Robert Whitley
FOUNDING DIRECTOR
Entry Instructions
International Entries
Category Codes
Entry Form
The Judges
About Us
Results
Medal Images
Links of Interest
Home
 

Results > 2026 Judge Comments, Gold and Platinum Wine Award Winners

Judge Comments on Platinum and Gold Award Winners 
(Listed alphabetically by brand)
Note to wineries - you may use these quotes with attribution in your marketing materials 
 
 
1924
2024 Double Black Cabernet Sauvignon Bourbon Barrel Aged; Limited Edition Lodi $15.00 Gold 90 points
Black plums, baking spice on the nose. Palate is fruity, full, tannins are silky and finish is smooth. Finish borders on sweetness. Pair with Cornish hen and baked apricots. - Stacie Hunt
There's a whole lot of grainy oak, but with so much luscious dark fruit that the end result is balanced, joyous and fun. - Mike Dunne
 
1881 Napa
2023 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $40.00 Gold 91 points
A crowd pleaser Cabernet with big fruit, but balanced with supportive oak. - Michael Cervin
 
Adobe Hill Winery
2023 Teroldego San Luis Rey $48.00 Gold 90 points
Tar and purple flowers on the nose. Big drying tannins with juicy acidity. A varietally correct Teroldego. - Allison Levine
Aromas of rose and tar, well-balanced, with sturdy tannins on the finish. - Tim Teichgraeber
 
Alamos
2024 Cabernet Sauvignon Mendoza $13.00 Platinum 94 points
Fresh, structured, elegant….made me stop in my tracks. Red and black fruits, forest spice, tar, and a freshness on the nose, really elegant and enjoyable. Subtle oak, almost nonexistent. So very drinkable. - Allison Levine
Refined, elegant, not overwhelmed with new oak, fresh blueberry and graphite notes with a nice, easy finish. - Tim Teichgraeber
 
2024 Malbec Mendoza $13.00 Platinum 94 points
Lovely nose of boysenberry and plum with violet, plenty of blue fruit on the palate with balance and verve. Outstanding. - Jeffrey Kralik
 
Arenas
2023 Moscato Valle Central $16.99 Gold 93 points
Medium straw color; slightly rustic aroma; medium bodied, firm and nicely built on the palate. - Wilfred Wong
 
badaBADOC
2022 Red Wine Priorat DOQ $17.50 Gold 91 points
Primary aromas of raspberry and lightly brown spice. The balance of tannins with juicy acidity is playful, with a mouthwatering finish. - Allison Levine
 
Barefoot Bubbly
NV Extra Dry California $9.99 Platinum 94 points
Lovely. Nice citrus with a touch of pear, a salty note looking for oysters, and just a kiss of sweetness. - Jeffrey Kralik
A delightfully crushable, mouth-watering bubbly with plenty of fruit and enough acid to keep that sweetness in balance. - Devin Parr
NV Pinot Grigio California $9.99 Platinum 94 points
Wonderful. A bit different, but we all need some different in our lives. Tons of tropical fruit, a lovely zing, and just the right amopunt of sweetness. Fun wine. - Jeffrey Kralik
This is a really fun, slightly sweet, slightly aromatic, perfectly tart sparkler. Everything is in balance, which makes all of these elements come together beautifully. Is it the perfect breakfast wine? Aperitif? Dessert pairing? Afternoon pick-me-up? Honestly, all could work. - Devin Parr
 
NV Pink Moscato California $9.99 Gold 92 points
Bubblegum pink in the glass, oozing classic muscat, tons of bubbles and even more character. - Jeffrey Kralik
Juicy, Jolly Rancher sweetness, with a vibrant effervescence, all balanced by nice freshness. This would honestly make the perfect breakfast wine. - Devin Parr
 
NV Brut Cuvée California $9.99 Gold 91 points
Lively with a lovely citrusy tang, a fantastic sparkler. - Jeffrey Kralik Juicy, fresh, and delicious. This is the perfect brunch bubbly or an elegant pre-dinner aperitif. - Devin Parr
 
NV Moscato Spumante California $9.99 Gold 91 points
Intense lime and peach with a fervent sparkle and a balancing sweetness. - Jeffrey Kralik
 
NV Brut Rosé California $9.99 Gold 90 points
Bubblegum pink with lovely red fruit on the nose. The palate is quite juicy, with a touch of sweetness. - Jeffrey Kralik
 
Barefoot Cellars
NV Sauvignon Blanc California $6.99 Platinum 94 points
Aromas of grapefruit, lemon/lime, fresh grass. Palate pulls grapefruit forward, grassiness follows, crisp green. Sprightly acidity & clean finish. Shellfish, asparagus, goat cheese. - Stacie Hunt
A spot-on Sauvignon Blanc for its clarity, balance and assurance, reserved in its sweetness, confident in its balance and vitality. - Mike Dunne
 
NV Cabernet Sauvignon California $6.99 Gold 92 points
An elegant cherry still life in an oak frame fitting in scale to the assurance and allure of the fruit. A Cabernet Sauvignon of deliberation and admiration. - Mike Dunne
 
NV Rodeo Red Blend California $6.99 Gold 91 points
Good fruit, good weight, a nice tang, and it all works well together. - Jeffrey Kralik
 
NV White Moscato California $6.99 Gold 91 points
Playful and easy to drink, this balances sweetness with drinkabililty. - Michael Cervin
 
NV Chardonnay California $6.99 Gold 90 points
Light straw, yellow color; weighty; oaky, with unusual tannic impression. - Wilfred Wong
 
NV Pinot Grigio American $6.99 Gold 90 points
A complete Pinot Grigio with weighted midplate and fresh acidity - Allison Levine
Refreshing and zippy, a pool-side sipper. - Tim Teichgraeber
 
NV Sangria $6.99 Gold 90 points
Medium ruby color; celery aroma, fruity; tangy and very fruity flavors; nice firmness in the finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
NV White Zinfandel California $6.99 Gold 90 points
Bright, ripe strawberry in a glass with that classic White Zin sweetness. - Jeffrey Kralik
A textbook white Zin! Sweet, candied fruit, with a touch of freshness. Just an easy-drinking wine, sure to delight fans of the style. - Devin Parr
 
Barefoot Fruitscato
NV Pear $6.99 Gold 93 points
Bosc pear from the jump, a wonderfully balanced and completely crushable wine. Outstanding. - Jeffrey Kralik
Like biting into the ripest, juiciest pear. Clean and fresh with the perfect amount of acid to really lift the pear notes and sweetness. - Devin Parr
 
NV Mango $6.99 Gold 92 points
Clean, fresh and inherently likeable, with genuine mango flavor, not a whiff of artificiality. There's a wonderful tropical quality that makes this tasty on its own but it would probably also be great in a cocktail. - Devin Parr
 
NV Peach $6.99 Gold 92 points
A sweet and dreamy little number. Makes me think of being carefree in a garden, grabbing fresh peaches warmed in the sun. A fresh, clean take on the peach flavor. - Devin Parr
 
NV Pineapple $6.99 Gold 92 points
Intense pineapple on the nose with fantastic fruit on the palate, like a big bite out of a pineapple that just fell from the bush. - Jeffrey Kralik
Like a sparkling Moscato that's been kissed by a touch of pineapple. A lovely, easygoing, crushable wine with some nice acidity to balance out the sweetness. The pineapple flavor is pure, subtle, and tasty. - Devin Parr
 
Basalt Cellars
2023 Cabernet Franc Estate Lewis-Clark Valley $34.00 Gold 93 points
Violet notes, elegant and balanced. Full-bodied and precise with a long finish. - Allison Levine
Blueberry, tar and earth aromas, black fruit flavors and an even, long finish. - Tim Teichgraeber
 
NV Sparkling Rosé Columbia Valley $34.00 Gold 92 points
Like a creamy brie cheese with a berry compote! Complex enough to stand up to food or for a special occasion, but enough fresh fruit and zip to make for a really enjoyable afternoon sipper. - Devin Parr
 
2023 Rim Rock Red Washington State $24.00 Gold 90 points
Deep ruby color; ripe black cherry, excellent depth in the aromas; medium bodied; black. - Wilfred Wong
 
Beni Duilio
2023 Montepulciano Abruzzo DOC $20.99 Gold 91 points
A tasty, fruit-packed, easy style of Montepulciano with lots of freshness and easy appeal. The perfect lunch red. - Devin Parr
 
Bezel
2024 Pinot Noir San Luis Obispo Coast $30.00 Gold 91 points
Taut tannins support subdued fruit with solid acidity. - Michael Cervin
Light garnet color; dried spices, kitchen cabinet aroma; medium-bodied, slightly taut on the palate, generous finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
2025 Sauvignon Blanc Paso Robles $25.00 Gold 91 points
Grass and clover aromas, lime zest, great acidity and length. - Tim Teichgraeber
 
2023 Cabernet Sauvignon Paso Robles $30.00 Gold 90 points
Dark ruby color; kitchen cabinet spices, black fruit aromas; medium bodied; black fruit, oak; bold finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
Black Box
NV Pinot Noir California $19.99 Platinum 94 points
Fresh red cherry blast on the nose.  Palate continues cherry , red plum, with earthiness & minerality. Burgers and ribs! - Stacie Hunt
Loping cherry fruit skips across the palate with gentle yet assured buoyancy. The wine is dry and pleasant, lingering invitingly. - Mike Dunne
 
NV Rosé California $19.99 Gold 91 points
Subtle strawberry, with a nice tangy kick. Keep this is the fridge and it will go surprisingly quickly! - Jeffrey Kralik
 
NV Cabernet Sauvignon California $19.99 Gold 90 points
Beckoning floral and fruity aroma is followed by sturdy red fruit, a frank earthiness, firm but yielding structure, and a perky acidity that keeps it refreshing. - Mike Dunne
 
NV Malbec California $19.99 Gold 90 points
Boxed wines only occasionally come with this much complexity, its fragrant red fruit in a nest of briars and leather. Its acidity drives it across the palate, finishing crisp while also respecting the wine's enduring fruit. Wood is evident but not upstaging. - Mike Dunne
 
Bolero at Europa Village
2023 Garnacha Paso Robles $59.00 Platinum 94 points
Very pretty and inviting…says drink me! Fresh raspberry and cherry on the nose, textured tannins, delicate long-lasting acidity. - Allison Levine
Proper Grenache with fresh wild strawberry and raspberry, blueberry and mint notes. Lifted, fresh and easy drinking. - Tim Teichgraeber
 
Boles Vineyard
2023 Field Blend Livermore Valley $35.00 Gold 91 points
Darker cheery based fruit, moderate tannins and acidity, a little brooding. - Michael Cervin
 
Bota Box
NV Cabernet Sauvignon American $22.99 Gold 90 points
Dark plum, black cherry on the nose. Palate is immediately savory from dried herbs, dried fruits. Grippy tannin. Pair with grilled lamb and roasted vegetables. - Stacie Hunt
 
NV Dry Rosé California $22.99 Gold 90 points
Bright strawberry and a dash of cherry with just a kiss of sweetness. - Jeffrey Kralik
 
Bourgmont Winery
2025 Seyval Kansas $22.00 Gold 91 points
Meyer lemon nose, lemon curd, fresh thyme.  Palate is dry and cleansing.  Pair with shrimp, oysters, crab. - Stacie Hunt
 
2025 Seyval Oaked Kansas $26.00 Gold 91 points
Persian melon, Meyer lemon, candied citrus peel.  Palate is fresh fruit, acidity keeps it lively.  Pair with clam or shrimp pasta, lobster roll, creamy cheeses. - Stacie Hunt
 
NV Voyageur Blanc Kansas $22.00 Gold 90 points
Honeydew melon, honeysuckle on the nose. Palate is very fruity, acidity gives the finish a crispness. Aperitif style wine on a hot day. - Stacie Hunt
Citric and crisp, with suggestions of peach and apricot to make this a finely layered white, refreshing and spirited. - Mike Dunne
 
Breathless
2021 Sparkling Pinot Meunier Sonoma County $60.00 Platinum 95 points
Wow! Great tree fruit couched in some brilliant acidity and poured over a freshly baked croissant. Delicious. - Jeffrey Kralik
Layers of fruit, floral notes, marzipan, and brioche, tight bubbles, and great length. The touch of peachy color almost suggests a blanc de noirs. Just a beautifully-made bubbly. - Devin Parr
 
NV Blanc De Noirs Methode Champenoise Sonoma County $39.00 Platinum 94 points
Rich and a bit nutty with a savory side that screams for food. Paired with roast chicken? Whoa. - Jeffrey Kralik
 
NV Blanc de Blancs Methode Champenoise Sonoma County $39.00 Gold 90 points
Tart and juicy with nice pear and peach, a fun and exciting wine. - Jeffrey Kralik
Savory and crisp. A toastier style with layers of herbal and brioche notes and a pleasant backbone of fruit and freshness. - Devin Parr
 
Brotello
2022 Primitivo di Manduria Primitivo di Manduria DOC $19.99 Gold 90 points Medium red color; dried spices in the aroma; medium bodied; bright finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
Brys Estate Vineyard & Winery
2024 Gewurztraminer Reserve Estate Grown Old Mission Peninsula $26.00 Platinum 94 points
Very pretty, zippy acidity, rose petal aromas, a very beautiful expression of Gewurztraminer with a lovely light lift. - Allison Levine
Lovely rose petal and apricot aromas, fresh and zippy, this is Gewurztraminer at its finest. - Tim Teichgraeber
 
2022 Pinot Noir Reserve Estate Grown Old Mission Peninsula $28.00 Gold 92 points
Bright fruit, solid acidity and supportative tannins make for a food friendly wine. - Michael Cervin
Light to medium garnet color; spicy, green olives aroma; silky on the palate; dried spicy flavors; elevated finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
Buena Vista Winery
2023 Chateau Buena Vista Pinot Noir Sonoma Coast $39.99 Gold 91 points
Medium garnet; fresh herb garden aromas, almost savory; lively on the palate; tart fruit flavors, clean and bright finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
C 'est La Vie
2025 Viognier Temecula Valley $49.00 Gold 92 points
Targeted lemon fruit, fresh and clear, bounding across the palate with energy and determination. A Viognier fit for a table where the featured entrée is grilled shrimp gussied up with a mango salsa. - Mike Dunne
 
Calvari
NV Red Blend Italy $14.99 Gold 92 points
Really juicy and fun with loads of fruit and a healthy dose of verve, a completely crushable wine. - Jeffrey Kralik
 
Cantina Etrusca
2024 Montepulciano Abruzzo DOC $19.99 Gold 90 points
A beautiful representative of the genre: fruity, tart, balanced, wonderful. - Jeffrey Kralik
Pleasant and easy-drinking. A classic style, approachable and well-made. Give this wine an elaborate charcuterie board and watch some magic happen. - Devin Parr
 
Casa de Alquería
2024 Red Blend Maule Valley $17.99 Gold 90 points
Plenty of fruit with good structure and balance. A completely crushable wine. - Jeffrey Kralik
A tasty, savory red blend. Nice balance of fruit and spice and a satisfyingly grippy finish. - Devin Parr
 
2024 Sauvignon Blanc Maule Valley $17.99 Gold 90 points
Medium straw, yellow color; herbal, vegetal aroma; medium bodied, weighty on the palate; celery leaf flavors; medium finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
Charles Woodson's Intercept
2023 Red Blend Paso Robles $19.99 Platinum 94 points
Nose of mocha cherry, black plum, dried herbs, baking spices, fruit carries through palate, youthful tannin. Wear jeans and have a hot dog, or dress up and have Steak au Poivre! - Stacie Hunt
Intense yet welcoming, its focused fruit sunny and abiding. A sublime, seamless weaving of Bordeaux varieties, resulting in a tapestry that demands closer examination for all its subtle threads to register. - Mike Dunne
 
Chateau Elan Winery
2022 Bianco Riserva Batch No GA-030916 American $50.00 Platinum 94 points
Amazing diversity of flavors represented here with candied almond, white peach, Asian pear, caramel and butterscotch, ending with lightly bitter almond. - Michael Cervin
Deep amber color; beeswax, ripe peaches; substantive palate textures; smashed stone fruit flavors; long. - Wilfred Wong
 
NV Duncan Creek Muscadine Georgia $11.95 Gold 92 points
A noble, rotund and engagingly sweet wine. It has balance, complexity, spice and persistence, bringing down the curtain with a standing ovation for its gloriously sunny fruit, running to peaches and nectarines, draped with curls of melon. - Mike Dunne
 
NV Port Riserva Batch No GA-020915 American $55.00 Gold 92 points
Nice fruit with that classic port flavor. Well done. - Jeffrey Kralik
 
2023 Choose Your Path American $26.00 Gold 91 points
Big, juicy, and grippy, this wine would welcome a juicy steak with open arms. - Jeffrey Kralik
 
2022 Petite Sirah Fingerprint Collection American $60.00 Gold 91 points
Deep purple, violet color; spices and ripe grapey fruit; lively palate; bright finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
Christopher Cameron Vineyards
2022 Merlot Van Alyea Ranch Dry Creek Valley $48.00 Platinum 94 points
Hell Yes! Would drink this every day! - Devin Parr
 
Clos du Bois
2024 Tropical Chardonnay California $10.99 Gold 92 points
Nose of vanilla, butterscotch, citrus flower. Palate has sweetness, which is offset by the acidity. A rich version of Chardonnay. - Stacie Hunt
 
2024 Buttery Chardonnay California $10.99 Gold 91 points
Nose of ginger flower, white citrus, sassafras.  Palate is sweet spice from the (overly) toasted oak. Finishes on the sweet side. Definitely has an audience. - Stacie Hunt
 
Clos Pegase
2023 Merlot Napa Valley $56.00 Platinum 95 points
Classy top-shelf Merlot with plum, graphite, blackberry and spice notes. - Tim Teichgraeber
A wine with depth and structure. Dark red fruits with a mix of earth and leather.  On the palate, the wine hits you everywhere and keeps going - sturdy tannins, fresh acidity, long depth of flavor. - Allison Levine
 
2022 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $70.00 Gold 93 points
Nose is a combo of plums, mocha cherry, earthiness & spice, touch of mint. On the palate fruit carries across grippy tannins. - Stacie Hunt
 
Costa Azul
2024 Carignane Organic Pine Mountain - Cloverdale Peak $42.00 Gold 92 points
Deep ruby color; ripe red fruit and mineral aroma; medium bodied, sappy on the palate; bright fruit and oak flavors; good tension in the finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
2023 GSM Sonoma County/Central Coast California $48.00 Gold 90 points
Medium deep ruby color; savory spices in the aroma; medium bodied, bright on the palate; lively red fruit flavors; medium finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
Curious
2022 Chardonnay Petaluma Gap $29.00 Platinum 94 points
A pretty nose invites you. Delicate acidity, finishes with baking spices. Varietally driven wine, not oak-dominated. - Allison Levine
Aromas that are a dead-ringer for Chablis, with a rounded, beguiling spiced baked apple finish. - Tim Teichgraeber
 
de Négoce
2022 Lot 476 Cabernet Sauvignon Mendocino County $21.00 Gold 90 points
Solid Cab, medium-weight with fresh red currant, blackberry notes, refreshing acidity and moderate tannin. - Tim Teichgraeber
 
DeLoach Vineyards
2024 Pinot Noir Certified Sustainable California $15.99 Platinum 96 points
Bursting with fruit, with hints of earth and a healthy dose of tartness, a welcome addition to any table. - Jeffrey Kralik
Wow, this wine has everthing. Enough body to pack a punch, so many layers of fruit, just enough of a savory note, but lifted by so much freshness. Really elegant and juicy. I could drink this every damn day. - Devin Parr
 
2025 Pinot Gris Certified Sustainable California $15.99 Gold 92 points
Pears, green apple, sweet citrus flowers on the nose. Palate carries through with the fruit into the crisp finish. - Stacie Hunt
 
2024 Zinfandel Certified Sustainable California $15.99 Gold 90 points
Medium ruby color; zesty red and black fruit aromas; medium finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
Due Mari
2023 Montepulciano Abruzzo DOC $19.99 Gold 91 points
An earthy nose leads to a fruity palate with cherry and red currant having a little tête-à-tête. Very nice. - Jeffrey Kralik
A really juicy Monty. This is the kind of wine that's an instant hit in a crowd. Easy-drinking, juicy fruit, a hint of new world spice. More international than old school in style. - Devin Parr
 
2024 Montepulciano Abruzzo DOC $17.99 Gold 91 points
Juicy, fruity, and loaded with Chuztpah, this is a party pleaser, and will empty quickly. - Jeffrey Kralik
 
2024 Sangiovese Puglia IGT $16.99 Gold 90 points
Medium garnet color; aromatic spice aroma; medium bodied, steady and firm on the palate with trace tannins; dried earthy flavors; firm finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
Eberle
2024 Syrah Alta Colina and Steinbeck Vineyards Paso Robles $43.00 Gold 93 points
A Syrah that resonates with exceptional fragrance, the juiciness of blueberries, the sinew and fat of bacon, and the support of well-honed timber. It's a romp of drama and pleasure. - Mike Dunne
 
2023 Cabernet Sauvignon Vineyard Selection Paso Robles $30.00 Gold 92 points
Dark ruby color; bold, black fruit aroma, quite fine; full bodied, layered on the palate; classy black fruit flavors; well-built finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
2023 Cabernet Sauvignon Estate Vineyard Paso Robles $60.00 Gold 92 points
Expressive cherry fruit with supportative tannins and acidity - Michael Cervin
 
2024 Côtes-du-Rôbles Paso Robles $40.00 Gold 91 points
Light garnet color; dried spices and kitchen cupboard aromas; zesty, red fruit flavors, zesty finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
2025 Muscat Canelli Estate Vineyard Paso Robles $25.00 Gold 91 points
Efervescent and playful, this has a great balance of flavors. - Michael Cervin
Light greenish color; pencil lead; apple candied; medium sweet; bright finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
2025 Côtes-du-Rôbles Blanc Paso Robles $34.00 Gold 90 points
Aromatic power promises and delivers rich nectarine, lemon and nut flavors that ride bright acidity through the long invitational finish. A winner! - Rich Cook
 
2025 Côtes-du-Rôbles Rosé Paso Robles $32.00 Gold 90 points
Light strawberry and green apple dominate this racy rosé. - Michael Cervin
 
2025 Viognier Estate Vineyard Paso Robles $40.00 Gold 90 points
Supremely floral on the nose. Palate picks up white peach, ripe apricot. Acidity is crisp.  Pair with roasted chicken and grilled artichoke. - Stacie Hunt
A swaying, swashbuckling Viognier, its honeysucle thick and long, its peaches fat and juicy, with just enough acidity to keep it afloat, bouncing brightly and sweetly across the palate. - Mike Dunne
 
Elizabeth Spencer
2025 Sauvignon Blanc Special Cuvée North Coast $28.00 Gold 91 points
Bright, clean, great citrus notes and bright acidity. - Michael Cervin
 
Estancia Mendoza
2025 Sauvignon Blanc No: 10 Argentina $16.99 Gold 90 points
A very different take on Sauvignon Blanc, but an interesting one. Floral aromas lead to a palate of soft acidity that pops stony mineral and mild grass in the finish. Pleasant! - Rich Cook
 
Ethic Drinks
2024 Pinot Noir Pays d'Oc IGP $19.99 Gold 91 points
Subdued but lovely fruit shines with a nice tannic balance. - Michael Cervin
 
Falkner Winery
2023 Cabernet Sauvignon Paso Robles $49.95 Gold 92 points
A lovely wine that offers candied fruit and soft tannins, an easy drinking wine. - Michael Cervin
 
2025 Viognier Temecula Valley $49.95 Gold 91 points
A Viognier that delivers on the anticipated peach front but also adds a thread of watermelon, with more spice than usually identifiied with the varietal. Dry and balanced, with a distant note of oxidation in the background that only adds intrigue. - Mike Dunne
 
2023 Merlot South Coast $59.95 Gold 90 points
Lovely red fruit aromas, forest berries, and bright acidity. oak tannins add some grip. - Allison Levine
 
Fallbrook Winery 33ºN
NV Passas Doces Estate Grown South Coast $80.00 Gold 91 points
Rich and big with plenty of that ambered fruit and a very long finish. - Jeffrey Kralik
A heady, spirited Ruby Port. There is fantastic intensity of fruit, with some delicious licorice and spice notes. - Devin Parr
 
2025 Moscato Brooking Vineyard; Estate Grown South Coast $35.00 Gold 90 points
Light straw, green color; slight candied aroma, nice; medium bodied, off-dry to medium sweet; pleasant fruity flavors, nice finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
Finca Antigua
2021 Merlot Sierra de la Higuera La Mancha DO $19.99 Gold 92 points
Dried red fruit with an earthy undertone and plenty of grip on the back end. Steak wanted. - Jeffrey Kralik
 
Florence Vineyard
2022 Petite Sirah Rockpile $60.00 Platinum 94 points
Deep purple color; spicy, black fruit, impressive; medium to full bodied; long and black. - Wilfred Wong
 
2021 Petite Sirah Rockpile $60.00 Gold 92 points
Deep purple, black color; full black fruits; dense; long finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
2024 Petite Sirah Reserve Rockpile $60.00 Gold 91 points
Finely balanced with oak, tannins  and dark fruit, representing a classic PS style. - Michael Cervin
 
2024 Zinfandel 30 Year Vines Field Blend Rockpile $60.00 Gold 91 points
Deep ruby color; bold berries; long on the palate; explosive berries in the flavors - Wilfred Wong
 
2024 Zinfandel Jack's Reserve Rockpile $60.00 Gold 90 points
Deep ruby color; spicy aroma, excellent density; oaky flavors. - Wilfred Wong
 
Francis Coppola Diamond Collection
2023 Cabernet Sauvignon California $19.00 Gold 91 points
Dark, and close to brooding with loads of blackberry and cassis, balanced by a zingy acidity and finishes with a nice tannic grip. - Jeffrey Kralik
 
NV Prosecco Prosecco DOC $16.00 Gold 90 points
Great tree fruit and lip-smacking acidity, with just a hint of sweetness. - Jeffrey Kralik
There's an appealing bitter almond note here, taking this from any easy-going bubbly to a noteworthy Prosecco. It's got nice length and some complexity, with a crisp, long finish. - Devin Parr
 
Frei Brothers Sonoma Reserve
2024 Chardonnay Russian River Valley $20.00 Gold 91 points
White citrus flowers, lemon zest, vanilla on the nose. Oak is integrated.  Palate continues the fruit and vanilla aspect. The crisp finish features warm spice. - Stacie Hunt
A representative of the surfer school of California Chardonnay - sunny and balanced, with clean, uncomplicated fruit, adequate acidity, and lingering finish. - Mike Dunne
 
George Phillips
NV Brut Signature Reserve California $19.99 Gold 90 points
Golden apple a go-go here with some toasty notes and a lengthy finish. - Jeffrey Kralik
Lots of dried fruit and some bitter herbs, with a creamy mouthfeel and a complex flavor profile. This is the kind of bubbly you pour alongside your main course, rather than as a pre-meal sip. - Devin Parr
 
Gerasim
2024 Frankovka Serbia $35.00 Gold 90 points
Electric purple color, dark red fruit aromas, good mouthfeel, intense tannins with fresh acidity. Long finish. - Allison Levine
Intense color, fresh aromas of flowers and black fruit, and a sturdy, long finish. - Tim Teichgraeber
 
2025 Tamjanika Serbia $20.00 Gold 90 points
Clear color with a greenish; faint floral aroma; floral flavors, nice finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
Girard Winery
2022 Artistry Napa Valley $65.00 Gold 91 points
Youthful yet confident, its fresh cherry fruit driving flavor across the palate, its spirited acidity lifting the fruit, and its adroitly handled oak helping carry its long finish. - Mike Dunne
 
Grape Creek Vineyards
NV Port Texas $54.00 Platinum 94 points
Nutty caramel with a shot of verve in a glass. Exceptional. - Jeffrey Kralik
Lovely structure, with cooked and dried fruit notes, plenty of spice and cedar and just a hint of umami. I love the touch of acidity to keep this bright and vibrant. A really well-made wine. - Devin Parr
 
2024 Grand Rouge Texas $36.00 Gold 91 points
Juicy and sweet, with enough acidity to keep up. Well done! - Jeffrey Kralik
Sweet, candied, and juicy, this is a sweet red wine lover's dream. Nicely made and a good representation of the style. - Devin Parr
 
2022 Right Bank Texas $47.00 Gold 91 points
Aromas of fresh plum, warmed red berries, dried thyme. Palate is fresh, fruit forward, youthful tannins. A bright& friendly glass of wine. - Stacie Hunt
 
2022 Prosperity Texas $54.00 Gold 90 points
Dark ripe fruit, quiet acidity, subdued tannins. - Michael Cervin
 
Grapes of Roth by Wölffer Estate
2022 Dry Riesling Long Island $26.00 Gold 90 points
Petrol character on the nose, stone fruit on the palate, mouthwatering acidity. - Allison Levine
 
Harken
2024 Joyride Chardonnay California $45.00 Gold 90 points
Big and bold, this offers a buttery, amber, resin and citrus notes. - Michael Cervin
Medium straw, yellow color; candied peach aroma; medium bodied, expansive on the palate, some tannins; eathy flavors; medium finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
Heath Family Estate
2022 The Individualist Texas Hill Country $88.00 Gold 92 points
Lovely rose and violet aromas, a bright mid-palate with cherry and blackberry notes, and a grippy finish, perfectly appropriate for the variety and more polished than the vast majority. - Tim Teichgraeber
 
2022 The Originalist Texas Hill Country $88.00 Gold 90 points
Some dark red fruit, a solid savory note, zippy acidity, and finishes with plenty of grip. - Jeffrey Kralik
 
Heath Sparkling Wines
2022 Adoration American $61.00 Gold 92 points
Lots of leesy goodness on this bright, tasty bubbly. Layers of fruit and toast with a savory finish. The kind of bubbly you serve with dinner rather than before. - Devin Parr
 
2022 Ebullience American $56.00 Gold 91 points
Tart golden apple in a glass, add a bit of a sparkle, and look for a party! - Jeffrey Kralik
 
House Party
2024 Moscato California $11.89 Gold 91 points
Light straw, green color; rustic spices; medium sweet, perky palate; candied pear flavors; firm finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
Hungry Hawk Vineyards
2021 Gran Reserva Tempranillo San Diego County $85.00 Gold 92 points
Whoa! Juicy, earthy, with plenty of floral notes, a lovely modern interpretation of the variety. - Jeffrey Kralik
 
2023 Recon Red San Diego County $70.00 Gold 90 points
Happy with upfront fruit, this is a wine that is immediately likable with solid acidity for food pairing. - Michael Cervin
Faded garnet, rose color; fragrant spices in the aromas; medium bodied, stylish on the palate; zesty, red fruit flavors, perky finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
Invention Vineyards
2024 Mourvèdre Rosé Texas $44.00 Gold 90 points
Beautiful salmon color, aromas of ruby grapefruit, meyer lemon oil, brisk acidity, crisp finish.  POOL TIME. - Stacie Hunt
Light in color, slim in build, vital with delicate strawberry fruit lifted by zingy acidity. - Mike Dunne
 
2024 Viognier Texas $38.82 Gold 90 points
Fragrant night-blooming jasmine, honeyed peach on the nose. Palate honeydew melon, white peach, sweet spice, crisp finish. Pair with curries. - Stacie Hunt
 
J. Lohr
2023 Seven Oaks Cabernet Sauvignon Certified California Sustainable Paso Robles $17.00 Gold 93 points
A wonderfully well-balanced, elegantly restrained Cab. Everything is in its place here -- there's great fruit, structure, concentration, and body… without TOO much body. - Devin Parr
 
2023 Cuvée ST. E Certified California Sustainable Paso Robles $50.00 Gold 91 points
Composed and elegant, speaking to Europe more than California in its seamless, savory flavors, well integrated oak, and abiding balance. Tannins don't much get in the way, and will be gone almost entirely with a few more years in the cellar. - Mike Dunne
 
2023 Hilltop Cabernet Sauvignon Certified California Sustainable Paso Robles $35.00 Gold 91 points
Slightly brooding, expressive macerated fruit, this has moderate tannins and acidity. - Michael Cervin
Deep ruby, black color; active berry aromas; firm palate; lively, a bit heavy fruit and oak flavors; firm finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
2025 Pinot Blanc F&G Vineyard; Certified California Sustainable Arroyo Seco $35.00 Gold 91 points
Pretty, delicate nose with citrus, green apple, stone fruit aromas. Rounded midplate with a light almond note on the finish. Lots of acidity. - Allison Levine
 
James Busby 
2022 Shiraz McLaren Vale Australia $25.00 Gold 90 points
Pure grape-y aromas lead to a palate with some sense of place. The finish is quite long and satisfying. - Rich Cook
 
Jenblossom Cellars
2022 Cabernet Franc Knights Valley $182.35 Platinum 97 points
Rich nose with violet aromas and a hint of herbaciousness that increases with each sniff. On the palate, the wine is intense but balanced with a lovely herbacious finish. - Allison Levine
 
2022 Cabernet Sauvignon Yountville $147.00 Platinum 95 points
Whoa. Rich red and black fruit with a slight hint of green pepper, this is a quintessential Cab. Just lovely. - Jeffrey Kralik
The marks of a great Cab for me are balance, structure, and concentration -- this wine has all three. Just a delicious, well-made, thoughtful wine. - Devin Parr
 
2022 Pinot Noir Petaluma Gap $112.00 Platinum 94 points
Loaded with fuit on both the nose and the palate with a classic dark cherry profile with earth and gusto. - Jeffrey Kralik
Just delicious. Dark fruit and some appealing chocolate notes, with a beautiful backbone of acidity. This is the kind of Pinot you buy at least two bottles of -- one to gift to someone you're trying to impress and one to keep for yourself. - Devin Parr
 
2021 Scary Good Napa Valley $234.00 Gold 91 points
This is a really rich, fascinating wine with an almost fortified, Port-like quality. It's dusty and dark, with cooked plum and mocha, and a black licorice finish. The flavors are well-developed, giving the impression this is a wine that has already been laid down and is ready to drink. - Devin Parr
 
2022 Cabernet Sauvignon Rutherford $147.06 Gold 90 points
Fruity and loaded with tartness, this would not turn down a ribeye. - Jeffrey Kralik
A well-made, approachable Cab. The perfect dinner party wine, but it would also be equally lovely on its own with a Netflix binge and a bucket of microwave popcorn. - Devin Parr
 
JOLO Vineyards
2024 Golden Hallows Reserve North Carolina $42.00 Gold 92 points
Lemony nose, Eureka lemon oil. Palate is very fresh, the lemon becomes Meyer, offering satisfying sweetness, acidity gives a crisp finish. Adult Lemonade! - Stacie Hunt
Lemon merignue pie without the sugar, seizing sunny citrus in the curd, structure in the crust. Overall, big and jovial, with balance and sass to make it an engaging conversationalist at the dinner party. - Mike Dunne
 
2023 Pilot Fog North Carolina $99.00 Gold 92 points
Black cherry, black plum on the nose, dark chocolate.  On the palate, spicy, rhubarb, ripe strawberry, clove. Pair with game, strong cheese (i.e. roquefort/blues) - Stacie Hunt
 
NV Tenth Anniversary North Carolina $99.00 Gold 91 points
Dried red berries, dried potpourri, mandarin orange peel (no pith). Palate continues with dried fruit, well-balanced and integrated. Med-Long finish. Pair with game, lamb. - Stacie Hunt
 
2023 Carolus XII North Carolina $59.00 Gold 90 points
Nose of wild brambly berries, sassafras.  Palate has tart cherry, dried herbs, red and black plums, finishes with fruit across back of palate. Pair with Carnitas or another roasted pork dish. - Stacie Hunt
Fine boned and lithe, a heartland hybrid blend that speaks of cranberries and sasparilla, with lifting acidity, fitting dryness and a finish both lilting and crisp. - Mike Dunne
 
2025 Pink North Carolina $32.00 Gold 90 points
Super bright and tangy with plenty of tangerine. - Jeffrey Kralik
This wine is the very definition of crushable. Light, juicy, and a touch savory with plenty of fruit to keep it refreshing. - Devin Parr
 
NV Sweet Vermouth No Appellation $27.00 Gold 90 points
Deep amber color; rustic; weighty on the palate; very sweet; explosive. - Wilfred Wong
 
K Estate Vineyards
2025 Rosé of Syrah Texas High Plains $43.53 Gold 92 points
Unusually rich for a rosé, as if drawn from strawberries grown on steroid-enhanced soils. Big and round, refreshing in its sweetness. - Mike Dunne
 
2023 Cabernet Sauvignon Oak Knoll District $73.00 Gold 91 points
Dark fruit (cassis, blackberry), zingy and layered. Very Nice. - Jeffrey Kralik
This wine is juicy and inherently drinkable, with great concentration and structure, plenty of fruit and just the right amout of tannin and spice. It's a nice, classic style. - Devin Parr
 
2023 Malbec Texas High Plains $58.00 Gold 90 points
Really lovely red fruit buoyed by a zing that lingers through to the lengthy finish. - Jeffrey Kralik
 
2023 Tempranillo Estate Texas Hill Country $59.00 Gold 90 points
Nicely balanced between the subtle fruit and the zingy tartness. Ggood now, but will improve over the next 3-5 years. - Jeffrey Kralik
Firm tannins are currently obscuring some of the fruit, but in time this wine will open up and be lovely. In the meantime, serve this one up with a hearty hunk of meat. Fans of grippy, savory wines will delight. - Devin Parr
 
King Estate
2021 Brut Cuvée Methode Champenoise Willamette Valley $40.00 Platinum 95 points
A classic style, with a fine mousse carrying apple, pear, lemon crème, moderate toast flavors that linger long and bright in the finish. Excellent bubbly! - Rich Cook
 
2024 Domaine Pinot Gris Estate Grown Willamette Valley $40.00 Platinum 95 points
Nose offers up very ripe yellow pear, nuttiness & spice, some oiliness on the palate along with some weight.  Pair with grilled shrimp or steamed Chilean bass. - Stacie Hunt
Fragrant, fruity and ripe, with a suggestion of hazelnuts uncommon for the varietal. Pinot Gris is rarely compelling, but this keeps inviting you back. Food? Seabass, shrimp, tortellini stuffed with crab. - Mike Dunne
 
2025 Artisan Series Pinot Gris Willamette Valley $20.00 Gold 92 points
A Pinot Gris of unusual heft, yet remaining light on its feet for all the ripe fruit, layering and exceptional persistence it delivers. - Mike Dunne
 
2025 Pinot Gris Willamette Valley $20.00 Gold 91 points
Vibrant with both fruit and acid, its fruit making it ideal to sip in a hammock, its acid making it ideal to pair with the seafood buffet at the casino. - Mike Dunne
 
2025 Rosé of Pinot Noir Willamette Valley $20.00 Gold 91 points
Soft pink color. Nose of ruby grapefruit, strawberry, watermelon. Palate has fruitiness of strawberries, very ripe watermelon, citrus-y acidity. Sprightly finish. - Stacie Hunt
Mature in its steadiness, yet refreshing in its zeal and balance, with atypical length for a pink. - Mike Dunne
 
2024 Sauvignon Blanc Oregon $20.00 Gold 91 points
Nose of gooseberry, grassy, herbaceous. Palate is grapefruit zest, meyer lemon oil. Crisp acidity, fresh  & dry finish. - Stacie Hunt
Sweet citric fruit, with a suggestion of crispy jalapeno skin just off the grill. - Mike Dunne
 
2024 Artisan Series Pinot Noir Willamette Valley $29.00 Gold 90 points
Crushed violet notes on the nose, velvety tannins. - Allison Levine
Well-made and balanced, perhaps from a warmer climate, but showing some restraint. - Tim Teichgraeber
 
2023 Chardonnay Willamette Valley $25.00 Gold 90 points
Good acidity, finishes with cinnamon apple notes. - Allison Levine
Ripe, sunny, apple and pear goodness, just what you want from a California Chardonnay. - Tim Teichgraeber
 
2023 Domaine Pinot Noir Estate Grown Willamette Valley $75.00 Gold 90 points
Earthy with dark fruit and a bit of heft, quite tasty with a bit of grip on the backend. - Jeffrey Kralik
Really nice structure, more savory in style, with woodsy fruit and a delightful forest floor vibe. - Devin Parr
 
2024 Pinot Noir Willamette Valley $30.00 Gold 90 points
Nose offers aromas of warm strawberry, raspberry. Acidity gives brightness on the palate.  Well integrated. - Stacie Hunt
 
L'Artisan
2024 Pinot Noir Vin de France $25.99 Gold 92 points
Medium to deep garnet; bountiful fruit aroma; savory, jazzy flavors; zippy finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
2024 Cinsault Grenache Vin de France $24.99 Gold 90 points
Medium garnet color; nice fruit and spice aroma; medium bodied, active palate; perky fruit flavors. - Wilfred Wong
 
Ledson
2021 Merlot Sonoma County $42.00 Platinum 94 points
Seriously delicious with black forest cake flavors, well-integrated oak and plenty of freshness. - Tim Teichgraeber
Inviting nose with black raspberry, cherry, bramble aromas. Structured on the palate with midpalate weight but also very bright and light. - Allison Levine
 
2022 Zinfandel Sonoma Mountain $60.00 Gold 91 points
Nose of black plums, blackberries, pepper and spice, creaminess from the oak and pleasant aftertaste of spice. - Stacie Hunt An exceptionally lively Zinfandel, with seizing fruit and punctuating peppery spice. Its acidity keeps it flourishing from first sip to last. - Mike Dunne
 
2022 Zinfandel Clifford's Block Sonoma Valley $50.00 Gold 90 points
One sassy Zinfandel, combining fat berry fruit with pinpoint acidity. - Mike Dunne
 
Leonor de Carrera
NV Brut Guarda Cava DO $8.00 Gold 91 points
This is what Cava should be: fruity, tart, fun. - Jeffrey Kralik
Dry, crisp, clean… dare I say elegant? I could drink this all day and would proudly serve it as the featured bubbly for any crowd. - Devin Parr
 
Maxville
2022 Estate Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley Chiles Valley $60.00 Gold 93 points
Well played. Concentrated Cab with every note in sync. Deep cassis and blackberry notes, hints of vanilla and tobacco. Seamless and sturdy. - Tim Teichgraeber
 
2023 The High Valley Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $55.00 Gold 90 points
Black cherry freshness, lightly structured but has a good fresh lingering finish. - Allison Levine
Serious structure, nice black and red currant notes, graphite and a bit of new oak on the finish. - Tim Teichgraeber
 
McIlroy Cellars
2025 Rosé of Pinot Noir Three Vineyards Russian River Valley $32.00 Platinum 94 points
Nose of watermelon, fresh strawberry, citrus oils. Palate a pleasant fresh strawberry, pink grapefruit zest,  fruitiness, finishes dry and crisp. Tastes of summer! - Stacie Hunt
A streamlined rose, styled to get to the point -provide refreshing berry fruit and stimulating acidity in equally rewarding proportions. - Mike Dunne
 
Miguel Caratachea
2023 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $295.00 Gold 92 points
Nose of red, black plums, dark berries, sweet herbs, sweet spices. On the palate, fruit hangs around to chat. Balanced. Medium finish. Pair with skirt steak and roasted vegetables. - Stacie Hunt
 
2023 Bracero Napa Valley $120.00 Gold 91 points
Formidable tannins don't get in the way of the fresh and sweetly flourishing dark-red fruit, given lift by springy acidity, underscored with well integrated oak. - Mike Dunne
 
Navarro Vineyards
2024 Pinot Noir; South Hill Anderson Valley $59.00 Platinum 95 points
Nose of black cherry, warmed red berries, dried herbs. Palate shows soft tannins, spice of oak. Plays well with meaty fish or roasted lamb. - Stacie Hunt
A model Pinot Noir for its fresh-fruit charm, perked up by bright acidity. The fruit drives across the palate with grace and verve, its finish lingering long after the final sip. The pleasure the wine delivers is both up front and persistent. - Mike Dunne
 
2025 Grüner Veltliner Anderson Valley $26.00 Gold 93 points
A classic Gruner style, embracing stone fruits, minerality and acidity. - Michael Cervin
 
2024 Pinot Noir; Hammer's Pond Anderson Valley $59.00 Gold 93 points
Berry Blast! Followed by warmth of spices, dried herbs, well balanced. A wine that spans both BBQ pork ribs and roasted salmon. - Stacie Hunt
Refined, angular and subtly complex. A Pinot Noir that qualifies as charming on the strength of its equilibrium and fresh fruit. - Mike Dunne
 
2024 Sangiovese Mendocino $29.00 Gold 93 points
A tannic structure supports subdued fruit, allowing for a wine with can both be consumed now, or held for a few more years. - Michael Cervin
 
2024 Barbera Mendocino $29.00 Gold 92 points
Aromas of red rose, red and black fruits, cherry to plum. A crisp acidity. Think pizza, pasta with fresh tomato sauce, or a sub sandwich. - Stacie Hunt
 
2025 Late Harvest Riesling Cluster Select Anderson Valley $39.00 Gold 92 points
Nicely balanced, good viscosity and a balanced sweetness level. - Michael Cervin
 
2024 Pinot Noir; Deep End Blend Anderson Valley $59.00 Gold 92 points
Nose is fresh with strawberries, red cherry, well balanced on the oak and fruit combo. Finishes clean and with a crisp note.  Crowd pleaser. - Stacie Hunt
 
2025 Gewürztraminer Estate Bottled Dry Anderson Valley $28.00 Gold 91 points
Stone fruit and floral aromas, lovely acidity driven texture with spice notes. - Allison Levine
 
2024 Pinot Noir    Méthode à l'Ancienne Anderson Valley $39.00 Gold 91 points
Loaded with dark cherry and hints of earth, a classic Pinot profile. - Jeffrey Kralik
 
2025 Muscat Blanc Estate Bottled Dry Anderson Valley $26.00 Gold 90 points
Good acidity, light strawberry, herbal notes. - Michael Cervin
Straw green; tangy on the palate; mineral flavors, lively finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
2025 Pinot Gris Anderson Valley $26.00 Gold 90 points
Nose of canned pears, citrus flowers. Palate is refreshed with acidity from green apple.  Finishes with the apple and cleanses the palate. - Stacie Hunt
Light in color, but not bashful in its delivery of fruit fresh from the pear orchard, given a boost by its zesty acidity. - Mike Dunne
 
2025 Riesling Anderson Valley $26.00 Gold 90 points
Peach aromas with intense acidity and lemon-lime character. - Allison Levine
Lemon, lime, refreshing acidity, a versatile food wine. - Tim Teichgraeber
 
2024 Zinfandel Old Vine Cuvée Mendocino $29.00 Gold 90 points
Medium to dark ruby color; rich and layered on the palate; full flavored and lasting finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
Noceto
2020 Aglianico Fumo e Terra Shenandoah Valley $49.00 Platinum 95 points
A really beautiful wine. Welcomes you with floral and savory red fruit aromas. on the palate, the wine has intense tannins and a fresh acidity that washes across the palate. Long, lingering finish. Yum! - Allison Levine
Arguably one of the more underrated hot climate varieties, this textbook Aglianico has plum and dried cherry aromas, bright red and black fruit flavors, subtle earthy notes, bright acidity and polished tannins. Delicous. - Tim Teichgraeber
 
NV Double D's Big Jug Red California $18.00 Gold 92 points
Yum! This is such a tasty wine. Crushed red fruit for days, like a handful of fresh cherries in the summer. But still some really pleasant spice, structure, and just enough seriousness, not to mention a lovely backbone of acidity to keep everthing bright. - Devin Parr
 
2023 Riserva Sangiovese Shenandoah Valley $39.00 Gold 92 points
Expressive fruit framed by quiet oak and vanilla, with tight tannins supporting the structure. - Michael Cervin
 
2025 Frivolo Moscato Bianco California $24.00 Gold 90 points
Classic muscat  flavors and aromas with a nice zing and bubbles! - Jeffrey Kralik
 
2023 Sangiovese Shenandoah Valley $29.00 Gold 90 points
Light to medium brick color; pencil lead aroma; medium bodied, alive on the palate; bright finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
Pajarito
2022 Riesling Reserva Valle Central $18.99 Gold 91 points
Petrol notes on the nose, textured acidity, lovely Riesling expression. - Allison Levine
Great Riesling character, with delicate pear and citrus notes. - Tim Teichgraeber
 
Papet Del Mas
2021 Cava Brut Reserva Guarda Superior Cava DO $9.10 Platinum 94 points
If all Cava were like this, I would drink more Cava. Bright citrus and white flower with near-perfect balance and a lengthy finish. - Jeffrey Kralik
Wonderful complexity here -- yes, a core of fleshy stone fruit and citrus, but there's also pleasant brioche and a creamy custard note. It's layered without being over the top yeasty. Just a great wine. - Devin Parr
 
NV Brut Guarda Cava DO $6.95 Gold 92 points Great fruit and acidity with some added verve. Fantástico! - Jeffrey Kralik Citrus fruit and juicy apple, a lovely, almost saline note. This is an excellent Cava. - Devin Parr
 
Perrucci Family Vineyard
2022 Merlot Santa Cruz Mountains $38.00 Platinum 94 points
Reserved fruit paired with a zingy tartness and a touch of earth. Very Nice. - Jeffrey Kralik
A leaner, elegant style… The non-Merlot drinker's Merlot. Gorgeous structure, juicy red fruit, some nice, well-integrated tannins, bright acidity, and a lovely cigar box note. I just love this wine. - Devin Parr
 
2022 Cabernet Sauvignon Santa Cruz Mountains $48.00 Gold 93 points
Though a big wine, there is a tremendous balance with the elements of fruit, wood, acidity and tannins. - Michael Cervin
 
2022 Sangiovese Family Selection Santa Cruz Mountains $48.00 Gold 93 points
Lithe and suductive, this offers subdued fruit and softer tannins. - Michael Cervin
 
2022 Malbec Santa Cruz Mountains $44.00 Gold 90 points
Fruity from the jump with plenty of plum and blueberry. A nice juicy Malbec. - Jeffrey Kralik
Elegant, floral, slightly savory, nice lift from acid. Slightly leaner in style for a Malbec, but that may be its appeal. - Devin Parr
 
Prince Michel
2024 Petit Manseng Mountain View Vineyards Virginia $29.99 Gold 91 points
A lovely example of a Petit Mansang. Intense acidity. A surprise! - Allison Levine
Intense and racy with lemon and apple fruit notes. - Tim Teichgraeber
 
R Collection by Raymond
2024 Cabernet Sauvignon California $15.99 Gold 91 points
A bold, hefty wine with lots of flavor and tannins that will please everyone. - Michael Cervin
Medium to deep ruby color; oaky aroma; medium to firm bodied; oaky, vanilla, black fruit flavors; some firm tannins in the finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
2024 Merlot California $15.99 Gold 90 points
Really nice fruit with a zingy kick, a wonderful quaff. - Jeffrey Kralik
A tasty, approachable Merlot with some sweet fruit, a touch of cinnamon, and a nice, put-together structure. An easy-drinking crowd pleaser. - Devin Parr
 
Raffaldini
2023 Sangiovese Classico Swan Creek $35.00 Gold 91 points
Light garnet color; spicebox aromas; nice palate; red and black fruit flavors with pleasing spices. - Wilfred Wong
 
Rayson
NV Elevage Blanc North Carolina $27.00 Gold 91 points
Pineapple and mango fruit flavors with a bright, citrusy finish. - Tim Teichgraeber
 
NV Merlot North Carolina $50.00 Gold 91 points
Bright and juicy with pretty plum and raspberry notes. - Tim Teichgraeber
Bowl of rapberries and blackberries, juicy with velvety tannins. Very easy drinking. - Allison Levine
 
NV Sweet Vermouth Blanc $29.00 Gold 91 points
Straw color; quinine medium bodied; active palate; herbal. - Wilfred Wong
 
2024 Vidal Blanc North Carolina $29.00 Gold 91 points
Lemon/lime prominent on the nose, cantalope semi-sweetness.  Palate is fresh, slight spritz enlivens, lemon -lime continues.  Pool, Beach, Lake Wine! - Stacie Hunt
With lemony fruit, sizzling acidity and a dash of spice, this wine meets all the standards for a wine to be called refreshing. Bring on the oysters and shrimp. - Mike Dunne
 
2024 Rosé Wine North Carolina $29.00 Gold 90 points
Light salmon color; savory aroma; medium bodied; dusty flavors; firm finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
Reustle Prayer Rock Vineyards
2025 Grüner Veltliner Estate Selection; Hefeabzug Umpqua Valley $37.00 Platinum 94 points
Classic Gruner with minerality, acidity, stone fruit, light savory and herbal wild flower notes. - Michael Cervin
 
2025 Grüner Veltliner Cask #2 Estate Grown Umpqua Valley $45.00 Gold 91 points
A more viscous iteration, this offers subtle peach and minerality. - Michael Cervin
 
2025 Sauvignon Blanc Estate Selection Umpqua Valley $33.00 Gold 91 points
Very lemon-lime, lots of juicy acidity…hits the tongue and then lingers... a light herbaceous note in the background. - Allison Levine
Crisp, correct, and refreshingly uncomplicated with a perky personality. - Tim Teichgraeber
 
2025 Viognier Estate Selection Umpqua Valley $38.00 Gold 91 points
Nose of honeysuckle, white rose, citrus flowers, sweet olive flowers, peach. Palate is freshened by white peach and crisp acidity. Pair with white meats, poached fish. - Stacie Hunt
 
2023 Deux Vine Estate Grown Umpqua Valley $45.00 Gold 90 points
Precise violet, cassis and cherry aromas, straightforward and delicious. - Tim Teichgraeber
 
2025 Grüner Veltliner Green Lizard; Estate Grown Umpqua Valley $39.00 Gold 90 points
Solid and bracing acidity lead off, followed by minerality and acidity. - Michael Cervin
Clear straw color; vitamin C aroma, medium bodied, active palate. - Wilfred Wong
 
2024 Syrah Estate Selection Umpqua Valley $40.00 Gold 90 points
Black plum, minerality (iron), dried herbs, balanced wine. Leg of lamb is a perfect partner. - Stacie Hunt
 
Robert Hall
2022 Artisan Collection Merlot Paso Robles $16.99 Gold 91 points
Floral notes of violets. Balanced wine with grippy tannins washed over with fresh acidity. - Allison Levine
 
2024 Regenerative Organic Cabernet Sauvignon Estate Grown; Hall Ranch Vineyard Paso Robles Geneseo District $29.99 Gold 91 points
Tasty, juicy, youthful Cab with a definite brightness supported by some grip and spice. A great food wine. - Devin Parr
 
Rodney Strong Vineyards
2024 Chardonnay Limited Collection; Single Vineyard Russian River Valley $37.00 Platinum 94 points
Here we go! Tart, fruity, balanced and wonderfully nuanced, even the ABC crowd would love this wine. - Jeffrey Kralik
An absolute study in balance -- juicy peach, apple, pear and meyer lemon with just a kiss of well-integrated oak notes. The structure is spot on, with racy acidity for lift and elegance. This is delicious now but should also age beautifully. - Devin Parr
 
2021 Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon Sonoma County $60.00 Gold 93 points
This is an excellent, juicy, well-made Cab. Just a delight to drink -- the kind of Cab that makes you want to keep sipping, rather than overwhelming you with its heft. - Devin Parr
 
2024 Pinot Noir Russian River Valley $30.00 Gold 92 points
Well balanced wine with pretty red fruit and floral aromas and spice notes. Structured tannins and a mouthwatering finish. - Allison Levine
Balanced and long, with elegant black cherry and spice notes. - Tim Teichgraeber
 
2024 Pinot Noir Limited Collection Russian River Valley $37.00 Gold 91 points
Gorgeous nose of bright red fruit, which carries onto the palate along with a dash of earth and a hint of spice. - Jeffrey Kralik
This wine is the very definition of crushable. Yummy, bright fruit with just enough baking spice to keep it from being one dimensional. - Devin Parr
 
2023 Red Wine Sonoma County $25.00 Gold 91 points
Nose of black plum, dark berries, fresh sage, thyme.  Palate has fleshy weight, spice, touch of vanillin.  Pair with game, stews, even meatloaf! - Stacie Hunt
A big wine in a big frame, its elegant cherry fruit and suggestions of olives combining to make it a wine broad shouldered and agile, continuing to stride effortlessly even long after crossing the finish line. - Mike Dunne
 
2023 Cabernet Sauvignon Knights Valley $37.00 Gold 90 points
A bit shy initially, but the fruit quickly wakes up and is joined by a nice tartness. Lovely now, will improve with 3-5 years of cellar time. - Jeffrey Kralik
A big, brooding Cab for fans of that rich, heady style. - Devin Parr
 
2023 Cabernet Sauvignon Alexander Valley $35.00 Gold 90 points
Good dark fruit, plenty of zing and a nice earthy component. Solid Cab. - Jeffrey Kralik
A straightforward, drinkable Cab with nice structure, well-integrated tannins, and a friendly flavor profile. - Devin Parr
 
2024 Chardonnay Sonoma County $18.00 Gold 90 points
Good acidity, well balanced. Apple and citrus notes, lingering finish. - Allison Levine
Flavorful and juicy with racy acidity and well-integrated hints of oak. - Tim Teichgraeber
 
Ryder Estate
2024 Pinot Noir California $15.00 Gold 93 points
Muscular, frank and striding, a Pinot Noir with enough structure, buoyancy and mature fruit to accompany steak as well as the customary salmon. - Mike Dunne
 
2024 Merlot California $15.00 Gold 90 points
Well made Merlot with plummy fruit and a bit of a savory, gamy note. - Tim Teichgraeber
A combo of red fruits and meatiness, balance of acid and tannins, wine has some grip that lingers on the palate. It's asking you to take another sip. - Allison Levine
 
Sadler's Well
2023 Pinot Noir Santa Barbara County $17.99 Gold 91 points
Proof that even light-colored Pinot Noir can deliver a bushel of flavor, in this instance boysenberries. Substantial backbone, layered content, and pleasing finish. - Mike Dunne
 
South Hill
2023 Malbec Winemakers Reserve Rattlesnake Hills $40.00 Gold 90 points
Dark fruit with a hint of cola, with spice on the midpalate, a solid Malbec. - Jeffrey Kralik
 
2025 Marsanne Winemakers Reserve Rattlesnake Hills $32.00 Gold 90 points
Delicate fruit, almond husks and an underlying spiciness add up to a Marsanne mysterious yet inviting. - Mike Dunne
 
Stemilt Creek Winery
2021 Caring Passion Merlot Estate Grown Columbia Valley $28.00 Gold 91 points
Bright, ripe fruit with a bit of heft and a nice, long finish. - Jeffrey Kralik
 
2022 A Day's Work Cabernet Sauvignon Estate Grown Columbia Valley $34.00 Gold 90 points
Deep ruby, black color; dried tea leaves; nicely built; black fruit oak flavors; sturdy finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
2025 Sweet Adelaide Riesling Columbia Valley $28.00 Gold 90 points
Light straw, green color; sweet fruit, spicy aroma; medium bodied, firms up nicely on the palate; nice finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
Stoneleigh
2024 Sauvignon Blanc New Zealand; Marlborough $18.00 Gold 92 points
Grassy, gooseberry, mild Jalapeño on the nose. Palate pushes forward the gooseberry, acidity is fresh. Finishes with grassiness. Pair with shellfish. - Stacie Hunt
Hello, New Zealand! But if not, a persuasive impersonation in its pungent aroma, citric flavors and streamlined build. - Mike Dunne
 
Substance
2022 Cabernet Sauvignon Columbia Valley $16.99 Platinum 94 points
Ruby, black color; excellent black fruit aroma, classic; medium bodied, solid on the palate; bright black fruit flavors, nicely balanced oak; firm and lingering finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
2025 Riesling Evergreen Vineyard Columbia Valley $13.99 Platinum 94 points
Ripe and rich, with stone fruits, juicyfruit gum, lemon. Layered roundness on the palate with lots of acidity. Very enjoyable with an exceptionally long finish. - Allison Levine
Absolutely delicious, with citrus, tropical fruit, and herb notes and a long, bright finish. - Tim Teichgraeber
 
2023 Chardonnay Columbia Valley $13.99 Gold 91 points
Citrus flower, Eureke lemon curd, vanilla. Palate has vitality and creamy citrus in the finish. Pair with roasted chicken, halibut, pasta with cream sauce. - Stacie Hunt
 
2024 Rosé Evergreen Vineyard Columbia Valley $13.99 Gold 90 points
Light salmon color; savory aromas, dried spices, stylish;  tangy red fruit flavors. - Wilfred Wong
 
Terre Gobelet
2024 Pinot Noir Pays d'Oc IGP $26.99 Gold 90 points
Solid wine, comprehensive structure where the fruit is harmonious with the tannins and oak - Michael Cervin
 
Tesella
2024 Cabernet Sauvignon Semi Dry Reserva Maule Valley $17.99 Gold 92 points
Deep ruby, black color; spicebox; black fruit; black fruit and oak flavors; stand-up finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
2024 Carmenere Reserva Maule Valley $17.99 Gold 90 points
A textbook example of Carmenere with elegant herbal aromas, grippy tannins and fresh acidity. - Allison Levine
If you are a Carmenere fan, look no further. Textbook black fruit and herbaceous notes with a moderately tannic finish. - Tim Teichgraeber
 
Three Hammers Winery
2025 Albariño American $34.95 Platinum 94 points
Nose of lemon, lime, apricot. Palate shows lemon/lime zest, apricot pit, white peach, salinity. Pairs with shellfish, tinned fish, olives, and the world of tapas. - Stacie Hunt
Just what Albarino is supposed to be, a white wine citrusy, charged with acidity, and confident in its striding finish. Bring on the oysters and don't hold back on a wide range of tapas. - Mike Dunne
 
2025 Rosé American $33.95 Gold 92 points
If this were in a hummingbird feeder, you'd need to call a cop to keep down the congestion, it is that pretty, refreshing and sweetly fruity. - Mike Dunne
 
2025 Chenin Blanc American $34.95 Gold 90 points
Nose is quite inviting. Elegant and delicate with pretty fruit aromas. Bright acidity with an elegant finish. - Allison Levine Dry Chenin Blanc with nicely-rounded citrus and pear notes. - Tim Teichgraeber
 
2022 Cuvée American $48.95 Gold 90 points
Red fruit brightness, toasted oak, giving a touch of sweetness, round tannins. A style for consumers new to red wine. - Stacie Hunt
 
Toca Madera
2015 Syrah/Grenache/Mourvedre/Viognier Madera $32.00 Gold 91 points
Soft dark fruits ride acidity that winds its way through this wine, making for a food friendly companion. - Michael Cervin
 
2025 Moscato Madera $24.00 Gold 92 points
A delightful sweetness fills the palatte and offers candied almond, butterscotch and citrus notes. - Michael Cervin
Medium straw, yellow color; heady aroma, spicy; medium sweet; ripe pears; firm finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
2025 Conmigo Madera $24.00 Gold 90 points
Medium straw color; dried spices and olive aromas; medium bodied, expansive on the palate; earthy flavors; firm finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
2025 Marsanne Madera $22.00 Gold 90 points
Pear, white melon, white citrus flowers on the nose.  Palate continues with white pear, quince, melon, citrus zest. Crisp finish. Pair with white fish, soft cheeses. - Stacie Hunt
 
Truth
2024 Pinot Noir Carneros $19.00 Gold 90 points
The nose is bright with red cherry aromas that lead to forest floor notes. Lightly textured tannins with an elegant finish. - Allison Levine
Forest floor and dried cherry tones with good varietal character. - Tim Teichgraeber
 
Verabolla
NV Prosecco Extra Dry Prosecco DOC $15.00 Gold 90 points
Prosecco has come a long way, and this is a fine example of how it has arrived, even in some macro DOC offerings. - Rich Cook
 
Vienza at Europa Village
2023 Montepulciano Temecula Valley $59.00 Gold 92 points
Nice fruit with great tartness, beautifully balanced, just a lovely quaff. - Jeffrey Kralik
This wine finds that delightful balance between seriousness and quaffability. It's got lots of juicy fruit, a touch of woodsy spice, great structure and just an all-round likeable quality. - Devin Parr
 
2022 Reserve Barbera Steinbeck Vineyard Paso Robles $83.00 Gold 92 points
Nose of dried rose, red and black berries, warm spice. The acidity keeps it bright. Vibrant. - Stacie Hunt
True beckoning fruit on the nose is followed by plush cotton-candy cherry fruit on the palate, its delivery frolicking and persistent. No one wil turn down a second glass. - Mike Dunne
 
2024 Vanita Estate Temecula Valley $46.00 Gold 90 points
Light, lightly sweet, nice citrus and delicate caramel notes. A very plesant wine. - Michael Cervin
 
Vinha Redonda
2024 Tinto Peninsula de Setúbal VR $15.99 Gold 91 points
Fruity, but also earthy in a really good way. Perfect for a Sunday meal. - Jeffrey Kralik
This is a juicy, undeniably yummy red, bright and fruit-forward with a backbone of earthiness and acidity. This would be sensational with food. - Devin Parr
 
Vinzo's
NV Primo Vino Red Wine $3.99 Gold 93 points
Youthful and fragrant, a boxed wine with the punch, fruit, grippy acidity and prolonged finish to make guests question whether it really came in a box. The acid really carries the fruit, and tannins get politely pushed aside. - Mike Dunne
 
Wakefield
2025 Jaraman Grenache McLaren Vale + Clare Valley Australia $32.00 Gold 93 points
A brash beast of a Grenache that is still integrating - it's like a peppery Red Bull at present, but it'll calm down nicely in a year or so. - Rich Cook
 
2023 Masterstroke Cabernet Shiraz Clare Valley Australia $60.00 Gold 91 points
A plush palate of juicy black fruit with a regional touch of menthol... this is quite seductive. - Rich Cook
 
WE KNOW JACK!
2022 ROCKPILE RIFF RAFF ZINFANDEL Jack Florence Sr. Vineyard; Single Block Rockpile $60.00 Gold 91 points
Blackberry  and black plum on the nose, cinnamon spice, soft tannins. ABV is well balanced. Pair with grills, pork roast. - Stacie Hunt
 
2023 ROCKPILE RIFF RAFF ZINFANDEL Jack Florence Sr. Vineyard; Single Block Rockpile $60.00 Gold 91 points
All the support players - tannin, acid, wood - agree that the lead deserves all their support for its clear and captivating projection of Zinfandel berries. - Mike Dunne
 
2023 OUTTA LUCK SYRAH Jack Florence Sr. Vineyard; Single Block Rockpile $50.00 Gold 90 points
A Syrah assured if soft spoken, capturing the grape's essence with respect and an enduring balance, first sip to last. - Mike Dunne
 
2024 ROCKPILE RIFF RAFF ZINFANDEL Jack Florence Sr. Vineyard; Single Block Rockpile $60.00 Gold 90 points
Sweet black fruits, sweet spices, good acidity to balance sweetness. - Stacie Hunt
A great picnic Zinfandel, with the fruit and acid to make it adaptable to all sorts of foods dragged from the basket, creamy cheese, ham sandwich, even biscotti. - Mike Dunne
 
Whitehaven
2025 Sauvignon Blanc Marlborough $20.00 Gold 90 points
Quintessentially grassy, grapfruity, luscious sauvigon blanc with a slight tropical note. Would love this poolside on a hot day. - Devin Parr
 
Wine Spots Wines
2024 Pinot Noir Sonoma Coast $25.00 Gold 90 points
Shy initially, but the dark cherry fruit comes roaring in on the midpalate along with a refreshing tartness. - Jeffrey Kralik
A likable, drinkable Pinot with soft fruit and an approachable structure. A great, everyday drinking style. - Devin Parr
 
Wölffer Estate Vineyard
2023 Diosa Late Harvest Long Island $37.00 Platinum 95 points
Out of the gate this offers a potent sweetness, but this is balanced by a light acidity, delicate notes of caramel, butterscotch and subtle citrus. - Michael Cervin
Deep golden color; attractive honeyed aroma; full bodied; sweet; ripe apricots, apples and peach flavors; long, layered finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
2023 Cabernet Franc Long Island $25.00 Gold 90 points Floral and earthy aromas, textured tannins and a savory finish. - Allison Levine
 
ZD Wines
2024 Rosa Lee Petit Verdot Napa Valley $68.00 Platinum 95 points
Super dark, even brooding, with heaps of blackberry compote. Big, and bold but balanced, boisterous, and beautiful. - Jeffrey Kralik
This is a big, brooding, dark wine and it totally works. It's inky in color, with ripe, blue and black fruit, and an appealing chocolately quality. It's hefty for sure, but a throughline of acid helps keep it light on its feet. - Devin Parr
 
2024 Pinot Noir Carneros $60.00 Gold 91 points
Classic and elegant, medium-bodied, with layers of soft fruit, well-integrated oak, a touch of savory, and a lovely structure. An excellent dinner wine. - Devin Parr
 
2023 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley $78.00 Gold 90 points
The Jaws of Cabernet Sauvignon, lurking in the deeps, popping up to startle with its smooth authority and unpredictability. In the end, rewarding in its composure and candor. - Mike Dunne
 
Zinfandelic
2023 Old Vine Zinfandel Sierra Foothills $19.99 Gold 92 points
Nose of fresh blackberry, fresh blueberry, spice, soft tannins. Fruit carries through the palate. - Stacie Hunt
 
Zonte's Footstep
2022 Eat Cake McLaren Vale $30.00 Gold 93 points
Dark ruby color; spicy aroma, some oak too; medium bodied, feisty on the palate; bright fruit and toasty flavors, long finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
2022 Age of Enlightenment Limited Release Australia; McLaren Vale $55.00 Gold 92 points
Dark ruby, purple color; dried spices aroma; full bodied, packed on the palate; bold fruit flavors; firm finish. - Wilfred Wong
 
2024 Violet Beauregard Malbec Langhorne Creek $30.00 Gold 91 points
A savory, spicy, Malbec. Notes of cedar, cinnamon, and juicy fruit. Nice structure, unmistakable food-friendliness. - Devin Parr
 
2023 Lake Doctor Shiraz Langhorne Creek $30.00 Gold 90 points
Dark ruby color; spicy aroma; medium to full bodied, good impact on the palate; black fruit and violets in the flavors; firm finish. - Wilfred Wong

  << Return
Critics Challenge
315 16th Street, Suite B
San Diego, CA 92101
Contact Us

Entry Instructions | International Entries | Category Codes | Entry Form
The Judges | About Us | Results | Links of Interest | Home