues with the nose then fully delivers in the mouth. Layers of flavor finish with a touch of spice. - Leslie Sbrocco Tin Roof
Critics Silver 2006 Syrah - Cabernet Sauvignon California $10.99 Relatively light in weight and notably sweet in flavor, this nevertheless proves quite winning on the strength of the purity of the berry fruit notes, which are left at center stage thanks to the subtlety of the oak. - Michael Franz
Critics Gold 2005 Merlot California $10.99 Immediate ripe fruit flavors give way to attractive subtle meaty herbal notes in this well balanced wine. - Michael Apstein
Critics Silver 2006 Chardonnay California $10.99 Friendly and versatile, with an overlay of tropical fruit. - Marguerite Thomas Toasted Head
Critics Silver 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon North Coast $13.99 Chewy and hearty. The mineral-driven nose leads to stoic dark cherry with robust tannins. - Jon Bonne
Critics Gold 2007 Viognier Dunnigan Hills $13.99 Bold and beautiful with ultra-ripe fruit, plush texture and bigger-than-life style. - Leslie Sbrocco Trefethen Vineyards
Critics Gold 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon Oak Knoll District $50.00 Ripe yet elegant, this beautiful Cab balances smooth tannins and vibrant acidity with lush fruit. - Leslie Sbrocco
Critics Gold 2005 Merlot Oak Knoll District $35.00 Leather and dried woodruff, lavender and smoky red berry. A subtle, grippy palate with nuanced fruit presence and a surprising power on the end. Graceful, with perhaps a bit of extra bottle time on it. - Jon Bonne
Critics Gold 2006 Chardonnay Oak Knoll District $30.00 Rich and ripe but also refreshing to drink, so a very versatile Chardonnay. - Paul Lukacs Trenza
Critics Gold 2007 Tinto San Luis Obispo County $30.00 A meaty, substantial red that never veers off into seeming overblown or chunky, this shows deep, dark berry flavors that are well balanced against the components of oak and tannin. - Michael Franz Trinchero Family
Critics Silver 2005 Merlot, Main Street Monterey/Santa Barbara/Napa $12.00 Ripe cherry nose. Soft, suave, silky, with straightforward cherry fruit and light tannins. But it's rather slack and lacks drive, fading on the finish. But an attractive wine that would be good with charcuterie. - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver 2007 Riesling, Main Street Monterey County $10.00 A nice display of pear and apple fruit followed by a juicy finish. - Marguerite Thomas Trinity Oaks
Critics Gold 2007 Pinot Noir California $8.00 Alluringly simple and fruity. An undemanding, fine little wine. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Grigio California $7.00 Well-balanced; harmonious. - Ed McCarthy Trivento
Critics Silver 2006 Amado Sur Mendoza $15.99 Ripe juicy flavors of boysenberry and blackberry jam, buttressed by firm tannins with a hint of woodsmoke. - Robert Whitley
Critics Platinum 2006 Malbec, Golden Reserve Mendoza $19.99 Dense oaky nose, formidable black cherry fruit. Lush and voluptuous, concentrated, tannic, powerful, spicy, with tremendous energy and drive, and a long bright finish to give it freshness as well as power. Super wine, with enough density to cope with a classy BBQ. - Stephen Brook
Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay, Golden Reserve Mendoza $19.99 Generous body but not overbearing. Bountiful fruit balanced by a strong finish. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Silver 2008 Torrontes, Select Mendoza $10.99 Light, refreshing -- a nice example of this summery varietal. - Marguerite Thomas True Earth
Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay Mendocino County $12.99 High-toned apple and pear. Flavors are also pearlike and fresh, very focused, firm, mouthwatering acidity. - Patrick Comiskey Tudal Family Winery
Critics Gold 2006 Napa Valley Cuvee Napa Valley $12.00 A tad off dry, this crowd pleaser just explodes with zingy, bright fruit flavors. - Nick Passmore Twisted
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay California $7.99 Subtle nose, clean with light mineral notes. Soft mineral fruit. Brisk acidity to finish. - Gerald D. Boyd V. Sattui Winery
Critics Gold 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon Mount Veeder $40.00 Rambunctious and ripe -- juicy blackberry and raspberry highlights, with eucalyptus and oregano highlights and a robust ending. - Jon Bonne
Critics Platinum 2005 Merlot, Reserve Stock Napa Valley $50.00 Simply sumptuous! This is a powerhouse Merlot, marked by opulent fruit, spice, and oak flavors, enticing aromatics, and a long, layered finish. It's bigger than many Merlots, and some people might say too big. But it's a beautiful example of a wildly popular style, and I would think a steakhouse favorite. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2006 Merlot, Henry Ranch Los Carneros $36.00 A serious Merlot, firm and tight, with real power on the palate. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2006 Merlot Napa Valley $25.00 Tight and tannic in the finish, but with enough fruit flavor to not be overpowered. Decant it -- or cellar it. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2007 Pinot Noir Los Carneros $36.00 Nice leathery strawberry note. Firm, a bit too firm, but pleasant juicy red cherry fruit, and powerful tannins. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Silver 2007 Petite Sirah North Coast $27.00 Medium-bodied. Flavorful. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Platinum 2007 Syrah Russian River Valley $27.00 Very ripe cherry nose, quite oaky. Plump, juicy, upfront yet structured, quite tannic but not tough, has vigour thanks to good acidity. Long assertive finish, and enough body to stand up to ribs. - Stephen Brook
Critics Platinum 2007 Syrah Napa Valley $29.00 Inky jammy nose. Soft, fleshy, juicy, mouth-filling, big ripe tannins. Has swagger rather than finesse, plenty of energy and drive, and a long spicy chocolatey finish. Hardly subtle but would be a winner with rare meat. - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver 2007 Zinfandel, Old Vine, Pilgrim Vineyard Lodi $30.00 Low intensity aroma, oak and blackberry. Medium fruit, touch jammy. Medium dry finish. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Silver 2007 Zinfandel, Old Vine, Quaglia Vineyard Napa Valley $35.00 Berry and mint aromatics. Dense fruit flavors, mint. Big tannins, some heat in finish. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Platinum 2007 Zinfandel, Crow Ridge Vineyard, Old Vine Russian River Valley $30.00 Forward raspberry aroma, light oak. Bright fruit flavors, good balance. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay Los Carneros $28.00 A subtle floral lilt to it, with lemon peel and soft honeycomb. Pretty and juicy, if broad-shouldered. - Jon Bonne
Critics Platinum 2007 Chardonnay Napa Valley $28.00 When I think of world-class Chardonnay this is the kind of wine I seek. It shows spicy, balanced oak character layered with juicy fruit notes and a lush yet racy texture. - Leslie Sbrocco
Critics Silver 2008 Sauvignon Blanc, Vittorio's Vineyard Napa Valley $24.00 Muted nose, a touch of lime. Plump, rounded, juicy, a touch heavy-handed, and could use more acidity, but the fruit is attractive. - Stephen Brook
Critics Gold 2008 Sauvignon Blanc Napa Valley $18.25 Muted nose, ripe grapefruit. Rich, juicy, ample fruit here, has some spice and vigour, grapefruity zest and a hint of bitterness that enlivens the finish. - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver 2008 Semillon Napa Valley $18.75 Full, lush mouth feel with a bracing, crisp finish. - Nick Passmore Valdubon
Critics Platinum 2003 Crianza Ribera Del Duero $18.00 This delicious wine shows fully -- but not excessively -- ripened fruit that is very nicely matched with spicy, smoky oak. There is a nice meaty, carpaccio character as well, and very fine-grained tannins that lend structure to the finish without drying it. This isn't the biggest, most 'impressive' Ribera you might find, but it is very nicely balanced and quite versatile for food pairing purposes. - Michael Franz Valley of the Moon
Critics Silver 2005 Syrah Sonoma County $16.00 Leads with scents of purple flowers and beeswax. Flavors are dark berry, texture is exceedingly firm and mildly tannic. It needs a meal of herb roasted chicken and it will shine. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Gold 2007 Chardonnay Sonoma Coast $16.00 Very nicely structured, with well balanced fruit and medium body. - Marguerite Thomas Vaza
Critics Platinum 2004 Crianza Rioja $15.00 Cherry fruit, soft tannins, well integrated oak -- nothing too razzle-dazzle, just a beautifully well made and pleasing Rioja. - Marguerite Thomas Velocity Cellars
Critics Silver 2005 Red Wine Rogue Valley $25.00 Soft berry fruit is fresh and slightly -- but pleasantly -- sweet, with quite light, ripe tannins. Well suited to white meat dishes or barbequed pork or chicken. - Michael Franz Vendange
Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Shiraz California $8.99 Sweet and soft and sexy, this is a relatively light rendition of the breed, and yet the freshness and purity of the fruit produce a very pleasant finished product, as the tannins are so light and fine-grained that the fruit is left free to shine. - Michael Franz
Critics Gold 2008 White Zinfandel California $4.99 When you want a sipper with a little sweetness and a lot of fruit, this refreshing blush wine is the answer. Not serious but seriously fun. Chill well and pair up with spicy BBQ, Chinese take out, or even summer fruit salad. - Leslie Sbrocco
Critics Silver 2007 Zinfandel California $8.99 Low intensity nose. Blackberry. Medium palate, balanced. Brisk acidity, clean finish. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Gold 2008 Chardonnay South Eastern Australia $4.99 Fresh melon, honeydew rind, pear and citrus, unencumbered by evident wood. Clean, racy and eminently drinkable. - Jon Bonne Ventana Vineyards
Critics Silver 2007 Due Amici, Estate Grown Arroyo Seco $28.00 A rich earthiness on the front palate leads to a highly pleasing, ripe plum finish. - Nick Passmore
Critics Platinum 2007 Rubystone, Estate Grown Arroyo Seco $18.00 Great balance of fresh plummy black fruit, spice, bacon fat and herbs. Concentrated but balanced and not over the top. Black cherry-like acidity keeps it fresh and you coming back for more. Lovely now, but its balance suggests it will evolve beautifully -- if you can keep you hands off it. - Michael Apstein
Critics Silver 2007 Pinot Noir, Estate Grown Arroyo Seco $28.00 A nicely balanced wine with lush black fruit and hints of toasty oak. - Michael Apstein
Critics Platinum 2007 Syrah, Estate Grown Arroyo Seco $18.00 Warm, inviting aromas of maple, smoke, and black pepper, at once warm and complex. The fruit flavors are welcoming and forward, notes of mulberry, before the wine reverts to more savory notes of leather and black pepper. Not a lot of acidity, but the wine remains balanced, lifted and elegant. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Gris, Estate Grown Arroyo Seco $18.00 Rich and ripe, with impressive length on the palate. - Paul Lukacs
Critics Silver 2008 Riesling, Estate Grown Arroyo Seco $18.00 Citrus and kiwi fruits float across the palate ending on a sweet note. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Platinum 2007 Sauvignon Blanc, Estate Grown Arroyo Seco $16.00 Aromas of fresh English peas, followed by a full-bodied palate of luscious guava, pear, and citrus fruit. An enticing grassiness lurks in the background. Firm structure and a mouthwatering finish make this a complete, multi-dimensional, utterly delicious Sauvignon. - Linda Murphy Villa Mt. Eden
Critics Silver 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon, Grand Reserve Napa Valley $15.00 Low intensity, slightly earthy nose. Deeply set flavors, firm tannins. Good balance. - Gerald D. Boyd
Critics Platinum 2005 Pinot Noir, Grand Reserve, Bien Nacido Vineyard Santa Maria Valley $25.00 Nice combination of aromas, oak, earth,creamy cherry. The flavors are driven and juicy, great acid, mouthwatering with gripping fruit tannins on the finish.Showing what an elegant creature a forward fruited pinot from California can be. - Patrick Comiskey Villa San-Juliette Winery
Critics Gold 2007 Chorum Paso Robles $24.99 Ripe and robust, this shows very tasty fruit recalling dark berries and ripe plums. Fairly dense but not hard in texture, it offers lots of delicious deep flavors without any harshness or astringency in the finish. An admirable achievement of getting a lot of structured flavor without having any component of the wine seem overwrought. - Michael Franz
Critics Platinum 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon Paso Robles $14.99 Lots of wood here in taste and tannin, yet underneath is well-ripened fruit, vanilla smoothness and refreshing, crisp acidity. This is a crowd-pleaser. - Linda Murphy
Critics Gold 2007 Petite Sirah Paso Robles $14.99 Savory black olive, toasty oak, asian spice, with vivid black plum and blackberry fruit. It's a big, flavorful wine, with super acidity to keep it lively and palate-cleansing. Flat-out delicious. - Linda Murphy
Critics Gold 2008 Sauvignon Blanc Paso Robles $14.99 Beautifully balanced in fresh citrus and pear fruit, ruby red grapefruit and meyer lemon on the mid-palate, and a refreshing close. Delicate in style, elegant, and not at all in-your-face. Would be great with food. - Linda Murphy Vina del Frade
Critics Silver 2007 Tempranillo, Oak Aged Ribera Del Duero $6.99 Not overly complex, but bright, fresh and juicy. Pair alongside pizza, grilled sausages, sharp cheeses and even fleshy fishes topped with tomato. - Leslie Sbrocco Vina Robles
Critics Silver 2006 Signature Paso Robles $39.00 Fresh and flashy, this shows very nice raspberry fruit notes backed up by sweet, ripe tannins and just a little whiff of oak. - Michael Franz
Critics Silver 2006 Suendero Paso Robles $49.00 Relatively simple but very tasty, this shows nicely ripened fruit recalling black cherries and dark berries, with a very restrained undertone of oak. - Michael Franz
Critics Gold 2008 WHITE4, Huerhuero Paso Robles $14.00 Crisp nose, pears. Fresh attack, fine texture, quite concentrated, attractive weight and spice, with considerable persistence on the finish. - Stephen Brook
Critics Silver 2008 Sauvignon Blanc, Jardine Paso Robles $16.00 Wet stones and rich pear/apple aromas lead to a mouthful of the same, plus some grassy and jalapeno notes. Some alcoholic heat hurts the finish. - Linda Murphy Wagner Vineyards
Critics Platinum 2007 Riesling Ice Finger Lakes $24.99 Masterful. Completely delicious. Long, pleasant finish. An excellent wine. - Ed McCarthy Waters Crest Winery
Critics Platinum 2006 Cabernet Franc, Private Reserve North Fork of Long Island $34.99 The Forbidden Forest - dark, mysterious and earthy. - Nick Passmore Waterstone
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay Carneros $18.00 Little green; soft low intensity fruit. Light finish. - Gerald D. Boyd White Truck
Critics Silver 2007 Chardonnay, Unoaked Santa Barbara County $10.99 Low intensity clean fruity nose. Crisp acidity, light fruit, citrus notes. Medium finish. - Gerald D. Boyd Whitecliff Vineyard and Winery
Critics Silver NV Awosting White Hudson River Region $12.95 A real winner thanks to the intensity of its delicious peach and pear fruit flavors. - Nick Passmore Willamette Valley Vineyards
Critics Gold 2006 Chardonnay, Dijon Clone Willamette Valley $18.00 A nicely perfumed and satisfying wine with a medium body and refreshing finish. - Marguerite Thomas
Critics Silver 2007 Riesling Willamette Valley $12.00 Mineral notes and a lemony finish. - Marguerite Thomas Williamsburg Winery
Critics Silver 2005 Gabriel Archer Reserve Virginia $32.00 Medium-bodied and fairly restrained, this isn't the most showy wine of its type, but is nevertheless very well balanced and likely to prove quite versatile with a wide range of moderately robust foods. - Michael Franz Wilson Creek Winery
Critics Gold 2006 Syrah, Estate Temecula Valley $32.95 Rich. Complex, very fine. - Ed McCarthy Wine Cube
Critics Silver 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon California $15.99 Lush blackberry nose. Medium-bodied, supple, juicy, not much personality but plenty of fruit and some light dusty tannins to keep it going on the palate. - Stephen Brook
Critics Gold 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon / Shiraz California $15.99 Closed nose. Plump, juicy, good fruit and plenty of spice. There is no subtlety here but it is a good mouthful of fruit that makes it an excellent BBQ wine. - Stephen Brook
Critics Gold 2008 Pinot Grigio California $15.99 Pretty floral nose, with jasmine and a hint of vanilla over fresh melon. The palate is ripe and juicy, delivering loads of flavor for this varietal, with a gentle touch of sweetness on the finish. Perfect picnic wine.. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver 2007 Sauvignon Blanc California $15.99 The aromas are quite shy, though there is solid apple-y fruit with lemony acidity and good palate weight. A good buy. - Linda Murphy Winesmith
Critics Platinum 2004 Crucible Cabernet Sauvignon Napa County $100.00 Ultra-elegant Cab that is proof positive wines don't need to be huge to be stars. - Leslie Sbrocco
Critics Gold 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon California $20.00 With an appealingly smooth texture and dark berry fruitiness, this subtle red is a winner. - Leslie Sbrocco Witch Creek Winery
Critics Silver 2007 Nebbiolo Guadalupe Valley $30.00 Brooding. Quite fine. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Silver 2007 Petite Sirah, Heringer Vineyard Clarksburg $25.00 Rich, gutsy, dry. Long finish. - Ed McCarthy
Critics Gold 2007 Zinfandel Lodi $32.00 Softly seductive, with a core of ripe fruit that lingers on the palate. - Marguerite Thomas Wollersheim Winery
Critics Silver 2008 Prairie Fume, Seyval American $9.00 Light and dry, with racy lemon-lime fruit and a tangy finish. Serve well-chilled on a warm summer afternoon or with fresh oysters. - Linda Murphy
Critics Silver NV White Riesling American $9.00 Light and as delicate as a butterfly's wing. - Marguerite Thomas Woodbridge Winery
Critics Silver 2008 Pinot Grigio California $7.99 Very light mineral-citrus aroma. Medium fruit, bracing acidity. Medium finish. - Gerald D. Boyd Wyndham Estate
Critics Silver 2005 Shiraz, George Wyndham, Founder's Reserve South Australia $17.00 Interesting notes of sea air, wet stones, plum. On the palate the fruit comes through, plum mixed with violets, relatively light weight. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Gold 2005 Shiraz, Black Cluster Hunter Valley $35.00 Rhonelike notes of white pepper and India ink. The flavors are figgy and ripe, the texture is big-shouldered, showing a richness on the palate that suggests barbecue for a good food pairing. - Patrick Comiskey Yellow Hawk Cellar
Critics Silver 2005 Solstice Columbia Valley $24.00 Aromas at the outset are only oak. The flavors betray a dark spiced cherry jam to go along with dark chocolatey oak flavors. - Patrick Comiskey
Critics Gold 2007 Muscat Canelli Columbia Valley $12.00 Something starkly phenolic amid the orange and apricot. Vivacious and upfront. - Jon Bonne Ysios
Critics Platinum 2004 Reserva Rioja $30.00 Ultra-smooth red with a seamless marriage of Old World complexity and New World fruit flavors. - Leslie Sbrocco
|
|
|
| |
|
|
