Robert Whitley
FOUNDING DIRECTOR
Entry Instructions
International Entries
Category Codes
Entry Form
The Judges
About Us
Results
Medal Images
Links of Interest
Home
 

Results > 2026 Judge Comments, Gold and Platinum Spirits Award Winners

BACARDÍ
Ron Superior Carta Blanca Puerto Rico $12.99 Gold 92 points
Surprisingly not sweet, it carries some pepper notes and a viscous quality. It holds itself in the mouth cleanly. - Michael Cervin
 
Reserva Ocho Rare Gold Rum Puerto Rico $25.99 Gold 92 points
Spot on aged rum, with bright spice and rich vanilla character without cloying viscosity. Sip or cocktail! - Rich Cook
 
Cemi
Ron Dominicano Reserva Especial Rum Dominican Republic $50.00 Gold 90 points
Lovely caramel and pepper notes, light sweetness and a strong midpalate. - Michael Cervin
 
Courvoisier
XO Cognac France $200.00 Platinum 96 points
For fans of lively wood spice that rides a silky spirit base, with pure toffee and baked apple that finish long and warming. It's winter somewhere… - Rich Cook
A solid iteration of Cognac. light caramel aromas lead into real depth of resin, spices, amber and light wildflowers. A seamless blending of fruit, wood and spice holds its own throughout the palate. The finish is strong and lengthy. - Michael Cervin
 
VSOP Cognac France $42.00 Gold 91 points
Classic Cognac, wood, fruit, spice and blending together to present a solid iteration. - Michael Cervin
Beautiful midpalate layers, with fruit, spice and oak toast in fine harmony. - Rich Cook
 
VS Cognac France $30.00 Gold 90 points
Textbook VS, this is the bartender's friend. Clean, bright and long, but with room for company. - Rich Cook
 
Griffo Distillery
Scott Street Gin Batch No. 35 USA $32.00 Gold 93 points
Bursting with juniper and classically styled, with just a tinge of California jazz in the botanical mix - a nicely realized profile. - Rich Cook
 
Vodka Batch No. 37 USA $24.00 Gold 90 points
Not a neutral vodka, opting for clean mineral flavors and a hint of sweetness. Nicely balanced! - Rich Cook
 
Espresso Martini Premium Cocktail USA $24.00 Gold 90 points
Simple but effective. The coffee notes are obvious and the viscosity works. A light sweetness pervades the cocktail, but in the end, this does exactly what it should do, which is taste great. - Michael Cervin
 
Punt e Mes
Apertivo Originale Vermouth Italy $26.99 Gold 92 points
Nice richness here - follow the advice to serve over ice - it's like a concentrate that benefits from dilution in a big way. - Rich Cook
 
Ron Santa Teresa
1796 Triple Aged Solar Rum Venezuela $40.00 Platinum 95 points
Bravo! This pops with flavor from the start, with tempered viscosity and a long blooming finish. A sipper extraordinaire! - Rich Cook
 
Weldon Mills Distillery
Weldon Mills Reserve Straight Bourbon Whiskey, Barrel Proof, Batch No: 3 USA $64.95 Platinum 94 points
A beautifully managed high proof, with a slow burn and subtle flavor mix in the finish. Sip neat if you dare, or go with a big cube and linger long. - Rich Cook
 
Wheated Straight Bourbon Whiskey Small Batch Barrel Proof, Batch 2 USA $124.95 Gold 93 points
Wheated whiskey that actually delivers wheat character, with fine tuned accents and a pleasant warming finish that lasts. - Rich Cook
 
Weldon Mills Select Straight Bourbon Whiskey, Batch. No: 2 USA $54.95 Gold 92 points
This is assertive, but in a balanced way that brings a nicely spiced finish push to bear. Sip with a small ice cube, or cocktail it up. - Rich Cook
An expressive bourbon that favors bold flavors over typical sweetness. The wood and spice notes elevate this beyond standard bourbon, and the longer finish gives it an edge in the category. - Michael Cervin
 
Soldier's Cut Straight Bourbon Whiskey USA $44.95 Gold 91 points
Great wood flavors, supported by amber and resin notes. Light caramel and butterscotch, while still being a little subdued. - Michael Cervin

  << Return
Critics Challenge
315 16th Street, Suite B
San Diego, CA 92101
Contact Us

Entry Instructions | International Entries | Category Codes | Entry Form
The Judges | About Us | Results | Links of Interest | Home